Chuuba Card Game Thread #3

[Anonymous No.]

Magic Set Editor (has YGO templates too): https://www.dropbox.com/s/94m0c1whx6svktm/Magic%20Set%20Editor%20Full%20-%20Magic.zip?dl=0
https://www.dropbox.com/s/ibm2wtzayn6s6ty/Magic%20Set%20Editor%20Full%20-%20Other%20Styles.zip?dl=0
Font Pack for MTG, YGO, etc.
https://www.dropbox.com/s/u1vqnl0f3lplzh8/Font%20Pack.zip?dl=0
Decent custom card info-graphic: https://i.imgur.com/IX80a76.png

[Anonymous No.]

>>2247486
OP of thread 2, glad someone revived it! Here's a bump friend. At work so no new card for me

[Anonymous No.]

>>2247486
no link to previous thread, no done cards gallery? how do you work without that?
also can't I use mtg.design?

[Anonymous No.]

>>2253579
Not op of this thread but here
>>2225886
You are welcome to use whatever you want, but MTG Set Editor is closer to the actual card design wise.
My favorites from last thread and picrel is mine.
>>2229443
>>2232906
>>2228641

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

>>2254033

[Anonymous No.]

>>2254033
>>2254483
Card is unironically playable in something like Duel Links.

[Anonymous No.]

Be considerate.

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

>>2254033
Thats actually pretty decent graveyard set up even if it would get NO'd

[Anonymous No.]

>>2256272
Oooooh fun

[Anonymous No.]

>>2256272
This card's cool, very cool. Might be a little broken, but very welcome. I am not sure how the expanded rules treats a card that is searched for, but isn't placed on any location. For example, check out Gonti, Lord of Luxury. The impetus is to exile it face down and let you cast it.

[Anonymous No.]

so when are we making the hololive game

[Anonymous No.]

>>2256558
Not a full game, but I have been thinking about making a yugioh archetype of Hololive where the gimmick would be that they gain stats based on the other holos on the board (I.E: Collabs). I haven't played yugioh since they released synchros though so it would probably be really bad compared to the current meta.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2256558
I am not nearly inspired enough to make an entire game.
But I had the idea of making a MTG Duel Deck, Amelia Watson vs Gawr Gura or something like this. Except the power level wouldn't be that bad.
But if this thread keeps going, in a few days/weeks we might have enough good cards for a mini cube.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2256442
I didn't play during Kaladesh but I do remember Gonti from some EDH decks that I played.

Unfortunately the cardsmith site only allows for a specific amount of text. For Ame's card you would reveal it and put it in your hand. Then, regardless of its location afterwards (hand, library, gy, etc), it would get exiled at the end of the next phase.

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

>>2257320
I feel that this ability is more green than blue? Search for creature is very green, especially if you're gonna place them to the battlefield.
This card would have been retarded in Ixalan block.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2257320
>Potential 8 for 1 for UUUU
>Can repeat the effect the turn afterwards by fucking exiling cards from your library which may as well not even be a cost at all

You better make this shit cost 8 CMC or something.

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

>>2257657
Fuck I also made an Ina planeswalker. I know it's the super special snowflake card type, but it was justified since she's an outer world entity.

She has shit constitution, reads her book, summons takos, and erases your sanity.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2256889
>create X 0/1 Human Chicken KFP employee creature tokens, where X is your devotion to red
>1RRR: Return Kiara Takanashi the Majestic from your graveyard to your hand
fixed

[Anonymous No.]

>>2256889
A legendary Human Phoenix is actually a sick card type that I'm surprised WotC hasn't touched yet.
Also needs a way to revive herself. Maybe if you control no creatures, you may cast her during your end step tapped?

[Anonymous No.]

>>2257657
>>2258296
walkers don't have subtypes other than the name IE Legendary Planeswalker — Chandra

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

>>2259395
The Haato/Haachama being special summoned when the other is removed from the field is supposed to represent how she switches between her personalities

[Anonymous No.]

>>2259448
Gosling's love their Oshi's so much, they'll sacrifice themselves and their wellbeing to benefit them.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2259485
Fuck I meant to put UNION instead of MACHINE under Gosling

[Anonymous No.]

>>2259530

[Anonymous No.]

>>2259561
Tried to reference Korone's endurance streams by making her a monster that has the potential to stay on the board for a while.
So that's the beginning of the set I plan to make, their honestly probably all garbge tier because I haven't played YU-GI-OH in forever but whatever.
also,>>2256663 is me as well lol

[Anonymous No.]

>>2257657
This card is too good. I would make it
+2 Make two 1/1 takodachis with menace
-3 Destroy creature + gain life
-10 get the emblem

[Anonymous No.]

>>2257657
>>2259664 is correct, i'm assuming the 3rd selection is a typo? should really be - at least

[Anonymous No.]

would you?

[Anonymous No.]

I just wanted to make a dumb combo. .

[Anonymous No.]

This needs more work and better wording, but I'm not mad at it.

[Anonymous No.]

I'm back with some more cards. I have a few ideas of how I want to do this >>2256774
>>2261299
Love the art. Very lore friendly. The template for this is "Kiara, General Manager enters the battlefield with X +1/+1 counters on it, where X is the number of life you've gained this turn."
>>2260966
Personally, I'd rework the text/templating. Usually for an activated ability, you put a : before the effect and after the cost. Scry requires a number.
If this were in a set, Ao-Chan would be a top tier mythic.
>>2257657
>>2258296
These two are great, ironically I think >>2258296 would be named Ninomae Ina'mis and >>2257657 would be the variant.
>>2260035
I would

[Anonymous No.]

Friend will have your back.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2261875
fixed wording on the equipment.

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

>>2256272
Give it Flash, coward!

[Anonymous No.]

I can't actually upload these Ina themed proxies to 4chan due to filesize, so here they are in all their glory on shitty imgur.

https://imgur.com/a/XCb1CQJ

What are they? Print ready proxies and tokens for Vampire Hexmage and Marit Lage, perfect for your weeaboo EDH deck.

You can use sites like makeplayingcards to have these printed for your table.

Glory be to our priestess, humu humu

[Anonymous No.]

>>2259664
>6 mana
its trash

[Anonymous No.]

