[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/vt/ - Virtual Youtubers


View post   

File: 358 KB, 2048x1534, ed7cca1d9fa2e3cb3dc77dd0a54678fa.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9321287 No.9321287 [Reply] [Original]

Yay or nay?

>> No.9321367

>>9321287
Noel: boring as fuck
Rushia: boring yandere bait
Marine: boring slut
Flare: boring who?
Pekora: boring adhd numberfag

>> No.9321479

For me personally it's Gen 5 because that's the only generation where I enjoy all the members.

>> No.9321631

>hololive
>peaking
pick one. literally only good for porn

>> No.9321697

>>9321287
Noel: Coomer bait. Boring. The whore of hololive.

Lucia: GFE bait. Boring. The loud character archetype of hololive

Marine: Failed coomer bait. Semi-interesting. The slut of hololive.

Pekora: Bully bait. Semi-interesting. Effortless PURE SEX.

Flare: Saviorfag bait. Indie tier, Bottom of the barrel vchuuba who belongs in nijisanji desu.

>> No.9321705

It "died" after EN was created, enough said
>>9321367
shut up marineschizo

>> No.9321757

>>9321697
>>9321367
Samefag

>> No.9321773

>>9321287
Great designs, I don't get the appeal besides that.
Marine is trash btw. Replying to everyone as "marineschizo" doesn't make her less trash.

>> No.9321820

>>9321773
Make your shitposting less obvious

>> No.9321829

Gamers has more people I like.

>> No.9321872
File: 360 KB, 2048x1448, 162654239588664.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9321872

Watame: FLUFF CUNNY.
Towa: PURE SEX CUNNY
Luna: PREMIUM CUNNY
Kanata: TOP SHELF CUNNY

How is this gen so underrated when they are without question The CUNNY GENERATION of hololive. What happened to the cunny buff bros?

>> No.9321963

>>9321287
Compared to HoloMyth they are nothing kek

>> No.9321996

>>9321820
kys

>> No.9322091

>>9321287
Considering 3 out of 5 members are 3 of the biggest chuubz in the world, for one reason or another, yes.

>> No.9322145
File: 313 KB, 931x427, Nene UOOOOOOOOOOHHHHH.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9322145

>>9321287
Considering Nene alone exists that statement is wrong

>> No.9322164
File: 242 KB, 588x288, 1630518447962.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9322164

>>9321872
>What happened to the cunny buff bros?
Overshadowed by these humongous Badonkers.

>> No.9322166

>>9322091
What's Marine?
Rushia is SC
Peko is hours viewed
Is Marine largest live audience?

>> No.9322234

>>9321287
>Literally who
>Manipulative paypig baiter
>Annoying memelord
>Literally who
>Obnoxiously fake

>> No.9322261

>>9322234
Why are cumbuds like this?

>> No.9322293

>>9322145
https://streamable.com/amp_player/q8k0df?__twitter_impression=true

>> No.9322299

>>9321287
It did peaked Marine and Pekora are the pillars of Hololive.

>> No.9322323
File: 21 KB, 595x516, images.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9322323

>>9321872
Cunny power still potent. You're just a faggot for even doubting it.

>> No.9322417

>>9322166
Largest average CCV is still Pekora. Marine however gets fairly close to her in both CCV and hours viewed, especially in the last few months.

>> No.9322432

>>9321367
>Noel: boring as fuck
this but unironically
>Rushia: boring yandere bait
this but unironically
>Marine: boring slut
she isn't boring, a lot of her persona is coombait though
>Flare: boring who?
this but unironically
>Pekora: boring adhd numberfag
she isn't boring, her autism is entertaining

>> No.9322729

That picture always bothered me how everyone has some sort of power or skill except Pekora who's in chains. I feel like she should have an army of nousagi bouncing towards her creating the dust cloud in the back.

>> No.9322743

>>9321287
define "peaked"
all of the JP gens are great, and the biggest flaw they have is... lack of gen 6
management clearly views EN and ID as seperate entities, just like holostars, and you should too

>> No.9322748
File: 164 KB, 954x674, 1630786089253.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9322748

Marin shitzo is back

>> No.9322778

>>9322729
>That picture always bothered me how everyone has some sort of power or skill except Pekora who's in chains.
You misunderstand. She is chained up is because she is the berserker of the group, and they unleash her when things are getting serious.

