[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/vt/ - Virtual Youtubers


View post   

File: 2.01 MB, 3588x1889, morys.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
51040354 No.51040354 [Reply] [Original]

>debut IRyS as a vsinger
What went wrong?

>> No.51040595

>>51040354
yes, she's the worst singer in her gen

>> No.51040882

>>51040354
>>51040354
Her lyrics are ESL trash and the backing tracks are mid AF. If Irys wants to be known as a singer she needs to put her foot down and get managment to let her do her own thing with her own people like Mori and Suisei.
Also CHaD cast song when?

>> No.51041030
File: 90 KB, 320x293, 1661482112242764.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
51041030

>>51040354
IRyS karaoke > IRyS songs
>>51040595
lmao I don't know what you're smoking to think Fauna or Kronii are better singers...

>> No.51041034

>>51040354
Who are the "official" VSingers so far? IRyS and AZki? Not to be rude but neither is particularly strong singer, if they were branded as regular Tubers then there wouldn't be any extra focus on them, but since they are VSingers they get evaluated by their (unfortunately underperforming) music. They need to pick VSingers with more distinct voices and not just generic JP speakers. IRyS is decent but Mori is a powerhouse.

>> No.51041162

>>51040354
Vsingers are only relevant as long as they keep making good music. How many albums has she published since she debuted back in 2021?

>> No.51041215

>>51040354
There has never been a good English-language song from Hololive and the fact that all EN fans want them is why they get exactly what they deserve with Irys whose most famous iconic song that made her worth hiring in the first place is in Japanese.

>> No.51041218

Bad production, genre/style is way too much generic j-pop, never advertises it.
And I honestly think her voice is incredibly mid. She just sounds like someone is crushing her windpipe. Certainly can't be compared to some of the gigaSOVL voices in HL.

>> No.51041246

>>51041030
Anon, she's the only member of her gen

>> No.51041277

>>51041162
0 I think? She produced two EPs and they both charted well, though. Her music sales do way better relatively than her YT views due to several factors from the management

>> No.51041327

>>51040595
IRyS is LITERALLY the best singer in her gen.

>> No.51041329

>>51041034
Azki seems to always get people creaming over her in vsinger discussions. She is Hololive's only actual vsinger but Suisei was also one once and arbitrarily gave up the title so if she doesn't count as one anymore, by that standard Azki wouldn't either because she also joined Hololive proper. Azki's whole shtick (and Suisei's) were their involvement in the actual music industry but the shutdown of the ability to do concerts ended that for Azki.

>> No.51041473

IRyS has great music, she doesn't pump it out like Mori, but IRyS isn't filling an unserved niche like Mori is.

>> No.51041498

>>51041473
lmao not even /HIrys/ listens to her music

>> No.51041513

>>51040354
What happened? What do nijifriends need to deflect from, now?

>> No.51041620

>>51041218
IRyS is content taking the shit given to her and just singing it. No creative input, no ideas of her own. No lyric writing. Don't blame it all management either because Susei and the others push back to have things as they visioned. At this rate IRyS will never get signed to a label and the work she puts out will be destined to heard like once by her superfans and never again

>> No.51041628

>>51040354
mid singer, no vocal range variety. only has that cutesy voice, unfit for an EN audience. trash songs.
no stage presence whatsoever. moona, kiara and fucking mori are better performers than her.

>> No.51041716

>>51041473
>great songs
She has like 4 if I'm being generous and half of are those are being carried by that famous composer

>> No.51041888

>>51040354
If you ask me as a normie, what is more atractive:
- A vtuber doing idol music.
- A vtuber doing hip-hop/rap/whatheverthefuck she does

Besides, IRyS shines more doing the common vtuber stuff (streams and karaoke) instead of produced music

>> No.51041962
File: 1.08 MB, 1412x798, Screenshot_2023-06-09_112006.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
51041962

>>51041628
Even the ccv runt is more successful with her music yeah

>> No.51042263

>>51041888
Why does Bae have more successful songs then? Is it rarity buff or is she better?

>> No.51042310

>>51040354
She became a one trick pony

>> No.51042393

Because IRyS sucks.

