[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]

/vt/ - Virtual Youtubers

View post   
  [?]In ghost mode, only threads with non-archived posts will be shown
File: 346 KB, 900x900, 1608483729013.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
[ERROR] No.7660958 [Reply] [Original]

They're all mediocre. Why do you even argue over this dumb shit?
Good singers don't become vtubers, they become singers.
The only passable exception is Comet and maybe Gura on a good day.

>> No.7661106

>>7660958
Wow, a very unpopular opinion that nobody had before.

>> No.7661110

>>7660958
>Good singers don't become vtubers, they become singers
>Vsinger
>IRyS
>Only sing on special occasion and always JP Song
>Fuck my life.txt
>Stream some games because you realized its not worth it

>> No.7661306

>>7660958
Suzy has a legit song now so she's definitely a singer. Gura does not have any will to go and improve like comet did. It's a bad thing that Calli makes more originals than Gura. You really can't be a singer if you just sing what the others sing.

>> No.7661600
File: 10 KB, 246x250, get in the mikodayo yagoo.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
[ERROR]

it's all about SOVL
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Wcr_vLtt2U

>> No.7661678
File: 7 KB, 225x225, dd.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
[ERROR]

>>7660958
>The only passable exception is Comet

>> No.7661752
File: 177 KB, 331x331, 1623731794168.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
[ERROR]

>>7660958
When was the last time you bought an album?

>> No.7661928

Oh boy another singer vs singer thread, hang yourself OP

>> No.7661944

You know it's a schizo thread when their best example of a Hololive singer is Gura.

>> No.7662408

This is the reason why I hate this fucking fanbase and that lazy ass vtuber

>> No.7662695

>>7661110
>>Only sing on special occasion and always JP Song
Watch streams, santa

>> No.7662785

>>7660958
>Good singers don't become vtubers, they become singers.
You can be both though? There's a whole VSinger market after all.

>> No.7663776

TWO OCTAVES

>> No.7664160

Pretty sure they make more than 90% of "professional" singer though?

>> No.7664308

>>7660958
Excellent bait thread, cumnigger.

>> No.7664395

>>7660958
>Good singers don't become vtubers, they become singers.
good singers join nijisanji

>> No.7664461

>>7664395
Literally who?

>> No.7664704
File: 260 KB, 262x435, sing.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
[ERROR]

My oshi might not the best but she's doing her reps and is pure soul
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r5GaMy1HSjk

>> No.7665200

>>7661110
>>Vsinger
>>IRyS
And she's mediocre

>> No.7665247

>>7665200
Still better than Gumber.

>> No.7665412
File: 436 KB, 567x567, 1617926437147.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
[ERROR]

>>7661306
>You really can't be a singer if you just sing what the others sing
>Whitney Houston wasn't a singer

>> No.7665461

>>7661110
>Only sing on special occasion and always JP Song
What the fuck are you talking about? Does this board not even watch any streams?

>> No.7665503
File: 241 KB, 220x205, 1613011132295.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
[ERROR]

>>7665461
>Does this board not even watch any streams?
how new?

>> No.7666636

>>7660958
Imagine be complaining that the people performing amateur karaoke at a talent show aren't professional singers and musicians capable of selling out a stadium. Chubas thrive on relatability and fan interaction, not pure star power.

>> No.7666945
File: 209 KB, 478x600, 1601053874612.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
[ERROR]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jqg79Ypt0Yg&ab_channel=GakiB
I see OP is a deaf faggot. You should consider an hero unironically. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ttJDWzJ3NwI&ab_channel=KozoVtuber was impressive too.

>> No.7667116

Kiara is not a great singer and limits herself even more with her mixer settings. I'm glad she makes some produced, psudo-professional stuff because it's a passion for her, but it should just be a fun little thing to do on the side.
I still love her and want her to keep making music, but I can admit it isn't the best.

>> No.7667701

>>7666945
I may as well be a deaf faggot after listening to that mediocrity.

>> No.7669881

>>7660958
>watame exists
>OP posts bait this poor anyway
what a spiritually impoverished existance. I almost pity (you).

