[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/vt/ - Virtual Youtubers

View post   
  [?]In ghost mode, only threads with non-archived posts will be shown
File: 88 KB, 333x1080, 317566_135793.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
619359 No.619359 [Reply] [Original]

ITT: Wasted artists

Ignoring any opinion of the actual vtuber, this is honestly my least favorite Huke design

>> No.619509

Robocco is the worst Hololive design.

>> No.619547

>>619359
was this supposed to be kamen rider gimmick? sword & shield looks funny. should have replace it with assault rifle

>> No.619745

>>619547
Holos get to influence their design. Knowing kiara, she chose the sword and shield because she likes RPG games. Chose the phoenix theme because of her roommate's backstory. Then decided to add the second hat because of HAHA chicken. Then asked for the skirt to stop right under her asscheeks and for big tits. Ending up with a design that's a hodgepodge of ideas and no single dominating theme.

>> No.619787

way too much orange.

>> No.619793

>>619547
If it is, it'd be because of Huke, because Kiara said she's not some Power Rangers dweeb
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q8-83QMx35g

>> No.619819

>>619745
I mean, at this point you could still make it work. Why does she have a belt, a sword and a shield that look like plastic toys? I don't think she's a secret sentai fan.
But now that I think about it maybe the sword, shield and belt are intended to be fast food toys? Like McDonald's Happy Meal? When you look at it this way it kind of makes sense

>>619793
Bad taste

>> No.619887
File: 213 KB, 333x1080, kiara_fix.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
619887

Fixing Kiara's design in 3 easy steps!!

>> No.619918

>>619887
Something about this feels cursed

>> No.619931

>>619819
I think the weird looking sword and shield are Huke's decision. Off the top of my head, his only other design I can think of that uses saturated colors is F/GO Altera. And her sword looks fucking retarded too.

>> No.619940

>>619887
Great work, you made it less..ugh

>> No.619942
File: 2.29 MB, 1418x1954, Astel_Leda_by_中村エイト.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
619942

>>619359
I don't know if this applies to the topic, but I feel like Astel actually looks good in 2D artwork, it's just that his avatar is bad with the toothpaste hair and all that.

>> No.619984

>>619942
Homostar designs should be based on gigachads

>> No.620005
File: 215 KB, 333x1080, yellow.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
620005

>>619940
>>619918
Yellow chicken!

>> No.620038
File: 14 KB, 340x425, 1600403859284.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
620038

>>619931
I think if you see her as some kind of fictional mascot for a fast-food chain it makes sense. She's like Ronald McDonald, Hololive version

>>619787
I like orange, and orange and blue go well together. Her hair is nice. The colors are not the problem

>> No.620039
File: 163 KB, 1200x1155, Shinove.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
620039

>>619984
>when the manager's design looks better than the talents

>> No.620076

>>620039
Plain designs always look good when in the middle of nonplain design because they have the "not even trying" aura, just like with A-chan and Enma

>> No.620178

>>620076
Exactly. And there’s also that one homostar with the dark skin and really fucking weird outfit. Jeez just fucking show a simple man with a based chin and shit who knows how to entertain like say, Sovietwomble, and I’d actually watch

>> No.620216

>>620178
I agree, however I think the Holostars were targetted at fujos and fujos are known for having awful taste in clothes/design

>> No.620326

>>620178
They're targeted at fujoshis and asian fujoshis don't want manly chins. In fact, they had a bunch of homostars that looked like chicks but they all retired.

>> No.620470

>>619887
>no visible, toned tummy
>no thighdentation
Ask me how I know you're a faggot.

>> No.620626

>>619359
She has the worst design out of any of the EN in my opinion
too much going on and nothing makes sense

>> No.621072

>>619359
not only is this meh for a Huke design, but it's also wasted on this retard

>> No.621115

>>619787
>>620038
Too much bright color though. The design would be better with more muted colors and the bright orange would be used as the highlight color here and there.

>> No.621126

>thighigh skindentation, shirt skirt, MIDRIFF
nothing wrong with it other than the sword and shield really

>> No.621312

>>621126
none of it looks natural though that's the problem
if you can organically do it then all the better
but if it's forced and weird looking then it's making the design worse

>> No.621358

>>621115
Maybe you're right, but I think that applies to almost all holos, considering they look better with casual clothes with small nods to their original designs

>> No.621453
File: 1.05 MB, 1280x720, 1589702476842.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
621453

ITT: retards. The design is fucking great.

>> No.621499

>>621453
>no arguments
>didn't read the thread
Sure anon

>> No.621538

>>621453
>has to crop out 98% of the design to prove that the design is "great"

>> No.621688

>hating 2hats
42% yourselves. The real problems are the colour scheme, toy sword & shield and those fucking chicken drumsticks.

>> No.621711

>>621688
The real problem is the whole "KFP" bullshit

>> No.621790

>>621711
Lol. You don't watch her, you can't provide meaningful input.

>> No.621810

>>621790
We're talking about her design anon, can you read?

