[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/vt/ - Virtual Youtubers


View post   

File: 159 KB, 763x959, 1653815902567.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25287305 No.25287305 [Reply] [Original]

If you don't kill yourself by then, that is.

>> No.25287374 [DELETED] 
File: 216 KB, 1600x1307, 162525183727834.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25287374

>> No.25287402 [DELETED] 

>>25274410
>>25274410
>>25274410
go back

>> No.25287413

>>25287305
What faggot still pays this bitch? Kill yourself nyancucks

>> No.25287424 [DELETED] 

go back retard
>>25274410

>> No.25287549

>lost 3.7k subs
What happened?

>> No.25287561 [DELETED] 

wrong thread holobro
this one is still up
>>25274410

>> No.25287649 [DELETED] 
File: 231 KB, 1600x900, 16233718482483.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25287649

>> No.25287663

>>25287549
Publicly announced she had a boyfriend.
Same thing happened to fucking Veibae when she anounced the same thing. Who the fuck would have thought they of all people would have unicorn gachikoi.

>> No.25287669

>>25287549
She stopped streaming.

>> No.25287695

>>25287402
>>25287424
>>25287561
https://youtu.be/Brz1KmFf5MQ

>> No.25287719 [DELETED] 

>>25274410
>>25274410
ok, but you should post on your thread holosister

>> No.25287720

>>25287649
Right is mentally ill and lying to themselves, one step away from becoming a terrorist

>> No.25287742

you know damn well she's going to drown in subs/donos in her comeback stream and fuck off for the week again anyway. It's always like that

>> No.25287747

>>25287402
>>25287424
>>25287561
>>25287719
How many ip’s did you hop just now?

>> No.25287759

>>25287305
My oshi already "crashed" by giving up the corpo buff. I don't care because I'm not a number-obsessed niggerfaggot.

>> No.25287796

>>25287720
oops, the left guy i mean

>> No.25287811
File: 595 KB, 1500x1089, 1654027497531.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25287811

>>25287402
>>25287424
>>25287561
>>25287719
nyancucks, this is pathetic.
you're linking an archived thread btw

>> No.25287833

>>25287663
Idiotic of them.
Just keep personal shit hidden and rake the simp bucks in, announcing a boyfriend is the worst thing you can do.

>> No.25287861

>>25287796
Hi, my name is retarded faggot and Im a nyancuck, nice to meet you

>> No.25287933

>>25287811
once in the now in hiatus nyan general it was suggested setting up a throne for gifts for their new apartment

>> No.25287973

>>25287833
not anymore, nobody cares about that shit, only holofags. and they think everyone is like them, watching vtubers for parasocial relationships instead of entertainment

>> No.25288054

>>25287549
Expired subs most likely. She didn't stream for the past month I think for moving into a new place. The actual move in is now around June iirc.

>> No.25288087

>>25287933
im so proud of you fags for fully embracing the cuck thing, and im so glad i left

>> No.25288088

Anybody who unironically enjoys and defends nyanners has an IQ classifying them as legally mentally retarded.

>> No.25288097

>>25287973
>nobody cares about that shit
>thread is about factual data that shows people do care
>Veibae's metrics show a sharp drop the exact day she announced it too
GUESS THESE GRAPHS AND TABLES ARE FAKE OR SOMETHING?!

>> No.25288113

>>25287973
>muh entertainment
yeah thats why you rub one out every time nyanners moans on stream, laugh at all her Amy Schumer tier jokes, and then proceed to donate your time/money to her

>> No.25288143

>>25287973
But at the same time, there is zero advantage in announcing it. It's not like she'd get more audience because she has a boyfriend. Just feels like women HAVE to announce they aren't single to everyone or it drives them crazy.

>> No.25288145

>>25287973
Damn, I haven't checked on this board in a while and now you tourists have totally infested the catalog. Guessing pretty everyone else also left. Sad.

>> No.25288183
File: 125 KB, 112x112, 439465E7-2A61-421B-9984-8548DFBAE913.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25288183

>> No.25288234

>>25287549
She hasn't streamed in 3 weeks.

>> No.25288239

>>25287973
read the OP faggot READ the DATA, its there, so a retard like you can understand

>> No.25288242

>>25288054
That makes the most sense.

>> No.25288246

>>25288113
There's a lot of fair criticism to give TO nyanners, but "Amy Schumer-tier jokes" is a big red flag that you've never watched her. You can shit on her but please at least try to be accurate.

>> No.25288263

>>25288143
no, people are actually happy for her. i know this sounds alien for holofags who want streamers to be miserable like them just to be relatable, but that's how it is. next

>> No.25288298

I await the day a HoloEN member announces a boyfriend. I will be refreshing catalog all day.

>> No.25288300

>>25288263
cuck

>> No.25288354

>>25288263
and others who relied on her streams for emotional support are heartbroken, but it's really convenient for nyanfags to deny their existence. you fags know no compassion.

>> No.25288470

>>25288354
>others who relied on her streams for emotional support
anon... you don't do this do you?

>> No.25288523

>>25287305
This bitch has always been a drama magnet.
There was that time she betrayed /a/ with the pomf video and said lolis are creepy.

>> No.25288570

>>25288470
tourist... why are you still here?

>> No.25288762

So, when exactly are we going to enact the Red Wedding on vshojo again?

>> No.25289032

>>25288762
if I didn't have other goals in life, I'd be happy to spend my time plotting to murder aethelstan for real.

>> No.25289033

She got /in/ with hololivejp btw

>> No.25289102

>>25289033
are you talking about the polka interaction from 2 years ago

>> No.25289221

>>25287305
It's just pathetic how they cling to their money printer instead of retiring gracefully. Go start a new career where the bf isn't a problem, pink whore.

>> No.25289233

>>25288354
> compassion
meme

>> No.25289309

She gets 5k viewers instead of 10k now! Oh no! I doubt they really give a shit considering you can go full time with only 100 viewers

>> No.25289352
File: 347 KB, 510x463, 1651736695357.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25289352

>Last stream 21 days ago

>> No.25289418

>>25289309
this isn't a number thread, this is a thread about the strange satisfaction of seeing someone you loved fail after cheating/shitting on her fanbase.