>> No.51042481

>>51040354
people who listen to rap somehow have less standards than people who listen to jpop

>> No.51042670 [DELETED] 

>>51040354
Irys is a nice girl anon, Mori isnt. If Mori has to drink some japanese "protein shakes" to get her career going she doesn't mind, shes a western ho doing western ho things. Irys on the other hand is Japanese, doing trash like that is unthinkable for her. Shes not gonna liwer herself like that, she probably got asked go to up to a producers room for an "audition" but daid no thank you. Same thing happens to Mori she goes there running and is gagging the second she walks into the room. It is what it is, anon best you cam do is support Irys and know in the back of your head that Mori is pretty much building her career on her back while biting a pillow.

>> No.51042869

>>51042481
What's the cope for this then?
>>51041962
>>51042263

>> No.51042887

>>51040354
Both IRyS and Mori are bad singers. IRyS sounds like a tryhard while Mori can't fucking sing at all. Gura and Mumei are the best while Bae is the absolute top for 3D peformance.

>> No.51042934

>>51042670
IRyS has only lived in Japan as long as Mori and its hilarious that you think the same shit doesn't happen in the Japanese entertainment industry.

>> No.51042964

>>51042670
>Irys on the other hand is Japanese
no

>> No.51043009

>>51042934
It never happens with japaneas women, if a japanese girl does anything with a producer is because she wants to explore her sexuality. Nothing wrong with that, on the other hand western hos do it to advance their career and have no shame.

>> No.51043022

>>51042670
IRyStocucks are truly a delusional bunch.

>> No.51043091

>>51043009
>if a japanese girl does anything with a producer is because she wants to explore her sexuality
>on the other hand western hos do it to advance their career and have no shame
What the fuck is this schizo dribble?

>> No.51043092

>>51040882
Irys is way too lazy to put her foot down and prefers the easy life of management dragging her along. She's just getting a note every other month that says "sing this" and then she's out to do her own thing for 30 more days. Vsinger is nothing but a pet project.

>> No.51043166

>>51040354
The worst part is she likely permanently wrecked her voice busting her ass with her hard work out of the gates and the fanbase just shrugged their shoulders and showed complete disinterest.

>> No.51043194

>>51040354
Everything went wrong
>Worst model in Hololive history on debut
>No genmates
>Managemente debuts council 1 month after IRyS, killing her momentum on the spot
>No new outfit for more than a year because RedJuice's design was so fucking bad she decided to just have them delete it instead
>She gets an ESL song writer
>Said songs are about shitty edgy weeab subjects, something no one would ever listen more than once
>MVs release months after the cover
>Management spoils the release of new songs/covers on twitter before IRyS herself announces them
>Management won't let her write her own lyrics, has said she wants to have "sad" music but management just won't allow it
>While her current model is better, it's also pure cancer for fanartists so she's the HoloEN with the least amount of art by far, both SFW and NSFW
EN staff just doesn't care about her, she's never the priority.

>> No.51043208

>>51043092
Doesn't reach out for collabs
Doesn't organize special streams
I know gura gets shit on for being lazy but I'm a surprised more people don't call or irys just being coast mode not to mention the side gigs her RM does go farm more money

>> No.51043318

>>51043009
Why are you acting like IRyS, who was born and raised in America, and only moved to Japan around the same time as Mori, isn't Western?

>> No.51043316

>>51041034
They were both well regarded and significantly influential in the NND Utaite market. Are you suggesting that they (NND JP viewers) are poor judges of good taste and that both of them failed to deliver when exposed to a wider and more judgmental audience?

>> No.51043459

>>51040354
As cringe as Mori's lyrics are, at least they sound like they were written by an english speaker. Half of the shit they make IRyS sing is unlistenable to me because the lyrics are so awkward.

>> No.51043597

>>51043318
Wait, IRyS is like Kson? For some reason I thought she was JP born and just took EN lessons alot more seriously than most JP.

>> No.51043700

>>51040354
Wtf is her most popular song a kinda meme song cover?!
That is pretty grim for a vsinger what the fuck

>> No.51043841

>>51040354
aint even Bae more successful with her songs?

>> No.51043993

Was Mori spotted with her BF Ao again? Deadbeats been acting more insecure than usual.