>> No.621886

>>621810
The most successful and liked thing both by streamer and her audience can't be a "real problem".

>> No.621927

>>621886
"Ignoring any opinion of the actual vtuber", can you read anon? It makes her design a mess. The fact that Kiara uses it very well, that she likes it and her audience likes it is not what's discussed here. This is not an attack on Kiara, this is a critique of her character design and only that

>> No.621985

>>621453
Shoulders up is amazing. Just her clothing is weird.

>> No.622005
File: 61 KB, 739x415, images (15).jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
622005

>>619359
I think Kiara may look cool with a dress like this (Triss, Witcher 3), just with some more orange to fit the theme better. Maybe even a fade like her hair.

>> No.622235
File: 78 KB, 1258x784, 1599954975456.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
622235

>>619359
I think I pinpointed my dislike for the design. It's reminiscent of 60's/70's flight attendants, rather than a fast food worker.
If she wants to be the CEO, it should be more sensible, if she wants to be a warrior it should be more practical, if she's working the fryers herself, then it shouldn't be so revealing.
Just look at her genmates, everyone's look showcases who they are, but Kiara looks... fuck, it might be genius. It looks like she doesn't know who she is or what she wants to be.

>> No.622282

>>622005
this suits reine more than kiara. color scheme and dress reminds me of peacock.

>> No.622287

>>622235
As I said, she's the Ronald McDonald of KFP so her design makes sense >>620038. Her pretending to be the CEO doesn't though, she's the mascot. The phoenix part, you can link that to her old looking design (like you said, 60's/70's flight attendant), and have the story of how the mascot of KFP wants to revive the company that died a long time ago

>> No.622304

>>619887
>no thighs
Queer

>> No.622370
File: 2.01 MB, 1419x1108, 1589720035032.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
622370

>>621499
What arguments? It's just meaningless shit that is parroted since the debut.
>didn't read the thread
It sure is full of professional designers.

>> No.622406

>>622235
I think it was what huke tried to achieve, he might have done his reps or kiara told him about her life and he made the character based on that, i disliked it at first for being a clusterfuck of things but it's a good representation of her life, the small white hat is probably the only thing that realy bothers me its fucking ugly but i do like the berret.

>> No.622529

>>622370
Sure anon, here's the Kiara thread to discuss her with like-minded anons, I think you would like it here >>606307

>> No.622761

>>619887
Zero soul. Try again.

>> No.623498

>>619359
I think Kiara's design is pure sex, I just don't like her personality

>> No.623538

>>619509
Yeah, I like the A2 "clothes" design, but she needs to ditch the sweater

>> No.623549

>>619359
it actually doesn't feel Huke to me. if i didn't know who her papa is, i wouldn't even recognize Huke in her design.

>> No.623582
File: 384 KB, 590x684, unhmymcpmet51.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
623582

>>619942
I like Astel's design, i think his general space theme with his hair looking like the middle of the space with stars and shit looks great, i dislike his outfit with the kimono though he looks weirdly... fat, as if he had pads on his shoulders and arms

>> No.623616

>>620626
Might be tied with Gura, the body is fine, but having the shark jacket on top of it just feels like overkill. Would be better if the mouth section was actually cut out

>> No.623794

Make the outfit a little less lewd, get rid of her toys and the weird fast food theme, and make her a flight attendant. I think it works.

>> No.624540

>>622529
No, that thread is such a hugbox! I want to stay here and provide humble criticism for Hololive™ English Takanashi Kiara's desing.

>> No.626889

>>619745
>Then decided to add the second hat because of HAHA chicken.
nailed
>>619819
implying she is capable of nuances, which i doubt

>> No.626927

>>619359
>Jenma: So... you want to be a warrior, a pheonix... a fast food ceo.... and an idol? Don't you think you're wearing too many hats?
>Kiara: chottou matte

>> No.626983

>>619359
What was Huke thinking? This is repulsive.

>> No.627051

>>619359
The sword and shield thing could have worked if she didn't go with a fucking fast food theme.

>> No.627155

>>619359
Not a big fan of the design ether, that weird watermelon esque color scheme bothers the heck
out of me.

>> No.627303

Kiara's design is fucking insane and that's why I've come to love it. The character is clearly insane, doubling as both a hero in multiple lives and a tyrannical manager of a KFC mixed with Hooters. The sword and shield don't match because they're not needed for her current existence.
She's a complete mess and that's why it's fun.
Her next costume should add another hat or swap the two for even less logical ones.

>> No.627651

It's just amazing how unfocused Kiara's outfit is compared to everyone else. Like, everyone else you get a sense of what they're about just by looking at them. Their accessories also make sense.

>Ame
Oh, she's a detective (name is also a giveaway)
>Gura
Oh, she's a shark girl
>Mori
Edgy reaper
>Ina
Edgy eldritch girl

Admittedly, Ina and Mori aren't immediately obvious but they are still thematically consistent. Then you have Kiara.