>> No.7670465

>>7660958
Comet has a tendency to strain her voice sometimes. Other than that she's decent. Better than me anyway. >>7660958

>> No.7670525

i fucking love chumfucks, you guys make me laugh

>> No.7670538

>>7664704
In all seriousness Miko has improved a ton. Before I would say her singing is "cute" but now I solidly put her in the legit good category.

>> No.7670845

>>7661678
>misses notes
>uncute voice
>pretend to be the best

>> No.7671138

>>7670845
>pretend to be the best
When?

>> No.7671733
File: 82 KB, 420x420, gensokyoholoism.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
[ERROR]

>>7660958
I like Marine and Flare's voices a lot.

>> No.7672764

>comet
I'm just gonna say it Suisei is overrated, sure she can sing but her songs are lame. I'd much rather listen to something like Ahoy or Mogu than any of Suiseis snoozefests.

>> No.7672910

>>7672764
Ahoy straight-up cures my blues on the way to work every Monday morning.

>> No.7675999

>>7660958
Both get mogged by Moona and Sora

>> No.7676332

I dunno man, if we're counting Holostars, Rikka, Izuru, and Astel are very talented singers and musicians. Izuru's cover of Aishite is one of my favorite covers in the company.

>> No.7678907
File: 44 KB, 828x792, 1621419799842.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
[ERROR]

>>7660958
Bait.
Ina exists, you fool.

>> No.7679003

There are so many good singers out there that becoming a vtuber is one option you can take to stand out.

>> No.7681046

personally, nothing has ever made me feel like this one https://files.catbox.moe/grwpzq.mp4
and it's a viewer request karaoke song

>> No.7682133

>>7660958
>Good singers don't become vtubers, they become singers.
People with good arguments don't shitpost on 4chan, they become lawyers.

>> No.7682169

>>7679003
Being a VSinger seems like it'd be an attractive option for budding singers who want to maintain anonymity. For example, it's very likely that Aimer and ClariS would have become VSingers if they were a thing a decade ago when they debuted.

>> No.7682187
File: 57 KB, 640x640, 1603507604994.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
[ERROR]

I find that japenese songs suffer from the inevitable constant hard k and t sounds inherent to the language which can be avoided or played with in english for instance
anyone notice this?

>> No.7682247

>>7672764
Ok, I've noticed you. You can go now.

>> No.7682352

Remember that this thread was made to bait and it's working because you are all idiots

>> No.7684916
File: 25 KB, 400x400, SIOecIDH.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
[ERROR]

>>7678907
Ina exists? Has she even did Violet? I don't see it anywhere do you? She needs to touch less grass and more music work.

>> No.7688541

>>7681046
this but https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s5CTmyhfqLo

>> No.7693395

>>07672764
get fucked, even in this shit thread

>> No.7693412

You talking shit?7https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hqURBTpvh0A

>> No.7693798

>>7681046
fuck you I wasn't ready to start tearing up.

>> No.7693883

>>7660958
>They're all mediocre. Why do you even argue over this dumb shit?
Compared to who?

>> No.7693911

>>7682187
The word take is in like every single song and thats a hard t and k
Not to be a weeb but Japanese songs are more fun because you can rhyme more

>> No.7693944

>>7693883
Kpop idols

>> No.7697338

>>7693883
Anyone whose native language isn't soulless.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FNCtlunWezk

>> No.7701569

>and maybe Gura on a good day.
pfftHAHAHAHAHAHA why are cumsharts so easy to spot

>> No.7702042

>>7660958
AZKi is good, or at least her doujin/utaite stuff is, I don't follow her vtuber persona

>> No.7702795

unfathomably based

>> No.7709408

>>7660958
A nice popular opinion.

>> No.7709473

>>7684916
...this is some weird bait.

>> No.7709490

>>7660958
>Gura
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHHAHA

>> No.7709506

>>7660958
You forgot Irys

>> No.7711166

>>7661678
This is how I feel about this thread.

