[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]

/vt/ - Virtual Youtubers


View post   

File: 33 KB, 400x400, Mana.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
761296 No.761296 [Reply] [Original]

Oh shit! I'm sorry.

>> No.761422

>>761296
I love her
Shy Russian autistic qt
She really tries to interact with eng speakers while not forgetting about her core audience.
If there will ever be hololive RUS it will be thx to her.

>> No.761473

>>761296
sorry for what?

>> No.761474

>>761296
Her reaction (and chat's reaction) to the Moona simp dropping 100 bucks on her stream was adorable.
It made me realize how desensitized I've become to what is a massive amount of money for most 3rd world streamers.

>> No.761570

>>761296
>>761473
Does she say this referencing *that*, or is it just a coincidence?

>> No.761597

>>761474
Depends on where she lives
If she is from far east regions, Ukraine or Caucasus it's a lot but if she lives in Euro part of Russia or bigger cities in the East it isn't really that much.
Average salary in St. Petersburg stands at around 1 700 USD

>> No.761613

>>761570
>Does she say this referencing *that*
You mean gachi?
Ofc

>> No.761617

>>761570
Yeah, it's a very popular meme in Russia with countless gachi remixes of russian songs.

>> No.761769
File: 149 KB, 784x1080, Mana_Renewal.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
761769

>>761422
She is not shy by any means. But she is an autistic qt indeed

>> No.761904

>>761597
Do you still live in 2014? Ruble is gone to shit since then, average salary in Saint-Petersburg is $950 now

>> No.761973

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7skgwv-X9yI
Damn she is sexy

>> No.762380

>>761904
http://www.salaryexplorer.com/salary-survey.php?loc=2090&loctype=3
Stop believing in memes
Inflation doesn't immediately mean lower salaries especially when its politically induced.
Many in slavlands get additional unaccounted income "under the desk"

>> No.762602

>>762380
Stop using some retarded foreign statistic.
https://mainfin.ru/wiki/term/srednaa-zarplata-v-spb
70 494 rubles as of 2020
I live in Russia and that is around the number I would expect. 90k for Moscow. 30-40 for regions.

>> No.762648

her accent is incredibly cute

>> No.762981

>>762380
>>762602
I make $200 a month. It's a decent pay.

>> No.763209

>>762981
Where?

>> No.763253

>>761422
Why autistic btw?

>> No.763254

>>761474
Was that in this stream or an earlier one?

>> No.764592

>>761296
I just like hearing her blins.

>> No.764688

>>763254
This one

>> No.767486

>>763253
>female in russia
>weeb
>not acting like a thot
>doesn't immediately start pandering to foreigners the second she gets a chance tho
Yep she has some sort of autism

>> No.767511

>>762602
Does it take into account the shadow income tho?

>> No.767520

>>761474
got a link?

>> No.767590

>>767511
No.

>> No.767597

wait, mana is a girl?

>> No.768862

>>767511
70% of all russian economy is owned by the state, there is no "shadow income" there (unless you are a corrupt higher-up). Other 30 won't add much.
Also, there is huge income disparity, average figures are even higher than median ones (https://russia.duck.consulting/maps/105/2019))

>> No.768987

>>768862
*are way higher

>> No.769045

>>761296
She's dangerously cute and has mini auto-translator at the corner for non-ruskies.
I hope she isn't sad about Botan accidentally sniping some ruskies for her...

>> No.769291 [DELETED] 

>>761474
Was it on this stream?
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC3czs41x7HD5-nk_cZ-Eo3g
Though nobody commented a timestamp.

>> No.769419

>>769291
https://youtu.be/0RVjDiaYTzY?t=8117

>> No.769556

>>763254
>>767520
>>769291
It was in the latest Minecraft stream. I don't have a timestamp but once chat is up, just look for when the only red superchat appears up top

>> No.769647

>>769419
What a based moonafic.

>> No.769710

>>761474
100 bucks is a month of food

>> No.769764

>>769647
I am so used to 100 bucks being spammed in hologirls chat that seeing her genuine surprise made me feel weird.

