[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/vt/ - Virtual Youtubers

View post   
  [?]In ghost mode, only threads with non-archived posts will be shown
File: 341 KB, 1920x1080, snapshot.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
632248 No.632248 [Reply] [Original]

Are they actually good singers or my dick is deluding me?

>> No.632258

Forgot link
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JYtt0inzDR4

>> No.632571

>>632248
depends on which chuuba you're talking about
marine is a bit of both for me

>> No.632594

>>632248
I love Marine's voice.

>> No.633029
File: 946 KB, 673x900, 1611925245179.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
633029

>>632248
Suisei is really good at singing.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LpkWFnRPd-M

>> No.633148

Whos is the worst singer?

>> No.633300

>>633148
Easy. That's Noel.

>> No.633417

>>633148
Noel and then Ame.

>> No.633435

>>632248
Both, some are actually just great, but if your dick tells you to like one (even Noel) then it's good (for You).

>> No.633566

A lot of them are better singers technically than the majority of pop stars. And that's a not le wrong generation thing its just that with pitch correction software as good as it is pop stars don't really need to be terrific, just marketable.
Compared to people who are actually great singers though who can perform amazingly on a consistent basis and completely live, such as those in music theater or opera, none of the girls are really up to that standard. But it's unreasonable to demand idol streamers be that skilled.

>> No.634259

>>632258
2:52 - 3:00 best part

>> No.634873

>>633417
Ame's pretty terrible but in an endearing sort of way. It's like going out to karaoke with your girlfriend but all she listens to is ska.

>> No.634950

>>632248
Towa and Suisei are pretty good

>> No.634964

>>632248
shes actually a really good singer.

>> No.635091

>>633029
Yeah she’s really good in certain ranges so I don’t why she keeps forcing herself to do ‘official songs’ in ranges that don’t suit her voice. Like even in livestreams she can 10 times better than a studio mixed song of hers.

>> No.635167

>>633148
all of HoloEn (don't know why everyone sucks off Gura) + Noel + Korone (it's a cute sort of bad, but she has little to no technical ability)

>> No.635535
File: 812 KB, 900x844, 1602486723933.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
635535

>>633148
>forgets half the lyrics
>mickey mouses the entire song off key

>> No.635592

>>633566
It's sad what technology has done to modern pop music. Practically none of the big stars today--even the ones supposedly known for being great singers--can actually perform their own music, because plebs don't care if shit is fake as long as the singer is hot and it sounds "decent" (read: pitch corrected to hell and back). It's so bad that if Michael Jackson had been born in the late 90s or early 2000s rather than 1958, he would undoubtedly have languished in obscurity because looks are everything and performance ability no longer matters.

>> No.635597

Korone can't sing but it's still fun to watch.

>> No.635644
File: 279 KB, 664x559, 1603649467772.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
635644

>>633029
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=asojeparbK0
just a casual Karaoke stream

>> No.635702

>>633148
In no particular order: Noel, Choco, Ame

>> No.635727

Do any of you know which of the Nijis aside from Toko are good singers?

>> No.635772

>>635535
she's gotten better!

>> No.635976

>>635592
I knew the music industry was shit the moment I heard T pain sing without autotune.

>> No.635996

>>635535
She'd be a blast at karaoke though.

>> No.636018

>>635727
machita chima

>> No.636204

>>635976
T pain uses really extreme auto tune as a stylistic effect. Where pitch correction is really insidious is with singers like Bieber and Rihanna. When done right you can't even tell its been used. But make no mistake, every big record uses it. There's too much money on the line to fuck around with human imperfection.

>> No.636248

>>633148
Noel, but she's trying her best and that's cute so it's ok

>> No.636331

>>636204
yeah but it's very clear that T Pain ended up disliking doing it after a while, and I'd imagine that for at least part of his time when he was more active he was forced to use it.