>> No.25289531

>>25287833
Thing is, everyone knew she had one. Dumping him to chase clout with a vtuber boyfriend, however, leaves a bad aftertaste.

>> No.25289554

>>25289531
Untrue. There had been zero evidence of her being in a relationship in years.

>> No.25290234

>>25287305
she's not streaming that's why. she's living like a queen on her mansion with her new boyfriend. and you fags are sperging on this board thinking this will actually change something.

that's like hating Elon musk just because he's a billionare while he makes more billions seeling his overrated tesla cars

>> No.25290236

What chuubas could I use as a replacement Nyanners? Need the same creativity and humor and charm but without the laziness and the boyfriend.

>> No.25290291

>>25289554
you don't even watch her holoturd

>> No.25290561
File: 29 KB, 736x588, what.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25290561

>>25290291

>> No.25290573

>>25290236
>shilling my oshi to nyanfags

>> No.25290691

>>25290561
>nyan
>vei
>content

>> No.25290789

>>25287663
Never considering it as a possibility was retarded and they paid the price.

>> No.25290828

>>25290691
nyanners was actually one of the best chuubas out there before she killed her career and cucked her fans, but there's no point in me convincing you of this now that it's done

>> No.25290912
File: 11 KB, 248x109, kroniicope.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25290912

>>25287305
She will always be more successful than you.
Now she's more successful AND getting fucked.

>> No.25290947
File: 742 KB, 1384x1496, 1650982700287.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25290947

I just wanted to say that I told you so but you nyancuck newfags never listen. You faggots are beyond hope

>> No.25291058

>>25290947
No, no, I unironically realize I was wrong and left her fanbase. Anyone who stayed is retarded.

>> No.25292052

>>25287720
The one on the left is the type kill himself if he found out his chuuba breathed the same air as a male. A weak specimen of human.

>> No.25292287

Wow holokeks really grab onto anything to distract themselves form their dying branch

>> No.25292354

>>25292287
...and other fun ways you can cope with your oshi hating you!

>> No.25292733

That traitor Nyanners should've killed herself years ago. She would not have gotten this big had she not recieved support from her old community when she was still small, later proceeding to betray and backstab her community in favour of fame and recognition. She cannot commit suicide soon enough, I need to see her dead.

>> No.25292790

>>25292733
maybe she just doesn't like pedos

>> No.25292839

>>25287663
The whole industry runs on gachikoi, who do you think is buying that stupid expensive merchandise and constantly donating, not casual watchers.

>> No.25292895

>>25292790
Anon she is a pedo. Then again she struggles with self-hatred so maybe you're right.

>> No.25292956

Apparently having sex makes a person stop caring about this silly streaming job where you try to amuse strangers you will never meet

>> No.25292966

>>25287663
fuck all happened to veibae except she hardly streams anymore, she pulls more viewers than ever when she does

>> No.25293009

nyancucks, I...

>> No.25293044

she gave up streaming because shes getting her back blown out by chad hourly

>> No.25293063

>>25292895
Damn you're autistic

>> No.25293276

>>25287549
Literally hasn't streamed in nearly a month. That's all.
Idk why people are talking about the boyfriend stuff.

>> No.25293323

>>25287305
Whether or not this is true, I think this is really interesting. What do you do in the future? How long can you vtube? Streaming appears to be a permanent thing now and a lot of guys are mid thirty somethings so maybe you just do this forever or transition into streaming as a real person and do that forever, but even guys like preach or whoever the fuck, I dunno. Can you do this forever? Then what? You just go into office work? You go to school get a degree? Could you imagine being forty and working in an office and taking shit from your boss and you're thinking back to the time that you actually sang and performed at real live concerts to thousands of people? Time, man

>> No.25293454

>>25293323
become a manager for a streaming agency or invest in a side gig

>> No.25293461

>>25293276
it isn't as good bait to blame it on her not streaming than her boyfriend instead

>> No.25293566
File: 1.47 MB, 2560x1440, 1647835688367.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25293566

>yeah I'm a lesbian!
Westoids not even once
Back to hololive

>> No.25293612

>>25287695
Is this real!?

>> No.25293626

>>25293276
>Literally hasn't streamed in nearly a month.
Gee, I wonder why.

>> No.25293709

>>25293626
the bait is that people bailed as soon as they heard about the boyfriend, rather than just because she hasn't been streaming

>> No.25293806

Oh nyo bros whatever will we do, I can’t believe she’s spending so much time moving and selling everything in her house>:( how dare she

>> No.25293963

>>25287669
>>25288054
>>25288234
>>25293276
so if she hasn't been doing any streams doesn't this mean she could basically make most of her subs again if she just streams more again?

>> No.25293985

is vtubing when she genuinely started making money? shes been active for years prior but i wonder if it was sustainable

>> No.25294020

>>25293963
Probably I guess. I don't care enough to check this but some autist probably will in the future

>> No.25294064

>>25293612
unfortunately not

>> No.25294149

>>25287973
The graph literally tells you that people care you retard

>> No.25294195

>>25294064
cope newnigger
https://youtu.be/_Pafzuf1T24

>> No.25294198

>>25289309
>She gets 5k viewers instead of 10k now!
We actually have no idea what her viewer average is now because she literally hasn't streamed once ever since she announced she had a bf.
I'm not kidding, you can check her channel. She's been gone for almost a month.
So we don't know if she gets like 10k or 5k or any other number of viewers on her streams now.

>> No.25294245

>>25294149
They probably cared more about the fact that she doesn't stream anymore than her getting a boyfriend.

>> No.25294247
File: 160 KB, 640x619, 1626162737174.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25294247

another bait thread by holofags

>> No.25294385

>>25294247
she can just go back to stream if she needs help with money. but retards are actually biting another holoturd bait

>> No.25294391

>>25294195
this guy is autistic

>> No.25294485

>>25289418
>seeing someone you loved fail after cheating/shitting on her fanbase.
How can you cheat on a fanbase

>> No.25294639

>>25294198
>>25294245
Does this mean we have to check back with another bait thread a month later to get a final ultimatum?