>> No.51043996

>>51040354
I see some anons commenting about IRyS's singing abilities, but for recorded songs it does not matter a bit. There are plenty of pop singers who sound like a dying cat live, but their MVs get hundreds of millions of views. Why? It all comes down to how a song affects your emotions (happiness, sadness, anger and so on). Even lyrics don't matter most of the time because songs like gangnam style or crazy frog have no problem hitting 4B with garbage lyrics (or lack of them). IRyS's songs are simply too generic. There's nothing in them to make you want to dance, sing, cry or scream. You could probably get AI to generate more catchy songs.
IRyS should be like Mori and start picking her own producers who are at least capable of producing passable tracks.

tl;dr
Shit producers

>> No.51044030

>>51043208
Can't really blame her for going along the easy life but as a result she'll never be anything more than a mediocre and very much replacable chuuba. I also can't bring myself to have even an ounce of respect towards that kind of attitude, there's nothing engaging in watching a sloth.

>> No.51044092

>management won't allow IRyS to make her own songs
>management ghosts IRyS when she tries to work on songs
>channel growth for all of HoloEN died down thanks to management decisions (Tempus debut)
>she has no gen
>even after Sana graduated IRyS isn't allowed to join council because management hates her
>she's stuck halfway between the JP and EN chuubas
being IRyS is suffering

>> No.51044191

>>51041277
Where did they chart? Oricon? itunes? Mora?

>> No.51044311

>>51040595
She is the only member in her gen
>But she's part of coun....
Discord leaks said they are four members

>> No.51044358

>>51044191
I remember her EPs sell pretty well. So I think it is nothing to worry about her music. Don’t know about her original songs tho.

>> No.51044361

Placing her as a vsinger just felt like a workaround to get an extra EN member at the time. She can certainly sing quite well but she's also a good streamer and has been since day 1. I see her as more of an all rounder for holoen.

>> No.51044413

>>51044191
iTunes if my memory was right.

>> No.51044810
File: 395 KB, 1356x497, lol.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
51044810

>>51040354
Because you shoud never let Cover produce any music
and also 1 channel algorithm (project hope) will never be able to compete with 5 channel algorithm (myth) and (council)

>> No.51045717

>>51043194
Which is sad to think about because she's more popular than half of myth at this point

>> No.51045861

>>51040354
There was no demand for a v-singer in Holo EN and then Cover mismanaged her music career to death.

>> No.51045878

>>51043996
True. Keep in mind that one of the biggest American pop stars of all time, Britney Spears, had someone else singing in her biggest hits to make sure she could hit the notes properly
https://youtu.be/S7dk9DXFrwk
Pop is an incredibly lazy genre

>> No.51045970

>>51045717
not a big accomplishment with their frequency of going on hiatus, the biggest one self-destructing her channel and the rat being dead on arrival

Fauna and IRyS are the only members of councilRyS that deserve the success that comes from being a holo

>> No.51046184

>>51044030
Yeah I don't blame her but I don't have the same drive to watch her as a result
At least Gura orgazined this looks that brain quiz and April fools vr collab.
>>51045970
Mumei is way more popular than Irys. Irys only wins with no competing for overlap which is why she makes sure to snipe other members with her streams first or after and never overlaps with gura if she knows gura is streaming

>> No.51046617

>>51046184
>never overlaps with gura if she knows gura is streaming
So you mean everyday ?

>> No.51046700

>>51041034
I agree about voices being generic, but IRyS got fucked over hard by having piss poor production, her songs sound like anime OPs and they were written in English by an ESL in progress.

>> No.51047215

>>51046617
Right now she must be overjoyed since she doesn't have to worry about a shark in her waters yeah

>> No.51047298

>>51046184
Reminder that she delayed a stream to force it not being overlapped with gura by saying she was out running late and it said posted from twitter desktop lol

>> No.51047395

>>51041034
AZKi is not a particularly strong singer? I'm curious who you have above her. I can understand that her breathy singing style can be divisive, but in terms of actual skill, I'd be hard-pressed to come up with a substantial list of people that can match up to her in the vtuber sphere.

But I agree that her music underperforms. Numbers and popularity are not dictated by singing skill alone.

>> No.51047466

>>51047298
>not being overlapped with gura
No I remember it was a male collab including Mori.

>> No.51047592

>>51047395
>who you have above her.
Suisei, Mori, IRyS, Moona, Gura, Bae, Sora, Towa.

>> No.51047628

>>51047466
Oh I misremembered then but yeah she's a numberfag and straight up lies to her fans for the most lame stuff

>> No.51047827

>>51040354
Cover mismanagement shutting her down

>> No.51048060

>>51044191
Don't remember about Oricon, but her songs did well on iTunes and Mora.

>> No.51048369

>>51047827
Cope she's just too lazy to push back on management ideas like suisei or Mori do

>> No.51048682

>>51047592
I have to disagree. Moona and Sora, maybe.