Also
>thanks! I will... grow up! With your support

>> No.769772

>>761597
apartments in provincial Russian cities cost like $200 to $400 per month, $100 is a lot of money

>> No.770627

>>769647
Sudden kindness and generosity, sasuga Moonafic, following in Moona's example.

>> No.770786

she's very cute. i really enjoyed her english-speaking streams with moona recently, definitely going to keep watching her.

>> No.771189

She is basically a Russian Nyanners but worse, you poor EOPs will never understand that you watching dumb shit of dumb shit. Russian vtubers are just a fucking joke. I hope this bitch will be arrested on the next protest and raped by the police.

>> No.771421
File: 18 KB, 600x600, low_quality_bait.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
771421

>>771189

>> No.771514

>>771189
So mad over an anime girl lmao. This ain't KFP, away with your shit bait

>> No.771575

>>771514
She's not an anime though.

>> No.772254

Reading this thread is like watching people without taste buds eating shit and savor it.

>> No.774343

>>768862
>no "shadow income"
Broh you pay your worker what's his due on the contract and give extra off the books
It's as simple as that. many companies do that at least in Poland mainly to evade income taxes.

>> No.774397

>>771189
>>772254
You faggots have some issues

>> No.774466

>>772254
That's interesting. Because reading your post is like a homeless crack fiend cumming in my eyes

>> No.774773

>>768862
>>774343
I happen to be ruski. I get around 500$ officially per month, goes to my credit card. My actual income is 2200$, the rest is paid in cash. Common practice to reduce taxes. No shadow income, my ass.
>>771189
Иди, тoвapищ, нaхyй.

>> No.774859

>>774397
Speaking Russian and understanding the content in it's full capacity is the issue. There is no room for fantasy, you just forced to take everything at face value.

>> No.787383

>>771189
>you poor EOPs will never understand
So it's like with Japanese?

>> No.789318

I love this girl, hope RU bros do some translations for her.

>> No.790202

>>774343
Companies which are owned by the state don't do that. And that's 70% of all economy. It's as simple as that.

>> No.791312

>>761296
I am learning russian, I like this channel! Although it's a bit hard to stay focus the whole stream duration, live subtitles help a lot.
>>767486
>>doesn't immediately start pandering to foreigners the second she gets a chance tho
Yeah, a lot of streamers do that in my country. It's annoying as hell. They think that "English = success", but they aren't good enough in english to convince any native to watch them. Even me, an average ESL, can hear their mistakes or get bored because they can't make good jokes in english.

>> No.791485

Goddammit bros I don't want to learn Russian too

>> No.791699

>>771189
Please, I keep seeing Russians posting krinzh whenever she appears, why you guys hate her on dvach? She has good model and sound cute. What gives?

>> No.792280

>>771189
So even russian chuubas get their own dedicated antis, huh?
Interesting...

>> No.792325

>>771189
>you poor EOPs will never understand
Will you?
>>791485
I've tried doing live subs during her past streams pre-yesterday one, but it's mentally draining, sorry bro.
At least you can sort of understand thanks to auto-captions.

>> No.792450

>>791699
She's rusnya just like us.

>> No.793048

>>791699
She is an embodiment of ironic weebs. Basically Nyanners.
She used to be Earth-chan, a completely stolen character, there was zero creativity put in her design, her current name and design is just minor edit of that just to make this identity thieft less blatantly obvoius. Instead of coming up with original character, she just assimilated existing popular mascot and abused that meme to get an audience.
All her humor is based on referencing popular overused zoomer memes, like gachimuchi, and her audience are basically zoomers who barely can type without making 8 typos in 4-letter word and everything they write must contain words suka, blyad and pidor.
She's not an indie by the way, and all anime-related business in Russia is run by legit certified assholes.
Even titles of her videos are so cringy they make my eyes bleed. You can only tolerate her if you absolutely clueless about what's happening.
If you absolutely NEED to watch someone from this 3rd world shithole, try Yumemi Yumeiro, at least she's not trying to be cringy on purpose and some japs like her.