>> No.25294655

>>25294385
I don't watch her so I don't know what her situation is like but I feel like the type of person that can take weeks off from their job at a whim probably isn't hurting for money.
For fuck sakes I hate how easy the life of a vtuber is. Literally none of these bitches deserve such an easy life.

>> No.25294722

>>25289418
is she really failing though if she's able to basically take a whole month off to be with her lover and then probably come back just fine?

>> No.25294778
File: 188 KB, 1439x371, Screenshot_20220521-140135_Twitch.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25294778

>> No.25294779
File: 148 KB, 550x550, 1648879720715.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25294779

>>25294485
holobronie logic

>> No.25294782

She did say she was selling snd moving everything in her house, alongside she most likely has been searching for a house t buy for a while now

>> No.25294794

>bf yab
>fucks off while the drama dies
everry time

>> No.25294814

>>25294655
For most vtubing is a side gig. You never hear about them tho because they never make it big. Being successful has its benefits

>> No.25294834

>>25294195
I wonder if vshojo has many Korean fans lmao

>> No.25294888

>>25294794
That's actually a good point lol
I wouldn't be surprised be surprised if she did this on purpose.

Ghost her fans for like a month so that people are more mad over no streams instead of getting a bf. Then their standards are lowered when she finally comes back.

>> No.25294963

>>25294834
They have a ton of jp fans, especially after the vills concert

>> No.25294995

>>25294888
she's been on his streams a couple of times since then, so no, she's just been busy

pure kino by the way

>> No.25295002

>>25294655
> easy
> daily death threats to her family by idolfags and parasocialfags
wouldn't be surprised if she never comes back, after finding a bf to settle down with all her money, you fags are mentally ill

>> No.25295049

>>25294888
as depressing as it sounds it probably is what's happening, i checked her channel and she literally hasn't done any streams since the one where she announced she has a bf
the playbook to dealing with drama is to go away for a while and then come back and continue doing your thing
this seems like a textbook example of it

>> No.25295095

>dont stream
>people leave and don't wanna burn 5 dollars or give their prime sub to an empty void

Wow what a world shattering concept

>> No.25295107

>>25295049
>>25294995

>> No.25295122

>>25294995
I don't think her being on other people's streams really counts though, that still is removed from most fans.
>>25295049
Yeah the fact that she has done 0 since the announcement is what makes this suspicious to me

>> No.25295176

>>25295122
It would count to the people who want to make drama out of it. But like you say, most fans wouldn't care one way or the other.

>> No.25295189

Reminder that vshojocucks actually think haachama and baelz are leeching from them kek

>> No.25295203

>>25295122
She’s announced on stream and twitter a few times that shes been moving

>> No.25295231

>>25287305
> holobronies seething because having a bf had no effect on her career

>> No.25295234

>>25294779
I legit have no idea what you're talking about

>> No.25295246

nyancucks tears thread.

>> No.25295289

>>25295176
>It would count to the people who want to make drama out of it.
I don't think it does. The whole relationship was being speculated on by months by vshoujo fans and they were collabing for quite a whole. The rest of this board only got wind of the whole thing when they made an official announcement
I doubt many dramafags are actively checking her bfs channel.

>> No.25295327

>>25295189
tribalism aside, they're all bigger than haachama, so yeah, it's basically leeching

>> No.25295352

>>25295289
people on this board really dont care about what nyanners does, she's always had a reddit/discord following
if you ever gave a shit about her you'd be in her sub only discord

>> No.25295418

>>25295203
I see but still she has done 0 streams. I don't see how moving means you can't do any streams unless you're literally retarded

>> No.25295490

>>25295418
Tbf they’ve been searching for a house, buying furniture, moving boxes and getting trucks, selling her old furniture and apartment, moving everything into her new house as well

>> No.25295540

>>25295289
Maybe, but it still seems weird that someone who was afraid of boyfriend drama would stream exclusively on that boyfriend's channel. So I doubt that that's her concern. She's probably just been busy.

>> No.25295564

>>25295352
>doesn’t care what she does
tons of bait threads, looking into her past and sending threats/doxxing, ship harassment

>> No.25295580

>>25295327
Twitch numbers =/= YouTube numbers

>> No.25295591

>>25294814
The most black pilling thing in this industry is looking at Veibae's channel.
The most laziest and uncreative vtuber ever, barely ever streams, and actively detests her fanbase. And yet she's one of the most popular ones.

>> No.25295627

>>25295231
I dunno bro that seems like a downward trend to me.

>> No.25295695

>>25295627
We need to see how it looks when she actually streams though, she seems to be going for the strat of disappearing and then coming back pretending nothing happened

>> No.25295743

>>25295591
Yeah but we're talking about Nyanners, who's been shitposting for over a decade and is one of the most creative and funniest chuubas in the business

>> No.25295798

Holofags are mentally ill Thread #72747

>> No.25295803

>>25295327
Haachama is bigger than baelz, vwhores are not bigger than baelz... They're barley bigger than Ollie

>> No.25295828

>>25295743
Ok I was just pointing out the Veibae thing since I thought it was somewhat related

>> No.25295872

>>25294247
if only you knew.

>> No.25295897

>>25295327
Haachama is bigger than all vshojowhores

>> No.25295905

>>25294247
This entire board is bait.

>> No.25295947

>>25295695
Veibae sticks to the twitch meta religiously, but she's good at it. That's more than can be said for most streamers.

>> No.25295975

>>25295695
You know.
You are right, we'll see then

>> No.25295979
File: 343 KB, 773x735, 1626118559867.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25295979

>>25295002
why the fuck would I send death threats to her or her family instead of aethel's and his family??

>> No.25296016

>>25294639
Don't worry guys, I'm autistic enough to remember this.
I'll make another thread in exactly one months time from now as a status report.
Cap this.

>> No.25296017

>>25295327
Only an actual retard would think this, the amount of delusion you need in you to even think like that is really surprising

>> No.25296026

>>25295803
Holocope

>> No.25296054

>>25295327
>there are actual fags who think like this
wow....

>> No.25296088

>jump right into moving out together after meeting over the internet and shipped by mutuals
>bring out their relationship into public
>even before muh honeymoon phase
>with a fucking menhera nutcase

kinda makes you want to watch it unfold

>> No.25296160

>>25295695
she was gushing about dating for a while in her last stream, anon

>> No.25296177

You guys do know vshojo is as well known/famous as hololive right?