Arguments can be made for Towa, Suisei, and Gura. They are at their best when playing to their strengths and singing to match their vocal range, but are also lacking in certain areas.
For example, Suisei self-admittedly claims she is not strong at higher registers. It can be argued that AZKi is the same, being better at ballad-style pieces but weaker with high-energy songs.
I might be writing a whole bunch of shit for replying what might be a troll post, but
>Mori, IRys, Bae
I will not stand for this slander

>> No.51048835

Cover being retarded as always and mismanaging its talents
At this point if you give Mori to IRyS as manager she would probably do a way better job than her current ones

>> No.51050918

>>51040354
Jpop

>> No.51052328

>>51040354
mori had first strikers advantage, nothing about mori specifically lead to her success except her work ethic, if mori never put out any music and ina for example was the one releasing songs every month, she would have had the same level of success, it was simply the combination of (having any music to listen to + releasing it when holoEN was at it's peak)

>> No.51052400

Vsigners are given generic slop to churn out as songs. Occasionally one breaks through, like Inochi but keep in mind that was Azki's EIGHTH song and it's the only one most people know. People care for songs the Holo makes or writes, not ones management does.

>> No.51052505

>>51041962
Kiara also shills her shitty music so hard it stunts her growth even more.

>> No.51053425

>>51040354
People always say the IRyS doesn't have input to her original songs and the management f*cked her over but none of her cover songs became popular or stood out. Internet Overdose? It just one of the many covers out there. Nothing is special in IRyS' version. It's not just the management's fault, IRyS herself is the problem.

>> No.51054311
File: 722 KB, 741x1080, 1681609992081679.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
51054311

>>51040354
she was 'pre poached' as an emergency hire and locked away to rot
>Myth was a standout hit of unironic diversity in its genmates
>There still remained one vtuber who was more viral than old gura with a 100 mil song
>gura's viral power level was 10-20 mil, imagine the success of IRyS!
>Hire her asap so she doesn't go to niji/elsewhere and potentially eclipse the likes of mori or suisei
She and or Cover likely joked that she'd have multiple 10 mil songs, let alone another 100 mil ultra viral hit, but made it clear that she was a special case and they expected great things from her before really supporting her etc. IRyS was 'blessed' with her original model with was the cope excuse for her not performing well, just wait for the new hopium model bro! Now with her redesign people noticed her attitude sort of changing which might be the apparent realization that it was never her model but the fact that she's good but not superstar 100 mil good.

>> No.51056102

>>51041215
Gravity is in Japanese?

>> No.51056636

>>51041498
Hirys doesnt even talk about it. It is a circle jerk of virgins sharing drawings

>> No.51057049
File: 82 KB, 282x186, Councilrys.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
51057049

>>51041246
Well she eventually integrated into CouncilRyS semi-unofficially

>> No.51057327

>>51053425
This. There's always cope about it being management's fault but irys has no musical talent besides being a someone who can copy the original which is impressive to only a point. She has no soul or creativity of her own. Just a hollow singing machine.

>> No.51057389

>>51040354
Mori spends her own money to produce more originals and covers.
Irys waits for cover to pay for things

>> No.51058269

>>51057389
But that doesn't explain the huge difference in views.

>> No.51058330

>>51040354
no 'lets own da chuds' twitter buff

>> No.51058768

Why does Mori get so much stupidly good art

>> No.51058784
File: 81 KB, 269x374, 1681406478978138.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
51058784

>>51057049
Well, is not like keeping her on a lonely Island is a good idea in general

>> No.51059568

>>51058330
>no 'lets own da chuds' twitter buff
Nobody in holo writes music about topics like this /pol/chama....

>> No.51060007

>>51047395
Post >>51047592 isn't me and is just some shitposter. Overall I just don't think she's really remarkable.

>> No.51060012

>>51058768
Because the character is absolutely rad as fuck, regardless of anyones feelings about the actress.

>> No.51060207

>>51041030
Saplings being fucking retarded as always.

>> No.51060290
File: 123 KB, 463x453, 1644826970025.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
51060290

>>51040354
How the fuck RIP got so many views?
That shit has to be the worst song ever made. It's embarrassing to hear.
I know it's hard for people to take my comment serious here because of all the hate Mori, but try listing to that "song" with objective criticism, it's baffling how bad it is, most of the song is not even her singing but rather Mori spewing random sentences over a cringe looping beat that's somehow worse than AI music.