>> No.636382

>>635727
Not Niji but outside of Holo I've been listening to these two sing
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gLTeAchkhIg
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vI_1xomTCVY

>> No.636525

>>635727
I like Ryushen

>> No.636602

>>635167
Gura has a perfectly fine "folksy" kind of voice.

>> No.636673

>>635167
Gura has a terrific sense of pitch. She doesn't ever belt which impresses most people more than any other aspect of singing. She also insists on singing in her character voice which flattens her affect a bit. Although she still sounds great in a cutesy way.

>> No.636797

>>633148
noel and coco

>> No.637533

Something I appreciate about Noel is that despite her being the worst singer in the company, she doesn't have a complex/ego about it and is clearly having fun when she does it.

>> No.638009

>>635597
Korone has improved, her rendition of メテオ with Okayu at 2nd Fes was legit very good.

>> No.638078

>>632248
Part of the appeal for me is that they're trying, most of them weren't singers or dancers before holo, they're doing their best practising for their fans... I want to fuck senchou so bad.

>> No.638184
File: 43 KB, 360x360, 1605707369925.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
638184

>>635167
Yeah poor Korosan can only sound good when heavily auto tuned and reverb on. At least she's smart to choose goofy or niche songs that fit her style.

>> No.638271

>>635996
I'd fuck her brains out in a karaoke if you know what I mean.

>> No.638301

>>638271
You lost me.

>> No.638479

I know some of you don't even care about HoloID, so in case you didn't know: Risu and Moona are top tier singer in holopro.

>> No.638688

>>638271
As long as I'm her while you do it

>> No.638803

>>635167
Here’s your (you) faggot

>> No.638826

>>633148
Noel is completely tone deaf
still cute though

>> No.638861
File: 211 KB, 400x400, 1592383750895.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
638861

>>638688
okite okite okite

>> No.638884

>>635727
Machita Chima, Joe Rikichii, Kenmochi Touya, Ryuushen, Yumeoi Kakeru, Mashiro, Mellisa.

>> No.638949

why haven't you listened to noel sing king today?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2T7Ql4D1UnQ

>> No.639483

A few of them were primarily singers poached from NicoNico anyway

>> No.639558

>>638184
I still listen to Okayu and Korone singing If
Honestly better than the original

>> No.639741
File: 209 KB, 311x295, sex machine.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
639741

>>638271
I think I know what you mean

>> No.645436

>>635535
Even if at her best she's "really bad" she keeps her singing streams fun.

>> No.645702

>>632248
>Are they actually good singers or my dick is deluding me?

I am New Delhi School of Music graduate. I can give you very objective singing power ranking

Red S+
Mori

S
AZKei, Suisei, Ayundai

A
Moona, Okayu, Towa, Kanata(?), Ayame

B
Marine, EmoGura, Korone, Sora, Aqua

C
Coco, Choco, Cyark

W
Wallaby, Noel

>> No.645720

>>645702
>W
>Wallaby
fuck you Wallaby is at least B tier

>> No.645733

>>645702
>New Delhi

>> No.645785

>>638949
fuck, i didn't take the dive on the bad singers and now that i'm listening to her and Ame how did they ever get hired?

>> No.645787

Marine is great.
>youtube.com/watch?v=RCZSiOoDkI4

>> No.645819

>>645702
lmao. totally pointless. nobody gives a fuck about your shitty college. they do pop music.

>> No.645837

>>645785
Contrary to popular belief, being a good singer is not a prerequisite for being an idol and it never has been (except for maybe 1970s-1980s era idols).

>> No.645862

>>645837
Yes but after the first gen it was pretty much expected. I figured they’d be looking out for that so even if they’re lame entertainers they could at least have something to add

>> No.645958

>>645837
>Contrary to popular belief, being a good singer is not a prerequisite for being an idol
>thinking Hololive members are actual idols

>> No.645966

>>645862
It's not, you can scrounge AKB's hundreds of idols and you can find a lot of 'not that good' singers.

Idols' main selling point is primarily charm plus perseverance as a secondary (hard work mantra etc) while a singer's main selling point is her vocal prowess.

