[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/vt/ - Virtual Youtubers

View post   
  [?]In ghost mode, only threads with non-archived posts will be shown
File: 69 KB, 640x487, 2j7dk3xmcaw61.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3433058 No.3433058 [Reply] [Original]

well they're all out now, rank the new outfits

>> No.3433487

>>3433058
Ina>Ame>Calli>Gura>>>Kiara

>> No.3433664

>>3433487
my list exactly.

>> No.3433719

Ame> Kiara> Calli> Gura> Ina

>> No.3433830
File: 45 KB, 156x272, 1620354361674.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3433830

>>>3433058
>Amelia
>Ina
>Kiara
>Mori
>Gura
All given pic related

>> No.3433904

Amelia>Kiara>Calli>Shit>Ina>Dogshit>Gura

>> No.3433967

>>3433487
absolute shit taste. please seriously consider suicide

>> No.3434454

>>3433058
I'd rather rank the reveals.
>Calli
Bit of a generic reveal, but she was so excited and the mini concert was nice. Costume and rigging were probably the best.
>Kiara
She gets a lot of shit on here, but the shopping skit was neat. The costume itself is an improvement on her original outfit but what the fuck is that pacifier about? She's already a little too obsessed with the cat ears, which make her look more like a fox anyway.
>Ina
Ina's my favourite HoloEN, but I've got admit the reveal and costume were unerwhelming. It's not terrible, but the costume itself is a little bland. comfy atmosphere all the same, which is what I expect of Ina.
>Gura
Oho, what a trainwreck. The reveal was the most generic thing I've seen, and the costume itself revealed why. It's the worst rigging I've seen for Holo, and the fact this was given to the biggest member of the group was awful. I hope Gura herself is feeling okay, it wasn't her fault.
>Ame
The best reveal, the creativity here was incredible although we found out that teamates are sadly retarded and can't follow basic instructions. The costume itself is cute.

>> No.3434963

>>3433058
Ame's is the best objectively

>> No.3435028

Ame > Ina > Kiara > Mori > Gura

Not really up for debate.

>> No.3435162

Ame>Ina>Kiara>My Hairy Balls>Gura>Calli

I like Gura but they really fucked up her style man.

>> No.3435212

>Kiara
Ebin memes. Lolololol chickun
>Calli
Fred Durst levels of try hard.
>Ina
Simple and effective, the Ipad was a nice touch
>Gura
So much hype for a squished face design.
>Ame
Used her stream persona on her favour, with Bubba and the Cafe.

I would say each costume made justice to their personalities and fanbase.

>> No.3435331
File: 2.22 MB, 1920x1080, 1620436404927.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3435331

>>3433058
We at least know which one is the worst.
>Bruh, look at this dude. Wait till you see the f- oh no no no no oh ho ho OoOoOoO- HA HA HA! LOOK AT THE TOP OF HER HEAD!

>> No.3435370

>>3433487
Kiara>Ame=Ina>Mori>Gura

>> No.3436863

>>3433058
Ame=Cali>Kiara>Ina=Gura

>> No.3436982

>>3433058
If we are just talking about the outfits themselves.

1. Gura
2. Ame
3. Kiara
4. Ina
5. Calli

>> No.3437491

>>3433058
Ame>Ina>Calli>Gura>>>Kiara

>> No.3437524

Ame>Kiara>Ina>>>>Gura>>>>>>Mori

>> No.3437593

>>3433058
Mori = Ame > Kiara > Ina > Gura

>> No.3437703

Ina: Cute!
Mori: Cute!
Ame: Cute!
Gura: Cute!
Kiara: Cute!

>> No.3437725
File: 220 KB, 1024x575, E00qgnGUcAQpCbm (1).jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3437725

>Ame!
>Ame!
>Ame!
>Ame!
>Ame!

>> No.3437870

>>3433058
By overall outfits

Ina>Kiara>Ame>>>>>>>>>Calli>>>>>>>>>>>bulltesticles>>>>>>>>>>>Gura

Going by reveal

Ame>Kiara>Calli>>>>>Ina>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Gura
Going by how much of an upgrade the outfit is

Kiara>>>>>>>>>>Ame>Ina>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Calli>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Gura

>> No.3437902

Ame-Had the best stream most creative a wide variety of attachments and her outfit was in character especially with all the bubbabits. Ame managed to become cuter than she was yesterday.

