3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
Previous: >>78728384
*GENERAL NUMBERFAG SITES*>https://playboard.co/en/>http://ikioi-ranking.com/>https://vrabi.net/>https://www.vstats.jp>https://live-ranking.userlocal.jp/vtuber-ranking>https://vt.poi.cat/Hololive sites>https://www.hololyzer.net/youtube/index.html>https://trackholo.live/en/>https://holosongs.com/>https://holo-spotify-stats.jirikunes.eu/Nijisanji sites>https://niji-mado.web.app/stats/hourly>https://twitter.com/2434rankings>https://twitter.com/2434subscriber>https://www.nijiuta.com/Twitch>https://sullygnome.com/>https://twitchtracker.com/>https://stats.roki.sh/
GRIM
fauna
We hate big tits in this thread
>>78736008Last post, true post.
Fauna...
4 hrs to get 7-10k they just might get it.
i cook da pizza
>>78736010My cowgirlfriends...
>>78735963Destiny 2 schizo STOP
Is Biboo's stream d ying
>>78736010SEX SEX SEX SEX SEX SEX SEX SEX
fine, I'll say it. the tied black shirt is MUCH hotter than the bikini. it hugs her curves and accentuates her breasts.
>>78736074Reaper
Elizabeth>>>>shitrys
>>78736010
We love big tits in this thread
>>78736074REAPER
>>78736130ERB might hit 100k before debuts yeah
>not even a million views within 24 hoursSharkie...
>>78736099For you, a small titty gremlin, my good sir
>>78736130In 2020, Botan made Hololive history for being the first girl to ever hit 100k subs on her debut day (after her stream or in the middle of her stream, one or the other)In EN that's just standard, jesus
>>78736178Yeah. Bikini is cool and all, but seeing Fauna in this outfit makes me want to just physically restrain her on the spot and prone bone without regard for her pleasure.
back reading the last threadI don't think anyone is ever going to poach dudulhe's a loyal chumbudhttps://www.youtube.com/live/86UdOrzFXxQ?si=WWz9PWsfu9XV0Dul&t=4465
Is there a cull or something what the fuck is going on with the bottom two
>sometimes you need to be gentle>sometimes you need to be ruthless, brutal
8 love how i read the dog water
>>78736130Day 2 will hit 100k before debut, It's possible for Liz and Gigi but it's cutting it close
>>78736130200k simultaneous connections incoming
>>78736099That's too bad
>>78736201what a great month to be KFP
I'm having a really good feeling, I think this will be the time, finally...
HoloGODS rule this world. Kneel, Nijisissies.
>>78736301He came back to life because of that girl, it's for sure a "for life" situation between the two
>1 month after debutElizabeth > Raora > Gigi > Cecilia >3 months after debut Raora > Gigi > Elizabeth > Cecilia>1 year after debutGigi > Raora > Cecilia > Elizabeth
>>78736178It leaves more to the imagination, which I'm more than happy to let fly
>>78736301Gura is his unironic muse. She saved his art.
>>78736303The streams just started nigger
>>78736130They'll be culled one more time before debut, culls have been happening around 10 EST or in that hour range
>>78736321I don't get it.
>>78736220The first 2 to debut will get the spoils. 2day subscriber surge. The next 6 months will be great.
>>78736338You get a Trailstuber>butIt's ElizabethWhat do you do?
>>78736379You clearly have not heard Gigi's voice.
>>78736324fugg
>>78736407>2k in 10 minutes is fucking normalYou're the retard
>>78736303Apparently Biboo is dying.Weird hour for FWMC to start, huh
>>78736130>Elden Ring Bloodborne 2k ahead from Pink KoyoriShe's picking up steam
>>78736130They'll all hit it during debut, they get a huge boost then. They also get a decent boost before debut, so about 9k for each isn't a long shot at all.
>>78736178Feels like her boobs bounce more with the shirt on tooI agree I also prefer it I think, both forms are utter sex though
>>78736450They are starting early to make sure they are able to end in time for the watchalong. Biboo mentioned they were gonna be in the studio for it.
>>78736324>>78736443STOP
>>78736293i mean, its probably standard for JP too, right? What were HoloX pre-debut subs?
Whining Kirin really is peak
Huh, Elizabeth's plan to pander to everyone is kinda working.
>>78736303I'm watching FUWAMOCO, I'm not going to watch any Elden Ring streams since I'm playing myself, I assume many others are the same
>>78736303dlc is literally a bait content, too many streams and people don't want spoilers
>>78736338Trails is overrated
>>78736130Thought you guys said Elizabeth would be the runt?Looks like she's kind of blowing everyone else up rn
https://x.com/naraicat/status/1804268797957747085
>>78736193You think she got to suck on those? Maybe fondle them?
>>78736178
>>78736493>Gura keeping up with La+I'm weirdly proud of her, good shit sharkie
>>78736007https://youtu.be/hyUXXXmFLQ4?t=762It's a cute face.
>>78736581Big tits = bigger pre-debut subs, when will you understand this
>>78736443
>random kusoge thursday stream - easy 10k>very cute 3d fauna playing a good game on a friday - struggling to hit 9k???????
>>78736367Was his life that bad? Or was it a medical condition?
>>78736178true. i'm so glad this shirt became normalized for hologirls
>>78736581and Doki got 120k, where is she now?
>>78736653Warioware is always debuff
>>78736656Nothing that dramatic, he just had quit doing content for years beforehand and was probably toiling away in a normal job until she set his passion on fire again
>>78736521Shion loves it tho.
>>78736599Told you fags Fauna would lose her artists
>>78736622Keeping up is used very generously here. Not to shit on anyone but Laplus mog both of them.
>>78736338Sorry but this is a Xenoblade gen>British>Red Hair>Crazy Sword Weapon>Big tits
>>78736178I just wish their thighs were a little thicker
>>78736324>>78736443
>>78736130i havent subbed to any of them and i wont till after their reveal and i see how they are. right now, highest likelihood to sub is orange, but that could change.
>>78736599This one was the Fauna artist yeah?
>>78736429I rejoice and watch only the Trails streams>>78736570>overratedI have never seen anyone talking about it besides people memeing about it in this board and I think I'm the only one who has played it
>>78736099>weNo, I enjoy tits
I really do think Elizabeth is gonna be the strongest streamer, but Cecilia will still have higher ccv
>>78736324>>78736443>>78736718
>>78736734she's gonna have extremely basic tastes and spam collabs
>>78736130Gen5, Myth, holox, Advent and many other gens gained an extra 100k/200k+ subs on their post-debut. I see the same thing happening here.