You can watch an idol train her voice to be better than before but most will come watch her because of her charm or perseverance in working hard to sound better.

>> No.645990

>>645733
>>645819

India is bowels of the Earth. All music pass through India, it is narrow minded to think that India does not know how to music.

>> No.646008

>>633148
Roboco

>> No.646029

>>632248
https://streamable.com/oed1xh

Ayunda has SOUL

>> No.646142

>>645720
I must apologize for tier W, it is a meme. I purposely placed Wallaby there... As a joke.

>> No.646175

>>639558
Korosan rapping with Okayu is SSS tier

>> No.646470

>>635727
https://youtu.be/BgMWNpHb0Eo
https://youtu.be/61nZBenEHUY

>> No.646668
File: 2.15 MB, 1972x1254, __minato_aqua_hololive_drawn_by_nyaruin__243a6a97e1ff4162b31987b5a9cf7a9f.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
646668

>>632248
Ok, serious question but... i unironically enjoy Aqua's singing. Should it concern me?

>> No.646763

>>646668
I mean it’s not bad for certain things
https://youtu.be/Zhp0uJ8CjBQ

>> No.646851

>>646763
nostalgic

>> No.646983

>>633148
Titty Knight

>> No.647037

Idol singers are supposedly diamonds in the rough that you choose to support until they realize their dreams. It gives off this positive never give up kind off vibe. People support them not because they are great singers but because you like their personality and looks. It's different from Kpop where they lock their idols up and only release them once they are good enough.

Tldr. It's your dick.

>> No.647097

>>632248
Depends on the Chuba.
In the case of Towa, Marine, Reine, Suisei and Gura, yes they are actually good singers.
In the case of the others...Eh...

>> No.647267

>>633029
She's got a huge range, too. Though she bottoms out in this song a few times.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bS5aqE2UZhI

>> No.647522

>>632248
Watame
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8xFNL46XU14
2:08:38
I think before she didn't reach those high notes. On this attempt she doesn't have to stop mid way on those high notes.

>>633029
This.
I fucking love Next Color Planet my god.

>> No.647601 [SPOILER] 
File: 36 KB, 500x489, 1613472268722.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
647601

>>645958
>thinking Hololive members are actual idols

>> No.647615

>>633148
Luna

>> No.647670

>>647097
>Reine
Moona and Risu are better singers

>> No.647690

>>634873
I thought I was having a stroke when I heard her covering Catch 22. I was not ready for that to come from a vtuber.

>> No.648342

>>638688
That's gay, anon

>> No.648579

>>648342
Coco is a woman so it can't be gay, even if Coco is actually anon.

>> No.648623

>>633148
I don't know much about the JPs, but ame's cringe is physically painful

https://youtu.be/wdUKgCMO9bg

>> No.648630

>>638271
what on earth did anon mean by this?

>> No.648692

>>648579
Is it gay to want to fuck Tailred from Ore Twintails Ni Narimasu?

>> No.648729

>>645785
they're streamers not singers

>> No.648768

>>633148
roboco or noel
amelia and coco are awful, but at least are funny about it

>> No.648891

>>638949
lefto saido righto saido

>> No.648913

>>648729

People overemphasize the idol aspect of Hololive. Hololive Idol Project only began with the release of SSS in Sep 2019. Hololive is not an agency for singers like Re:act.

Some members, like Choco, Noel, Coco, Ame, etc., clearly passed the audition because of experience in other areas.

>> No.649693

>>635167
>don't know why everyone sucks off Gura
Probably because professional vocal coaches have chimed in on saying she's godly and every rando anon on this board who says she's not that good are coping retards with zero singing knowledge.

>> No.649868
File: 34 KB, 600x648, it hurts.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
649868

>>635996
You will never get trashed in a karaoke booth with Coco

>> No.649892

wait coco actually can sing what the hell

>> No.649927
File: 178 KB, 646x729, okaghost.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
649927

>>648623
Shiny Smily Story Special Soul...