Ina-She had a pretty normal stream but the house was a nice touch and very well put together. Her outfit had a great mix of attachments was perfectly in character and was really cute possibly cutest

Kiara-Pacifier/Ears aside its a really nice outfit had a lot of cool attachments stood out from everyone elses. The Paci and ears are extras but may not be for everyone. Overall while it was more sexy with the Daisy duke look while while jump Holo Gorge in the General Yagoo it was still pretty cute

Cali-It was a pretty normal stream. Nothing whatsoever was wrong with it and it had a lot of moving parts that all fit well. The worst thing I could say is it was fairly simple and predictable but still manages to be pretty cute

Gura-Ok we know it has problems. The tiny hole the head shape the plainness of the ears. Beyond that though the rest of the outfit actually looks pretty nice with a couple little attachments similar to her hairpins cute feet and a Bloopbag.. It was going great up until the mid-way point. Gura probably deserved some more development effort/time and definitely needs more attachments like her trident and maybe a hat/bow between the ears but Gura will still be cute no matter what

>> No.3439999

Ame>The rest don't fucking matter

>> No.3440068

Kiara>ame>ina>calli>gura

>> No.3440582
File: 175 KB, 828x828, IMG_2944.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3440582

Ame>Kiara>Mori>Ina>Gura
My ranking is objectively correct

>> No.3440770
File: 337 KB, 525x525, ina_forehead.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3440770

Personal preference:

Ina >= Ame > Kiara > Calli >> Gura

Complexity/competency in art/rigging:

Kiara > Ame > Calli, Ina >>>>>>>> Gura

>> No.3440829
File: 129 KB, 625x506, 1619792851140.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3440829

>>3433058
>using the inferior reddit version
I see you redditorfag

>> No.3440866

Ame > Gura > Ina > Mori > Kiara

Yes despite guras shitty riggin

>> No.3441194
File: 1.72 MB, 220x220, 1610589032095.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3441194

>>3433058
Ame > Ina > Kiara = Mori > Gura

>> No.3441213

>>3433058
Kiara>Calli>Ame>Ina>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Gura

>> No.3441490

Ame>Ina>Calli>Kiara>Gura

>> No.3441491
File: 13 KB, 379x374, 1601764663178.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3441491

>>3433058
>Cat ears

>> No.3441524

In terms of quality:
Ame>Calli>Kiara>Ina>Gura
In terms of personal taste:
Ina>Ame>Gura>Kiara>Calli

>> No.3441559

>>3433058
Ame -> Ina -> Gura -> Kiara - Calli

>> No.3441643

Ame > Mori > Gura > Kiara > Ina

just on design not rigging since Gura's is fucked.

>> No.3441650

Based on aesthetics:
Ina>Gura>Ame>Calli>Kiara
None are bad except for Kiara, but that's just because huke's artstyle isn't really the best for a vtuber, everything below the waist is atrociously rendered. You can tell he put some extra effort into the main model but now I just assume it was because it was his first time and he was getting paid handsomely for it.

>> No.3441668

>>3434454
Why do people think they can't follow instructions and weren't just ignoring instructions? It was obvious trolling.

>> No.3441685

>>3435331
Stop posting this image, i will literally commit Zhang Genocide if I see this shit one more time

>> No.3441764

Anyone who isn't putting Gura dead last is trolling or doesn't love Gura.

>> No.3441776
File: 133 KB, 290x430, gura1.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3441776

Outfit:
Ame>Gura>Calli>Kiara>Ina
Reveal Stream:
Ame>Kiara>Calli>Ina=Gura

>> No.3441881

>>3441764
Why? The outfit itself is nice and the side ponytail is cute, makes her look like a sassy brat.

>> No.3441884

>>3441764
I still have some faith that they will actually fix at least some of the issues, but time will tell

>> No.3442069
File: 292 KB, 594x424, 1620444959444.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3442069

>>3433058
Outfit:
Ame>Kiara>Mori>Ina>Gura.
Stream:
Ame
V
Ina=Mori>Kiara>Gura.

>> No.3442082

>>3441881
I don't hate it, it's just kind of underwhelming especially after showing all the ideas people came up with from the silhouette, plus the rigging makes it 10x worse.

>> No.3442144

>>3433487
just by the design of the outfit (quality of rigging for Gura and shading for Kiara excluded) I have this list in the exact opposite direction.

If I take the rigging into the equation, it gets a bit more complicated.

>> No.3442201

>>3433058
Ame>Calli>=Ina>Kiara>>>>Gura

Gura's outfit is retarded even without the rigging problem.

>> No.3442329
File: 259 KB, 1393x2048, 1620368073789.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3442329

>>3433058
Gura > Ina > Kiara > Ame > Mori

Gura was top form during her outfit reveal stream and the design by Nacho is top notch.
The rigging does need serious fixing but antis are taking this opportunity to shitpost everything about her outfit and its too far.