>>2262568
As it's printed right now, it can get the emblem and 16 loyalty in the first tick, which is broken.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2254033
>>2254483

[Anonymous No.]

>>2262601
>6 mana
Still trash.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2262601
the emblem is hot garbage though and theres plenty of planeswalker removal

[Anonymous No.]

>>2261889

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

Relevant to today's stream

[Anonymous No.]

Posting this to see y'all thoughts. It would be horrible for a set, but I was trying to give the HoloEN Girls different Token Interactions

[Anonymous No.]

Extremely low effort, that probably already exists somewhere

[Anonymous No.]

>>2264687
rrat

[Anonymous No.]

Bump. My take on Mori.
>>2261912
Renaming Chumqueen to Online and having a few Online cards for each of the chuubas.

[Anonymous No.]

Need to sleep but here is my contribution. Might do more tomorrow.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2264687
>>2264875
Here's another.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2265945
>3 mana enchantment
>Storm but 1/1 tokens
>plus extra gravy for graveyard silliness

anon, Storm is a 10 on the Storm scale for a reason. It's not coming back. This card is beyond busted. Even a bad Release the Warrens is still a good card.

Mori is fine, strength wise, but that's a mono-black card. There's nothing White about casting from the grave or casting creatures from the grave. That's a strong Black identity. Make her a 2BB spell and you're set.


Also, I'm more confused to why Mori is WB in your set. Mori's character has little to do with order, identity, and the common self. If anything, she would have a Red splash as that's the color of artistry and emotion (in addition to the obvious Black identity).

Also I like the Gura equipment. It's cute.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2267344
I actually thought about the Storm issue (also technically, TECHNICALLY, storm came back with Thousand Year Storm). The easy nerf would be to simply rework it into only storming off of other Deadbeat cards and then bumping their cost. (And dropping the "every other" tag)
The white part was because I always viewed her as the sane and orderly one. Trying her best to be the pure one of EN. I don't really watch too much of her streams if i were honest.
I'll sleep on it.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2267344
>>2267466
I re-read what you said and mechanically you are correct. Looks better in pure black anyway.

[Anonymous No.]

Anyone here play Shadowverse (a.k.a the weeb Hearthstone)?

[Anonymous No.]

>>2266011

Hey, what programs are you using to make those?

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

Meme card that is also niche.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2268528
It’s the program in the OP with the templates in the OP

[Anonymous No.]

The forbidden meme card

[Anonymous No.]

Does MSE still have Pokemon Card templates? I want to make some for the EN mascots.

[Anonymous No.]

This is fun. It does bother me that I have no idea how to decide if a card should be common, uncommon,
rare or mythic, but I guess it doesn't really matter.

[Anonymous No.]

I made a quick sorta set around Mori-Deadbeat themes.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2268797
Yeah, its right there on the website.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2269172
It's not an actual set, but I tried to include flavor that synergized somewhat.

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

>>2268964
It boils down to 1) Power Level and 2) Card Complexity

[Anonymous No.]

>>2268234
Used to play it but I felt it got too degenerate after verdant conflict (I mainly play jank homebrew and I have 16% winrate after that expansion). I can't even farm my dailies in 2+ hours.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2268234
Eyyyy. Finally, some more Shadobabs. Here's my take on Rushia from the previous thread.

[Anonymous No.]

shit this looks like a fun thread
now i'm sad i never spent any time on tcg's

[Anonymous No.]

Why, yes. I am a degenerate Portal main. How could you tell?

[Anonymous No.]

>>2262277
>Marit lage
Extremely fitting. I like.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2268964
If you wanna be technical/accurate, it’s explained by MaRo here https://magic.wizards.com/en/articles/archive/making-magic/new-world-order-2011-12-02

[Anonymous No.]

>>2268577
I get the theme but all creatures ETB have Summoning Sickness regardless of stuff like Haste or not

[Anonymous No.]

Morning lads. The updated Amelia collection, I'll probably change some of the names when I figure out better ones for them.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2278669
Give me a sort of Yu-gi-oh vibe with the design.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2278669
The Timesplice reminder text reads weirdly to me. I think it should read: Timesplice (As long as this spell is on the stack, players can't cast spells or activate abilities that aren't mana abilities, and triggered abilities can't trigger.), which is tacking "and triggered abilities can't trigger." to the end of the Split Second reminder text instead of shoving it in the middle? Or is there something I'm mis-parsing about it?

[Anonymous No.]

>>2280156
You're probably right. I felt off about doing it this way but I wanted to make Amelia centric instants that didn't become useless to her ability. Maybe the correct decision is to not use instants this way or not to use Split Second at all. Not sure, it's one of those things that I would actually have to sit down and do some real playtesting to get a feel for but there aren't nearly enough cards done to do that.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2257378
Blue doesn't get to search for "creatures", only green and sometimes white.
Any color can search for creatures named by the card, and any color can create tokens. But blanket "creatures" is a green ability.
And its not one of the rules that can be broken with a legendary tag. Instead of searching, it should search and exile, then let you cast them from exile or create illusion tokens of them.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2261985
Mmmmm... Does Doubling Season or Proliferate go through shroud? I think not so this card is deceptively weaker than you'd think because a 10 turn counter is too slow for anything however.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2280438
Both go through shroud without a problem. Shroud protects cards from being targetted, and cards are only targetted if it literally says target.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2280519
Ah then this card isn't that great but it's definitely better. Doubling Season turns it into 5 turns and you could probably just win outright if you had some shenanigans with untappers

[Anonymous No.]

>>2262568
How bout my moderately op Mori then.

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

>>2260966
Ao should be something big and colorless like an Eldrazi

[Anonymous No.]

>>2280692
The only untappers you could use would have to be global, like Dramatic reversal or you could could cheat in a "Freed from the Reel" or "Pemmin's Aura" with Zur - since he puts them directly onto the battlefield you can attach both of them to a creature, without them having to target anything

>>2280901
That's 8 CMC.
Honestly, I feel like she could be Tron playable. With either Chromatic Sphere or Chromatic Star on the battlefield you can get her down by T3, if you manage to assemble Tron. And the combination of her keywords in addition her pump ability, can get your opponent down in a single swing. By paying 8 life you win on a clear board. For every 1 life you pay more than that you can basically ignore two blockers, thanks to Trample+Deathtouch.