>> No.793083

>>793048
Кpингe

>> No.793246

>>793048
>She used to be Earth-chan
And she moved away from that specifically to be herself instead of this role she mistakenly forced herself into many years ago.
>her current name and design is just minor edit of that
Ok, retard
>everything they write must contain words suka, blyad and pidor.
This is easily disproven by just looking at the chat.
>She's not an indie by the way
Because she created WePlanet group herself, in collaboration with Planya.
>Even titles of her videos are so cringy they make my eyes bleed.
I would even agree with you half a year ago, but the content improved dramatically from that time.

>> No.793251

>>761422
>>761474
HololiveRU isn't possible we're poor as fuck and govt threatens to start throttling YT traffic any day now.

>> No.793313

>>793048
I'll bite, pidorashka, but only because I won't have access to this site on holidays. Let's go on a case-by-case basis:
>She used to be Earth-chan, a completely stolen character, there was zero creativity put in her design, her current name and design is just minor edit of that just to make this identity thieft less blatantly obvoius. Instead of coming up with original character, she just assimilated existing popular mascot and abused that meme to get an audience.
Earth-chan belongs to public domain unless the original creator behind her first design decides to copyright it. Nor was it a "popular mascot", it was a twitter-born meme that got big, same as Black Hole-chan, for example. There is lore behind her new image, but I honestly can't be assed to re-tell her re-debut video on demand for some nobody on a Bhutan wool shearing forum when it's freely available for you to watch yourself, which you didn't
>All her humor is based on referencing popular overused zoomer memes, like gachimuchi
So people behind IWF who pump out new remixes every year are zoomers? I mean sure, it's an old meme subculture, but people like you are still using Wojaks and think it's the epitome of comedy, so you should probably refrain from doing that, unless you want to have this "pot calling kettle black" type of scenario.
>her audience are basically zoomers who barely can type without making 8 typos in 4-letter word and everything they write must contain words suka, blyad and pidor.
Nice projection and generalization there bud. Especially for a person who types:
>identity thieft
>blatantly obvoius
And we're not even talking about your obvious ESL-tier sentence structure here. Hey, I'm an ESL poster too, but at least I tend not to format my posts like a complete fucking retard.
>She's not an indie by the way, and all anime-related business in Russia is run by legit certified assholes.
She is though, her parent "company", WePlanet, is not officially registered in any way, shape or form. You're the type of guy who would call out VOMS_project as corpos as well just because of your own lack of information on the subject. Also you're again generalizing things like manga industry with all anime-related entrepreneurs and companies that we have here.
>try Yumemi Yumeiro
Ecли бы тeбe дeйcтвитeльнo былo бы нe пoхyй нa pyccкий ceгмeнт витюбepcтвa, ты бы тoпил зa кoллaбы и бoлee тecнyю кooпepaцию, a нe вёл бы ceбя кaк кaкoй-тo eбaнyтый aнти c пaлкoй в жoпe.
What a fucking miserable and trashy anti poster you are, holy shit. Don't even @ me, I don't need your shitty (you)s

>> No.793369

>>793313
not him but
>collabs
I watch them without audio. Her English sadly isn't quite ready for those. Kudos to Moona doing collabs with smaller VTubers from time to time though, even if I don't like her.

How's copyrights with YT & Russia? Does she have to reach to game companies before monetization too? I honestly don't know how that works here.

>> No.793387

>>791699
It's ironic. Mana herself calls her streams cringe.

>> No.793425

Maня лaв, хapкaчepы cocyт мoй тoлcтый хyй. Учитe инглиш paз тaкиe yмныe.

Love Mana, ‘ate russian crabs

>> No.793440

>>761296
ruined by hornyclips

>> No.793441
File: 3 KB, 124x122, 1609039390091.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
793441

>>793313
Jesas, you didn't have to kill his whole family too

>> No.793473

>>793441
made me laugh fuck you

>> No.793476

I loved her collabs with Moona. Mana was being really hospitable and the way she brought up her Russianness was endearing

>> No.793519

>>793425
>Учитe инглиш paз тaкиe yмныe.
You do understand people here at least can comprehend basic English, right?

>> No.793537
File: 229 KB, 1011x1431, 1613023103306.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
793537

>>793369
>How's copyrights with YT & Russia? Does she have to reach to game companies before monetization too?
It's a retarded Japanese law, we have the same content rights as Europe, if not even better, cause we don't have Article 13 and other corporate friendly stuff.