>> No.649970

>>649892
Anon... no... I love Coco but you have ear problems

>> No.649994

>>649970
I think she does pretty alright in certain songs. She would need a fuckton more practice tho.

>> No.650025

>>649994
I mean that depends on your definition of alright. In my field when you say something like "this person can actually sing" it means good enough to make money doing it as a full-time career.

>> No.650037

>>650025
Well she's definitely not recruited for her singing.

>> No.650068

>>649693
I assume the people that write this stuff are trolling because it seems so obviously disconnected from reality.

>> No.650096

>>650068
They're just antis who can't accept Gura is actually talented because she makes them seethe for schizo reasons.

>> No.650130

>>650096
I was talking about the guy calling her godly.

>> No.650137

>>650130
Lmao you are retarded.

>> No.650276

>>650130
I'm sorry anon but you're the one disconnected from reality, you either have legitimate ear problems or have never bothered listening to Gura sing any of her numerous standout performances.

See >>604013

>> No.650616

>>650276
Not sure what you are linking that post for? Writing a lot of words about why you think someone is good and using technical terms doesn't make an opinion any more correct. I'm not even saying she is bad just that hyperbolic statements like those make me think that people aren't being serious. I even agree most of what the guy is saying is good about her singing from a "technical" point of view but I just can't say I find any of it to be all that impressive to the point where describing it as godly would be appropriate when put together. Good in the context of Hololive though certainly.

>> No.650701

>>650616
The 'godly' is in context of hololive. She's not world class compared to real pro singers, but compared to any of the other girls at Cover she's in another league, and idiots like >>635167 who listed Gura in the same line as Noel are just absolutely fucking delusional. The difference in skill between Gura and fucking Suisei is like the difference between Suisei and Noel.

>> No.650804

>>650701
Fair enough.

>> No.650833

>>650276
>raw skill = good
Stopped reading there, If you think the only thing that makes an artist good is technical skill then you haven't listened to enough music and just wasted your time studying music theory.

>> No.650843

>>650130
Gura has highs and lows performance wise. This is mainly because of her song selections. She sometimes insist singing songs that are out of her register. She's more of a crooner or a taylor swift pre-pop. She fails when she pushes too hard. She can definitely hit the notes if she tried really hard but you can tell she is straining her voice. I hope she just avoids singing overly high pitched jpop songs. It doesn't match her.

>> No.650931

>>650701
You're insane.

>> No.650933

>>650833
>soul meme cope in more words
Funny enough that same anon also had a response to that

631222

>> No.650958

>>650931
How?

>> No.651015

All these faggots jerking off Suisei when she's not even the best female singer in hololive, let alone the best in holopro. Someone post that clip of her dogshit live performance

>> No.651016

>>650931
Imagine being so stupid you can listen to Gura's plastic love where she harmonizes perfectly with the backing vocals while holding a sustained note doing runs while improvising her own fucking melody into a voiced glottal and never going off pitch without running out of breath, and then thinking she isn't obviously the best in hololive.

>> No.651032

>>650843
Gura literally almost never ever fails to hit notes, her few rough points are in completely different areas.

>> No.651061

>>634873
she needs lessons
it pains me when fans laugh it off and call it cute when she stumbles on songs

she's messing up because she's nervous and forcing it

>> No.651098
File: 150 KB, 549x578, he.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
651098

>>650933
>NOOOO YOU CAN'T JUST SAY TECHNICAL SKILL DOESN'T MATTER, I HAVE A DEGREEEEEEEEE
Cope more retard, no one that actually listens to music cares about your degree in music theory. You are the equivalent of audiophiles telling others to throw over 2000$ in headphones to hear the drummer fart.

>> No.651146

>>651098
Massive cope and you don't even make sense. Not only does technical skill obviously fucking matter but the point of the post you're responding to is that Gura also, in addition to being skilled, manages to put more emotion and feeling into her singing than most of the others too.

