[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/vt/ - Virtual Youtubers

View post   
  [?]In ghost mode, only threads with non-archived posts will be shown
File: 266 KB, 698x1294, 1696234040431820.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
59749551 No.59749551 [Reply] [Original]

>JP Talents = Year-over-year growth
>EN Talents = Year-over-year decline
What are the JP girls doing differently than the EN girls to be so consistently successful? How did the EN branch fall so hard?

>> No.59749865

EN viewers simply aren't corpo-friendly, at least in the Japanese-style "owns your entire IP and persona" sense

>> No.59749964

>>59749551
What could've possibly happened in 2022? Hmmm, this is a noodle scratcher

>> No.59750141

>>59749964
StarsEN happened

>> No.59750151

The vast majority of JP talents stream even when their health is declining. EN talents actively look for any reason to not stream. It’s the difference between loving your job and loving a paycheck.

>> No.59750388

>>59749551
EN has no market to grow in. Vtubers are inherently cringe outside of Japan. At this point just about any westerner who doesn't want to watch hololive isn't going to change their mind. That's why Gura and Mori - the two with the most JP fans - are the most successful. People will blame the talents for it, and yeah they weren't perfect, but I think overall they did well. EN could not have done anything to stop their decline without also sacrificing their image. the whole tempiss situation seemed like a failed attempt to get holoEN a way wider audience.

>> No.59750684

>>59750151
>Posting this when you can look at the graph and the 2 JPs with the highest numbers both barely streamed

>> No.59750762

>>59749551
Is more about the target audience, JOPs are abandoning real life more and more and joining the vtuber audience, while the west has the attention span of a child is already moving to the next thing.

>> No.59750890

>>59749551
>decline
the amount of subs is still going up though?

>> No.59751357

>>59749551
>Juufuutei
She's a niji even in the name sense, ew

>> No.59751674

>>59750684
I’m not going to walk you through the definition of the word “majority.” Either figure it out yourself or die, I don’t care which.

>> No.59751906

>>59750388
Yeah, this sums it up well. EN’s decline is due to a mix of the fad waning in the west and Cover trying to replicate Niji’s success in Luxiem and (to a degree) Noctyx, only to completely go 0 for 2 (StarsJP and Tempiss) and double down on top of that.

>> No.59752033

>>59751674
Yeah, and the point is that the girls who are streaming more aren't necessarily the ones getting bigger growth so your post doesn't answer the OP.

>> No.59752061

>>59751906
Honestly I don't understand why people even talk about EN declining. I guess most of this board just lives in a bubble and forgets that almost everyone outside of it is a normie. Even I was a normie till I watched pikamee. If not for her I would still be one. I wouldn't be in vtuber hell if not for her being so damn funny and entertaining. Fuck you pikamee

>> No.59752361

>>59749551
>What are the JP girls doing differently than the EN girls to be so consistently successful?
streaming

>> No.59752701

I hope gura graduates so the entire branch can just crumble.

>> No.59752783

>>59752061
more people watch vtubers on Twitch than nijiEN and holoEN combined these days, but you wouldn't know going from /vt/

>> No.59752911

>Gura only does mandated big event streams so her CCV remains high

>> No.59753269
File: 2.97 MB, 411x452, 1692991937843667.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
59753269

>>59749551

>> No.59753541

Holy shit you would expect ReGloss to be worse than Advent but it's the opposite.

>> No.59753871

>stream games in english
>don't stream on the biggest platform for streaming games as english speakers

They're already at a handicap, every successive EN gen will just continue to cannibalise the existing viewer base rather than expand it. Doesn't help that whoever they use to get perms for games is a complete failure so they're stuck streaming the leftovers of shit that the JP crew streamed years ago.

>> No.59754178

>>59753871
But anon youtube pays like 5 big twitch streamers millions of dollars each to stream on their platform, which they would not be doing otherwise, TWITCH IS DYING!!!! LUDWIG TOLD ME SO!!!

>> No.59754200

>>59753871
That's some incredible cope

>> No.59754318

>>59753269
Sui-chan number one!

>> No.59754518

>>59753871
shill more, twitch troon

>> No.59754535

>>59750890
It's impossible to lose subs unless you get culled (which only happens to pre-debut holos) or commit a massive yab, at worst you'll have dead subs.

>> No.59754823

>>59749551
Are you sure that the likes of Mel, Aki, Matsuri, Polka and Choco are growing?