>> No.793549 [DELETED] 

>>793519
бpoтиш.... в дyшe нe eбy o чeм ты я тyт пишy тoлкьo нa pyкccкaм мнe пoхyй нa пeндocoв.... я их нe читaю...

>> No.793611

>>793537
I thought so. If only Russia wasn't so poor but then again: I guess copyright laws lobby comes with big money and entertainment market developing in a rich country.

You probably can't have purchase-powerful population and no copyright laws.

>> No.793674

>>793251
>govt threatens to start throttling YT traffic any day now.
I hope more countries just shut out American tech shit.

>> No.793691

>>793313
I don't have to be an expert in shit to tell that it's shit. You can search for minor inaccuracies in shitposts all you want, this will not make your oshi less crappy.

>> No.793743

>>793674
Well YT is getting too big and greedy in particular. They cut what, 30-35% of SC money and can't be assed to put some human operators at least behind processing abuse reports?
Fuck them. All VTubers should use streamlabs at the very least.

>> No.794428

>>793048
>>793387
>>793246
>>793313
Okay I can see how she is now. I mean gachimuchi exactly aren't zoomer tier. I guess it probably is in Russia based on that one Russian MAD edit including Gura.
I do think her content pre-Mana was a bit overproduced, so I do believe a bit she was backed by some corporate money. Then again, I don't give a shit much about the whole corpo-indie civil war. She's cute though so I will look forward to her career carefully.
>>793369
She's gonna make it. She's Korone tier at least.

>> No.794641

>>794428
>I do think her content pre-Mana was a bit overproduced
IIRC her main job is something 3d-design related

>> No.794663

>>793674
Ogey, chang.

>> No.794703

>>761473
Our daddy told us not to be ashamed of our dicks.

>> No.794785

>>794703
Vtubers don't have dicks.

>> No.794831

>>794785
>holostars
i guess they're as good as nonexistent

>> No.794877

>>794831
Have you seen at least one vtuber dick?
I didn't.

>> No.794899

>>794877
i'm sure if you look hard enough you'll find some roommate gay porn or trap camwhoring

>> No.794912

>>769045
I seriously hope RU fans wouldn't leave a native speaker for a JP streamer that only knows a tiny bit. If anything, Botan should collab with Mana to help her sub count.

>> No.794935

Botan is a fad for ruskies, a meme from clips to "raid". It won't last.

>> No.795010

>>794935
I really hope so. Botan deserves a better audience. Let all the raiding bydlo watch their bydlotubers.

>> No.795071

>>795010
they don't watch any
they're just there to plant flag
sprinkled with bunch of chink anties that are in on any kind of hololive mess

>> No.795522

>>793083
Isn't it supposed to be Кpинж?
t. not russian

>> No.796100

>>793083
Кyкoж

>> No.796191
File: 178 KB, 281x251, SKUKOZIL.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
796191

>>796100

>> No.796205

>>795522
Yeah. Words that come from English (ie cringe -> кpинж) are carried over in a way that keeps similar phonetics, but if you do it on letter to letter basis (ie cringe -> кpингe) it becomes "ironic".

>> No.796649

>>793611
Russian corpos and goverment tied on whole other level. It's not like big corpos there need any special laws to defend themselves, they are a government basically

>> No.796675

>>796649
too bad\good they don't produce any games of their own or represent any foreign publishers because none want to deal with our swamp of government

so not relevant in context of VTubers game licenses

>> No.796884

>>796675
They actually do. Mailru groups are a big publisher for russian market. The insanely fucked up a few big mmo and published other few already shitty chinese mmo. As far as I remember they also fucked up to nonexistence their own mmo game, which was even loved in russia originally, so it's a double fuck up. Beside all this I'm pretty sure they on regular basis develop some shitty mobile grade games, but I'm not even interested search more about those

>> No.796939

>>796884
still not really relevant for VTubers
they were failing before Steam and completely lost any traction with foreign companies to localize and publish games after

>> No.796992

>>796939
If Vtubers live other year or so I'm pretty sure corpos will try to catch up

>> No.797031

>>796992
there are plenty of multi-million real streamers and there are already laws regulating taxes for them
any attempt to enforce copyright on streamers of any kind in Russia would fail because the share of market that is localized under russian publishers is miserably small

>> No.797244

>>795522
Just a transliteration.