>Biboo 2.5kGura really did a number on her huh
SHES SO HAPPYKYUUUUUUUUUTE
>>78736819So what would make her the stronger streamer
>>78736729>generouslyOkay okay but I mean La+ is La+ and will give a pass to shion because she's probably rusty but do we have to pull up the tapes of Gura?
>>78736303fuwamocos twin schtick is getting old and they have nothing to back it up with, you gotta be in touch with the culture you are trying to entertain and the weeb dogs know nothing about north america
>>78736870
>>78736819Either Gigi or Raora will have higher CCV, because they're not living in Europe
Go back to posting doxx schizos, your baits are so fucking bad.
>>78734905Why does the male in gen 1 have the highest sub count?
>>78736890Not afraid to do events with twitch streamers like Hassan
>>78736810I've played them all up the CoTS4 and I really had to struggle through CoTS 2 and 4. Haven't tried Reverie yet. Crossbell and SC are still the best entries imo.
>>78736819Let's see their honeymoon period. whoever make the best first impression will be the strongest for the next 3 months untill someone pull a retarded schedule or stunt. That's how it usually go
>>78736890Great personality. It's the most important factor. People focus too much on raw skills but look at Fauna.
>>78736954But you said Cece will have higher CCVHow can you be a stronger streamer in that specific wording while having less CCV
>>78736954Hassan?
Sex with Fauna
>keep mentioning and teasing her playing dark souls to keep building hype for her playing a souls game>waiting until after the ER DLC hype wears off to start her first ever playthrough so she can catch the spoiler-free people who already completed the DLC Fauna is quite devious
How many awards have your oshi won
>>78736955I also enjoy the 2D games the most, same with YS. I only post Rean because he's funnier
>>78736379>no "right after debut" prediction>right after debutLiz > Raora > Ceci > Gigi>1 month after debutRaora > Liz > Ceci > Gigi>3 months after debutRaora > Ceci > Liz > Gigi>1 year after debutRaora > Ceci > Gigi > LizLiz is going to slowly lose steam, while Raora becomes a stand out, and Ceci & Gigi will both carve out good communities and places for themselves. Keyword is slowly on Liz, I think that the true consequence of being the first open Homocollaber since Bae is just going to give her a small initial boost, then as the amount of sisters subbed starts to run low, she's going to just keep losing out on potential subs that would have, if it weren't only for how unsafe (quite literally the opposite of safe, roru) she is as a CGDCT Holo. That voice debuff is bad for Gigi, though. I think that Raora can easily overcome her voice debuff with her design, but Gigi won't be able to. But maybe she'll be good enough at singing that she'll manage a Suzy-like role after enough time. I highly doubt it, though.
my oshi has the only reward that matters: my heart
>>78736954>German collabing with a tankierumao
27 hours left.
Jwu>Austria wonHow was Kiara's watchalong?
Fauna roleplaying as a unicorn
>>78736303It's anyone guess, you could cite that this is Biboo timeslot and with Fauna+Ina still going the audience is a little tapped but the numbers are indeed muted
>>78736220why the fuck are you guys calling her ERB? Liz sounds infinitely better and is 1 syllable instead of 3
Reminder that liz and raora are the only good new hires in JUSTICE
>>78737173really fun actually
>>78737173a few dozen shy of 10K
>>78736460Shiori debut first too and she gained 100k subs within hours post debut. I Kneel.
>>78737108Suzy only does professional male collabs, and I can guarantee she would take a hit if she strayed from that
>>78737212Could just call her “red cunt” if you want:
>the janitor
>>78737121Green women love
>>78737173very fun
>>78737173She got extremely horny looking at the soccer dudes and global had a straight-talk meltdown again
>>78737273thats 2 syllables, technically better than ERB I guess
>>78737212Kiara said she was calling her ERB and I guess that caught up.
>>78737121I can't wait for the debuts to be over.
>>78737173first time i ever watch and having fun with orange woman's stream from start till the end
>>78737212ERB is funnier and more unique.Liz also reminds me of one of the worst characters from FGO
>>78737173it was greathttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=annqNJMZL8c
Community page likes as we approach debut
>>78737087It's unfortunate that he became the most popular character in the entire series, because he's by far the most boring protagonist. Estelle is still number one in my heart.
>>78736712Oh, nice. Although I was mid at art I'm considering buying a tablet and starting to draw again.
>>78737302I don't know if there was any good looking baller in Austria she must be blind
>>78737371Pink green 10k
>>78737371Liz...
I really do believe there is an untapped euro market and Kiara just couldn't tap into it because she's annoying.
>>78737401The only way to stop being mid at art is to do it until you're not, after allBy the way take this and read ithttps://ia904602.us.archive.org/3/items/understanding-comics/Understanding%20Comics.pdf
>>78737371Interesting. This corresponds more closely to my perception of fanbase buzz than the subs do.
Fauna should squat down onto Mumei's face more often
>>78737273Combine both words and you get runt
>>78737428What are the implications of the mage adding the might of modern weaponry to her arsenal
>>78737064Fauna is a numberfag, but a smart one. Despite having the lowest subs in Promise, she's the defacto #2. Slow and steady wins the race.
>>78737265Yeah. I meant moreso if Liz realizes what the consequences are early and then manages to fix what people think about her, and leaves male collabs to professional only. It's basically what might happen if she isn't an Ollie, and just a clueless girl that was told to be open to the Homos by fujo managers. I don't think she can ever turn her reputation around completely, just like how Mori and Kronii can't even after a pretty long while since dumb and dumber quit, but she can at least pull herself back up to Mori or Kronii's level with time and intelligence.
>>78737371That a really stark difference in likes.Still convinced the subs are being throttled
>>78737371>cc got more cgdctfags so more like even tho she (currently)have the second lowest sub>dirty red got the dramafag audience so low like but more sub
How are the twitter followers looking
PANTSU SHOTPANTSU SHOTPANTSU SHOTI MISSED IT
>>78737371I wasn't going to give importance to this at first, but the fact that Elizabeth has so much less engagement than the others cannot be a coincidence.
>>78737514Have you watched Frieren?
>>78737570
No she's ending...
