/vt/ - Virtual Youtubers

>>6218652
Reflect is S tier

>>6218652
anon its a small thtning but i really like how you colorcoded the song names

>>6218752
The chorus is S tier but I dont like other parts of the song as much.

i dont really dislike any of them..

>>6218838
I just thought it would be a neat way to visualize just how dominant calli is as EN's musical girl. Who knows how long it will take the vsinger to match her.

>>6218752
agree

Oh shit, first time i've seen someone rank RIP lower than the others

Red should be in B tier.

Damn what did Red do to you?

>>6218652
Wah wah Land in A

a deadbrapp made this thread

>>6219008
someone mentioned the offbeat laugh sfx and it bothers me ever since

>>6219035
>caring about originals
Did you expect any less?

Reflect is literally the cringiest shit I've ever heard. The tryhard to be edgy was so bad, felt like a 13 year old kid claiming they have "color changing eyes" and shit. Fucking cringe, can't listen to it without wincing in pain.

I don't listen to any of them regularly, except cursed night once in a blue moon.
I haven't even listened to Sparks yet

>>6219166
the cringe is (You)

>>6218652
>sparks in A tier
no

Mori is an actual musical artist. I'm not even a Deadbeat.

>>6218652

>>6219166
>felt like a 13 years old kid
T o T

an objectively right tierlist

>>6218652

>>6218652
all the japanese songs are D and they will NEVER BE JAPANESE

S tier songs have themes I can connect with very well, great musical backing, and a sense of their singers pouring their heart into them.
A are the same except I don't relate to them so well, and/or the non-vocal work on it carries them. Sparks is great, but I don't think it's Kiara's magnum opus even if I really like what she sings about.
B are in some segments as great as A, but I don't care as much about them in terms of lyrics, except for CN where I feel the lyrics tend to be great, everything else is fine but not amazing.
RIP has a backing track that is over-the-top, Heart Challenger is cute but >Valentine, and I never got invested in Live Again even when I have no particular reason to dislike it.

>>6218945
It's solidly middle of the road and held back by cringe lyrics. It only got such a positive response in the first place because it was a pleasant surprise. Many of Mori's other songs are significantly better.

>>6218652
Violet is SS tier.

>>6218652
Reflect is very weird to me because there are parts where I think the song is SS tier but for some parts it just sounds garbage.

HOLY SHIT FUCK THIS CAPTCHA WTF

>>6218652

>>6219256
Sparks was disappointing imo not to mention there's so many better songs out there about sparks.

>>6220345
based

S tier gives me goosebumps whenever I hear them.
A tier gets me similarly pumped but less so, with the second half having like one or two small parts that bug me a little.
B tier are also good but I can't really loop them.
I don't really consider Reaper Rapper a song, just an intro to listen to like once and then never again.

>>6220798
I forgot the fucking image god damn it

>>6219203
>I haven't listened to it but I rate it a D
hurr durr

Live Again is the best EN original song, partly because Mori actually wrote the lyrics and they're meaningful to her. Hinotori has a similar thing where the English bridge was written by Kiara (in a hurry, actually) and has a kind of sincerity that I really like.

Mori's other songs have a tendency to be a little too cringe for my taste, but I guess "pardon my rudeness" would be the other somewhat good one. I'm not really a fan of her other songs.

Sparks is a good song that's catchy, same with Heart Challenger, but in neither case does it really feel like Kiara's own song the way Hinotori does. She also seems to want her vocals over-mixed which seems like her being self-conscious about her own voice (I might be projecting that onto her though).

Reflect has the same kind of "manufactured" feeling that Heart Challenger & Sparks have. Doesn't really seem to be genuinely a Gura song. I know this is kind of an amorphous impression but I am not very good at expressing myself.

D for "Didn't Listen (yet)"

>>6219166
>I used to tell people I had color changing eyes and I forgot all about it until I read this post
Fuck you anon

Fuck you guys I like Sparks

>>6221228
Go listen to it on repeat, then. You don't want your oshi to cry, do you?