[Anonymous No.]

Best thread on this god forsaken board, second only to watamelon. Bump.

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

>>2266011
Altered amesame and made the other myth girls. Probably not going to continue after this. Somewhat designed with a set in mind that would care about 1/1 Fan creature tokens, but it didn't wind up mattering much. Each holo would of been at least uncommon with a toughness of at least 2, while the mascots/fans would be commons. I also think having songs as Sagas is a cute idea but didn't make any.

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

>>2282280
Why are these silver bordered again? I do like them a lot though, low powered designs in this thread are quite rare.

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

>>2282280
I like the songs as Saga's idea, might try to make it later.

As for the cards, I like with most of them but I feel like Ina could use a little something. It's a nice enough card, but doesn't feel as thematically on point.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2282391
Forgot to say you can summon the hololive monster from the deck.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2282378
Thank you. No real good reason.
>>2282438
She is definitely the one I spent the least amount of time on. I just didn't get a good idea of what to do with her.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2282772
Ina is known for art, squid/eldritch and support via priestess which all have niches already.
I feel like she's a Blood artist type card, some powerful combo machine.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2260035
>>2263048
>>2261889
>>2281806
>>2282391
Would you guys mind if I add these cards with some slight changes to my HOLOLIVE set? Some really interesting effects here, especially for some Holo's that I didn't have any good ideas for.

[Anonymous No.]

I gave it a try.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2284396
Most of the abilities don't feel very fitting to their character or their character settings either.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2284396
I general Magic uses the first name of a PW as their type line.

Ina's +2 seems too good. It should probably create two 1/1 without invasion at best for +1 instead. Her -3 is fine, although I'd ditch the requirements and maybe even the lifegain. Also most PW can't downtick twice off of their starting loyalty, so probably lower the starting loyalty to 5. With that you can also lower the ultimate to probably -8.

Kiara seems really weak. Being able to Ult after ticking up once is weird, but I don't see too many problems. Temporary Tokens are exiled when they are supposed to disappear.

Gura is way too strong.

Calli is fine, probably lower starting loyalty and ultimate by 1 for the same reason as Ina above.

Ame is fine.

[Anonymous No.]

There's more than just the Vtuber and the Fans. Lots of in jokes and temp characters can be made into cards too.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2285663
Cleaning up the template a bit will make it fine.
> no need for 1 target, the 1 is implicit.
> lower converted mana cost is the official wording, it will become a mouthful so just hardcode the cost to 4.
When Go Strider enters the battlefield, you may gain control of a target creature whose converted mana cost is less than 4 for as long as Go Strider remains on the battlefield.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2285831
WITH converted mana cost less than 4

[Anonymous No.]

>>2285831
> lower converted mana cost is the official wording
not anymore. With Strixhaven CMC was changed to manavalue

[Anonymous No.]

>>2285888
Jesus christ you're right. Welp, i might have to change some of the wordings in my set when I get home.
Also is this seriously a harry potter themed plane?

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

>>2282867
Not really what you suggested but I feel like it's more appropriate than the last one at least.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2286139
B-Bob? Is that you?

[Anonymous No.]

Cool. Another custom card thread means another excuse to post every card I ever made.

https://files.catbox.moe/jx0rgv.jpg

I remember I noted feedback about adding better flavor, but I kinda lost steam on custom cards. Maybe when I feel motivated again I'll take a second edit on these cards

[Anonymous No.]

>>2286472
>placeholders
>designed bottom up, not top down
R-risu chama... I kneel.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2286139
Yeah, I'd say it certainly is. Even in official MTG you get multiple cards that represent different facets of the same character. Have a new idea, make another card. Its not like we have to worry about unbalancing the game, though it's more fun to make fair cards.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2286472
Cringe and Kino. You live in another plane from us mortals, but it might not be a step up.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2256272
What's the point in Exile if you can use a card from it?

[Anonymous No.]

>>2285973
You think they're getting a little too friendly with those "pick a card outside the game" mechanics?

[Anonymous No.]

>>2286808
I am not sure if i were honest. I quit Magic right around the start of Eldraine cuz fuck Oko. I had basically lost all hope at WoTC maintaining this game since then. I have no clue how this plays.
That said, it just means you can dip into your sideboard in regulation play, so a pool of 15 cards. a 75 card deck essentially. Kinda interesting, but also seems like a design space that is easy to fuck up in.

[Anonymous No.]

Not sure if the card is one generic mana too cheap or not.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2287176
Basically unusable as is. Even under rare ideal circumstances, it's not very good.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2287389
Maybe I was going for flavour too much.
Could be fun in casual commander though.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2258296
Mill isn't an official keyword

[Anonymous No.]

>>2288553
They started using mill as official term on cards recently.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2282290
>>2281806
kek

[Anonymous No.]

>>2288553
It is. You would have been right 6 months ago.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2287176
It's kind of weak since it's too expensive and the statline is kind of meh. You could make her a 9/9 or a 10/10 and it would still be fine at that mana cost. Also that kind of effect is a very black effect. As it is, it could probably be a neat 2BB costed card.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2288553
>>2285888
/vt/ card nerds, do you guys like WoTC moving to converting common phrases into ability keywords?
Personally as long as MTG doesn't start abbreviations like YGO I will be fine.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2281322
I wonder just what being Tron playable means, in terms to quality.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2289659
I feel like as long as it's short intuitive words like this it's fine. But having multiple words you need to explain in a sentence is exponentially worse with each word, which is where this could head.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2289659
honestly, I like it. It's clears up a lot of text and adds new possibilities.

Ward {x} or Mill {n} is a great way to template commonly understood abilities and Menace is just cleaning up words words words.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2256558
I've been working on it here and there. Got the basic ruleset down and was working on getting some starter decks prepped so I could show it off to you guys when it's done.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2284396
>Ina
This is a strong card but i don't wanna change anything in her lol

>Kiara
Change her mana value to 4 change the ultimate to 6, it's not that strong and is not too game ending like some other emblems

>Gura
A bit too strong but changing the mana value to 1UU nerf her a little without make her unplayable

>Mori
Make her mana value at 5 and change the ultimate to 8

>Amelia
She's weak and i don't know if any change can make her competitive


>t.tako

[Anonymous No.]

watamelon?