>>78737496first one to debut always has the most subs tho
jesas
>Fauna endingNo... too soon
>>78736903They don't care about having a huge ccv, that's not their business model. They make their money through farming gachikois, which is working because they're the 3rd most superchatted girls in the company right now
>>78736130After regross I'm more cautious, I will wait 1 month.
>>78737428sheep was very cute today
>>78736581Remember when Shiori was leading in subs and Biboo was the runt? Pre-debut numbers mean nothing
>>78737614Bless you anon
>>78736607Nerissa looks especially turned on by Biboo here. She knows what her tiny body is really like thanks to sleeping together before debut.
Why are the numbers so shit right now across the board?
>>78737654I'm glad we have another horny cat on the group
>>787376112 episodesMust be for people with sleeping problems
>>78737577Twitter audiences don't bother with youtube.
>>78737614Damn tracker still not good enough
>>78737577Who subs? randos, tourists, anyone who's just kinda interested in watching the debut and wants to check it out, wide varieties of levels of interest.But who goes into community pages, leaves comments and likes? core audience holofags
Saplings this is your oshi?
>>78737717I can't post the meme then
>>78737577Honestly i feel like there isnt any hype behind these chicks, i wish them well but they really werent needed right now, advent is still somewhat fresh and the majority of the audience was ok with the current state of EN. Plus the controversial casting choices dont help them a single bit to say the least.
>>78737654I believe in Pink potential
>>78737707Everyone is out celebrating Austria's victory.
>>78737371Holy shit. I didn't expect to see the red one take a hit so early. I know this place holds a lot of sway since nearly everyone comes /here/ occasionally and stuff reverberates, but for it to happen so soon and just from twitter interaction really is startling.
>>78737765Yes
I love debuts because it's them trying their 100% hardest to get people to love them before they eventually become bored, jaded, and distant.
fauna so cute..
I can
OMG FAUNA CUTE AAAAAAAAAA
WITCHER TOMORROW
what happens if the debut doesn't get 50k ccv
I banged my desk because she was too cute and it spooked my dogs.
>>78737797Don't co-opt my post to start doomposting, nigger.
WITCHER TOMORROWFAUNA CUTEFAUNA MY BELOVED
>>78737797Should have been Spring 2025 with only three girlsThis whole situation is dumb, making the same mistakes niji made and letting below average hires dilute the quality
ADVENT DEBUTS TODAY
>>78737707EN viewership is unironically reclining. Gura's 3D was the canary in the coal mine. Still very good numbers for EN, but it shows that the audience is leaving faster than it's being replaced.
>Advent
Cute giggle after she said her memory is fading.
>>78737859>>78737886Don't you ever get tired of this song and dance? You think anyone is getting fooled?
...what now?
>>78737806
>Fauna goneNo...
>>78737948bibu
>>78737972Good
>>78737938Retard
Another day, another NIJIGOLD!
Raid Baby Biboo
>>78736293Did Myth hit 100k before debut?
biboo saved
FAUNA RAIDED BIBOO
>>78737948Biboo because that's where Fauna put me
>>78737948apparently Biboo
>>78737496a possibility we haven't considered for a while is that yt accounts that got unsubscribed during the council culls are permanently marked to never count for anything (views or subs)pre-debut council fans would be pre-debut green and orange fans now, probably(yeah me)
>>78737938kys schizo
Faunwell...
>>78737548How do NijiJP's predebut subs usually play out? Their current wave is really low but the top is less than 3k from the bottom. Is that normal for them or is that an oddity too?
>>7873792525k box across 4 streams are normal retard. Nice bait
>>78737925Getting tired of trying to get attention and being ignored 5 times in a row is not a reason to reply to yourself
>>78737822If it was just a single polite message to a few random holostars it might not be so bad (it still would have been kinda bad but ENs have done that before with no real long term damage) but she basically did a sustained little interaction campaign/skit with the two Filipino members of the least-popular gen in the company bar Uproar. It was over-the-top, experienced hololive fans are definitely going to see that and be very wary.
I hope they play together sometime
FROMSISTERS?WTF are these numbers
Thanks god for the debut stream because I couldn't live with a world where Kiara is the highest solo stream in EN on a day where Fuwamoco, Ina, Fauna and Bijou streamed.
>>78737948It's 1:30 for me so I'm going to sleep before debuts. Normally I would stick around for some Biboo since it's already weekend, but then I would be dying for the big streams. Laters.
Thoughts?
>>78738103i want another hitman collab
BIBOO KAKKOI
So when are we gonna add new girl to this picture?
Fauna knows how to move saplings in force
>>78737371When back to check advent>Shiori 16k>Fuwawa 16k>Bijou 14k>Mococo 13k>Nerissa 13k
>>78738146Elden Ring DLC is debuff thoughts.
>>78738103real games play by themselves
>>78738061Explain how Gura's 3D was more than 20k lower than in 2022. The core audience who watches streams is still there, now it's just split between the girls. Ina used to get 12-14k for Elden Ring, now she's getting half that. Audiences are being cannibalized by newer gens.
What's the skibidi fragment?
The saplings are leaving Biboo and funneling into FWMC btw
>>78738146Erdtree? MORE LIKE TURDTREE.
>>78738192the 80% from yesterday was absurd
>>78738192FUNNEL GODS
>>78738241Kill yourself subhuman
>78737925Reminder that Gura's 3D live this year had HIGHER CCV than last year's 3D showcase.
>>78738301Inclining and healing
>>78738192Amazing...she often casts the same spell on my dick.
>>78738274Probably could've hit 10k with time, or Ina finishing up, not bad
>>78738275>No argument
>>78738355Disingenuous shitposters don't deserve proper responsesNow seek rope
Surprised the debut song hasn't leaked yet considering the cover art did
>>78738301>3D showcase>3D LIVE BIRTHDAYThese are surely both the same thing.
This will be roughhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hs9URYX-IzI
>>78738353Nah, FWMC streaming in the 7PM slot outright sabo'd any chance of that happening
>>78738353
>>78738054Not paid too much attention, there's been so many, but I'm pretty sure they've been pretty low for a while now.Actually Niji sub growth has been pretty bad for some time, it doesn't get much discussion here but they talk about it on the JP side.
>>78738480...do people really just watch streamers the second a game releases instead of playing it themselves?