>> No.51060312

>>51040595
I'm better :)

>> No.51060526

>>51060290
Why is it so hard to just say "I personally don't like it."
Why do you have to act like a clown?

>> No.51060764

>>51060290
As a deadbeat who doesn't like the Deadbeats EP I had trouble wrapping my head around why the song has so much staying power, but here are some reasons I think that R.I.P. stayed on top despite Mori releasing better songs since.
1. It was her first song in a time where EN vtubers, and vtuber singers themselves were a novelty
2. Japanese people love it because they can't understand the lyrics, it straight up got club and radio play over there.
3. The remix contest from a few years back brought a ton of attention to R.I.P specifically, giving it a second serge in views.
4. It has the most views, so Youtube pushes it into more people's recommendations. Don't underestimate the amount of tech illiterate people who don't know how to turn off autoplay.

>> No.51060972

>>51060526
>Expressing thoughts beyond the most basic of possible expression is acting like a clown
Why are Americans like this?

>> No.51061055

>>51040882
For real. I dunno what seafag is writing her songs but their lyrics suck ass. Why hire a singer that speaks fluent english if you're going to give her songs written phonetically by japs?

>> No.51061156

>>51059568
newfag-chama...

>> No.51061209

>>51040354
Management has been sabotaging her for her entire career. Shit first model, poorly written songs, no musical direction and just a scattershot of different genres leading to her not having her own unique sound, MVs not coming out for months after the release of the songs (if they even bother to put them out at all), denying the majority of her requests for covers (she had to fight tooth and nail to get to do Internet Overdose, which ended up being her most successful song), and being just generally overbearing and giving her very little creative control over her brand. Every other girl gets to just release whatever they want, but Project Hope is so strictly managed that being debuted as a vsinger may actually be the thing that harms her music career the most.

>> No.51061228

>>51040354
Mori is ridding the myth buff. If she debuted now she wouldn't get shit.

>> No.51061296

>>51060764
It's really not that deep lol
It's both first her ever song and released at time when there was massive hype on top of being a fun character song
I swear it's impossible for anyone on this board to talk about Mori's music without writing verbose pseud essays or just stright up arguing in bad faith when the answer is usually just "It's fun and sounds nice"

>> No.51061299

>>51044030
Considering IRyS is a lazy 85 IQ JSL/ESL retard, I think she'd be licking boots to stay where she is. Women like her either get married early, or find something like this and ride it until they're a lonely hag.

>> No.51061323

>>51061209
>Shit first model
??? do you mean her rigging was bad or something? because that model is pure fucking sex
the wigger outfit on the other hand...

>> No.51061328
File: 816 KB, 498x498, 1650689865544.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
51061328

>>51058784
>lonely island
I THREW IT ON THE GROOOOOUUUUND

>> No.51061458

>>51061228
>ridding the myth buff. If she debuted now she wouldn't get shit.
This logic doesn't make sense considering she's largely in part of why there's a "Myth buff" to begin with and her current stuff still gets decent viewership

>> No.51061501

>>51061323
I agree, but there's no question that her original model filtered a lot of people and sabotaged her early on. Also, most people love the wigger outfit. People just have shit taste.

>> No.51061589

>>51061209
This. It's been 2 years and she still hasnt had one sololive - despite living in Japan. Even now, she's still having trouble with her model. At Holofes she looked like she was being strangled by her stupid hair.

>> No.51061670
File: 207 KB, 460x460, 17998679[1].png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
51061670

>>51061323
>>51061501
>wigger outfit
It's literally just a tracksuit??
Why do so many SEAnig ESLs love using this term without knowing what it actually even means?

>> No.51061887 [DELETED] 
File: 62 KB, 1024x491, calli-1024x491.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
51061887

>>51061670
are you really going to argue this isn't what a wannabe white nigger would wear?

>> No.51061936

>>51061296
It's still the most complete hard-hitting playful rap song she's ever done.
She's had better lyricism, better rhyme schemes, better shitposting(C-man and myth or treat) better flow, better singing, better beats(heck look at the remix contest) but not all within the same song since.

>> No.51062089
File: 33 KB, 404x1100, 51qcvAZna6L._AC_UY1100_[1].jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
51062089

>>51061887
>are you really going to argue this isn't what a wannabe white nigger would wear?
Yes? It's literally just a track suit?
Do you go to the gym or a running track and think "Whoa holy shit all these guys are wannabe niggers!!!"