>> No.651149

>>651098
I agree with you, but kill yourself wojakposter

>> No.651219

>>651098
>wojackposting
Damn, gura antis have sunk this fucking low lol

>> No.651252

>>651061
Her whole princess connect karaoke was a rough one. You guys can't tell me it was a great. It was decent at best. She struggled a lot. She does need lessons. Once she has practiced a song really hard she nails it. But a lot of loud songs don't fit her.

>> No.651269

>>651146
She literally doesn't care about singing, she just happened to be gifted on it.
She's good, but if you still fail to see why she isn't in the top of the list of others who don't fanboy over her then you're just focusing too much on technicality.

>> No.651290

>>651269
>She literally doesn't care about singing
Holy fucking shit how are you this dumb?

>> No.651337

>>651252
She was still sick when she did that stream anon, and all of those songs were in other languages. Of course it was rough.

>> No.651353

>>651269
She cares a lot about it. Her goal is to be able to sing in the holo fes concert. It's only Gura and Kiara have this goal. It matters a lot to her. Who are you even watching. She wasn't trained and she only sings for fun back then but singing is very important for her

>> No.651393

>>651337
She sang Plastic Love and Renai Circulation quite well. If she was sick then that's too bad. It sounded really rough

>> No.651398

>>651353
The fact that she got as amazing as she did by only singing for fun without formal training is exactly how you can tell how much she cares. Only someone with true passion for singing develops that much skill by doing it so much for the sheer enjoyment.

>> No.651422

>>651393
Those weren't in the priconne stream, I think you are confusing your karaokes.

>> No.651512

>>650701
Gura's great and >>635167 's list is insane, but you don't have to suck her off THAT hard. I love her but Suisei is amazing, and at MOST Gura is in the same tier, not leagues above.

>> No.651524

>>646029
Ayunda!

https://youtu.be/wedBMBeLUk0?t=1850

>> No.651566

>>651512
Suisei is about at my singing level, which took years of practice. Gura effortlessly does things I still can't even get close to yet. If you want someone closer to Gura's level, look at Risu. Claiming Gura is at most in the same tier as Suisei is delusional.

>> No.651693
File: 54 KB, 508x680, GuraMarine.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
651693

Reminder that when Gura takes the singing seriously, she's better than 90% of Hololive, equal to Marine and Okayu. Only Towa, Sora, and arguably Kanata are better without studio effects.

Senchou/Same-chan duet when, Cover?

>> No.651717

>>651693
I've done direct comparisons of her and Towa, Gura is far above Towa's level. Towa is underrated though.

>> No.651761

>>651566
You can just compare how Gura and Suisei sang Next Color Planet. You can see the difference. Gura just needs more training. Nobody has to really hate on either. If anything, i wish they would do a song together.

>> No.651813

>>651761
>You can just compare how Gura and Suisei sang Next Color Planet
I have, Gura blew her out of the water on that one. Within 20 seconds you can tell Suisei isn't even in the same league. Are you comparing Suisei's live version, or do you not understand the massive difference post-production makes? Remember we don't have any examples of a post-production Gura song yet, all of the singing we have from her is live.

>> No.651924

>>651813
Of course i am talking about live. Did you watch her 500k stream?? Man. Blew her out of the park?? You are ridiculous.

>> No.651986

>>646470
I wonder about her with things like this
https://youtu.be/5z39--ZYaes
if she does she go to some kind of music school or has a professional background

>> No.652053

>>651924
https://youtu.be/UciPumOwnys

https://youtu.be/NkE9sahsgK4

Anon, listen objectively, with no bias, headphones in, volume up, listen to their voices in this first 30 second introduction part of this song. Gura crushes her.

I'm not hating by any means, either. This isn't to put Suisei down. I like her, I want to see all the girls keep improving and succeeding. I'm just making observations on skill as someone with a background in vocal knowledge who spends hours practicing singing every day. Gura is better. And Gura doesn't even try her hardest during this song, in the later parts she relapses to her more cutesy character voice as she often does when she's nervous. She didn't even stand up for this stream. And it was still clearly better at parts.