[Anonymous No.]

Turn 3. Tap 3 swamps, Takodachi, Takodachi, Takodachi. Pass, your go.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2294224
AHH FUCK I MEAN ELDRAZI HORROR!

[Anonymous No.]

>>2291305
nice

[Anonymous No.]

>>2262568
The fuck are you talking about? It comes in and immediately blows up an enemy creature/planeswalker and if your enemy has multiple creatures you just minus and block them unless they have trample.
The emblem is kinda weak but that +2 and -2 is more than good enough lmao

[Anonymous No.]

Watamelon, a.k.a battle fader on crack.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2294417
>>2291305

also stop with the first person wording, its cringe af

[Anonymous No.]

>>2294450
>kill a creature/PW
>for 6 mana
Never go full retard, anon.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2294450
These guys are playing on mostly eternal format from what I'm guessing. In cEDH, Modern, etc it's absolute trash for the mana cost. Also, remember that Jace the Mindsculptor came back to Modern and it didn't really warp the format like it used to.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2294450
>It comes in and immediately blows up an enemy creature/planeswalker
Wow, a 6 mana kill one thing.
> if your enemy has multiple creatures you just minus and block them
A 6 mana two 1/1 blockers.

It's barely even a win more card.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2296623
>eternal format
The only format where this could be good is draft.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2296538
>>2296682
>>2296623
It's comparable to this Garruk, but I'll give you your due in saying it wouldn't be played at all in cEDH or Modern unless you're maybe playing a superfriends meme deck.
It's still a good as fuck planeswalker for standard/limited because the kill effect means every single creature or planeswalker thereafter must have hexproof, trample, or do something immediately when it enters the battlefield or else it just dies when you untap. It even has inevitably with the -2.
I will concede that it does seem like one of those purposely shit planeswalker decks planeswalkers, though.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2297016
>It's comparable to this Garruk
which is shit but not as shit

[Anonymous No.]

I feel there's a lot of design space with MTG you guys aren't really exploring, what with

>generic big creature
and
>generic scary planeswalker

Instants, sorceries, enchantments, not everything has to be [[generic representation of chuuba]]. Be a little more creative.

>>2286139
>>2285663
>>2267508
Also the yugioh templating on cards is weird. Just make a YGO card then.

>>2291305
I saw this idea going around here and there, and honestly having so many stats is kinda cringe. It makes cards difficult to use, and not having a system of unmixable attributes would make deckbuilding super uninteresting.

I mean, anyone who wants to get into CCG design should at least watch this

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6g5001__cY0&list=PLphu8NE8GQc4ldfNEEFX3dOPv_ihxADv

>>2293982
This is a fun design though, hornets nests are always cool.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2297676
>>2267508
>Also the yugioh templating on cards is weird. Just make a YGO card then.
It's just this but strictly better.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2297016
>kill effect means every single creature or planeswalker thereafter must have hexproof, trample, or do something immediately when it enters the battlefield
Aka the current state of standard for god knows how many years now.
Reminder that meta is full of monored decks loaded with haste and low curve or R/G decks with fat haste or U/B flash creatures that laugh at sorcery speed removal or the wide white decks or the U/B decks with fuck all creatures that will NEVER let you land a 6 mana sorcery speed removal and will continue pinging your face.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2297676
Stats are mostly used as deckbuilding guides rather than stuff that you pay attention to during gameplay. It's similar to Arkham Horror and Marvel Champions' stat system, but since the idea is that you choose three holos to manage and make popular, I wanted the system to be flexible enough to accommodate deckbuilding in multiple directions. There are clear directions for archetypes and I have one other system I'm trying out that would guide deckbuilding so that it's not just a goodstuff-fest. But point noted.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2297016
>>2296538
>>2296623
>>2296682
>>2297760

I think you guys are too daft. That Ina is badly designed, yes, but it's also a card that can conceivably see a LOT of play, even in a format like modern or legacy. The ability to UNCONDITIONALLY kill a creature/PW on a + ability is ridiculous. Although, like I said, it's bad design, because if you plus it on an empty board Ina has no choice but to commit suicide. Killing creatures is no big deal, killing creatures on a + is huge though. Compare Ina to Nicol Bolas, or Chandra, heart of fire. There's very few PWs with removal on + abilities, and it means that you can remove something each turn, effectively meaning your opponents can't play anything into it. This is also why Oko was so strong, and while Ina's not Oko-tier, it still outpowers just about every standard PW rn, and would likely be stronger than Teferi, Hero of Dominaria.

Yes, if I had a 6 mana PW that +2's to Hero's Downfall, I'd play that shit all day long.

>>2297901
In that case, just make cards one type or the other. Like Idolmaster, or you know, any other card game. Make some sort of restriction, like a leader card in FoW, that prevents you from using too many different types of cards in one deck without drawback. Honestly, you need to write a design doc before you even bother templating cards.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2294224
in response i dismember a takodachi and cast surgical extraction targeting takodachi

[Anonymous No.]

>>2298011
I've already got a design doc on hand so no worries on that. I don't think hard line divisions of cards are necessary when there are plenty of popular games that have soft lines, especially for a project that's only going to have a limited number of cards in the first place.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2298011
> This is also why Oko was so strong
Oko was also 3 mana with colors that can protect the shit out of it, not 6.

>Yes, if I had a 6 mana PW that +2's to Hero's Downfall, I'd play that shit all day long.
You are free to make bad decisions but we are also free to laugh at them

[Anonymous No.]

>>2298062
In response, I am sad.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2298177
A small playerbase is no reason to design a bad game, though if you're just fucking around then sure. When I was a kid I'd draw custom cards in crayon too. If you want it to ever be really playable, though, you have to take it a tad more seriously.

>>2298258
>Oko was also 3 mana with colors that can protect the shit out of it, not 6.
>UG
>protection
lmao

The strongest part of Oko, and honestly most powerful PWs, is that they can protect themselves. Which this Ina does laughably well.

>You are free to make bad decisions but we are also free to laugh at them
have you never bothered to think WHY WotC doesn't ever print PWs that + to perform removal like this?