>> No.25296213
File: 20 KB, 242x191, FB_IMG_1650084210469.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25296213

>>25287402
>>25287424
>>25287561
>>25287649
>>25287719
>>25287973
>>25288263
>>25290291
>>25292287
>>25294247
>>25294779
>>25295002
>>25295231
>>25295798
>>25296026
OOGA BOOGA NYANDERTHALS

>> No.25296312

>>25296177
HOLY FUCK MY SIDES
vshojo is as barely known as the ENs and those are only known because of their subs, and they're already considered a side branch too you fucking mong
I'd say vshojo is about as famous as nijisanji ID

>> No.25296341
File: 889 KB, 820x741, 1638492742082.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25296341

>>25296213
best post in the thread, thank you
t. op

>> No.25296515

>>25296312
Holy cope holokeks will latch onto anything, holy shit you holoshits are pathetic

>> No.25296584

I like Debi more
thought she was botting? Did i fall for the rrat?

>> No.25296590

>>25287305
What exactly are you mad about?

>> No.25296598

>>25296515
Says the faggots who are gushing about someone like nyanners not streaming for almost a month straight because she can't get enough of her boyfriend's dick
Keep seething cuck, your whores will never be on the same level
You should be happy we've even graced you with baelz, let alone haato.

>> No.25296601

>>25296515
incredible retort anon, not even the guy you're replying to but wow that must've taken you some effort to pull off.

>> No.25296617

>>25296054
>>25296017
they get more views and average live viewers, who are you trying to fool? subscribers are useless if they're dead. retards

>> No.25296644

>>25296584
wrong thread lol lmao

>> No.25296658

>>25296590
My oshi not only got a boyfriend, but was unable to keep it a secret. Why wouldn't you be mad?

>> No.25296684

>>25296213
Don't you have ms.desuwa to destroy with?

>> No.25296691

>>25295002
You're retarded man. Nyanners always comes back, she's just that way. First she could have just hopped off the internet after she ditched 4chan and became normal, but she went to tumblr instead, then after that she jumped to vtubers. People like to say 4chan is obsessed with hating her, but you have to admit, based on how she acts and the choices she's made, she's also obsessed with being hated.

>> No.25296861

>>25296691
i used to like that side of her, rationalizing it as her humiliation fetish or whatever, until she specifically cast fans like me out.

>> No.25296908

>>25296658
Genuinely curious, why does that make you upset?

>> No.25296915

>>25296658
So what are you gonna do when/if bounces back up in subs when she starts streaming again?

>> No.25296920

>>25296658
I'd be miffed with her not being consistent since last year but I dropped her since then anyway

>> No.25296993

>>25296617
Once they come to YouTube where the numbers are actually accurate, you can use that argument faggot
The literal runts of hololive are better than your whores, let alone the 2nd biggest Gen 1 member, maybe even 1st at times

>> No.25296996

>>25296920
This is much more rational reason to mad at her lol
Who cares if she's in relationship, real issue is that she's basically decided to stop doing her job for months now

>> No.25297084

>>25296996
Problem is that twitch basically encourages this sort of behavior in streamers once they get popular. A bunch of people get popular and then they start streaming less because they can.

>> No.25297118
File: 397 KB, 1037x588, 1650498115494.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25297118

>>25296993
>Once they come to YouTube where the numbers are actually accurate
kek. hello extreme newfag, I see you weren't there last month when they proved this to be factually incorrect in real time, have a read >>22828612

>> No.25297132
File: 124 KB, 960x540, SOCIA.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25297132

>>25295803
Haachama leech.

>> No.25297177

>>25294195
Metokur's got it wrong tho, these were before she became an sjw tumblrina and definitely before she settled into a normalfag redditor she's no a dobule agent rumao.

>> No.25297201

Hey maybe you holokeks can watch rushia! Oh wait… maybe coco? Oh nevermind she left as well, what about the en side? shit they don’t stream…. Maybe ayame? fuck she doesn’t stream either

>> No.25297210

>>25297132
Please refer to >>25295580

>> No.25297261

>>25287305
She traded money for Thundercock.
>Captcha: GAYGG

>> No.25297270

>>25297118
Yes real numbers, you can tell when something is off due to graphs, that's how you can tell which numbers are right and which numbers aren't, why do you fags try to numberfag when you literally have no idea what the fuck you're doing?
Look at this retard for example >>25297132 who doesn't even know what the graph he's showing actually means

>> No.25297350

>>25296996
look, i watched her for entertainment at first. then i fell for her, and watching her brought me emotional comfort. and now she's another man's fucktoy, so it brings me dread instead. surrogate gf for lonely men, as much as you may hate it, remains one of the biggest reasons why people spend so much time and money on vtubers.

>> No.25297418

>>25297132
OH NO HOLOBROS, I GUESS OUR NARRATIVE WAS BTFO

>> No.25297433
File: 6 KB, 225x225, download (18).jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25297433

This is what happens when you announce you have a boyfriend

>> No.25297455
File: 183 KB, 1081x907, 1650492454098.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25297455

>>25297270
>anon is utterly illiterate
literally click the thread, it's right there anon...

>> No.25297520
File: 38 KB, 282x396, 1637361803104.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25297520

>>25297201
yes vsjfags, be directly antagonistic to everyone else on the board, see how far that gets you

>> No.25297540

>literal joke hire hime streamed more than her this month
>no one for tonight
how are things going to look if the alleged new member(s) stream end up streaming more hours than 3/4 of the company?

>> No.25297590
File: 589 KB, 960x960, 1637361803106.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25297590

>>25297540
>new members

>> No.25297605

>>25297455
Are you fucking retarded? You're acting like twitch can't be botted, irs even worse because you can't actually see the proper graphs for twitch numbers, raiding is even worse... That just throws away your peak numbers.
Do you really not understand what I'm trying to say? Is it really that hard?

>> No.25297632

>>25297540
Hime, my queen.

>> No.25297646

>>25297433
...nothing? trying to understand your point holokek....