>> No.652376

>>652053
See, the problem is that you've chosen the WORSE of the two renditions that Gura did, which is—objectively—about on par with Suisei's live performance. Try a comparison using this one instead:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gj_mokeTCvU

>> No.652420
File: 1.82 MB, 1153x1001, seethe.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
652420

>the eternal gura vs suisei debate
do we really have to do this every time

>> No.652440

>>652420
This wasn't even a thread about the best singer, it was about the worst, which is pretty clearly a debate between Noel and Ame

>> No.652488

>>652440
its noel

>> No.652506

>>652053
Better at what? It is not even close, you are either biased as fuck or smoking some high tier weeds

>> No.652510

>>652420
It's going to keep happening until the cometfags actually listen to reason. Suisei isn't even the one they should be comparing to Gura, there are at least 4 or 5 other holos better than her, I think it's just one stubborn Suisei gachikoi.

Again, not hating, I don't dislike Suisei. She's got some really enjoyable stuff I've saved in my holo sings playlist, like this https://youtu.be/i7aDLnDvB5s

>> No.652528

>>652053
Not him but nah, Gura doesn't "crush" her at all.
And this is even with Cover's shitty audio that's a staple now in every 3D live.

>> No.652545

>>652506
See >>650276 again. You are the one who is biased as fuck. If you know anything about singing you can immediately tell how much better Gura is.

>> No.652576

>>652506
>It is not even close
You are right, it is not even close, with Gura coming out way on top.

>> No.652583

>>652440
It's not even a debate imo, Noel is absolutely tone deaf to the point I feel like she has to be doing it on purpose. Ame just doesn't know how to sing, she is obviously second worst but there is a power gap in the middle.

>> No.652624

>>652510
>I think it's just one stubborn Suisei gachikoi.
Suisei's not even my favorite voice in Hololive, it's just clear to me that where they are now Suisei and Gura are both good enough that acting like there's a massive gulf doesn't make sense.

>> No.652708

>>652583
Ame also has some throat issues going on, but nothing that can't (probably) be fixed if she takes a break and learns how to care for her voice.

>>652624
Massive might be overstating it but there's a noticeable one. Because again, I've been practicing for years, and I am very much around Suisei's exact level, I recognize the same mistakes she makes as things I struggle with. I try to emulate techniques Gura does and I can't even approach it. I have professional training and I know the science behind singing, it's not just some nebulous poorly understood magic, it's actually a very well-researched field. If you can't hear the difference between them you probably just don't have a very well trained ear or much musical experience.

>> No.652977
File: 280 KB, 687x458, 1612997010888.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
652977

>I've been practicing for years, and I am very much around Suisei's exact level
post proof or shut the fuck up

>> No.652983

>>652510
>I think it's just one stubborn Suisei gachikoi
Multiple people are disagreeing with you my dude, you can't just claim victory by denouncing the other side as just one samefag.
Chumbuds really need to get their head out of their asses. You can't criticize her singing without some supposed music major showing up as if anyone believes or cares about him.

>> No.652995

>>652420
What amuses me is that during summer, before EN was a thing and no one followed ID, the singing tier bullshit was all about reeeing about how "nobody cares about Suisei's skills, I listen to [my oshi] for the SOUL." But now it seems to be shifting towards "nobody cares about Gura's skills, I listen to Suisei for the SOUL."

>> No.653018

>>632248
I love Rushia's raspy voice. Totally underrated singer.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9nSXQU499iU
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XRDDS0Agvbw

>> No.653109

>>635167
Gura literally had an entire channel of her singing meme songs very well before becoming a chuuba???? Hello????

reps, retard

>> No.653137

Are there any examples of Gura singing something that is actually difficult? Her singing only seemed remarkable in that it was consistent.

>> No.653149

>>648913
>Choco
She must have sucked a mean cock to get it. I like Choco-sensei but other than ASMR, she's not really entertaining for a long period.