[Anonymous No.]

>>2298646
Not necessarily small playerbase, but small unique card count, where most of the problems of having goodstuff.dek arise (when there's too much generically good stuff that people can include in every deck so decks become super homogenized).

For obvious reasons, I have no plans to monetize or take credit for the game, it's mostly an excuse to flex my design muscles.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2298011
>it still outpowers just about every standard PW rn
An incredible achievement in a format with weak planeswalkers that see almost no play.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2282280
Made the mascots as partner cards. If I ever make more, I'm going to continue this theme.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2298646
>UG
>counterspells out the ass
>veil of summer

>have you never bothered to think WHY WotC doesn't ever print PWs that + to perform removal like this?
but they have though you literally just pointed to Oko in your last post, they dont need to print creature removal when they can do more degenerate shit like Teferi/Cosmic Imposter

[Anonymous No.]

Maybe our 5th favorite custom card reviewer will review your guy's hololive archtype if it isn't trash, seeing as he's a total holofag.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2299016
Roosting Worker ruins it's own upside
Some of these are pretty bad commons unfortunately...
>>2299403
Who?

[Anonymous No.]

>>2299403
What hololive archetype lmao

>>2298801
>For obvious reasons, I have no plans to monetize or take credit for the game, it's mostly an excuse to flex my design muscles.
Then design better

>>2298833
>An incredible achievement in a format with weak planeswalkers that see almost no play.
I don't disagree, but that's the power level we're balancing things against, for the most part. Ina is certainly a better card than the 6 mana kaya, for example.

>>2299084
UG, even at the peak of its power, was known for not having much interaction. That's why UG decks tended to splash for removal and interaction. Oko is busted, because it's loyalty goes so high it's difficult to effectively kill with damage and removal, but that doesn't mean UG is good at protecting Oko. Veil of summer is a fantastic card, but the turn you land Oko it's going to be vulnerable to the board. Oko's abilities allow it to protect itself, but that's because he's Oko, not because UG is a strong archetype defensively, unlike, say, UW, UR, or UB, all of which have cheap removal to protect its walkers. Oko is the single best piece of UG removal ever printed, and it's also a bitterblossom. But there's a reason UG was considered a weak color pair before the UrOko mess of 2019-20.

[Anonymous No.]

Which does /vt/ prefer?

[Anonymous No.]

>>2300280
The templating is all wrong, and neither works particularly well in those colors, The art and frame are quite nice though, but the second reads better at least. Both should be RW though, they both have VERY RW abilities. But I also don't see what either ability has to do with Gura, they're rather generic.

Why a shark would have RW abilities, though, seems iffy to me. To be on theme it needs U.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2300280
Flavor fail with the colors being green and red. Green hates equipment because equipment is the antithesis of nature and I don't understand what the red is doing here.
It should really be blue and white or green and blue

[Anonymous No.]

>>2300488
Red gets First strike, G doesn't. But the card should absolutely be RW, and it doesn't fit the theme of Gura. RW is both the equipment archetype, as well as the "underdog" archetype, where smaller creatures get bonuses vs bigger creatures.

The sacrifice bit is the most puzzling, RG and RW don't really get that stuff.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2297676
Took a stab at a "song as a sagas" as suggested by some anons earlier, though I like the more traditional take on events-as-sagas too.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2301059
ok card just get rid of the nearest opponent shit

[Anonymous No.]

>>2301059
Now thats a busted saga

[Anonymous No.]

>>2301059
Cool card, too wordy and would be more elegant if you removed the reminder text. Songs as Sagas is a cool idea, but it does seem to take away that connection to Vtubers, and become more about the song.

if there was a Holo/vtuber card game, I'd presume that could be neat, treating songs like sorceries.

>>2301249
In an EDH environment? It's meh. In something like Legacy? Still, kinda meh. Waiting for the effects of a saga is definitely a big deal, and a card like this would never be printed into standard anyways.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2300444
>>2300488
>>2300657
Very good criticisms. I'll go back to the drawing board with this one.

[Anonymous No.]

Can anyone make basic lands using holo art? I really wanna get some made, but there are no decent basic lands with a holo theme.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2301812
if you have the images, I can whip up proxies for you. I have all the templates anyways.
Try for 600dpi, 2400x1800 or greater.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2301965
I'll see what I can fish up, but I don't save good art, just memes.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2301992
reason I ask for huge dimensions is because I try to make alters print ready for anons to use for proxy cards.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2302043
Gomenasai, over the past year all I'd save is memes to use as reaction images, never actual art. So even having good dimensions is a tall order from me. I was hoping anybody else would have good art lying in wait for making good basics.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2297676
>>2301059
I also made a song saga
Trying to capture that "everyone is here" feeling

[Anonymous No.]

>>2302217
Should be up costed 2

[Anonymous No.]

Pretty straightforward top-down design here. The more 1/1 creatures (i.e. viewers) you control the richer you get.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2302681
very nice. It's thematic and appropriately costed.
>>2301059
take out the word nearest also opponent shouldn't lose two life
>>2300657
I can see this as a good card
>>2299016
>detective
Fair
>shark
Gura isn't a human
otherwise fine.
>phoenix
Red doesn't populate. Splash white and haste, make it legendary.
>artist
decent
>reaper
decent, but I think she might just want to cost B instead of hybrid W/B. A boros deck shouldn't be able to run something with deathtouch on the creature.
>Hunting hound
take out the token generation and just have it as a 2/2.
>roost
Just give it flying outright.
>>2297676
>Coco conquers
Based. Good flavor, good abilities, good cost.
>>2294261
Should be Eldrazi or Horror and it should be seven. You can grab much more insane eldrazi than you can demons, which is what I assumed you based this card on Shadowborn appostle. The best demon you can grab is Grisildad, while the best eldrazi is Emmy.
>>2293982
I like it, but it should be Non-combat damage being prevented, or else you just hose red outright.
>>2287176
R/G doesn't deal with cards in hand nor discard.
>>2284396
I hate planeswalkers in general, so I won't comment
>>2280901
>8 mana for a threat that can't be answered and kills in one hit
lmao
>>2278669
>timesplice
Just use splitsecond
>Savestate
Just say "exile all other spells and abilities"
>Watson concoction
Should be, "deal 3 damage to any target"
Also just have it check for detective, not two creature types at once
>Watson's Office
Should cost 2 more honestly. Veldelkin Orrery already is an artifact that gives flash, and that clue cracking is pretty bonkers.
>>2268964
I don't think that fits the flavor of Fubuki, and the ability is underwhelming for five mana on a creature, while Asceticism is 5 mana enchantment in one color (easier to cast) that also regenerates.
>>2268577
Actually pretty cash, but you might wanna up the cost by B since it's a pretty powerful, yet interesting ability.
>>2267508
Hakkon but better? Also Reaper isn't a creature type. Spectre and spirit is, so you can choose between them or both of them.
>>2267466
>deadbeat
Interesting mechanic
>Online
Put the condition before the effect. It should start with "When you cast" before "create a skeleton"
>>2264661
Bad
>>2262277
Dark depths, onegai
>>2261985
Should be 20 but there should be a way to remove counters like having another creature an opponent control enter the battlefield.
>>2261912
>merfolk shark
One or the other or add "or" please
Also, equipment should not act as enchantments that interact with non-equipment so blatantly.
>>2256272
interesting.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2284157
go wild