>>78738414>Pointing out that Ina is getting half her viewership on the same game is shit postingI see you're upset by facts. Consider transitioning.
>>78738500Despite Mumei having few streams, the fact that Hoomans are visible on the red filter is amazing
>>78738500>>78738353Wrong stream dummy
>>78738471Naruhodo
>>78738218>Fuwawa 16k>Mococo 13kThat's messed up
oh thats cool mori i think im gonna skip out on that one on the 27th
>>78738542Walls of text are not facts, post graphs or rope ennacuck
>>78738471what a slut. my slut
>>78738471>slick to the fanarts>cropped it to made thumbnail in sage mode
>>78738550I got distracted by Biboo how embarrassing
>>78738544i never understand what the color coding actually means on these
>>78738536I haven't played games since I found Hololive.
>>78738543Literally nothing wrong with cropping porn for thumbnails
>>78738471>>78738543EN for this feel
>>78738657
>>78738536Depends on the gameIn this case no, I don't think soEven Critikal's stream of the DLC has been pretty low
>>78738694SNO even stronger here. >>78738664Red = chatters who are members of Fauna and the other girl shown
>>78738680Mori
>>78738680Mori, nerizzler and fauna sometime.
>>78738583
>>78738471>>78738543Funnily enough this is actually her "cleaning up" her thumbnails because of her position as cultural ambassador. This is used to be her go-to waiting room thumbnail
Fauna really saved Biboo's ass. The way she's bleeding I don't think she'd have made 5k even with Fauna ending
>>78738471ecchidanye
>>78738471>>78738543Based as fuck
>>78738536I don't care for most games but I do for anything Fromsoft, I even avoided Armored Core 6 streams for a few days until I had gotten a few endings.I also cared for Starfield, but I'll never make that mistake again, fuck you Bethesda, I'll watch Fauna play it first before even buying it
Please stop with Mikochi. I've already blown loads on IRyS Fuana and Noel today.
>>78738536This is her playing regular Elden Ring, not the DLC yet
>>78737486Oh maybe with practice, but I'm doing it because it is fun, I made several doodles at work with a bic pen over failed reports sheets and found out I was having a good time again. Thank you for the link btw.
>https://x.com/moricalliope/status/1804298174464692246ENTER ANOTHER WATCHALONG
Look at my wife
>Bijou los-AAAAAAAAAAAAAACK AIEEEEEEEE I'M SHARTING MYSELF SISTERSSSSSS
>>78738856
>>78738937>Elden ringNo...
>>78738976kek
Saplings went to fwmcDon't want to get spoiled
>>78738937You guys think the new girls are beating advents debut numbers?
>>78738536I don't play games anymore (only Blue Archive thanks to that Fauna's sponsor stream).
>>78738955The look of someone who can't keep getting away with it.
>>78738694That's a lot of JP in Fauna's chat especially with JP streams happening.>>78738751Gura streaming regularly again has really highlighted how much chat overlap the two have
>>78738969So the core gachikoi of these dudes just sit and grudgingly watch them play boring boy games while the dudes deceive themselves into thinking they're still a brotuber with a brotuber audience, huh. Reminds me of Vox doing "post-nut runescape" kek
>>78738937Why doesn't she just watch with advent?
The twins always seem to do pretty well considering their waiting rooms.
>>78738471>>78738543
>>78739048No one thinks that.
>>78739080It's an advent offcollab.
>>78739061Goth Fauna really awaken a lot of people, huh?
>>78739080Apparently Advent will be in the studio
>>7873904860 quadrupillion watchalongs. What do you think?
<3
>>78739061not bad
>>78736130I'm subbed to all of them but can change depending on what happens in their debut and the days after.
>>78738583Big tits buff. So it's surprising the red woman is so low on main channel.
>>78739029
>>78739080No, but I think 100k is possible, but it will be close.
>>78739157Cute!
>>78739054
>>78739154>60 quadrupillion watchalongs>It's only Korone and HoloID on Ollie's channel
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qraKhxcuv6c
>>78739157> Faumei separated.Unbased.> Fauna and Mori together.Fair enough.
Well well well, looks like Mint is winning the waiting room race
>>78739157I love upclose Biboo in this image
>>78739157The only HoloEN I care about
>>78739157>Nerissa and Kiara with matching nailsHot
>>78739202this is how i imagine ennacuck
>>78739291>Korono>HoloID>Mori>Advent offcollabRetardchama ?
>>78739310Ina's tentacles are connecting Fauna and Mumei together, so its okay
So which gen had you the most hyped pre-debut? For me, it's Myth=Advent>Council>Justice.
>>78739364didn't ask
I am going to watch the debut with Jurard, who's with me?
>>7873601020kg in each pair.
>>78739364I asked, interesting
>>78739440Promise
Dramafags sure are coming out to support the homos
>>78739157Justice is going to take this away from us...
>>78739440Probably same ranking for me
>>78739364This will unironically mog every EN today besides debuts.
>>78739480Kys promisefag, but yes, promise is pretty great.
>>78739503too busy fighting the invisible war before debuts happen. please understand
>>78739291Jurard and Octavio's is gonna mog every else's anywayAll while they talk about how much they wanna fuck Gigi
>>78738146This looks like a cull of some kind
Imagine streaming From games day 1 instead of waiting at least 1 weekend LMFAO
>Gura's lolikami cover is 830k nowPossible 1M before 24 hours?
>>78739364Doki will probably end up with a higher peak since she has a larger pool of subs to pull from
>>78739503Two boderline 3view streams for Bettel in a row?This soon after 3D buff?Jeeez
>>78739604I want to see mumei reaction to this.
>>78739440It's Advent by far. You should have seen /hlg/ when Myth was teased. Everyone thought they were going to get Veibae tier whores. Thank God Covers scouts are goated though.
>pomucuck starts samefaggingnaruhodo
>>78739070you have to take into account that vrabi has bias toward JP but indeed people aren't that interested in ER
>>78739604cosplay for the goth outfits have been 10/10
Where is the waiting rooms?
is this good or grim?
>>78739680I usually agree but...>Red brit cunt*sigh*
>>78739738On their channels. Been up for like a day.
>>78739310eh Mom and Dad
>>78737173I thought you gringos didn't like soccer
>>78739680/hlg/ was shitting itself but /hlg/ always does that. The hype for Myth on twitter was unreal.
>>78739608I predict this game will still not get good numbers a week from now. Everyone is coping, the base game did not have this problem at all.