>> No.25297651

>>25287695
https://streamable.com/0u90ns

>> No.25297667

>>25294391
>REEEE NO YOU'RE WRONG ABOUT HER PAST BECAUSE THIS RETARD IS TOO OBSESSED WITH DUMB POLITICAL SHIT
Whatever helps you sleep at night. In the end people change, but she was just looking for attention and acceptance and she found it originally on 4chan, so she played into it. Now she doesn't have to. Nothing with with that, just understand that some people might not like that.

>> No.25297673

>>25297350
No offense man but this sounds like a problem with you and not her.
I could be more sympathetic if it was a vtuber that did GFE. But fucking Nyanners? LMAO
You did this to yourself but deciding to fall for a someone who doesn't do GFE shit

>> No.25297684

>>25297132
So according to this shitty graph you have, you're saying that ironlungs isn't only more famous and popular than haachama but also more popular than the rest of hololive?
Holy Mother of cope....

>> No.25297708

>>25296861
Well yeah, of course she'd do that eventually. From what I've seen of her, she needs two things. One, she needs "backers", a group that supports her, it doesn't matter if she likes them, or actually agrees with them or their views, they're there to be her "supporters" or "fans. A backdrop for her, like the girls behind the popular girls. From there she needs the second group, people who she pisses off. Examples;
A) She pandered to 4chan with lolis and other things, such as the race comments, jew comments, Korean stuff, etc. This got 4chan as her backers and the tumblr types to hate her.
B) She went to tumblr and became sjw, it's unknown whether she actually supports any of it because she changes her opinions all the time to get at people, but this successfully made some of the tumblrinas her backers and 4chan the ones that hated her.
C) She now became a vtuber, but instead of being a normal one, she became one that spits in the face of what people like about other vtubers, purposefully contrarian to cause anger. She now has the weird "streamers don't owe you anything" twitch kiddie coomer crowd as her backers, and 4chan and holo fans hating her.
She's literally never matured past the point of being "that girl that wants to make her dad mad", but now she just does it with anyone on the internet. That's what gets me about vshokeks, they say things about how she's successful now, but she literally doesn't care. She'll have them in the background for however long she wants to piss off whatever group she's pissing off this time around, and then eventually she'll drop them and add them to the crowd of people who hate her. My bets on her shitting on Vshojo later down the line to do it, then moving on to whatever else she wants to use for her next make daddy mad plan. I'd say this boyfriend situation she's made is one of the things she's using to tide herself over, pissing all over the people who don't like the boyfriend on stream and using it as a way to get the "inti-parasocial" on twitter as her backers and everyone else on the other side. She'll breakup with him down the line because she isn't actually dating him, she's just using him to make daddy mad all over again.
Bit of a long read but watching nyanners do weird shit all the time is actually pretty interesting, if you recognize the patterns of her behavior over time.

>> No.25297727

>>25297605
> bots
oh ah numberfaggot, go back to your containment thread
>>25287315

>> No.25297741

>>25297605
>"YouTube where the numbers are actually accurate"
>shown direct proof that YouTube numbers CANNOT be accurate as you can give thousands of views on youtube for a few bucks and susan will display them for you
>starts shitting himself and crying
many such cases.

>> No.25297746

>>25297708
holy autism

>> No.25297785

>>25297746
She probably is, yeah

>> No.25297881

>>25297708
makes me think of Pippa right now. She's in the A portion of your post.

>> No.25297950

>>25297727
>>25297741
I'll allow it this time since it seems I'm talking to actual fucking children, reminder that you need to be 18 to post on this site faggots
The fact that you showed me "proof" that YouTube streams can be botted, just means that twitch streams can be botted but unlike twitch streams, you can actually know when a YouTube stream has been botted and if you can't get that through your dumb thick skull then all I can tell you is to cope, seethe and dilate cucks.

>> No.25297964

>>25297673
she had the charm for it. those vrchat date streams felt personal and honest, so it sold it for me. parasocialbaiting is the bread and butter of most vtubers since they're not very entertaining on their own, I guess we'll see if nyan can retain her numbers when she comes back. but man, I'll have the biggest smirk on my face if they keep dropping down after she comes back. not like she cares about numbers anyways, i don't wish for her to be unhappy.

>> No.25297967

>>25297177
no fucking shit that clip was from 2015, retard

>> No.25297974

>>25297210
True, twitch adding 5 million more people is really fucked up. Poor Valkyrae the youtube streamer only got second place.

>> No.25297998

>>25297708
>"streamers don't owe you anything" twitch kiddie coomer crowd
We call those Deadbeats.

>> No.25298005

>>25297708
>My bets on her shitting on Vshojo later down
To be fair that is not hard to do

>> No.25298140

>>25297950
>you can actually know when a YouTube stream has been botted
>his first response to seeing a graph of a botted stream was "you can't tell when something is off due to graphs" (>>25297270)
how are you this bad at arguing dude

>> No.25298143

>>25297708
>shitting on Vshojo later down the line
the corp or the other girls? I wouldn't doubt the former after the whole nux shitshow

>> No.25298232

>>25294778
Are you the same faggot that keeps constantly whining about her not streaming in /vsj+/ around the same time everyday?
If so can you stop and shut up, it's annoying

>> No.25298256
File: 464 KB, 590x489, 1632868996896.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25298256

>>25297974
kek

>> No.25298369

>>25298232
Kys cuck

>> No.25298454

>>25298140
This is mental disability at its finest, are vcucks all like this? Wow.

>> No.25298457

>>25298369
I don't even watch her, I'm just fucking annoyed at you faggots constantly spamming about her not streaming all the time there

>> No.25298472

>>25298232
boo hoo

>> No.25298535

>>25287305
Problem is, what does it matter? She has so much money at this point that nothing matters. She can buy a house already that most people look forward to years and years down the line.

>> No.25298537

>>25298454
excellent retort, didn't expect anything less

>> No.25298586

>>25298143
I'd say both. She'd come out about some shady shit the corp did, true or not, and also come out against some of the girls for things like the ones said here (froot cheating, etc.) so she could frame it as her being in the right and get the usual formula of backers and haters out of it.

>> No.25298599

>>25298535
It matters to OP on a personal level, since she was his oshi apparently.