[Anonymous No.]

>>2303472
>R/G doesn't deal with cards in hand nor discard.
I hope you mean with opponent's hand because R very much uses discard/draw mechanic on yourself. Mr Koro should be something like "whenever this creature (or any creature you control alternatively) deals combat damage to a player, you may discard a card. If you do, draw a card. (Or you may discard you hand, if you do, draw 3)

[Anonymous No.]

Kinda feels lonely when i'm the only one posting yugioh cards.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2303472
>decent, but I think she might just want to cost B instead of hybrid W/B. A boros deck shouldn't be able to run something with deathtouch on the creature.
You're right. My bad.
>Red doesn't populate. Splash white and haste, make it legendary.
I think giving her haste is a little much but I did alter her slightly to be more inline with population.
>Just give it flying outright.
I'd rather not, but if this edit doesn't go over well I'll rework it so it's just flying.
>Gura isn't a human
<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/IWRRxHDuqlU?start=880" title="YouTube video player" frameborder="0" allow="accelerometer; autoplay; clipboard-write; encrypted-media; gyroscope; picture-in-picture" allowfullscreen></iframe>

[Anonymous No.]

>>2303472
>decent, but I think she might just want to cost B instead of hybrid W/B. A boros deck shouldn't be able to run something with deathtouch on the creature.
You're right. My bad.
>Red doesn't populate. Splash white and haste, make it legendary.
I think giving her haste is a little much but I did add white.
>Just give it flying outright
>>2299449
I'd rather not but if this edit doesn't go over well I'll reconsider.
>Gura isn't a human
https://youtu.be/IWRRxHDuqlU?t=880

[Anonymous No.]

Rather than a full on Holo game, it might be fun just to make a Holo custom set. That said, these cards will need to revolve more around specific archetypes rather than the smattering of custom cards posted in this and similar threads. What would be interesting draft archetypes for the Holos? Would it be better as a 3-color archetype set or 2-color?

I'm thinking maybe

>WU - Flicker (themed around chuubas taking hiatuses)
>UB - Control
>BR - Reanimation
>RG - Non-Human tribal, stompy
>GW - Go wide, fan tokens
>WB - Sacrifice
>UR - Artifacts
>BG - Graveyard value
>RW - Aggro
>GU - Ramp

Seems like most hololivers can find a place in those archetypes.

>>2306278
Frankly, YGO just isn't as good for custom cards as MTG.

>>2309245
These cards are just kinda... meh? Like, they might be okay draft fodder, but don't feel thematic or interesting at all.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2310049
can you give colors to the fanbases?

We'd need creatures.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2310087
Thats a good idea, but what colors would fans be?

[Anonymous No.]

Bump

[Anonymous No.]

Too slow for aggro?

[Anonymous No.]

>>2312775
What the fuck?
Enchantments don't tap!
Also, if you have tokens, you...
Ahhh~
Put a silver border around it and it's golden

[Anonymous No.]

>>2312775
Enchantment usually don't tap - there are three that do, but they are all from Future Sight, so they aren't the norm by far
Next if you make Pepeloni Tokens, you'd need to specify what kind of Tokens they are. It would probably be easier to have Hachama Cooking enter with Pepeloni counter.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2312990
I know, but it didn't feel right to make it an artifact. Maybe she thinks she is one...

>>2312998
>>It would probably be easier to have Hachama Cooking enter with Pepeloni counter
That's actually what i wanted to do, I have no idea why I changed it to tokens. Maybe cause I was playing around with the idea of Food tokens, but that wouldn't be Rakdos at all.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2313271
Instead of tapping you could make 1colorless mana cost, and "only activate this ability once per turn"

[Anonymous No.]

>>2313271
>>2313325
Also probably better "up to one creature"

[Anonymous No.]

>>2313271
Something you could add is "Whenever a creature you control dies, you may pay 1, if you do put a Pepeloni counter on Haachama cooking"
Not only does this prevent the Enchantment from being useless once all counters are depleted, but it also implies that haachama uses the recently deceased for her cooking.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2303472
Heyo! Thanks for the input
>Eldrazi and cost seven
got it
>timesplice
Splitsecond doesn't stop triggered abilities, otherwise I would have.
>Just say "exile all other spells and abilities"
Templated from Summary Dismissal
>reaper isn't a creature type
Online is a workaround for having cards with an additional mode if you have the specific chuuba on the board. Magic isn't really designed for these interactions but there instances of it (MTG Planeswalker Decks with "If you control a X planeswalker")
>>2261912
Noted

[Anonymous No.]

>>2313325
>>2313357
>>2313398

[Anonymous No.]

>>2313462
>>Just say "exile all other spells and abilities"
>Templated from Summary Dismissal
Ahh, well still, I used the reminder text from Discontinuity that says you can Exile spells and abilities on the stack, even if you aren't ending the turn.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2313478
>>2313357
Disregard this, i suck cocks. I misread the first one as "deals 2 damage to target opponent AND 3 damage to target creature". It doesn't make sense to have "up to 1 creature" since you already have another choice of a target. I was wording it in a way that would prevent you to force to shoot your own creatures if opponent had none

[Anonymous No.]