>> No.7711720

>>7660958
Nah, they sing well and have a lot of soul. The fact that most of their singing is done in karaoke streams with little or no voice editing only makes their singing seem better when you remember that every single song you hear nowadays on Spotify has so much editing to it that if you found the singer irl and asked them to sing it for you live it would probably sound like shit. Let the affection you hold for a vtuber make you not pay attention to the lack of professional-tier technique.

The REAL reason why vtuber songs suck (and they do) is because the vtubers or whoever they hire are complete dogshit at composing. You could get anybody in the world to sing it for them and it would still be a terrible song. But this is a general problem of the music industry since at least the 80's when Pop became hegemonic.

>> No.7712022

>>7660958
Good singers don't become vtubers or aidol, they go sucks producer cocks
Fix you, nigga

>> No.7713374

I wonder why AZKi even bothered with hololive. I would have thought she was doing fine with her doujin/utaite stuff.

>> No.7714290

>>7711720
I feel this way about Gura's stuff, her karaoke is generally great and her releases have been mediocre to bad. For whatever reason Hololive has pigeonholed itself into flavorless anisong bullshit. It doesn't even have to be different genres, there's a lot of jpop/doujin/vocaloid that's pretty good. But like you say, they're hiring mediocrity.

>> No.7714351

>>7660958
yeah they suck at singing when they`re sucking on my cock

>> No.7714894

>>7676332
Based. Rikka has the most technical training and skill in addition to his ability to actually compose good music but Izuru has serious chops and a very unique raspy voice that gives him a lot character. Astel is actually the weakest (looking at level of vocal polish and skill) singer of the three but his range is extremely wide. They all carry notes really well in any case.

>> No.7714975

>>7660958
>Good singers don't become vtubers, they become singers.
I'm not going to disagree that everyone sucks but plenty of good singers never get noticed or even want to pursue a singing career. Literally American Idol bullshit shows this. Unless your definition of a good singer is only a finalist or some shit.

>> No.7715058

>>7714975
Idiot, you can't be called good at something unless you have big number next to your game. Bigger number = more gooder.

>> No.7719460

>>7660958
That's not true.

>> No.7719485
File: 200 KB, 1124x1172, 1586709112285.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
[ERROR]

>>7660958
It's because al JP SONGS SUCK ASS

>> No.7719724
File: 53 KB, 600x600, aps,504x498,small,transparent-pad,600x600,f8f8f8.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
[ERROR]

I just wish gura will take singing classes (a vocal couch perhaps?) Her voice have so much potential, even at mainstream level and she would became like gorillaz famous-tier.

>> No.7719776

>>7719724
Yeah she probably needs someone to help her make her life less busy and work on her singing skills

>> No.7719826

>>7660958
you probably like the nigger music

>> No.7720470

>>7688541
This. Some switch flipped in her lately and she was so confident in this song and sadly we haven't gotten a serious karaoke since this one for the most part.

>> No.7721311

Some of us must clean our ears, yes you, and yes me.

>> No.7721486

>>7719826
But hololive has that.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5y3xh8gs24c

>> No.7723671

>>7660958
As you can see OP, not all singers can be a traditional singer. Theres something called luck. and with the birth of vtubers, more chances will be given to those people to be heard all over the world.

>> No.7723993

>>7664461
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XwZZeMNanKw
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h41KFaq4UXc

>> No.7724134
File: 145 KB, 1024x1024, 1628053241266.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
[ERROR]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BbMYBWvUbVI

>> No.7725829

>>7660958
too bad she doesnt sing ultra cute songs like spOWOky OWOky anymore

>> No.7725977

>>7661110
>>>Good singers don't become vtubers, they become singers

Does Mousey count?

>> No.7728122

>>7660958
I thought Gura's first original was just ok. I hate that it got overhyped just cause she's just very popular. The genre of it never really came off to me as something she would sing either. Is it a good song? Sure. Will I listen to it again? Not really.

That one eurobeat remix of it was unironically better IMO

>>
Reply to thread [?]Don't expect anything heroic. Your post will not be uploaded to the original board.
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action