>> No.3442330

Ame > Ina = Kiara > Calli >>>>>>>>Gura

>> No.3442572

>>3434454
Had chat followed instructions it would have been a wasted effort. You don't replicate TPP without wanting the anarchy.

>> No.3443098

>>3434454
>although we found out that teamates are sadly retarded and can't follow basic instructions
I guarantee you it was more people being retarded on purpose to get a rise out of Ame.

>> No.3443167

>Outfits
Mori > Ame > Kiara > Ina > Gura

>Revealkino
Ame >>> Kiara > Ina > Mori > Gura

>> No.3443537

>>3433058
Ame > Ina > Mori > Gura

>> No.3443644

>>3433058
Calli>Ina>Gura>Kiara>Ame

>> No.3443767
File: 71 KB, 1024x575, E00qt0MUYAEQAiR.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3443767

Outfit:
Gura = Ame > Ina > Kiara >>>> Calli

Stream:
Ame >>> Kiara > Calli > Ina = Gura

Rigging:
Calli > Kiara > Ina = Ame >>>>>>>>>>> the void >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Gura


Gura and Ame have peaked in the GFE casual outfit department, just perfect summer wear for going out on dates, girly and stylish in every way. Ina falls slightly behind with a more understated design, but it's still really cute and befitting of her. Kiara's outfit screams "I want to appeal to every mainstream weeb demographic" but it still looks fine thanks to Huke papa (in spite of her feet looking weird and her entire design looking desaturated compared to the others), she should use her straw hat more instead of ripping off Gura's cat ears gimmick. Calli's design actually stripped her of any nuances she had with her reaper character and became a basic "I'm a rapper vtuber, see??" outfit that makes her far more one-dimensional than before.

Ame's stream was the best by leaps and bounds, you simply can't compete with someone who got a TPP-like chat interaction program actually coded into her reveal. Kiara's shopping for clothes roleplay was genuine and quaint, and she successfully curve-balled everyone with her cat ears and tail. Calli's reveal was simple, but she held a mini-concert afterwards which was great fanservice for deadbeats. Ina and Gura's reveals were more simplistic but were not necessarily bad: Ina's house exploring and AO-chan making a mess in the background was comfy and lighthearted, and Gura handing out "WOW CUTE" awards to prediction fanart was nice and a solid confidence boost to the artists who were featured, as well as her energetic mood and her delivery on the feet and cat ears reveals.

Calli's rigging was very impressive, getting her long hair to flow as good as it does, and her microphone arm motions are quite decent. Kiara's rigging is well done and has a lot of well-animated bits. Ina and Ame's rigging are serviceable, with no issues to note but also nothing that really wowed me (except maybe Ame's hair). Gura's rigging was a disaster in every level, and there's no way she herself wasn't aware of how bad it was, especially the complete lack of accessories. I hope she gets herself a professional rigger soon instead of keeping this amateur employed, and that the rigging criticisms keep coming until that change is made. Don't let them get away with this crap, Gura deserves better.

>> No.3444201

Ame>Ina>Mori>Kiara>Gura

>> No.3444273

>>3433058
Ina=Ame>Kiara=Callie>Gura(fuck riggers)

>> No.3444366

>>3433487
I don't even agree with the order of your two top spots but I can tell your a man of culture anon. Fpbp.

>> No.3444582

Ame=Ina > Gura > Calli > Kiara
Gura’s outfit is cute and even though she’s my oshi, Ina’s and Ame’s outfit are top notch. Takobros, Teabros, I kneel.

>> No.3444771

Kiara=Ame > Mori > Ina > Gura
I like Mori's from a thematic perspective since it has the utility of being useful whenever Mori wants to go full rapper mode but I believe her original outfit is superior.
from the silhouettes Kiara, Ina and Gura were pretty obvious about what they were going to be but Mori and Ame were more up in the air. I was absolutely blown away by Ame's reveal, I really didn't expect to like her outfit so much.

>> No.3444793

Ame>Ina>Calli>Kiara>Gura
Not even really a fan of Ame but the outfit is top notch. Gura would be third with proper rigging.

>> No.3444975

>>3433058
Interms of how much they make my dick hard:
Calli>=Ame>Kiara>Ina>Gura

In terms of how pleasing they look:
Ame>Ina>Calli>Kiara>Gura

>> No.3444995

Ame > Mori > Kiara >>> Ina >>>>>>>>>>>> Gura

>> No.3445030

>>3443767
>dungarees
>stylish
Fuck off fake Teamate

>> No.3445133

Official objective rankings
Kiara>>>>>>Calli>>Shit>Ina=Ame>>>Gura

>> No.3445162

Ame=Ina>Mori>Gura>Kiara

As a Chumbud, I disliked the rigging and outfit reveal. I was hoping for more accessories on top of her outfit, like a coat, long sleeves, a hat, glasses, alternate hair styles, shorter tridents or fitting bloop like Bubba on Ame's hat but there's none of it.