Anybody get their tickets already? Looks like there is an early access drophttps://animenyc.com/hololive-soar/
A little late since it took me a while to find it but go to Miko's channel, go by oldest livestream and count the number of streams with this in the thumbnail. Not an explicit image but absolute sex nonetheless
>>78739834How many seats anyway?
>>78739869Ayyyyyyy
Gooba's latest follow is the animator for her 3D live.
>>78739830Watch as Kanata gets better numbers than Noel and Koyori playing the base game instead of the DLC
>>78739666>3D debuts used as graduation from the hobbywouldn't be the first time it happened, but it's just gameplay debuff saw him around 2k the other day
>>78738969>Only 6k on elden ring dlcholy grim advent really did flop
Mococo trusts ruffians more than her sister
>>78739834I wish they had synced up the Breaking Dimensions ticket drop better. I'd like to know if I can actually go to the main event before buying a pass to this convention and that tour.
>>78738471Miko is great at thumbnail making
>>78739440Pre debut Myth was grim with everyone expecting twitch whores or woman sounding like they're straight out of a funimation dub who knew nothing about chuubas.
sub 100k debut because of watchalong?#supportJUSTICE
>>78739977People don't want to get spoiled.
>>78739977Not now brownsister
>>78739157>gura far back>biboo up front>lolis at both endswhat did the artist mean by this?
>>787401213k drop on her 2nd streamHOLY GRIM
>>78739827>twitterIrrelevant website where Luxiem gets 100k likes on random posts
Going to McDonalds before the debuts. What do you guys want?
>>78739604nice
Saplings are not gonna like hearing this but it's about time you hear the truthDiscussing numbers on any factors besides who starts first is meaningless, if someone like Biboo can get destroyed in an overlap then anyone who's not Gura can. Fauna has the luckiest slot in the world where she never or rarely gets overlapped The reality of numbers is that no factor matters more than overlap, an empty slot or the last resort, being a garbage collector, if you have those, you will eventually have better numbers than others, it's as simple as this, it has nothing to do with the entertainer's inherent quality anymore. It's about doing any of these three above in order to get numbers and Fauna is doing one of them while we watch Biboo get massacred under overlap when she has had the luxury of getting away with it in the pastTLDR: Fauna's numbers are due to her slot and nothing else, these are cold hard facts
>>78740057that shit was fucking cringe. don't remind me kek.
3 hours until /vt/ forgives Elizabeth.
>>78740171Most stream to least stream maybe?
>>78740210Happy meal
Elden reaper time, please gatherwww.youtube.com/watch?v=Hs9URYX-IzI
https://x.com/raorapanthera/status/1804303563553972665Well, that's it
>>78740210Apple pie.
>>78736752Watch Raora be nerfed too
>>787402102 hot n spicy mcchickens and a large HI-C
>>78740210the fries are never bigger than the bigmac
>>78739896https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MutoDmUJlmA
How does the blue homo have the most subs but the least views?
It couldn't be closer
>>78740210Get me the Gawr Gura combo meal and the FWMC shake from the collab, please.Ah shit, wait, I forgot I'm back in 2024. Uh... A double quarter pounder with cheese and a large diet coke.
>>78740174It's where Cover posted the announcement and how I saw it so it's what matters for pre-debt. Get cover to buy an ad on 4chan if you want me to care about what /hlg/ thought at the time.
>>78740290Its over
>>78740210big mac is such a scam with those thin patties, its "special" sauce is all it has going for it
>>78740210Ramen Mcshaker fries
>>78740210spicy nuggets if they have any
>>787402103 bag of fries.
>>78740229no way jose
>>78740290
>>78740210filet-o-fish, 10 piece nuggets w/ sweet and sour, and a mango smoothie
>>78740315leeched kobo
>>78740020She is the manipulator, after all.
>>78740210Do they have shaker fries at the moment? I only order stuff from them if shaker fries are available.
>>78736379Gigifag...
>>78740216tldr
So is Justice 3/4 so far?
>>7874021660/40 talent and slot
>>78740316https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mXMyZohVDi4
>>78740315Same reason oily got the most sub in ID2.
>>78740318My bad, it actually could!
At the end of the day, was this just a clever ploy from the jews to get me to eat more Mcdonalds?
>>78740315We are about to witness a similar phenomenon with Elizabeth.
>>78740321Those are man thighs
>>78740290She has watamage on her side, sisters will be smitten down if they try to shittalk her again
Will raora be the nerissashojo of #justice?
https://youtu.be/-Vc8MSEPFIk?t=21777WDSMBT
>>78740216
Do you guys think Korone decided to do a watchalong on her own or did management ask? Maybe management was concerned about the more muted response to Justice compared to Advent and is trying to get some JP eyes on it.
>>787404383/4 how? QRD
>>787404384/4, red has the best voice and in the end that's what matters.
>>78740436Fauna is shmort
>>78740210two no.9s, a no.9 large, a no.6 with extra dip, a no.7, two no.45s, one with cheese, and a large soda.
helmite status
>>78738543mikochi is a cgdct lesbian madlass
>>78740162*sigh* I guess I can jack off again...
>>78740550Cucked.
>>78737265She did a random homo collab once. Dunno what she was thinking.
>>787404658k combined
>>78740216You just have to ask, cutie.
>>78740290My pink calls are going to print, see you guys in the Mediterranean on my yacht suckers
>>78740216>if someone like bibooyou talk as if she were of any significantbibot only got watchtime on her because the long ass streams + bots
>>78740404Ramen and Tzatziki flavour
Jwu>No homos mention in Yagoo's speech They're useless as shit
>>78740622DOA
Here's the real question, numberbros: which of these new girls is going to curse like a sailor? If red is a bong it's probably guaranteed.
>>78740706Woman alert
Gigi is gaining steam, she's about to pass Ceci and Raora. The cull is scheduled to hit in about 50 minutes though.
sorry guys going to go on a 8 hour piss break, don't reply to this post to tell me how the debuts were later
>>78740672heh
>>78740707Never tried those. Get me one of each.
Interesting choice of game from Doki and Mint
>>78740745He's farming good will.Can't do that if you put the cancer in.
>>78740526On her own. What they did with regloss is what management mandate looks like
>>78740687Her small mouth makes her cheeks look extra fat. In a good way, of course.