>>2313587
Eh, my fault for editing it like that.
Thanks for all the input, I'm not used to making actually playable cards.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2303472
Tako Alters Anon here.
I'd do Dark Depths if I could find the art for it.
If you can find me a nice piece of artwork that fits Depths and Ina, I'll make the proxy for you.

See >>2301965 for what I usually use as guidelines when making a print. 400 DPI is the minimum for a decent proxy.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2301812
full art unhinged lands with holo art when

[Anonymous No.]

>>2314631
Only if we replace forests with 草

[Anonymous No.]

>>2301812
Gave it a go

[Anonymous No.]

>>2315258
Shit, captured my cursor over the island.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2310049
>>2310087
>>2310236
Do it like Ravnica, pick a Holo to rep a dual then base the creatures off the fan base, like Ina could be blue black, with Tako's as her creature base

[Anonymous No.]

>>2247486
https://gatherer.wizards.com/pages/card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=509479

[Anonymous No.]

>>2261299
This one's good

[Anonymous No.]

>>2303472
In my defense moderately op Mori can be bounced, countered, blocked by indestructible (like theros gods), phased, Soul seared, and tapped.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2315258
Can you post the original artworks in the thread too?

[Anonymous No.]

is there a negrohombre card already?

[Anonymous No.]

>>2316106
>blocked by indestructible (like theros gods),
literally does nothing except removing 1 damage like every other blocker

[Anonymous No.]

>>2316110
Plains - pixiv.net/en/artworks/88583252
Island - pixiv.net/en/artworks/85713312
Forest - pixiv.net/en/artworks/86406742
Mountain - twitter.com/i/web/status/1273234565314695168
Swamp - twitter.com/i/web/status/1304979032149078016

[Anonymous No.]

>>2316106
>Bounced
Hah. The only unsummon that was even relevant ever was vapor snag and chain of vapors, which only appeared in very fringe legacy infect or delver decks
>Blocked
She has trample and you can pay 15 life to make her a 34/34
>counter
The only meta counterspells are force of negation, cryptic command, and spell pierce.
So we only have one counterspell
>phased
Even in the phasing block there are close to no cards that instant speed phase an opponents creatures
>Soul seared
She can outgrow soul sear if you pay life in responce to outgrow soulsear

Let me tell you how bad this is
>Chancellor of the Annex reveal
>Badlands
>Dark ritual/lotus petal
>Entomb/faithlesslooting
>Reanimate
>pay 10 life
>Swing for 24
That's a turn 0 kill with five cards in hand no ability to react, sometimes even only 4 cards.
It's bad dude.
Even if you played it in another format it's still fucking stupid, because they'd have even less answers

[Anonymous No.]

>>2316287
Bit more consequential when you played 8 life to get that damage.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2316401
It is OP, I said it right in the title, it's just not maximally op.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2316460
Just make her an uncounterable instant that costs 0 and says "you win".
Why bother thinking any harder than that if you only want to flatter your waifu with a shit card no one likes?

[Anonymous No.]

>>2316502
Because I wanted to make an op card that still interacts with the medium.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2316401
The only card I can think of that effectively hates this is Imprisoned On The Moon.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2316537
>interacts

[Anonymous No.]

>>2316436
>pays 1 more life
wew

[Anonymous No.]

>>2316597
Maybe if can come up with a more consistent combo that doesn't involve the Dark ritual/Black lotus I'd agree with you.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2316736
Dude that's just B/R reanimator. It wins games consistently, all the time, and it goes off on turns 1-3 all the time. Mori would just make it uninterruptable.
That's aside from U/B reanimator, show and tell, Sneak Attack, etc
She'd be format warping. A stupid card every one hates

[Anonymous No.]

I'm shit at creating cards so any input is welcome to improve them

[Anonymous No.]

>>2317154
Choco, should have something to gain flying outright or conditionally. Otherwise they look pretty good.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2317031
That's more a problem with reanimator than with the OP card that is not and never will be legal.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2317785
Even without reanimator
>Swamp
>Dark ritual
>Simean Spirit GUide
>Seething Song
>Cast
>Pay 10 life
>Win

[Anonymous No.]

>>2317154
What's the point of giving Roboco a tap ability if the same ability just untaps her? Is it only to make it impossible for her to activate her ability the turn she comes down?
Other than that with those specific names they probably should be legendary.

[Anonymous No.]

I fucking suck at wording cards properly

[Anonymous No.]

>>2317901
Eh, suppose that's fair. When you replace that with Kozilek, The Great Distortion. It takes a whole 3 turns to win the game while your opponent has next to no change to retaliate.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2317941
Can't gain indestructible in response to removal after you declare her as an attacker. Can't use her CMC buff as a combat trick for the same reason, instead you have to do it pre-combat, which leaves her very vulnerable. I didn't want to make her too strong, but i think she's too weak this way, i couldn't find the right balance

[Anonymous No.]

>>2318001
Shouldn't that be an artifact? It's a piece of hardware.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2318047
Kozilek is actually pretty bad of a card and next to no one runs it even in Modern Tron.
It has a high demand for cost, isn't good to reanimate, doesn't have haste, and takes two swings to kill.
If you want to make a Big Furry Monster, you gotta make it not feel cheap.
Make a cheating into play clause like Phage the untouchable, make the mana cost higher, make her be interactable with.
Just don't turn something you like into, lol I win, because she's my waifu and the best and I was using a forcefield the entire time.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2318229
I suppose if I wanted to make it fair I'd replace the pump with double strike at 4 life cost then.

[Anonymous No.]

I like to think this is somewhat flavorful, but I'm pretty sure the balance is all over the place. The Theros Titan template is not easy to work with.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2320685
Oh, it's cause of the all the genocide Pekora did, I get it now.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2320685
This is great, I love it!

[Anonymous No.]

For YGO Korone should get support cards in the form of Listener-San Tokens that sacrifice themselves to protect her.

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

>>2316337
>>2316110
>>2315258
same art but as classic frames
also print ready proxies: https://imgur.com/a/NK352oM

[Anonymous No.]