It's probably the rigger's fault due to time constraints. Nacho-mama probably had them.
The audacity of the rigger to post her work's video with none of the accessories other than taking of the cat ears.

>> No.3445347
File: 427 KB, 629x614, 1602996493362.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3445347

>>3433058
Gura > Ame >>> Ina > Calli > Kiara
Obviously this is just ranking the designs rather then rigging or reveal quality.

>> No.3445379

Kiara>Ina>Ame>Gura>Mori

>> No.3445399
File: 254 KB, 1448x2048, Es6DNB_U4AEWdIP.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3445399

>>3433058
Kiara>Mori>Ame>Ina>Gura

>> No.3445421

>>3433058
Ina>Ame>Gura>Mori>Kiara

>> No.3445707

>>3433487
You have to rank the outfit, not the girl you retard

>> No.3445723

>>3433058
Ina >Ame>>>Gura>Mori = Kiara

>> No.3445793

Kiara=Ame>Ina>Mori>>>Gura
Gura would be higher if not for the rigging.

>> No.3445923

>>3433058
My gut reaction is Ame > Kiara > Ina > Gura > Calli

That isn't to say that the gap between Ame and Calli is large. Their outfits are all earnest expressions of their personalities and wishes. Ina's going to be the butt of forehead jokes for the rest of the month, goslingposting for Ame will be on the rise, and more people than ever will thirst for Kiara and Calli. Gura stuck to her guns and went hard with the cute angle.

>> No.3446195

>>3433058
They all suck, none of them got the most important accessory of stink clouds.

>> No.3446255
File: 302 KB, 800x600, E0jk0CJUcAAUDwa.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3446255

>>3433058
Reveals:
Kiara=Ame>shit>rest
Outfits:
Kiara=Mori>Ame>Ina>Gura
Rigging:
Mori=Kiara=Ina=Ame>shit>lol>lmfao>gura

>> No.3447212
File: 2 KB, 116x125, 1620424858498s.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3447212

I can't take all these people putting gura over ANY of the EN girls seriously, there is just no fucking way kek

>> No.3447233

>>3447212
other than the cat ears the outfit is pretty cute

>> No.3447261

>>3435331
Fucking hilarious Gurab looks so bad it looks like someone just photoshopped a bootleg Gura onto that image

>> No.3447739

>>3433058
My oshi > the rest > shit > your oshi

>> No.3451071

Ame
Kiara
Ina
Calli


Gura

>> No.3451986
File: 130 KB, 789x1810, 164646474657.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3451986

Ame ame ame.

Ame ame ameee~

>> No.3452124

>>3442082
This thread is for rating the outfit, not the rigging.

>> No.3452140

>>3442329
>the design by Nacho is top notch.
FUNNY WAY TO SPELL DOG SHIT

>> No.3452195

Mori - cool
Kiara - sexy
Ina - smart
Gura - cute
Ame - All of the above

All of the outfits are good disregarding the rigging

>> No.3452392

Ame = Mori > Ina = Kiara >>>> SHARTra

>> No.3452531

Ame > Ina > Gura > Mori > Kiara
Seriously, Ame's is so fucking good.

>> No.3452587

>>3433058
The Design itself:
Ame>Gura>Kiara>Mori>Ina
Reveal:
Ame>Kiara>Ina>>>>Mori>Gura
Rigging ad accessories:
Kiara>Ame>Mori>Ina>Artemis>>>>>>>>Gura
Improvement compared to the last Model:
Kiara>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Ame>Ina>>>>>>>>Dr.Dre feat Semenscythe>Gura

>> No.3452613

>>3433058
Original outfit designs objectively:
Mori>Ina>Gura>Ame>>>>>>>Kiara

Original outfit rigging objectively:
Kiara>Mori>Ina>Ame>Gura

Original outfits overall sunjectively:
Mori>Gura>Ina>Ame>>>Kiara

New outfit designs objectively:
Ame>Mori>Kiara>Gura>Ina

New outfit rigging objectively:
Kiara>Mori>Ina>Ame>>>>>>>>>>>>>kek

New outfits overall subjectively:
Ame>Kiara>Mori>Ina>>>>>Gura

Biggest winners:
Kiara>Ame>Ina>Mori>>>>>Gura

Bonus SEX ranking:
Ame=Kiara>Mori>Ina>UOOOOOOOOOOOH

>> No.3452629

>>3452531
Agree with everything said.