She looks like a slutty orange flight attendant and her default accessories are the sword and board instead of the drumsticks. She's also supposed to be a Phoenix but the strongest phoenix motif is her feather earrings whereas Ina is the one who actually had wings. First impressions are important.

>> No.628452

>>627651
Ina is VERY consistent if you've seen the artists' other works of eldritch horror girls.

>> No.628524

I like how she looks but not the outfit. I want a casual darker outfit or something. It'll definitely get people to watch her more. I hope she doesn't go with that frog shit she keeps mentioning and waste her new outfit opportunity

>> No.629314

>>627651
i think that kinda hits the nail on the head for kiara. She went too hard to be an attractive IRL girl with very light cosplay instead of her actual theme. The sword and shield also look like nerf toys.

>> No.632179

>>619359
The sword/shield is what ruins it. Too many concepts at once

>> No.632205

>>619509
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nsxWN7S8Ivo

>> No.632294

>>619359
I think the toku stuff is based but it sadly doesn't fit that well with the rest of the design

>> No.632326

>>621453
Her face/hair are quite good but her overall outfit is literally the worst in Holo.

>> No.632363

>>619509
no it's that zombie chick

>> No.632395

>>632363
Ollie’s design is nice but it’s too inhuman looking for Hololive, I’d say.

>> No.632657

>>632179
Yeah, it seriously comes across as teenage DeviantArt tier shit, going "what if we took a fast food worker - and gave her a weird futuristic Servant-looking version of a fast food outfit? What kind of hat should she wear? Beret or one of those little cap things they put on turkeys? Fuck it, both! Also damn, I forgot I like Toku so I want her to have that too.. I know, she'll have a Toku sword and shield too!"

As far as I can tell Holos generally have a fair amount of input/guidance in the design these days (originally they had 0 input) so literally it's possible Kiara herself fucked it over and refused to take advice, because that sounds exactly like her tendency let's be honest. Of course she has weird two-tone hair too like all fucking shit OCs; I'm surprised her eyes are the same color.

>> No.632708

>>632657
No I want Huke papa to release the original concept desings before kiara's suggestions to see how much better she would have looked

>> No.632727

>>632179
lol i thought op photoshopped those in

>> No.633082

>>619359
It would be nice if she didn't wear both hats at the same time.

>> No.633172
File: 237 KB, 469x1011, chicken.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
633172

>>622761
>>622304
How about if she looked more like the KFP manager she is!

>> No.633372

>>633172
This actually looks really good

>> No.633485

>>633172
yeah this is like 75% better easiliy

>> No.633579

>>633172
I disagree with losing the exposed belly but otherwise I like it.

>> No.633624
File: 89 KB, 262x262, tumblr_41b99d10caaa658e7a37ac8ef01151ac_1efedd63_400.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
633624

>>633579
i think losing the midriff but keeping the absolute territory is sexier

>> No.633705

>>633172
I like that design a lot more. The main issues with it though is the bottom of the blouse area and the turquoise green in her hair.
I feel like there should either be a middriff there or the bottom should be lower. The turquoise worked better in the old design due to it being more present in the costume. A more deeper blue/only making the hair orange would look a lot nicer and consistant.

>> No.633787

>>620039
For the longest time I thought this dude was just another talent promoting the others because no one else would.

>> No.633998
File: 230 KB, 469x1011, chicken2.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
633998

>>633705
I see. I gave her heeled mary janes too

>> No.634026

>>633998
The sleeves are a bit too long. Looks like it doesn't fit properly.

>> No.634040

>>633998
>Fast food
>Heels
You need to get a fucking job anon.

>> No.634042

>>633998
Looks good anon

>> No.634045

>>634026
Long puffy sleeves are cute you fucking hack

>> No.634132
File: 226 KB, 469x1011, chicken3.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
634132

>>634026
shorter sleeves

>>634040
sorry I'm NEET. Here's some crocs.

>> No.634134

>>634040
She's the boss, not the wagie behind the counter.

>> No.634155

imo people would dislike the design less if the person behind it wasn't so obnoxious.

>> No.634338

>>634132
That's better
>>634134
>Middle management in fast food doesn't work
You ALSO need to get a job

>> No.634361

>>634338
Well then how about CEO?, not store manager

>> No.634390

>>634361
She explicitly says she's a store manager, damn son. Reps. Besides, flats are hot.

>> No.638258

>>623616
What are you saying? She only has a grey shirt without the jacket.

>> No.638481

>>634132
add a single blue line in the skirt and make the end of the sleeves tight to her hands

>> No.638836
File: 220 KB, 469x1011, chicken4.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
638836

>>638481
I did 2!

>> No.638897

>>638258
Yeah, they could give her something naval themed without the "btw did you notice I'm a SHARK" jacket

>> No.639063

>>619359
She looks hella cute without the hats desu. I don't know what is it about Kiara's design that isn't as appealing as the others, but I hope she gets a better alt costume in the future.

>>
Reply to thread [?]Don't expect anything heroic. Your post will not be uploaded to the original board.
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action