A bad pun is a good pun

[Anonymous No.]

>>2322037
Crazy Zoombie, Craaaazy Zoombie.

[Anonymous No.]

What does /vt/ think of Planechase?

[Anonymous No.]

>>2329374
Also holy fuck why is this template broken...

[Anonymous No.]

>>2268234
Played it briefly long ago when the first expansion was still new. Rhinoceroach was fun and I have caused at least once concede by using forest's curse on a Wincon monster.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2315258
>>2324969
Not the same dude, but here is my attempt at unstable variants
https://imgur.com/a/NPPY3VM

[Anonymous No.]

>>2309245
Decided to make Stage lands and Korone.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2303472
>>2301232
>>2301457
Cleaned up/fixed version. Cut down the text, etc.

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

I don't know who made this but this card is genius

[Anonymous No.]

>>2332376
I feel like it needs some sort of snarl. Maybe a clause for the monarch. Still like the left saido right saido idea and the 3rd step.

[Anonymous No.]

>KFP= slivers
>Takos = elves
>Chumbuddies = merfolk
>Deadbeats = Skeletons
>Teamates = Humans

Am I Rite?

[Anonymous No.]

DO YOU KNOW WINGSPAN?

[Anonymous No.]

>>2259485
The most underrated.

[Anonymous No.]

DO YOU KNOW WINGSPAN?

(updated, Asia is know the natural habitat of the Ogey)

[Anonymous No.]

>>2339252
>know

fml, I should stop drunkposting on /vt/. Anyway.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2339546
Never heard of it until now, but now I have.

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

>>2345894
That feels like it might actually be a good card.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2347276
>>2345894
Is it a wheel if it doesn't draw from the deck? The card is making me ask some deep, philosophical questions.

[Anonymous No.]

Where the ygo bros @?

[Anonymous No.]

>>2345894
make it 4 cmc, 1RBB

[Anonymous No.]

>>2331767
These are good highres. Thank you. Now I can place an order for a shipment of some proxy cards and get a bunch of these lands too

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

>>2325107
Heh, good one anon

[Anonymous No.]

>>2348400
should be, "Whenever a creature you control"

[Anonymous No.]

Episode 12 of "Fuck control and fuck blueniggers"

[Anonymous No.]

>>2348720
*Laughs in duress*

[Anonymous No.]

>>2347340
Yu-gi-oh takes every problem magic has and makes it worse.

[Anonymous No.]

Bump

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

>>2355544
>objectively better thoughtknot-seer
lol

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

>>2347939
I only demand pictures when they arrive, anon.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2355544
Deathtouch is one of the most evergreen of evergreen keywords in Magic, you do not need reminder text for it unless its in a product designed for new players and it has to be a common.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2257320
>1 card Flash+Hulk

Absolutely broken.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2322037
I don't think that last part actually works. You could probably replace it with

>Hellbent - Kureji Ollie has double strike as long as you have no cards in hand

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

>>2365480
I actually like it

[Anonymous No.]

>>2365480
I really like it.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2363537
dude...

[Anonymous No.]

Reminder if you make Holo-proxies that you think might actually get used, make sure to keep it really big and high-res. Card will look blurry if it ever gets printed from 300x600.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2332376
its still clunky as shit, just have it be target opponent

[Anonymous No.]

Bump!

[Anonymous No.]

A pogu pogu dance Aqua that activates when you defeat a card

[Anonymous No.]

>>2370747
You are missing the point of the card.
It's based off the "you are king song" as shown on the right hand side art.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2262277
>>2324969
>>2331767
Ordered a lot of these land proxies.
I ordered at least one of each, so I could get a good look at them all, but I mostly got swamps and islands for my edh decks
I should get it in 2 or so weeks.
I'll post images once they arrive

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

>>2389393
I like it. I like it a lot

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

>>2389891
This isn't bad at all. Nice job

[Anonymous No.]

NOT /vt/ RELATED

GET THE FUCK OUT

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

>>2384987
I wish I could put into words I how happy I am that my proxies are getting used by others. ganbatte, anon, I'm looking forward to the proxies!

[Anonymous No.]

NOT /vt/ RELATED

GET THE FUCK OUT.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2331783
Even more. Last two are just artwork changes on existing cards.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2390328
Thanks, but I should be thanking you.
I don't feel comfortable playing alternate proxy arts of real cards, but I love custom art on lands and tokens. If more keep getting posted, then when the current shipment arrives, I'll order more.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2391752
Here's a few more I think could work if someone wants to try to make them high-res. Tried to pick art with different characters.
Island - pixiv.net/en/artworks/84391823
Forest - pixiv.net/en/artworks/79828548
Swamp - danbooru.donmai.us/posts/3904272
Mountain - images8.alphacoders.com/113/thumb-1920-1131243.jpg
Plains - the left side of the Hololive Alternative website banner. The side with the big sword is probably better for some sort of nonbasic land, perhaps.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2391661
I like the bottom left.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2397042
If I could get high res versions, these'd look great

[Anonymous No.]

Basically a Gravedigger that can turn into a Rise from the Grave.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2356021
kek

[Anonymous No.]

>>2389393
>>2389891
Why do these have those color indicators, that makes no sense. Those are only for cards without colored mana costs.

Sora seems interesting if underwhelming. Mel's templating is way off.

>>2390238
This feels boring, if fitting for Fubuki. I do think she fits Bant most of all.

>>2331783
>>2391661
The problem with this "Fan" archetype is that it's unlimited and kinda dull. It doesn't lend itself to a particular color combo, and it's not interesting enough of a theme to make use of. Like, imagine if a set had every color care about creature tokens, it'd be awful boring.

I understand the desire to represent fan-creator relationships, but this is the most blunt and boring way to do so.

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

[Anonymous No.]

>>2254033
Are Pekos/Ogeys/Rrats the new Pepes? Ultra rare shiny special edition "Oggey!"

[Anonymous No.]

>>2404319
How's that Sorcery to Human thing supposed to work? I see the concept but the minutia seems funky.

[Anonymous No.]

>>2429561
That's a new mechanic i the last few sets. Basically when you cast the card you choose which side to cast. They are called modal double faced cards, or MDFC for short.