>> No.3452648

>>3447233
It's fox ears

>> No.3452708

>>3451986
What the fuck, she has gun? I didn't catch the reveal live, I was at work. But this is a nice surprise

>> No.3452712
File: 48 KB, 513x599, 1619665781969.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3452712

>>3452648

>> No.3452744

>>3452613
Moris and Kiaras outfit really fit their respective personalities, being either a 10 or a 0 depending on your previous opinion

>> No.3452950

>>3452613
I'll put Ame bellow Kiara for rigging just for her dorky glasses with proper reflection.

>> No.3453253

>>3452950
As much as as I love Ame's dorky kpop glasses, Kiara's sunglasses have that great reflect effect going on. It's good work.

>> No.3453447

Gura's is the most underwhelming for sure

>> No.3453676

>>3433058
Ame > Ina > Calli > Kiara > Gura>

>> No.3454446

Mori > Ame > Kiara > Ina > Gura

Mori is absolutely perfect from the clothes to the color scheme. It's cool as fuck, it's cute, it's even SEEEEXXXX if she drops the jacket.

I ended up liking Ame way more than I expected, without the coat it just looks extremely good and pure GFE, also the fucking pantyhose legs and heart earrings hnnngggg.

Kiara is a mix of amazing and bad, the upper part of her is really great (although I personally would have loved to see a tied shirt, goddamn), but the hotpants look kinda bad. They're weirdly too long and the orange buttons look ugly. If they were better this would have been above Ame probably.

Ina is sadly just plain as fuck. I don't like the generic grey dress that looks like it was made for a catholic gradeschooler. There's no soul in it. The french beret, fivehead and glasses are all amazing though.

Gura is an abomination. Even if you ignore the horrible rigging, it's some dungaree looking childish dress and not the erotic kind of child but the real, fat kind that screams and slobbers all over everything. I'm sure genuine pedos get off to this but I don't. Literally all her prediction fanart was better than what she got.

>> No.3455508

>>3433058
And Anne chimkin take the win, I'm ambivalent to gooruh's, unimpressed by ina's, and kaliope loses due to my distaste for rap and the culture surrounding it.

>> No.3455877

>>3433058
>Ame
The other ENs hyped it up and I thought it lived up to it. So amazingly cute and sexy at the same time. A really well made outfit with some lovely props to go alongside it. I did not expect Ame to get a gun, it's a really nice touch.

>Mori
A really unique design and it suits her personality so well. I love the contrast in colours and the way she can use the microphone. My 2nd favourite behind Ame's.

>Kiara
Sexy and with really great rigging and props, such as the cat ears and tail. I'm happy that Kiara got an outfit that suits her probably a even more than her original. It's a massive upgrade.

>Ina
I find it cute. But for me it's a little bit too plain. The painter theme certainly suits with what Ina is all about though and after seeing her wear it in her latest drawing stream it's a good look.

>Gura
A bit too underwhelming if I'm honest. No doubting it's cute, but like Ina's it's almost a little too plain. Also the lack of extras and accessories leaves little to be desired compared to what the others got. (I won't mention the rigging, we all know how bad it is)

>> No.3459234

>>3433058
Ame=Ina>Kiara>Cali(no jacket)>>>>Gura=Cali(jacket)

>> No.3459460

>>3455877
>>Ina
>I find it cute. But for me it's a little bit too plain.
You find it plain because its contrasted with her regular outfit which is probably the second most intricate after Polka.

>> No.3459789

>>3433830
9001%

>> No.3460281

>>3454446
>Ina is sadly just plain as fuck.
That's her appeal though. She's simple and plain but that just makes her cute and comfy.

>> No.3460340

>>3433058
Ame > Ina > Gura > Mori > Kiara

>> No.3460351
File: 1010 KB, 1200x1716, 1620175757464.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3460351

>>3460281
Fuck that, give the people what they want Kuroboshi. You fucking hackfraud.

>> No.3460455

>>3460351
if Ina gets it from AO-chan's tentacles wouldn't that be yuri?

>> No.3460632

All I get from this thread is that Gura's is objectively bad

>> No.3462917

>>3460351
probably the best picture of ina i've seen

>> No.3463731

>>3433487
Exactly my list

>> No.3466753

Kiara>Ame>Ina>Calli>Gura

If Gura didn't have the car ears I'd have ranked calli and gura the same

>>
Reply to thread [?]Don't expect anything heroic. Your post will not be uploaded to the original board.
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action