>>78740465They should join EN5>>78740777Hit me with the link senpai
>>78740777Context?
>>78740777Who?
>>78740290divine protection status?
>>78740745>Jwu>HOMOS HOMOS HOMOS HOMOS HOMOS AAAAAA MY HOMOOOOOOOOOOOS
>solo live-posting drama buff
>>78740776Should be closer to 110 minutes no?
>>78740855>>78740867>>78740874I'm pretty sure that's Pomu's deleted members stream.
>>78740777how the fuck am i supposed to know whose chat that is
>>78740820small indie dev doesnt matter for shit. Nijigods get access to chinese and konami mega games. Holocucks can have tiny indie feces.
>>78740776They got culled?
>check /grun/>They're using üüüWhat is actually wrong with Saplings?
>>78740777>more opportunites will come? i don't think sothis is the infamous pomu member stream no?
>>78740745remember that according to that video the boyz aren't hololiveBe sure to spread that information to whoever asks it, as the organizational schematic of hololive is quite complicated so nothing quite like having a recent source when a poor lost soul is confused
>>78740867I assume this is the clip of the deleted Pomu membership stream
>>78740672They are virtually tied
>>787409422k yesterday.
>>78740820kek nice
>>78740622Lmao
>>78740942They've gotten culled every day 9pm est i think.
>>78740942two rounds of 2k culls
https://files.catbox.moe/k0ov7n.mp3
>>78740942Everyone on youtube gets sub culled, easier to see on new or smaller channels as the ticks are smaller.
How the fuck are threadshitters still using Pomu here? Please at least be logical.
>>78740977They should've uploaded a short on day 1 like Advent
Why is Korone doing a Justice debut watchalong? Is she trying be a unity queen as well?
>>78740943based
>>78741048Advent was losing ~2k a day too
>>78740968>Virtually tiedI see Mint mogging Doki so hard, she may not be able to stand up for a while.
>>78740776>all that doom posting and ERB is still aheador is this just the leader buff?
>>78739957>gameplay debuffDoes any chuuba that matters have anything resembling like that?
>>78740550he's commissioning her for Watame lewds
>>78741070>israel What the fuck?
>>78741091Unironically, biggest tits buff. This always happens.
>>78740943You can find anons who aren't even Saplings uuuuing in almost every general here.
>>78741091She was already ahead but it's probably first debut buff. Everyone heading to the waiting room is subbing.
FWMC gonna raid Biboo
>>78740968What the heck, Mint just surged into the lead
>>78741102Kiara. She sucks so bad and she's so obnoxious while sucking that she filter people who like the games she play.
>>78741014K I N O
>>78741147Context retard
babby schizos first debut, awww
I'm bored...
>>78741091community post shows her with the least engagement.
>>78741102most twitch vtubers
>>78741070Yes. She is a good dog
>>78741239Im going to take a nap
>>78740959The hololive famiry
>>7874117210k combined viewers!!!Just 14 minutes in. I wonder what the peak will be?
>their top batter is Homosisterskek gimping her own genmates in all fronts
>>78740943Multiple generals stole that from saplings
>>78740216Wow you just called Fauna a good and entertaining streamer for people to stay
>>78738543>>78738471is she slicking at the thought of her lews fanarts are being used and stared at by thousands publicly?
Blufags from reLOSS replied to everyone on twitter and get the most subs before debut just to end up last/second last.
>>78741383
>>78741091Big tits + pagpag dramabuffLowest in the actual community posts though
>>78741428
nooo I don't want to watch spoilers ahhhhh
>>78741452Oh, it's gonna be grim. She could be the runt in everything except subs early on.
>>78741383ultimate singularity
>>78739061>>78739604made for brown cock mine [/mine]
>>78741494
>>78741504kek
This guy is having a conversation with himself about doki and mint. Not the worst schizo we've seen.
>>78741507she'll probably make up for it in music views which is what really matters
Has any indie ever fumbled the bag as much as Mint?Not even talking CCV and debut wise, even though she could have ridden the dokiwave and gotten like 3x numbers on debut and first month..But talking about monetization. She has zero merch and zero sponsorship in two months. Doki probably had 50 combined merch runs and sponsors at two months in. And sure Dokibird has 500k more subs and special circumstances and yadayada whatever. But Mint is still a 3k+ indie, there are literal 2views that regularly have merch runs. Mint only has a single membership tier, and it is $2 tier. She had a meet and greet at offkai, but it was free to enter. Her only income is middling donos.Has anyone ever done less with a golden goose than her? And now she will probably lose half her viewership to justice so when she actually get some merch they will sell a fraction of what they could have
>>78741507I want to see her SC.
>>78741595Some people just don't care about money.
>>78741383now what?
she should do the debut watchalong
>>78741595Anon, she clearly doesn't want to go all in because she wants to get into Hololive.
>>78741494best voices in EN
>>78741284Good idea.
>>78740210>>78740549
>>78741595Doki hired some sort of experienced twitchfag businessman to be her manager which apparently worked out really well. I thought the guy was a retard at the time (fucked up her first merch drop and store really bad) but the results do speak for themselves.
>>78741623beautiful
>>78741595Unlike dookie the fairy aren't in for the money.
>>78741507Don't count on it early on, dramabuff is real anon. It'll depend on if her genmates can outshine that. Also some normalfags may not be turned off by the twitter shit and will only leave when the collabs start stacking
>>78741595Sounds like a nice girl.
>>78741595entertainers don't necessarily make good businessmen
>>78741659With Sayu as a guest.
>/grün/ shitting on the homosIt seems like it will be a pretty decent fanbase.
Elden Ring is a boring game to watch desu
>>78741595EN5 is the goal
>>78741747>>78732606
>>78741587Maybe early on but I believe that every holo needs to have a strong base for them to thrive long term
>>78740959>>78741285What? When? Was it at that party for the employees? Why he needs to do that? Does he plan to graduate all of them?
who said elden ring dlc wasn't a buff
>>78741595>dookie is a greedy bpdyeah...
>>78741749there's schadenfreude to be had in watching streamers die constantlyunfortunately dlc doesn't have a malenia tier bossthe dlc story is also pretty bad, ironically the vagueness of the base game did it favors
>>78741788I love Ina!
>>78740776Please just strike the bong whore.
Alright one of you guys has to bite the bullet and live post the homo watchalong.
>>78741837she's on the front page
>>78741623This is very relevant to my interests.