>> No.9322795
File: 2.48 MB, 1430x2000, 1603362472793.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9322795

>>9322164
HONKA
DONKA
BADONKERS

>> No.9322851

>>9321287
Nay.
Gen 5 is the future

>> No.9323203

>>9321287
Gen 5 is the undisputed best Gen. Anyone who says otherwise lacks the refined taste of an experienced boomer.

>> No.9323301

>>9321287
gen 3 was the peak but fags who got into it in the later gens will deny it because their oshi wasn't part of it.

>> No.9323323

>>9322432
pretty much

>> No.9323623

>>9321963
HoloMyth is fucking failure compared to Gen3, only gura can compete with them

>> No.9323714

>>9322748
OBSESSED

>> No.9324546

Gen 3 is the best but the rest aren't bad. Gen 5 is probably my second favourite gen so hololive is doing ok, just struck gold early

>> No.9324593

>>9321367
>>9321697
samefag, also never watched any of gen 3

>> No.9324834

>>9321287
Yes.
Noel - the most popular ASMR vtuber in the world (and the best IMO).
Nice voice, good variety in games, good sense of humour and really good at maintaining a conversation (which is why she has so few EOPs).
Rushia - Most SC'ed YouTuber with Coco gone.
Everyone knows her for her GFE experience stuff, but she actually can be really witty and funny, which is really interesting when you combine it with her clumsiness.
Marine - We all know how popular she is.
The queen of collabs, full of creative ideas and also really good at maintaining conversations.
Flare - The biggest otaku of Hololive. Her anime knowledge (besides mecha) is impressive. She also shines really well in smaller collabs. Her utawakus (especially with Patra) are great. Also can be really witty.
Pekora - We also all know how popular she is.
Her streams always feel exciting as you don't know what is going to happen next. So many iconic Hololive moments involve her. Really good at gettimg her audience invested in games.
I could go on as this only really scratches the surface of the magic of 三期生

>> No.9324849

>>9321367
>Pekora: boring

Kill yourself, right now

>> No.9324905
File: 9 KB, 246x250, 1624268921749.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9324905

>>9321287
Insider Holobrony here. Hololive peaks at gen 6

>> No.9324948

>>9321287
That would be VSinger.

>> No.9325231

Flare is based and has good taste in games. Noel's autism for audio equipment, Souls games, and recently Zelda games are endearing enough. Pekora's constant kayfabe filters me. Marine's coomer jokes also filter me. Rushia is kind of boring. 6/10 generation overall. Also, as someone who thinks the Myth and Council lore is cringekino, they should have leaned into the HoloFantasy theme more.

>> No.9325301

>>9325231
It’s sad that this is bait. Noel and Flare aren’t bad per say just stuck in a gen that’s overloaded with talent. They both have their qualities

>> No.9325396

>>9325301
NTA, but how is it bait?

>> No.9325826
File: 22 KB, 720x481, 1609569347234.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9325826

>>9323714
Not as obsessed as you leaving your home board just to shizo post and samefag about an old hag pretending to be an anime girl

>> No.9325901

my oshi isn't in gen 3 but I have to admit, that when compared to other generations, 3rd really does have the whole package.
Still remember being amazed that I was genuinely interested in all of them back when they debuted, as I usually only followed 1-2 per "gen" up until that point.

>> No.9326058

>>9321697
Shit bait. KYS. I'm not joking.

>> No.9326165
File: 16 KB, 189x267, srsly nigg.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9326165

Pretty sad actually seeing the people who voiced their opinions getting called out as bait. But then again what do you expect from /vt/ - Virtual Tourists and Redditors.

>> No.9326258

>>9326165
Stop using this bait to make more bait using a boogeyman you created, you autistic faggot.

>> No.9326271

>>9321287
No the irreparably destroyed any soul Hololive had

>> No.9326273

>>9325231
council is cringe, myth is based, i don't care, 4 fucking cryptids and a detective investigating on them, that's just kino.