>> No.25298616
File: 39 KB, 503x531, 1653278526436.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25298616

>>25287973
>Muh only Holofags care about being cucked!
>The vwhores thread totally didn't have a nuclear tier meltdown over the Vei bullshit
>It totally didn't continue to burn and erupt into hellfire during the Nyanners bullshit now
>Its only holofags who care about this guys! T-trust me!
You are delusional as fuck

>> No.25298665

>>25298586
>froot cheating
nyan's at least knowledgeable enough to pick one of the rrats that are actually true

>> No.25298690

>>25294195
Reminder that Cancer Jim is a ZOG operative that just got destroyed by a Nick the Carboy Spics. You can also tell by how he gets triggered by the Jew jokes.

>> No.25298701

>>25298586
I'd honestly start liking pink cat a little if she decided to unleash and take down vshoujo lol

>> No.25298711

>>25298457
It's not like that thread talks about the girls anyway. There's more discussion about connor/soda/aethel than zen, silver or mel

>> No.25298740

>>25287973
Bro people care so much that this shit affects actual e-thots. Pokimane has lost a collective total of like 300k plus subs combined from all the bf yabs she's had over the years. If not more.

>> No.25298742

>>25298537
says the faggot who made zero sense from his first post till now

>> No.25298757

I stopped watching pink cat because react content is lazy and bad.

>> No.25298779

>>25298701
wasn't she the founder? Or was it the literal e-whore?

>> No.25298898
File: 30 KB, 480x360, 1614032059817.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25298898

>>25298757
i want one of the clones from her creative golden age period, doesn't matter if it's defective, it'd still be better than the pink cat we have now

>> No.25298930

>>25294794
It wasn't a yab.

>> No.25298934

>>25298779
No, I think that was Melody.
Pink cat was just one of the people that was asked to join.

>> No.25298968

>>25298711
At the end of the day it's a popularity thing.
Ironmouse, Veibae, and Nyanners are the most popular VShojos so they of course get talked about more there than the other members.
For various reasons all 3 of them haven't been streaming as much currently. But that doesn't mean their fans have disappeared though. Instead they'll still find ways to talk about them in some form. So it's not surprising they talk about their bfs/boytoys instead while they're gone.

>> No.25298978

I already saw my former oshi crash and burn.
And its funny how this thread keeps talking about gachikois, like no motherfucker, Nyanners didn't fucking have any, she's declining because she doesn't fucking stream.

Youd think you faggots would have learned after Rushia but no, you still cling to that nonsense.

>> No.25298979

>one month break
That's called maternity leave.

>> No.25299034

>>25295580
Twitch numbers are more valuable since you make more money on there than ok YouTube.

>> No.25299046

>>25298757
Technically she doesn't do react content anymore as since she isn't streaming that means she has literally no content right now.

>> No.25299072

>>25287649
Right would've been fine if it just stopped at the first line. The rest sounds like overcompensating, and then devolves into the same parasocial bullshit with the last line just from a different perspective. Although maybe that's normal. I never really understood thinking about the relationships of celebrities who have absolutely no impact on my life except what I watch on a screen for entertainment.

>> No.25299113

>>25287305
Why is pink shit crashing though?

>> No.25299128

>>25298978
>Nyanners didn't fucking have any
i swear i exist, anon.

>> No.25299144

>>25298701
You'd just be playing into her game if you did, anon. Then later down the line she'd inevitably piss you off for the usual kicks again. There's no point in liking or disliking her, so ironically this site still plays into it so long as they regard her with anything but complete indifference. Nyanners literally isn't even real, she's entirely fictional. Everything about herself she invents and reinvents over and over again to do this weird ritual like dance with the internet people she's so strangely obsessed with.

>> No.25299153
File: 150 KB, 847x864, haneko.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25299153

>>25298898
Time for Katawa VShoujo

>> No.25299177

>>25299113
Hasn't streamed in nearly a month

>> No.25299186

>>25297708
That's called anti-narcissism look it up.

>> No.25299230

>>25287663
>unicorn
I really doubt it. It's just that these girls aren't interesting and their fans probably don't want to watch her suck another guy's dick on stream, that's all. Suspiciously male streamers and vtubers never do a "girlfriend reveal" stream. Women's entire lives revolve around what's going in and out of their vagina and getting angry at people who do not want to touch their vagina.

>> No.25299262

>>25299113
publicly announced her boyfriend, all her goslings are killing themselves
oh and if you think nyan goslings weren't a thing just look up the term on an archive and you'll see >>25298978

>> No.25299319

>>25298143
The whole Nux drama actually involved her and Mouse getting in conflict with Mel and Froot.

>> No.25299372

>>25299262
Nah I would say her not streaming at all is the thing. That likely has way more of an impact than her getting a bf.
Also it doesn't matter how many goslings she had or not on this board. This place is a very small subset of the vtuber fanbase, especially for vshojos.

>> No.25299380 [DELETED] 
File: 78 KB, 1280x720, maxresdefault(2).jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25299380

>>25287374
>>25287413
>>25287424
>>25287811
>>25287861
>>25287973
>>25288087
>>25288088
>>25288239
>>25288263
>>25288300
>>25288354
>>25290234
>>25290573
>>25290789
>>25290828
>>25290947
>>25291058
>>25293009
>>25294149
>>25294195
>>25294247
>>25294385
>>25295002
>>25295189
>>25295246
>>25295289
>>25295798
>>25296017
>>25296054
>>25296598
>>25296617
>>25296691
>>25296993
>>25297118
>>25297177
>>25297270
>>25297520
>>25297605
>>25297667
>>25297708
>>25297727
>>25297950
>>25297967
>>25298232
>>25298369
>>25298454
>>25298457
>>25298616
>>25298690
>>25298742
>>25298779
>>25298978
STFU racists

>> No.25299382

>>25299113
Don't think she's crashing. She's been so inconsistent this whole fucking year so far, since late last year now that I think about it. When she returns there's always a surge but she fucks off again for a while
>t. was actually looking forward to chrono trigger streams

>> No.25299405

>>25299230
nyan WAS interesting, which is why her rejecting parasocial fans for no reason makes me mad. if i wiped off all my memory of nyanners and started watching her, i'd probably be entertained and nothing more like your usual normalfag.