>>6221156
>She also seems to want her vocals over-mixed which seems like her being self-conscious about her own voice
This seems to be you projecting that. The chicken voice is all her idea so I doubt she has any self-consciousness related to that. People with voice self-consciousness like me talk as little as possible, which Kiara infamously does not do.

They're all B-tier for me. Not bad, I don't dislike listening to them, but I don't really want to go back and listen to them again. I would definitely be embarrassed if anyone caught me listening to them.

fucking captcha how the hell can i post this?

>Reflect
>Gura has no fucking clue what shes saying
That itself makes me not like it

>>6221437
She didn't write her own lyrics?

>>6221437
surely knows more Nip than I do and even I understand a handful of the lines.

t. KFP

>>6221477
i think anon means she doesn't understand the meaning behind the lyrics, not that she doesn't know the literal meaning of the words. unless she's just that bad with moon runes which would be a shame.

>>6221219
i remember some half nig half white girl in 8th grade kept telling people how her eyes were grey in summer, and green in winter. No one gave a fuck. Is that the type of shit you guys are talking about? Or is it more cringy like, "My eyes turn red when im angry"

>>6221548
the meaning is about HER telling Gura to stop playing nice country girl and come drink and hang out with Belle Delphine and Nyanners but Gura saying "no, I want a seiso circle of friends now like I was raised."

>>6218652
I've only heard two of them. Rip was okay and Reflect as also okay.
Has Ina made any songs yet?

>>6222038
She has one in the works but it's been a while since it was teased so who knows when it comes out.

>>6221452
>>6221548
She described the concept behind the song and passed the Japanese lyrics off to someone else. Of course she knows what her own song is about. She had an entire stream about it.

Kiara's voice is awful
Gura's voice is annoying and song is cringy as fuck
Mori has 2 catchy songs, her roommate has much better music

They should stick to games. Ame knows.

>>6222415
>watches hololive for gameplay
How embarrassing

Explain your tierlists people. Otherwise there are all just vague personal bias that can be expected to not have anything to do with the actual songs. Absolutely zero significance.

Red is the weakest song on Your Mori.
Also Empress would be in A.

>>6222826
I can agree with these except with Bullys placement

>>6222925
Went between having it A or B, settled for it being B just because I felt better about B being fuller than A. No slight to the song.

Does Ame know that she doesn't have to sing well to make a good song?

>>6223391
Does Ame want to make a song?

>>6219238
Wtf is that real??

>>6218652

>>6223527
yeah rats can wash themselves

I've listened to Reflect over 20 times and have yet to feel anything from it. Why no vibrato?

>>6223645
Try this anon.

https://youtu.be/ghSedPM6i5Y

Cursed Night and Live Again are just plain good songs, i'm not a huge fan of meme songs and those two are the ones that i could imagine being in the EP of a random non-anime related artist. All the other ones are just waaaay too anime, which i like anime songs but i don't listen to them on the daily.

Spark's mixing sounds weird to me, too disjointed i can't really find a rhythm but its not awful. The ones on D are just kinda cringe to me and too memey.

There you go

>>6218652
>RIP and Red in C
>Hintotori not in C
op is sussy baka cunt

t. Deadbeat

I'm probably too harsh on RIP, but I just can't listen to it anymore after hearing it/remixes of it a million times at this point.

>there are """"""people"""""" who think Bully isn't at least A tier

ready to be torn apart by you mouthbreathers. never reading this thread again though, so fuck off

>>6225876
Typical cumshart with absolute diarrhea tier taste

>>6219348
BASED ALARM

>>6225914
lmao i'm a deadbeat, but go off. i just don't blindly worship everything my oshi creates.
Reflect and Sparks are energetic songs. I like energetic..

>>6225990
>n-n-never reading this thread again
>responds
BOOOOOOOOM shakalaka. Diarrhea tier taste btw.