>> No.9326334

>>9326271
TL: "Hololive became popular and I'm a contrarian, so I had to start hating them."

>> No.9326364
File: 126 KB, 1110x733, ss (2021-09-06 at 07.35.12).png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9326364

>>9322166
Marine has the most views. Mostly thanks to short animations but hey, that's also content. The only other vtuber I know who make short animations is Tamaki

>> No.9326407

>>9321287
They are probably the only Gen where all members are genuine friends and that always makes their collabs 10/10, so Yay.

>> No.9326587

>>9326364
Is this market saturation?

>> No.9326853

>>9321287
I love these kind of "ENTER" fanart. There's probably at least one of these for each gen

>> No.9326891

>>9321367
Marine schizo is trying to disguise himself but everyone know it’s him.

>> No.9326928

>>9321287
Peak (in numbers) and nadir (in soul) both

>> No.9327021
File: 139 KB, 1080x641, 3rd gen ENTER.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9327021

>>9321287
I feel like they get the coolest fanart thanks to to fantasy theme. People love fantasy setting

>> No.9328061

>>9321773
Marineschizo

>> No.9329662

>>9321287
>>9327021
Together they look like a party from a 'Tails of ' game, which is good.

>> No.9329737

Hololive peaked at Sora, afterwards it was just downhill

>> No.9330314

pekora: 9.6
marine: 9.3
rushia: 8.9
noel: 8.2
flare: 7.8

>> No.9330428

>>9327021

What the fuck
Why did they replace flare with an orang utan.

>> No.9330547

>>9321287

Id say those are the 4 most succesful streamers vtubing has seen in the same gen since holo gamers became a thing. Oh and flare is there too.

>> No.9334015

>>9324834
The only anon itt who actually watches their streams

>> No.9334048

Gen 3 feels like the most manufactured gen.

>> No.9334092

>>9334015
TL : "The only anon who posted things I'm agreeing with"

>> No.9334111

Nay

>> No.9334159

>>9321287
why pekora is slaved by flare ?

>> No.9334409

>>9321367
why are kfp like this?

>> No.9334525
File: 17 KB, 523x587, 16736638585631.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9334525

>>9321367
>>9321697
Why are ChumCHADS this fucking based. We don't call her Reddit shark for nothing now do we?

>> No.9334527

>>9321773
Ogey marineshizo

>> No.9338578
File: 2.02 MB, 850x1237, edzdfdf.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9338578

>>9321287
3 very strong in their own way but 2 deadweights.
Pekora is the peak of solo entertainers in the media, and he passion and character draws the biggest numbers to watch her
Marine is the best Holo for collabs on top of being an actual otak with deep knowledge, and have many interesting anecdotes to share from her long life
Rushia perfected GFE and dominates everyone in donations
Then you have Flare who is "nice" or "comfy" but really not much else and very forgettable, and Noel who just has her ASMR going for her and the most boring of personalities and a singing voice that makes even Ame sounds gound

>> No.9338682

>>9323203
36 year old boomer here can confirm Gokisei are the champions

>> No.9338736

>>9321287
it was the first rise of hololive. they all come together like the russian 5 with how solid each member is

>> No.9338787

>>9338578
>Marine actual otaku with deep knowledge
>the most boring of personalities
Noel has more otaku knowledge than Marine. Marine mostly likes mainstream stuff (not that there is anything wrong with that since it will appeal to a wider audience) where as Noel likes all sorts of niche mecha shows.
Noel can also talk about literally any topic from weird philosophies to science to gravure idols to old NND memes to sound equipment, just because she isn't loud doesn't mean she is boring.
Also you can't say she just has her ASMR when she is the number 1 ASMR vtuber in the world.
Flare is the biggest otaku in Hololive and also a great conversationalist who can be extremely witty at times and she shines in smaller collabs like bakatare and minecraft autism.