>> No.59755031

>>59752783
Why did Hololive and Nijisanji fail to hold onto these viewers?

>> No.59755777

>>59754823
Why mention Polka? She's doing fine

>> No.59755843

>>59754518
Enjoy your inferior streaming product

>> No.59755933

>>59755777
Just 5000 ccv seems low for her, figured it would be more like 6000-7000 or so.

>> No.59756986

>>59755933
Polka along with Risu are the most disappointing talents in the entire company. So much wasted potential.

>> No.59757936

>>59753269
Suisei is worth more than all Vshojo

>> No.59758021

>>59749551
Why is Gura like this?

>> No.59758052

Every time you blame men for the reason your oshi isn't growing as fast as she used to, Gura's delays her stream another 24 hours.

>> No.59758091

>>59749865
retarded cuck

>> No.59758184

>>59758021
What's hilarious is that she could have easily just said she has health issues. She does not give a fuck lol

>> No.59758277

>>59749551
Vtubers are a niche in the EN streaming market. Vtubers increasingly are the JP streaming market. If you look at a list of the top streamers in Japan, it's dominated by vtubers.

>> No.59758426

>>59758277
grim

>> No.59758473

>>59753269
Oh I fucking love this gif, thank you anon

>> No.59758746

>>59750684
While you're technically correct, I think it's worth pointing out that those two actively create content/participate in events aside from streaming (Suisei with music, covers and concerts, Marine with shorts/TikTok, covers and singles) which goes to prove what I think was the core of that anon's point

>> No.59759921

now post nijEN

>> No.59760086

>>59756986
I still remember when people found out who she was and how much early on she seemed to have special access to Yagoo for content. I really thought she had the potential to take off and make her mark. She still provides great entertainment every so often but it really feels like she didn't meet those early expectations when everyone went bonkers for her at the very start.

>> No.59760322

>>59754535
Then it's not in a decline.
Thread over

>> No.59760911

>>59753541
As much as some people on /vt/ are trying to depict ReGloss as a failure, they are actually entertaining in their own different ways. Ao might be an exception because from what I've seen she's struggling to find a way to make people interested in her.

>>59760086
The problem is that Polka isn't consistent, except for Polden. But I don't think that Polden can attract new people. Streams are much better to attract new people, but you need to be consistent in the vtuber sphere to have a chance to build a bigger audience. However, as everyone says, Polka is the type that only can work either on 0 or 100 percent.

>> No.59761652

>>59749551
Stop sorting crap by average CCV, that only matters in /#/. Hours watched is the relevant metric in the rest of the world.

>> No.59762056

>>59753541
>>59760911
Comparison of monetization streams according to Playboard in USD
Bijou 14,204
Shiori 19,712
Nerissa 20,298
Fuwamoco 26,539 (split between 2 chuubas)
Advent total 80,753

Ao 7,600
Hajime 16,181
Kanade 26,071
Ririka 34,491
Raden 48,941
ReGloss total 133,284

Outside of Ao being a colossal failure, DevIs branch will do better than EN every gen. Since this gives is a very good picture of the current market since they only debuted a month apart. Now we know why Yagoo didn't want to ACCELERATE the EN branch cus it just isn't worth it in comparison to the JP market. He spent all his time to make a side JP branch that makes more money than EN.

>> No.59762189

>>59761652
hours watched is now a shit metric with twitch vtubers spamming dono/subathons. 24/7 stream online running vods while they sleep, it's the reason why ironmouse is one of the highest hours watched even though her average streams are 7k vs pekora 25k

>> No.59762334

>>59749551
The English indie scene is a hundred times more robust than the Japanese indie scene, and Hololive's "walled city" approach isn't as appealing. People discover vtubers outside of them, then they never get to see the Holos interact with them. The content they enjoy gets stale, and non-Holo vtubers are inclining.

There you go. There's the answer. Feel free to seethe.

>> No.59762621

>>59762189
How you feel about them doesn't matter, it's the main metric Youtube uses to figure how much viewers are engaging with your channel.

>> No.59764960

>>59761652
The top ccv talents happen to be the biggest merch movers. You're fucking retarded

>> No.59765064

>>59750151
You are aware that HoloEN actually has *higher* average streaming hours per chuuba than HoloJP, right?
They just have significantly less members to fill the gap so even a single absence is way more obvious

>> No.59765318

>>59762621
Youtube (and YT streamers themselves) has access to the actual hours watched metric (which isn't publicly available), though.
The "hours watched" you see in OP or sites like StreamHatchet is a meme one calculated by average CCV x stream hours, which is nowhere nearly as accurate.