>>78741837Raids?
>main channel watch along>Advent watch along>homo watch along>a fucking Korone watch alongWhat the actual fuck are they thinking?
>>78741595Mint got really damaged on her way out of Niji, she wasn't sure if she even wanted to go back into vtubing, had to get convinced by Matara to do a podcast and until a few weeks ago she constantly was "well dunno if I'm gonna stay around, I might go away after the podcast, dunno". She probably wants to get into Hololive, but she knows people enjoy her right now as she is.
>>78741923sasuga nepomouse
>>78741887Not it
>>78741315Minto 6k
>>78741958dont forget about mori
>>78741958Maximize exposure rather than CCV, long term better outcome.
>>78741595Doki treated vtubing as a business while Mint is still "hobby" tier.
>>78741958and mori is watching long too
>>78736903>fuwamocos twin schtick is getting old and they have nothing to back it up with, you gotta be in touch with the culture you are trying to entertain and the weeb dogs know nothing about north americaOh?
>>78741837nice first page embeds lol
>>78741837I assume front page
>>78741595Mint is posting about her porn doujinshi hauls on twitter I don't think she cares as much about pursuing sponsors lol
>>78736535100k+Chloe had like 600k in a week.
>>78741837lolRaid or frontpage?
Biboo just brought up Axel, it's over...
It's watchalong time
Elizabeth will be the EN Suisei
>>78741958maybe gpt-kun thought it was a good idea or something
>>78741837kai ...
>>78741958It's the legendary HoloEU. They're trying to give them as much visibility as possible. Just not at EU time.
>>78741837Classic
>>78741837Front page
>>78741958This might come as a surprise, but ccv is a meme
>>78740622Imagine entering grimmer territories than the actual twitch whore so fast
i won't be able to watch the debut today due to some family meeting. gimme the qrd later bros.
>>78737661Who are the 1st and 2nd? After Rushia termination, I didn't pay attention to SC rankings anymore
>>78736130How many will have elden kek in their schedules?
>>78742117>>78741837>Front page>Only 10K
>>78742093>moonmoonhey, I watched him before hololive... I left twitch behind after myth came though.
>>78742033noooo, the fwmcschizo was probably feeling themselves before you destroyed their delusion.
>>78742117Imagine needing an entire website just to prop you up kek
>>78741958management mandate. same shit niji did during the luxiem craze
>>78742065>loli rape doujin on mainbrave
>>78741852wait, didn't it hit like 95 and beat witcher blood and wine, which was at 92. Man.....game journalists are as bad as ever
>>78742187Chloe and Pekora?
>>78742050raids would drop immediately on the next ccv check. Ironmouse is being pushed to literally the first stream on twitch first page.
>>78742189Probably not many, needing to start from the very beginning feels like it would be a pretty big debuff unless that was going to be their bread and butter content.
>>78741837She's not even playing the DLC though, that's the one that's debuff.
>>78741958just put the aggregate ccv of all the costreams like esports, it's a meme /here/ but it's the tech used for advertisers (or the few that still exists post-bubble burst)
>>78742142>ccv is meme>subs is meme>spacha is memeIs merch the only non-meme number?
>>78742199Koishi Biboo
>>78742107>HoloEU>Debut at 5:45 amFuck you cover
>>78742137>>78742074>>78742050damn pityboosted from 4k to 16k embedded, what a sad existence
>>78741958They don't care about CCV, they just want as many people aware as possible.
>>78742289Based
>I don't care about CCVwhere did you faggots come from? Go back.
Everyone streaming Elden Sneed lolJust tuned into Noel beating Rellana how long did that take her
>>78742310Money is the only non-meme number, whatever gets them the most money is what really matters
>>78742117doesn't appear to me
>>78742289Fauna really would have benefited from some red eyes
>>78742424How many bosses left for her?
>>78742289KOYORI IS PINK YOU DUMB SNOW ELF
>>78742417Peak CCV is not the be all end all metric. All Cover wants is as many eyes on the debuts as possible.
>>78742310Everything is only as valuable as it can be framed to investors, unless it generates money by itself. Unless an amount of subs pushes them above a competitor or breakline they can brag about, it's generally not worth much. CCV, again unless it's going to be high enough to brag about it doesn't end up meaning anything.
Which new EN is the most nervous about debut??
>>78742089I asked and actually it gives what seems to me like a pretty good and comprehensive strategy for shilling a new gen, and yes, it did suggest watch parties with "vtuber influencers" which is an amusing term.
>>78742289Fuwawa?
>>78742089Maybe.
>>78742514Gura
>>78742514Gigi
>>78742493
>>78742385This. It's like Geoff Keighley and the Game Awards whoring themselves out and letting anyone do a watchalong. It doesn't matter if it reduces the number on the main stream. It still gets your name out to more people.
Will the red one mention about wanting to bring holopro closer together and will biboo and FWMC keep quiet?
>>78742417>i don'tshadowboxing, people are talking about why there would be watchalongs rather than redirects, I'm sure this thread would jerk off endlessly if every watchalong did a redirect before the debut ended to max out the CCV graph.
>>78742597She should be, her voice and humor is going to tank her channel
>>78742535the pikachu.
>>78742008doki 6kLooks like Mint is winning this race, surprisingly enough
>>78742576>US Primetime overlap with EU late evening hoursHe's retarded.
>>78742260>a streamer named "Calli's proficiency in various games"What a weird name
>>78741837
>>78742586Gura's nervous demeanor was so hot... that's why her karaoke is S class for me, she's still a bundle of nerves.
>>78742417moving the goalpost as debut draw near, wonder who we heard this kind of talk from before hmmm....
>>78738691Based doggos
>>78742615cuck
how many tonight?
>>78742417this is uuu2 and mans2, get with the times
>>78742706filliankeks not like this... You said she was stronger.....
>>78742385Does it when it's stretching the same box? I don't expect that much jp to tune into Korone for it cause they don't care much.
>>78741837I thought she already had 2 mil followers
I'm glad Fauna is playing something other than Elden Ring because I'm already fucking tired of it
>>78742514Cecilia
>>78742385If they want to brag about the number they can just combine ccv for their report anyway.>n many people watched the new debuts across our channels, our official watchalongs, and community streams using the #holoJustice tagIt wouldn't get them gold in this thread, but it's fine for an investor report.