>> No.9338837

>>9338787
>noel has more otaku knowledge
what the fuck are you smoking my nigga? marine is a bigger otaku than noel and flare supplies most of her knowledge as a result.

t.kishidan

>> No.9338853

>>9321872
>cunny
>but none of them are lolis, not even the baby princess

>> No.9338885

>>9321287
Yes. I don't care much for Rushia's GFE, but no other Holo talents are as entertaining as Pekora and Marine.

>> No.9338903
File: 81 KB, 591x391, 1630544832162.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9338903

>>9321287
Gen 3 tier list
Top tier: Marine, Pekora
Midtier: rushia but only when she's telling stories about her family, Noel but only when she's being a creep about little boys or her brother
Low tier: rushia, Noel, Flare
Shit tier: when Noel and Flare are pretend lesbianing it up
This in undeniable truth

>> No.9339004
File: 814 KB, 2508x3541, 1626050359748.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9339004

>>9324905
Indeed.

>> No.9339022

>>9321287
No, they peaked at GAMERS

>> No.9339099

>>9338837
>t.kishidan
Fuck off falseflagger.
Noel likes stuff like UC Gundam, LoGH, obscure 70s stuff like Zambot 3, Planetes.
Marine literally only ever talks about extremely mainstream stuff like HxH, Jojo, the most obscure thing she has talked about in my recollection is Gunbuster which Noel told her to watch.
If you want to bring up 2hu, Noel has also played them.
If you want to bring up Rozen Maiden, Noel is also a fan.
Noel has also read niche seinen manga like Histories.
The reason why Noel isn't considered an otaku within Hololive is because her taste is so radically different from the rest.
If you were actually a kishidan you would know this.

>> No.9339163

>>9338837
Noel had to explain what newtypes were to Flare and Marine didn't even know who Char was. Marine only likes popular anime from the 90s onward.

>> No.9339181

>>9339099
yes i do know that

i just know that marine has a better knowledge of other otaku culture. noel's is there but her knowledge on other edges isn't there

>> No.9339236
File: 18 KB, 739x415, images (19).jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9339236

>>9324905
>>9339004
>Indeed

>> No.9339283

>>9321367
EOP RETARD
EOP RETARD
EOP RETARD

>> No.9339327

>>9339181
Like what?
Like Seiyuus? Marine is a seiyuu otaku but Noel isn't completely clueless when it comes to that either, she often goes on about how she likes sakuma rei.

>> No.9339368

>>9339327
do you have the time to talk about our lord and savior rilakkuma?

>> No.9339438

Gen 4 and 5 are amazing so hell no. Though gen 5 would have been even greater if they didn't get hit with 4 immediate debuffs back to back. Losing a member, introduction of massive company restrictions, the china shit, and EN mogging their numbers.

>> No.9339526

>>9339368
That san-x bear? Okay I will admit Marine knows more about than Noel. Not that I would know since I know fuck all about that stuff.

>> No.9339570

>>9339526
but i still respect noel's knowledge on gundam, her geeking out over sakuma rei, and how well she does enjoy DQ. has marine ever done a JRPG stream now that i think about it?

>> No.9339609

>>9339099
>>9339327
>>9338787
You guys sounds like those guys on MAL debating who is the most otaku by comparing their anime list

>> No.9339624

>>9321287
noel: ethot tiddy streamer
rushia: gfe pandering fake bitch
marine: actually talented but ruins it by being gross and creepy
flare: who?
pekora: actually good but in the end she does it for the money.

gen4 unironically better than gen3.

>> No.9340107

>>9339570
No, the only JRPG Marine likes is Tales.
>>9339609
Its a fucking dumb narrative that Noel isn't an otaku when she is one of the biggest so I want to put it to bed.

>> No.9340136

>>9340107
she is, but in hololive? she's middle of the pack. iirc before even coming to hololive subaru was pretty much away from most of that stuff

>> No.9340310

>>9340107
I'm pretty sure you are baiting for (you) at this point, but nobody said otherwise.

>> No.9340384

>>9340136
Outside of Kanda and Ryushen in Niji, I can't think of any big company vtuber that likes some of the niche stuff she likes.
You then have to remember her audiophile autism on top of all this.
It shouldn't really be suprising that a shut in is a massive otaku.