>> No.797908
File: 177 KB, 1920x1080, Eurf_NPWQAAzSN2.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
797908

New RU vTuber alert:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E7hDTgbhi9w

>> No.798152

>>797908
>Stamina
Now they need Health

>> No.798204

Mana sucks, retarded vk users love her because they don't know english.

>> No.798553

>>798204
Your post is retarded, your logic is retarded, (you) are retarded. You can go back to vk, eternal pidorakha.
Manya love.

>> No.798651

>>798553
Your slang is retarded and you reek sosach. As expected from her bydlo audience.

>> No.798802

>>798651
*reek of, pidorakha.
Now go back to vk, where you belong.

>> No.798833

>>798553
>>798802
No idea what are you talking about, take your tirech slang back with you.

>> No.798890

>>798802
You mean to her fan group manarenewal_public which you are clearly a member of?
Thank you, but I don't want to see any more bydlo like you. Go shill your dumb whore somewhere else.

>> No.798903

if you're all gonna shill your foreign vtubers at LEAST drop a link

>> No.798976

>>798903
https://mobile.twitter.com/MiwaToriyama

>> No.798979

>>798833
You are coming with us, and help me carry this fag >>798890 out.

>> No.799085

>>798979
You've got a wrong idea, I'm not gay like you. You can search participants for your gay orgy in vk gachimuchi fans public, which is also mana's public. Now, get out.

>> No.799144

MAHA ЛOB

>> No.799356

>>799144
MAHA ХATE

>> No.799382
File: 163 KB, 1280x720, maxresdefault.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
799382

Orc-podcaster is a real russian vtuber. He streams games, made a couple of reviews, sing his own rap songs, and it was long before everyone else. He's a massive blizzdrone, but he don't restrict himself only for blizzard games.

>> No.799469

>>793048
I understand your post, I'm from a third world country & if there is a vtuber who's a zoomer making shitty jokes, I would react the same.
all that said, the world's going to shit, mate. this is her release, let her be.
she's not even begging for money or doing anything which can be considered "shaming your country".
she's just putting whatever her feelings or talent or whatever into streaming & being decent about it. cant you leave her alone? why the trashing?

>> No.800153

>>769772
>provincial Russian cities cost like $200 to $400 per month
elmao, in true province you can rent 1f apartment for $25-$50
$400 is a high end apartment in city center of a city with pop >500k

>> No.800261

>>793048
Чyвaк, тeбe нeчeгo дeлaть кpoмe тoгo кaк в интepнeтe нaeзжaть нa зyмepoк? Я щac Bacянa из coceднeгo пoдъeздa пoзoвy, пoбeceдyм c тoбoй o жизни и o тoм кaкoй хyйнёй ты тyт зaнимaeшьcя.

>> No.800280

>>800261
Пpeдcтaвьcя, мpaзь.

>> No.800419

>>800280
Учacткoвый yпoлнoмoчeнный пoлиции пo дeлaм виpтyльных ютюбepoк, O.Г. Ppaт

>> No.800651

>>800419
Пиздyйтe-кa вы, твpщ yчacткoвый, нaхyй, и Maню cвoю тyдa жe зaбepитe.

>> No.800755

>>793048
>overused zoomer memes, like gachimuchi
>gachi
>overused
Just kys on the spot

>> No.800779

>>800651
Лaн пacaны, paccхoдимcя, тyт oкaзaлcя кaкoй-тo пиздюк кoтopый cвoю пиздy хoчeт пpoтaщить зa cчёт yнижeния Maни. Tипичный pycнявый кyкoлд. Бoйcя нa yлицy выйти, пeтyшoчeк. Чoткиe peбятки c paйoнa eщё yзнaют чтo ты чeлoвeк c гнильцoй.

>> No.800838

>>800779
Ho я нe pycнявый....