>> No.653166
File: 4 KB, 48x48, smol.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
653166

Gura will never have sex with you
Gura will never even know you exist
no matter how hard you wank her ITT

>> No.653187

>>652995
Speaking of ID, Moona gets slept on pretty hard when it comes to singing. Easily the best ID member imo.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q4N7EhUWOAA

>> No.653318

>>650833
I bet you belive toan is in the fingerz too

>> No.653370

>>653137
I kind of think that's where a lot of this stems from, hitting the right notes consistently is one of those things that doesn't sound particularly impressive when listening even if it is a technically impressive skill, it's kind of like how bad 3dcg sticks out like a sore thumb while nobody notices the stuff done well.

>> No.653432

>>652510
>I think it's just one stubborn Suisei gachikoi.

While Hoshiyomi, delusional or not, are no doubt involved, I honestly think it's more of a JP vs EN thing. And I doubt any amount of paragraphs with timestamps and point-by-point analysis is ever going to settle that. Which shouldn't necessarily discourage you from writing your stuff, since I at least enjoy reading them.

T: Suiseifag

>> No.653483

>>652977
When I get hired as a holostar you will know.

>> No.653522

>>653432
Based and thanks.

>> No.653576

>>653187
>Easily the best ID member
Considering Risu is also exceptional, I don't know if it's so easy to call a winner there. But both of them are sadly underrated as hell.

>> No.653608
File: 146 KB, 238x216, 1613025358193.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
653608

>>653483
yeah im sure anon
vocaroo or you're completely full of shit

>> No.653985

I think this might be Noel's single greatest vocal performance. Which, again, is not really saying much, but I think it's clearly above almost all other attempts.

https://youtu.be/54SaJFKJQzE

>> No.654046

>>653985
It's sad that her best song is the one she could just kind of talk through

>> No.654146

>>653576
Moona is a good singer among Hololive. I'd put her on Matsuri level. Risu is a good singer on a professionally trained for a decade plus level. I feel comfortable saying she's the best in Hololive by far.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iROjR5VdWJU

>> No.654322
File: 1.67 MB, 228x498, 1604605401153.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
654322

>>654146
Risu is fantastic

>> No.654777
File: 91 KB, 850x1204, moonasuki.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
654777

>>653187
the center and the flagship of hololive indonesia generation 1. check her out if you haven't, she's a good holo singer. also check her gen mates out, Lofi and Risu.

>> No.654841

>>653576
they're both good in their own way. like moona is more of a cool/passion type idol while risu is more of a cutesy type.

>> No.654847

>>653608
>vocaroo
Do you know literally nothing about audio quality.

>> No.654876

>>654322
Only Risu would say something like this

>> No.654877

>>652420
#TeamSuzy

>> No.654923

>>635535
Coco is for Karaoke with Friends

>> No.654941
File: 9 KB, 250x187, hlg.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
654941

>>654847
stop making excuses you pathetic liar
you aren't a good singer and your appeal to authority is pure horseshit
take your meds

>> No.655078

>>654941
Oh you're one of the /hlg/ no capital schizos, hahaha.

>> No.655198

>>638688
>>>/trash/vtsg

>> No.655281

>>647615
Die, you kike nigger faggot, don't even breathe in my direction

>> No.655359
File: 55 KB, 463x453, 1612555707353.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
655359

>>654941
>/hlg/ no capital schizos
what the fuck are you rambling about

>> No.656137

>>655359
He's deflecting criticism, what else? It's all he's been doing this whole thread.

>> No.657153

>>652583
>Noel is absolutely tone deaf to the point I feel like she has to be doing it on purpose
She has meniere.

>> No.658343

>>651146
>manages to put more emotion and feeling into her singing than most of the others too.
I mostly agree with about about her technical skill but this is a lie.

>>
Reply to thread [?]Don't expect anything heroic. Your post will not be uploaded to the original board.
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action