>>78742594>Nobody got the best endingBunch of fucking simps, only went with Ranni because she's popular.
>>78741958CCV = meme numbers, VOD matters the most
>>78742706The absolute STATE of Vtwitchers
>>78742613Are any vtubers outside of holo even doing watchalongs of the justice debuts?
>>78742772That's the thing, it's for the westabos who do care.
>>78742751I miss when this was mans2...
>>78742594Ranni is overrated
>>78742706What the FUCK is that monstrosity on the bottom right?
>>78742816I thought Biboo was going Frenzy this run.
>>78742816Isn't that just the>fuck everything up foreverending? With Ranni you get smol wife.
>>78742832You're looking at EN5,6,7,8 like usual.
>>78742858>hispanic>furry>vtuberI never want to hear the word grim applied to anything less than this monstrosity.
>>78742824ok beggars, you guys can leave now.
>>78742772The idea is to catch some people who might not usually watch the debut because they'll watch one of the girls reacting to it. Whether this actually works is up for debate.
>>78742074The absolute state.
>>78742816>shit ending
>>78741958They will just aggregate the CCV for the investors' report.
>>78742706Which did you remind me that whore Froot exists
>>78742934what the fuck does that have to do with beggars? are you just regurgitating words you've seen in the thread?
>>78742706>A lot of vtubers getting 1k+ viewersWhat is NijiEN and homoEN excuse? Why can't they all be consistent 4views?
heh mousey already mogged shitrys and bijflops elden ring streams
>>78741932
>>78742785might happen tonight
>>78742934The fuck you mean? Homos CCV and VOD numbers are shit
>>78742686It almost works if it's assuming that US Primetime is Eastern Primetime. But that's still 10pm in Britain when Primetime is starting.
>>78743033I miss Fauna's minecraft
debut vs debut for gold today right? No GTA stream i think?
>>78743008niji is dead. homos shares about 2k actual viewers over 10 channels kek
>>78742934Imagine yourself trying to sell a product, and you'll realize the goal is to have more people see your product, not a slightly higher amount at one point in time.
>>78742907>>78742953It's the ending where Elden Ring turns into Dark Souls so it's canon to me.
>Mousey at 16k>Doki and Mint about to hit 7kHoloEN is cooked.
>>78743008anon twitch ccv is a meme
>>78743003because you talk like one>CCV = meme views blah blah CCV doesn't matter blahbut sure, go ahead
>>78743152Okay so you're just a newfag trying, and failing, to fit in. Got it.
>>78743152you've given up
>>78743136
>>78743152It is fact that they're meme numbers with a lot of cull and shit, but go ahead jerk off to that.
>>78743008sometimes it doesn't work anon....
>>78743068Primetime start around now for the east coast and it's in a few hours for the west coast. It's 2AM in most of Europe.What the fuck are you talking about ?
>>78740316>PekoMiko$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
>>78743150SEETHE
Korone doesnt even follow them on twitter Thats how you know this is management forcing her to watch it
>>78743234She should have bought bots like Bijou and Fuwamoco
>>78743150so is YT or any other platform. Tribalfagging over a website is embarrassing to say the least.
>>78743150Why does Twitch allow someone to openly farm fraudulent ad views on their platform? Why wasn't that channel just banned instantly. I mean I get that a lot of twitch views are fake, but it seems beyond the pale to openly admit it and ask your audience to do it
>>78743241Why are men so much more loyal than women?
>>78742706>road to 2 million followersBut Ennacuck was adamant that she had 2 million followers and beat IRyS, what happened?
>>78743275>management is only forcing korone from all the jps to watch the debuts for some reason
>>78741659Think she ever GIWTWMI do
>>78742824Both matter coping retard.
>>78743234
>>78743257ohhhh im retarded i thought primetime was 1700-2100
>>78743306>should>implying it hasn't
>>78742090She'll be EN Ollie lets be realLike BEST case scenario for her is she's EN Matsuri
>>78743325t. ennacuck
>>78743297Fuck you, I will not fap to you again today, Fauna.
>>78743241what a horrendous avatarmale vtuber designs are just so fucking bad all the time. Vox, notwithstanding his actual stream content, seems like an easy example of one done right and yet these fucked up weird ones are so much more common
>>78743325Cope nigger
>>78743352Everyone else was busy or uninterested
>>78743338I'm sure ex Holos are getting peak numbers. It probably has more to do with the individuals personality and glaring flaws that make people bail on them once the corpo filters are removed.
>>78743241Why didn't he get a black model?
All Cecilia has to do is have a cute voice and giggle a lot and she will be a 10k chuuba easy
>>78743410You can get like 100k CCV but if it's all bots they're not going to VOD numbers. You are coping retard.
>>78742790Only because we're building her up. I remember Mumei crumbling pretty hard due to the expectations.
>>78743507Let's not get ahead of ourselves. There is no permanent 5view in EN besides Gura.
>>78743329they tried to ban her soon after the event was done for some tangent reason; it didnt work because all the other >big twitch streamers felt threatened because they also do it so gave them a hell of a backlash, so she was unbanned in less than 1 hour
>>78743125Is it actually? I thought Fromsoft loved being retardedly unclear with literally everything all the time.
>>78743507>All Cecilia has to do is have a cute voiceAbout that, how do you like germans?
>>78743329>Twitch fake numbers look big>Clueless investors buy ads on the platform>The site gets to live one more day
>>78743266https://imgur.com/UPJeDon
>>78742658This seems to be about the peak 12.7k combined or so.
>>78743633She sounds like a mix between Shylily and Kiara so she will be fine.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EOOx4eqNQ7A>Vampire Survivor COOP up to 4 people in LoLpossible numbers ahead?
>>78743562Who is getting 100k bots on yt and how does their VOD view not correlate to it?
>>78743352She doesnt follow them on twitterYou would think that someone who is genuinely interested in them would follow them already
>>78743448>Vox, notwithstanding his actual stream content, seems like an easy example of one done rightTell me what constitutes a good male design to you anon
>>78743507She's like Sora, pretty bland unless you're into it.
>>78743697Kuzuha
>>78743507most ens have cute voices, doesn't work like that
4 days
>>78743241incidentally it looks like over half his streams this month are facecam
>>78743150reminder thats a good friend of ironmouse lol
>>78743697this guy
>>78743152Does Cover even talk much about CCV in their investor reports? Is always subs and $$$.