>> No.59765339

>>59758184
A liar is sooner caught than a cripple

>> No.59765492
File: 1.09 MB, 3176x3995, 1696201154640147.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
59765492

>>59749551
nijien flopped deflection thread

>> No.59765499

>>59765064
Lawl
Lemao even.
I'm sure you have the figures to back that up

>> No.59765637
File: 14 KB, 758x126, StreamHours_Holo_June2023.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
59765637

>>59765499
Surprise, surprise, I actually do. See picrel
(It's a bit outdated now since it was before Advent debuted, but the point stands)

>> No.59765979

>>59765318
Sir, please don't waste your time trying to educate a Vshotard

>> No.59766171

>>59765339
Probably the only talent who I hope accidently exposes herself with an incriminating accidental RM post or discord dm. The schadenfreude would be insane.

>> No.59766179

Vtuber niche is dying in the west.

>> No.59766475

>>59766179
Seems pretty healthy on twitch

>> No.59766788

>>59762056
I will never understand the mindset that makes someone compare four people to five, end up with a 50k difference and calls one branch a failure
Not to mention the 50k came entirely from one person

>> No.59767447

>>59766788
Even if you theoretically doubled Fuwamoco it wouldn't even really matter cus you can say the same thing about Ao cus she might as well not even exist. If you replaced Ao with a reasonably successful chuuba and doubled Fuwamoco it would still end up with DevIs on top. And that 50k from one person is exactly why the JP market is more profitable than EN, the ceiling is way higher for gachis over there.

>> No.59769206

>>59767447
The point is that painting 4 people earning 80k as a bad thing because they didn't earn 130k is retarded.
And your point is doubly retarded considering regloss also has a far lower floor but here you are trying to paint it as five radens, just like retards like >>59750151 who try to paint the JP branch as 40 koyoris

>> No.59769721

>>59769206
NTA but that loops back to ops original question of Why does JP do better than EN, Why did most members of ReGloss(sans Ao) match or beat FWMC in SC despite having many debuffs on debut, is it something EN as a whole did or were Advent just not as appealing as JP or is Gachi culture just bigger in JP.

>> No.59770286

JP streaming culture sort of grew together with vtubing as they started to go away from NND and to youtube and twitch. EN on the other hand had already had a healthy streaming culture for like a decade, so instead of becoming a central part of it vtubers just got their own little corner to sit in. It also doesn't help that EN corpo vtubers are behind on stuff like turning streams into shorter videos, which is something tons of normal streamers see most of their success in.

>> No.59770397

>>59749551
JP viewers are mindless drones who unironically like mobile games and Nintendo slop, and thus easier to please. The melon game? instant GOTY for them

>> No.59770638

>>59769206
Of course 80K is good for any vtuber corpo, but we're comparing Regloss/DevIs to Advent/EN. This is one of those moments in time where you can compare the markets to see exactly where they are at cus they both debuted within a month of each other. The pecking order now goes JP-DevIs-EN as a priority/investment in the future for Yagoo.
And nowhere in my post did I state there was 5 Radens, there's only one. As for the lower floor that is purely on Ao as a character not DevIs or Regloss as a whole. Who is Ao pandering to? males? females? Why is her avatar and outfit so bad? Ao is clearly not the norm, if she was replaced by a more standard character that pandered to the regular male otaku audience she would do much better. If Ao was in the main JP branch she would still perform just as bad.

>> No.59770744

There's a few things to consider.
A: twitch is way more popular with streamers in the west than YouTube is, while that's slowly starting to change due to the terrible policies of twitch, YouTube is piss poor at recommending vtubers these days.

B: anime has only in recent years become something that's actually talked about in a positive light in the west and even then it's mainly with adult (18+) males and of course that demographic tends to work full time jobs.

C: Vtubers from Japanese corps like hololive get preferential treatment over their en counterparts with constant events and concerts and ads and appearances all over the place in Japan with next to no money spent advertising in the west. Unironically fans do a better job advertising than the company

>>
Reply to thread [?]Don't expect anything heroic. Your post will not be uploaded to the original board.
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action