>>6218652
Every single hololive song is dogshit, why dont you holofags listen to real vsingers like kaf?

>>6218652
Off With Their Heads is a great song, but it reminds me of how much of a failure I am.

>>6226109
You fell for that bait nigger, get played.

>>6218652
Anything with Kiara. D.

>>6226149
That's the point, anon. Now are you gonna be a sayer or a doer today?

>>6218652
>hinotori
>above any of calli's songs
>cursed night and RIP
>anywhere below any of kiara's songs
jesus christ you have shit taste.
>>6225990
kek
as a chumbud, Reflect isn't THAT good.

I don't like Kiara but Sparks gets a bump up for at least being in english.

>>6218652
i havent lisetn to any kiara songs

>>6226396
neither

>>6226436
Wouldn't Reflect technically go in your bottom tier as well?

>>6218867
I agree.
This is also the same problem with Blue Clapper.
Godlike chorus, but the rest of the song is puke inducing

>>6226523
>as a chumbud
No. I refuse to put Gura's song that close to Kiara's.

>>6226603
Hinotori is fine, the rest...

>>6218652
reflect fucking sucks
Gura spent too much time trying to make her first song perfect instead of actually producing and getting better

>>6226436
>hurr durr X is bad
>unless le meme shark does it
Cumsharts in a nutshell

>>6226683
>hurr durr X is good
>unless le meme shark does it
Tranny /qa/tards in a nutshell

>>6219307
funny how you say this but the only one she actually made the track for is ranked the lowest

>>6219432
Objectively correct

I don't really dislike any of them. I just think Hinotori is bland and Reaper Rapper is so hilariously out of place next to the rest of Mori's repertoire. Ibasho is so forgettable it didn't even make the list. That said, I find it funny, thinking back to how wowed I was by Mori's first EP on debut when the only song I think still holds up in every aspect is Live Again. A real testament to how letting your real emotions and experiences into your music improves your songwriting tremendously.
I like Reflect and how different it sounds to most holo music. I like to think of it as Gura's version of Live Again. I like Heart Challenger more than Hinotori, and the more I stream Sparks the more I'm enjoying it. Looking forward to Violet.

>>6226883
I excluded Ibasho because soundtrack for something that doesn't exist doesn't count

I just can't get into Kiara's voice at all. That said I'm not the biggest rap fan as well.

>>6218752
Now that the hype has died down I actually don't think it's S-tier. Initially I thought that, but only because I love Gura so much. Outside the chorus it's sort of mediocre and I don't like a lot of the production on it. Gura's voice can only go so far.

>>6226715
The cumshart's one response to anything is to accuse you of being a tranny. Cumsharts are literally children.

>>6227443
I really like the song, but the back and forth between the Gura's does not interest me musically. Conceptually it's kinda neat. The verses and chorus are killer though. I put it in A on mine

>>6223719
Many thanks.

>>6221184
alright I heard Sparks and it stays there.

Also regarding Heart Challenger:
https://youtu.be/7TYs30lTalE

>>6218652

>>6219348
accurate to the point of having calli's song as the worst, good job

>>6218652
All of them are soulless

This thread is again proof that tier lists are the official template of "I have shit taste and no clue what I'm talking about"

>>6230705
people here are giving Holoen songs high marks out of pity and because they're simps, in reality most of them are pretty garbage

>>6230832
you're supposed to rank them as Hololive songs, not rank them relative to other music you retard.

>>6231566
Agreed, but that still doesn't solve how there's not really any EN songs you could give an S rating to

Have fun coping with your "idols", "artists" and "entertainers", fucking children.

>>6218652
Honestly very easy

>>6218752
B at best, and I say that because I like Gura

Nothing in S.
Nothing in A.
Reflect only in B.

>>6227477
Dilating made you a bit cranky, huh tranny?

Spark's okay, maybe I'd like it more if I heard it a couple more times

Live Again is the only song from EN I like enough to listen to regularly