>> No.9340452

>>9340136
That is correct and nta, but I don't get your point. Why would you say she isn't a big otaku and then bring up Subaru being a normalfag?

And by the way, does it even fucking matter? Just because my oshi read Soloist in the Cage, or liked 13 Sentinels Aegis Rim doesn't mean we're gonna fuck.

>> No.9340518

>>9340384
yes i do know noel is a massive audiophile as well. she adores her ASMR equipment and even provided to other members. she's useful for that
>>9340452
>and then bring up Subaru being a normalfag?
because i wanna say who's at the bottom for otaku stuff and who's at the top. don't make it a bigger issue

>> No.9340572

>>9340310
The point is that if Marine gets credit for her interests then Noel should too since they are broader.

>> No.9340617

>>9340518
But you didn't mention who is at the top. And I doubt people will agree with you unless the talents themselves all agree.

>> No.9340664

>>9340617
i think flare would be at the top. maybe contested by someone like marine or fubuki but i think flare is the biggest otaku of them all

>> No.9340764

>>9321479
are you me

>> No.9340775

>>9340664
What about an idol otaku like Kanata or a retro game otaku like Korone and Noel (again)? Its kind of hard to compare, but I definitely don't think it is Marine, she is just the loudest about it.

>> No.9340840

>>9340775
kanata is a idol one so she's in the top at the least. okayu would also be there since she also cares for her mangas and openly discusses also. korone becomes a matter of do you put gaming into otaku culture, specifically retro games? i still find it very interesting with the knowledge every member has at least on some aspect of otaku culture, since that phrase is a catch all for a ton of things

>> No.9340845

>>9329662
i'd play that

>> No.9340933

>>9340664
What makes you say that?

>> No.9340964

>>9340933
one word: loli

>> No.9341030

>>9340764
I don't know. Is Nene your favorite too?

>> No.9341101

>>9341030
y-yes

>> No.9341167

>>9322432
Basically. Gen 3s a turning point but it only had two standouts. Rushia being alright on a good day.

>> No.9341233

>>9321367
Why does xer call pekora a number fag

>> No.9341286

All of this otaku talk made me realize why the oneesan gumi is a thing, since Rushia can hardly be called an otaku and Pekora is mostly known for games.

>> No.9341325

>>9340310
The reply chain started with a post praising Marine for being an otaku and denigrating Noel which implies that poster thinks Noel is not an otaku (and Flare too, for that matter, who is also a bigger otaku than Marine.)

>> No.9341359

>>9341325
huh? I actually never meant to insult noel at all.

>> No.9341622

>>9341359
This post >>9338578
called Noel and Flare deadweights and also implied Marine is the biggest otaku in the gen which I still maintain is Flare and that Noel is a bigger otaku than Marine.

>> No.9341638

>>9341622
oh so that wasn't me then. i thought it was to >>9338837

>> No.9342007

>>9321287
But Botan is gen 5

>> No.9342431

>>9321773
marineschizo

>> No.9347128

>>9338837
Marine is literally not an otaku
She is a normalfag into some pretty basic mainstream anime and that's it

>> No.9347205

>>9342007
Gen 5 have the best chemistry without a doubt.

>> No.9348822

>>9347128
you sure?

>> No.9349461

>>9348822
NTA but compare it to Noel or Flare's anime taste, people always claim Marine is hardcore anime and manga otaku but then when asked what she likes its always super popular stuff.

>> No.9349512

>>9347128
>normalfagscan recognize and name every single touhou character from only seeing their eyes

>> No.9349567

>>9349461
Her knowledge of Touhou lore and characters and games and doujin circle is really deep tho, Touhou itself being well known doesn't mean it's common to know that much

>> No.9350481

>>9348822
Yes

>>9349512
Marine can't do that

>>9349567
That's all mainstream shit and Noel knows all of it too

>> No.9350859

>>9350481
Marine did do the touhou faces quiz thing, so she can do it.
Yeah both Flare and Noel know touhou lore just as well as Marine and Flare knows the doujin circles just as well.
People in the west don't realize just how big touhou was in the early to mid 2010s in Japan and especially on NND, it was basically mainstream there.