>> No.25299407

>>25288143
Ironically this is why I distrust streamers who aggressively insist they are single.

>> No.25299444

>>25299144
It makes sense that she is friends with Hbomb. He also does the whole contrarian but while pretending to be genuine.

>> No.25299480

>>25299444
I don't see how hbomberguy is contrarian

>> No.25299491

>>25299380
Reminder that Mori watches Nyanners and Cum Town. She also forces Irys to watch it with her.

>> No.25299533

>>25287305
Soon.

>> No.25299558

>>25299319
It was amusing that the fucking tts tranny implied she was told to join into the shitshow and had the humility to apologize after that

>> No.25299560

>>25288113
>Amy Schumer tier jokes
kek

>> No.25299581

>>25299480
He toned it down but the Fallout 3 and Dark Souls 2 were peak contrarian.

>> No.25299646

>>25299491
Where the fuck did she say she listens to cum town?

>> No.25299786

>>25299405
>which is why her rejecting parasocial fans for no reason makes me mad
Do you really think there's no reason?
If I could between between being popular but having parasocial fans vs being a bit less popular but still successful with a normalfag fanbase I would chose the latter all the time.
Much less of a headache and a better thing for a person mentally.

>> No.25299891

>>25299382
Maybe she's been feeling a bit burnt out of her job lately kek
That seems to be a common trend I've seen in a bunch of chuubas here nowadays

>> No.25299934

>>25299786
that's true, but you're also (likely) a male so you could keep an audience by entertainment skills alone. anyways, I guess we'll just see after she comes back.

>> No.25300057

>>25299934
True but so can some women to be fair.
But yeah, not much else to speculate on what she's doing until she finally comes back

>> No.25300088

>>25299380
>>25297651

>> No.25300138

>>25298978
There was a dedicated falseflagger, back with /nyan/ that would come in every hour or so. Write a paragraph about how he was leaving forever and pink cat sucks now.
Based on polls and overall reaction in that thread I would bet there are more falseflaggers then actual Nyan goslings but there are still some... probably. I mean, it would be retared to think Nyanners would stay single for her fans, but y'know we are on /vt/.

>> No.25300164

>>25299786
this is probably why vshojo seems to be slowly trying to attract some of the normalfag twitch viewers
probably easier to deal with and in my opinion those type of viewers tend to have lower standards

>> No.25300187

>>25299646
She mentioned it when she started chadcast.

>> No.25300212

>>25300138
>stay single
no one said this
simply avoid telling us about it, that's all we ask. is it really that big an ask.

>> No.25300371

>>25300212
Nyanners has always mixed her character with her personal life tho. Its not like the chuubas that are on kayfabe all the time.

>> No.25300396

>>25300212
>simply avoid telling us about it, that's all we ask. is it really that big an ask.
In most cases I might agree with you, but I actually don't think this would be reasonable in Nyanners case.
Isn't the guy she's dating also a vtuber with his own career? If she's dating and moving in with some guy who also has a public presence then sooner or later people will find out. They probably thought it would be best to rip the band-aid off early before it instead gets leaked and becomes a bigger controversy.
That probably sucks for people like you but it probably was the right thing for her to do.

>> No.25300406
File: 109 KB, 612x596, 1653681660375.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25300406

>>25300212
>simply avoid telling us about it, that's all we ask. is it really that big an ask.
jesus christ, anon.

>> No.25300507

>>25287695
WTF I love Pink Cat now.

>> No.25300513

>>25300371
plus like this guy said >>25300396 the man she's dating is also a vtuber/streamer
I don't know how you can keep something like that secret for so long

>> No.25300543

>>25300164
hard to imagine that if their founder was shoving a 17-inch dildo inside her in a chaturbate stream over easter

>> No.25300562

>>25300371
i wish she were though her keyfabe is legitimately the best one in the vtuber scene and would lead to so much kino were she to still be using it like she used to a year ago

>> No.25300644

>>25300396
>That probably sucks for people like you but it probably was the right thing for her to do.
sure, that might be true. i just need to let go and find something else.

>> No.25300645

>>25300396
isn't it way too early to come into public with that anyway? Let alone moving out together?

>> No.25300650

>>25300187
Got a timestamp?

>> No.25300664

>>25300543
Their founder is that GunRun dude, to my knowledge he's not shoving dildos up his own ass.
That dude has been well connected to Twitch, I believe he's actually one of the co founders of that site

>> No.25300762

>>25300645
Is there really such a thing as too early? Seems better to get it out of the way immediately

>> No.25300839

>>25300762
based, you really should just get married after the first date anyway

>> No.25300840

>>25287549
It turned out that they are not vtubers.
They are just female streamers using anime avatars.

>> No.25300872

>>25299372
I dont watch Twitch much but is it normal to lose 70% of your subscribers if you dont stream for a few weeks? Doesnt that shit auto renew?

>> No.25300933

>>25300839
I was talking about the announcement thing, not her relationship sure lol

>> No.25300976

>>25300664
I think he meant Mel. Also it seems very fucky if a co-founder formerly worked over a platform known for being very arbitrary where they're now set on

>> No.25301115

>>25300872
>but is it normal to lose 70% of your subscribers if you dont stream for a few weeks?
Pretty much yeah. If you're not streaming you're basically nonexistent on Twitch. Especially since they don't keep vods forever there.
>Doesnt that shit auto renew?
You can set it for that but most people likely aren't that retarded aren't gonna leave that on. Especially for a streamer that hasn't streamed in weeks.
Also some fans will only wait until the next stream to resub so that it gets "noticed" by their streamer. Some sub while they aren't online but that's a small part.

>> No.25301133

>>25300872
Only your prime, I think? Most fags renew them during stream time anyway

>> No.25301192

>>25300976
To be fair, Twitch's management was probably a lot better back when that guy worked there I guess

>> No.25301474

>>25300976
>company is established in a platform you formerly worked on
>known for double standards in arbitrarily enforcing their own ToS
>10+million venture capital investment in your company
you're onto something

>> No.25301484

>>25298232
kek are you the zenfag that keeps getting mad over anyone talking about people other than zen during her streams?