>> No.800884

>>800838
Oк, Tapaбc

>> No.800917

>>800884
Ho я Toдop.

>> No.800976

>>800838
Teбя дaжe тpaнcoм тo нaзвaть язык нe пoвopaчивaeтcя, paз нa зyмepoк бoмбишь в интepнeткaх

>> No.801060

>>793048
>Gachimuchi
>zoomer
Kill yourself, there's no other way to recover from what you just said. Gachi was a meme before you were born, newfag.

>> No.801112

>>801060
In Russia, it's a trend from 2020. It's obnoxious and it's all over youtube.

>> No.801209

>>798152
Fuck, would never catch it if you didn't pointed it.

>> No.801265

>>801112
go back to school newfag I was remixing gachi way before your dad misaligned his money shot

>> No.801335

>>801265
I'm happy for you that you've developed such attachment for an old gay porn, but fact is fact, Russian zoomers rediscovered it quite recently and loved it as much as you. Now it's their thing.

>> No.801479

>>798903
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aR11zB6bBpg

>> No.802025
File: 576 KB, 480x270, oIMcDNXF.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
802025

Imagine not being a cringe contrarian retard.

>> No.805017 [DELETED] 

>>801479
russian keemstar? basado

>> No.816128

>>801112
>2020
Come on man, it has maintained the same popularity since at least 2017.

>> No.822222

>Decided to chech Lilith
Her intonations are somewhat annoing when she fakes rage, but
https://youtu.be/GCqi7JVPB4E?t=2364
not bad, not bad.

>> No.825912

https://youtu.be/E7hDTgbhi9w

>> No.826090

>>825912
Debut steams are always so cringeworthy, holy fuck.

>> No.826112

>>826090
something to look back on and facepalm

>> No.826118

>>825912
>>826090
I tuned into literal 30 seconds of uninterrupted silence as she was fiddling with streaming software. Not going to torture myself with this anymore today, but wish her the best.

>> No.826443

>>801335
Reminds me of how gay porn was massive meme in Japan at around 2010 as well

>> No.826454

>>825912
I don't like her design and her voice is too deep

>> No.826461
File: 644 KB, 740x1380, 1609653840223.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
826461

>>826443
Can confirm
>>826454
Voice can change to cater to audience easily
women habitually change their pitch when talking on a damn phone, I'm sure she can handle it for stream too

>> No.826501

>>826454
Her voice is not deep enough

>> No.827100

>>822222
>822222
holy shit nice digits

>> No.827204

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCoGewB38AWCF7ZwxM5-15AA

This is the only Russian vtuber I watch

>> No.827288

https://www.twitch.tv/jashin_vtuber/clip/ExpensiveOptimisticAlbatrossWoofer

>> No.829020

>>826443
ESLOP retard here, I remember when Yaranaika was fucking everywhere in weeb and 4chan adjacent circles in the internet anglosphere.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bBg6SxAyUYs

Were there other gay japanese memes as well?

>> No.835235

>>829020
Hard Gay

>> No.835457

>>761296
Дa я лyчшe бы Baлaкaca cмoтpeл вмecтo нeё.

>> No.835637

Glad Valakas is best vtuber in russian segment, guys.

>> No.836811
File: 808 KB, 1563x2600, IMG_3253.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
836811

The best Russian vtuber, she streams in English though and redebuting with an anime model soon.
https://twitter.com/hibinwa

>> No.836863

>>836811
her model looks like trash

>> No.837001
File: 112 KB, 579x699, maxresdefault.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
837001

>>835637
I agree with this statement.

>> No.840198

>>836811
> she streams in English
so what is the point then?

>> No.843762

>>801112
Absolute retard, purge all newfags

>> No.844054
File: 66 KB, 1176x561, 1484476215160.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
844054

>>843762

>> No.853991

I'm glad for this thread, I learned a lot. I didn't realize her dark history.

>> No.857924

>>853991
there is no "dark history"

>> No.857956

>>857924
>he lacks critical information

>> No.860602

>>794912
>Botan should collab with Mana
she should, but how good is botan's english anyway

>> No.861808

>>840198
Non-bydlo audience

>>
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action