>> No.9350935

>>9350481
>Marine can't do that
She did do the face blindness quizz and got a perfect IIRC it was in may 2020 or something, honestly not many people even in the touhou fandom can do this

>> No.9350974

>>9350859
>>9350935
She cheated

>> No.9351198

I really like Marine because she's from the exact same era as me and shares basically every reference from back then be it Touhou, Tatami Galaxy, Haruhi, Zetsubou Sensei, Lucky Star, Eden of the east and so on
It's nice, feels like reuniting with friends from back then

>> No.9351271

>>9350481
>all mainstream shit
Funny reading that from someone watching Hololive, I assume you qualify yourself as a normalfag vtuber watcher

>> No.9351362

>>9351198
>Tatami Galaxy
Finally something Marine likes that isn't really popular.

>> No.9351460

>>9351198
There are better to watch than her who are from the same era and actually like anime

>>9351362
Pretty sure she doesn't like it

>> No.9351776

>>9351460
>Pretty sure she doesn't like it
Probably not, the opening is a banger that she would sing over and over again like she does with everything.

>> No.9351920

>>9351271
Ok? This is a thread about rating these hololive members and Marine is particularly bad

>> No.9354396

>>9351920
> Marine is particularly bad
She’s more popular than your favorite vtuber in Japan tho. How is she bad?

>> No.9354573

>>9354396
Popularity /= quality.

>> No.9354688

>>9339099
Noel was also the only holo who tweets about Miura when he died.

>> No.9354786

>>9354396
Marine is just like the biggest pop artists who make really bad music and pretend to be nerds to score points with teenagers

>> No.9354892

>>9354688
Oh yeah, I forgot about that. She hasn't really talked about (or I missed it) so I am not sure if she was up to date with Beserk.

>> No.9354957

>>9354786
Sounds like a you problem. Her fans loves her voice and music also she’s loves drawing different anime characters.

>> No.9355014

>>9354957
BTS fans also think they are really good.

>> No.9355329

Marine has the shittiest normalfag taste I’ve ever seen

>> No.9355380

>>9354957
That doesn't make her good. All other vtuber fans cringe hard at the sight of Marine and her fans.

>> No.9355906

>>9355380
That’s sounds like baseless slander. She’s nice person there’s nothing cringe about her.

>> No.9357382

>>9355906
You are her fan though so you don't have the right viewpoint to judge her.

>> No.9357904

>>9357382
I do have the right viewpoint there’s nothing about her bad. I get it you don’t like her everyone different taste in chuubas not my problem.

>> No.9358167

>>9357904
She is bad because she sells herself as an otaku while not being one.
She also claims she's into all kinds of hetero fetish shit to get R18 fanarts even though she's gay.

>> No.9358255

>>9358167
>She also claims she's into all kinds of hetero fetish shit to get R18 fanarts even though she's gay.
Marine is straight.

>> No.9358543

>>9358255
She only pretends to bait for gachikois and fanarts

>> No.9358682

>>9358167
>She is bad because she sells herself as an otaku while not being one.
She’s knows Touhou lore and she’s a big seiyuufag
Now do I think she is a real otaku? Probably not anymore.
Most of her Otaku interests come from her time when she was in middle school and high school.
She obviously does do Otaku pandering and relive her youth a bit. You can hate her for that if you want to.

>> No.9358697

>>9321697
>Noel: Coomer bait. Boring. The whore of hololive.
This narrative has to stop. She is literally the purest of Hololive.

>> No.9358720

>>9358543
>She only pretends to bait for gachikois and fanarts
Crossick (the dykes in Niji) get hetero fan arts, she doesn't need to pretend to be straight. They are also way less popular than Marine.

>> No.9358847

>>9358697
The boring part is the most egregious. If you actually take the time to listen to her she is actually fun and interesting.

>> No.9358965

>>9358682
She took a spot of co-host on the otaku radio show with fubuki even though she's not otaku anymore and she gets paid for it
She should have let an actual otaku take that opportunity as they could actually do something with it

>> No.9359646

>>9358965
Collab organizations has never been a problem with Marine.

>>
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action