>> No.25301541

>>25301474
So basically it turns out having connections helps out a lot?
I'm not sure what's exactly shocking about this anon

>> No.25301565
File: 3.86 MB, 1873x1899, AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25301565

fuck i clicked back here and didn't notice it wasn't /vsj+/

>> No.25301742

>>25301565
Not really that much of a difference since somehow even after weeks of her being gone there are periods where literally all that people are talking about over there is Nyanners.

>> No.25301755
File: 498 KB, 761x715, [sound=https%3A%2F%2Ffiles.catbox.moe%2Fwilg34.mp4].png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25301755

>>25301565
you're in my territory now, cuck

>> No.25301773
File: 342 KB, 342x504, pomuPray.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25301773

>>25301755

>> No.25302339

>>25301742
That's basically the only place to talk about her whether you're a fan or hater since the nyan thread decided to hibernate. Unfortunate for people who want to talk about the other members there.

>> No.25302445

>>25302339
I can just keep making this thread with this same OP image if you want

>> No.25302464

>>25288523
>pomf
This. Fuck her in every aspect and endeavour of her life.

>> No.25302721

>>25302445
No. I appreciate the concern but this would probably make things worse since it would just encourage more tourists to come to /vsj+/ since that's usually what happens with bait threads.
At this point the only thing that can remedy things in /vsj+/ is if people just slowly forget about this stuff overtime. It sucks but not the first time that thread has had to deal with stuff like this.

>> No.25302878

>>25302721
Doesn't help that the retards kept humoring the schizos and also let the shipfags run rampant. I swear vsj had a dedicated janny ffs

>> No.25302894

>>25302464
I still think her decision made sense, but I'm not gonna sit here and defend her post-cucking.

>> No.25302926

>>25302878
I wouldn't be surprised if whatever janny worked on that thread gave up ages ago.

>> No.25302954

>>25302878
i honestly dont think theres any hope for /vsj/ being a good thread post-nyangosling removal, they're the only posters who tied the thread to the atmosphere of the rest of the generals.

>> No.25303004

>>25302721
i can't exactly forget that my oshi is being fucked by another man anon, i wish i could but i can't

>> No.25303007

>>25302894
>post-cucking
man no wonder people think vtuber fans are losers
anyone normal person who looks at this board would probably think we all belong in a asylum

>> No.25303229

>>25303007
i don't seek acceptance unlike a certain social chameleon

>> No.25303283

>>25303229
>haha you guys are crazy
>NYAN IS A LITERAL LIZARD PERSON
meds

>> No.25303298

>>25302954
Probably true. The nyan thread back when it existed felt more similar to other generals on this board. Even after the whole bf thing I still think that was true, her non gosling fans still seemed to also understand the rest of the board at least.
There are so many twitch normalfag posters there now thanks to Ironmouse and Veibae and they've predictably been cancerous. To her credit Nyanners hasn't really tried to clout chase after large streamers as much as some of her colleagues.

>> No.25303426

>>25287305
If she announced her marriage, or even engagement, I would be happy for her.

>> No.25303507
File: 16 KB, 659x188, goback.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
25303507

>>25303298
>There are so many twitch normalfag posters there now thanks to Ironmouse and Veibae and they've predictably been cancerous.

>> No.25303520

>>25303004
unironically seek therapy

>> No.25303592

>>25303507
Kek yeah that's a great example

>> No.25303621

>>25302954
>nyanfags were the ones tying the thread together
Holy fuck how bad did it get? You are literally able to discuss about 8 chuubas and people close to them

>> No.25303788

>>25303621
It was always dominated by nyanfags and fans of the other top two girls. And still kind of is but of course the lack of streaming from Nyanners has not helped the mental stability there.
To be fair, most of the other girls also haven't been streaming that much either. That makes talking about them harder. Even Ironmouse too since she's now extra sick and can't stream as much currently, she was one of the most consistent ones in the org.

>> No.25303817

>>25293323
Any vtuber that isn't retarded should have savings and money in stocks. Their lifestyle is theoretically cheap since 99% of their day is spent at their computer so they should have a shit ton of savings. However asking a vtuber to not be a retard and make good financial decisions is unrealistic.

>> No.25304076

>>25302954
>>25303788
Veibae dating Sodapoppin has unironically caused more irreparable damage to that thread than any vshojo related yab combined.

>> No.25304150

>>25287305
you know she has like 5 channels on twitch right?

>> No.25304547

she hasn't been streaming because aethelstan is throbbing her ovaries full of cum in preparation for the vshojo baby saga, and there's nothing you cucks can do about it

>> No.25304648

>>25304547
vei is already on that but not in the way you'd expect

>> No.25305223

>>25297708
you forgot to mention the drama she caused on /a/ for fucking a guy inside the /a/-sings circlejerk which almost killed the project altogether

>> No.25307298

Am I the only one who watched Nyan because the character looks kind of edible? Like you'd take a bite out of her and it'd be yummy as fuck?

>> No.25307388

>>25307298
elaborate

>> No.25307411

>>25307298
least deranged poster itt

>> No.25307455

>>25307298
Based

>> No.25307888

>>25307298
what

>> No.25308408

>>25307298
She's like cotton candy someone dropped on the ground. I kind of get it

>> No.25308570

>>25305223
>almost
Therein lies her real mistake.

>> No.25308634

>>25307298
Yeah like a skin oil covered pink easter peep.

>> No.25308927

>>25287305

Nyanners is entertaining for me but like most things i wouldn't pay for her entertainment on twitch, because most of the time its not the highest of quality. Her editor helps her look better then she is most of the time when shes LIVE. I literally couldn't give a fuck what pilled type she is or if he has some BF. If she stops streaming because shes scared of backlash for getting one she truly is the pinkest of pussies. The bitch just needs to start up a gum road and upload whatever the fuck she wants with a good editor i would pay for that shit. and if that silly bitch lurks here consider what the fuck i am saying you have a large enough of cult following you, they will fund you.

Stay true to yourself, pink cat you’re capable of more than you know.

>> No.25309167

>twitch react
>entertaining
lol lmao even

>>
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action