>> No.51062131

>>51062089
when your gf starts wearing shit like this don't be surprised when the baby comes out brown

>> No.51062183

>>51062131
/pol/ has unironically melted your fucking brain lol

>> No.51062259

>>51062089
When I go to the gym the people there aren't wearing multiple gold chains. It's the accessories that elevate it to wiggerdom.

>> No.51062321

>>51041034
IRyS's old cover of Renai Circulation was so popular and so massive that its the first result that shows up when you search for Renai Circulation on youtube. It has like 80 million more views than the actual official version. She must be doing something right.

>> No.51062376

>>51062259
>Gold chain = wigger
What the fuck is wrong with your brain?

>> No.51062402

>>51062321
IRyS is a fucking phenomenal singer who joined a really shitty company that's sabotaging her career, like this guy said.
>>51061209

>> No.51062505

>>51062376
Stop being such a retard.

>> No.51062623

>>51062505
Are you talking to a mirror?
Cause you're quite retarded if you think wearing a gold necklace is enough to qualify someone as a """wigger""" lol

>> No.51062736

Is this the yabairys vtuber from the hololive clips?

>> No.51062902

IRyS is a weird case in that she's arguably not the best singer in EN despite being the EN vsinger. The issue IRyS has is she isn't naturally talented at singing. She suffers the same issue that Suisei has. They both had to work really hard to get good at singing. The problem is that singing is 99% genetics and raw natural talent. So you can only go so far no matter how hard you practice. Gura and Mumei both have natural singing talent. If Gura put as half as much effort into singing lessons as IRyS she'd mog her into oblivion due to natural talent. Same with Mumei.

>> No.51062957

>>51062089
Please understand anon, foreigners only see the worst of our culture, they've never seen some chick jogging in a tracksuit or a sleazy guy in a mid-2000s movie wearing one as semiformal wear

>> No.51063061

Being IRyS is suffering because despite being the designated vsinger for EN she gets massively outclassed by multiple other Holos.
>Moona
>Mumei
>Towa
>Risu
>Kanata
>Gura
Like she just doesn't compare. She sings like a traditional Idol which basically means shes generic at best.

>> No.51063210

>>51040354
People want to support their oshi not a corpo. It's that simple. It was clear as day her music was entirely Covers baby and she was only providing vocals. Who is going to play these songs on repeat and shill and hype every release if the chuuba has no actual stake and actively supporting it forces MORE work on them damaging their throat to the point of medical leave. They had one shot to make it work by coming out swinging with concerts but they fucked it up. Cover still has major control over cover songs too btw

>> No.51063413

>>51062902
This, Moom's My Dearest is one of the best Holo covers of 2023. What has IRyS done recently?

>> No.51063481

What is it with you fuckers and IRyS? Why do you fixate on her with this narrative? I don't think I'll ever understand it.

>> No.51063497

>>51060007
Fair enough. At a certain threshold, singing skill becomes one of the less important factors in capturing an audience. And once you get into that territory, things get really subjective. My autism just won't let me ignore people who call AZKi mediocre because they don't like her style. I think the way she expresses emotion is basically unrivalled

>> No.51063503

>>51062902
>singing is 99% genetics and raw natural talent
Theres zero shot anyone this retarded exists. I refuse to believe it.

>> No.51064447

>>51040354
While I'm a fan of IRyS as a streamer, I don't like her singing. It's average. Well to be fair, no one really sings well in holoEN. I hope EN3 has Miori or Chapipi https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dYsE6TKBtDg

>> No.51065055

>>51063061
>>Gura
you're fucking trolling

>> No.51068206

>>51062321
That's called a one hit wonder, she just got lucky

>> No.51069370

>>51040354
The accessibility to her songs is outright dogshit. You could search her channel for music and find less than 30% of all her songs. Unless you know what to search for you won't find it.

>> No.51070060

>>51040354
Honestly I checked out the VSinger thread out of curiosity a few weeks back and it just simply turns out that aside from superstars like Suisei, Hololive just doesn't have super proficient singers. Sure Sora for example can use some opera inspired techniques but there are some chuubas who are true professional opera singers. When you've come to terms with this it becomes clear that Hololive does not stand on the merits of pure talent, but on the characters they play. So when you look at IRyS, sure she may have a pleasant sounding voice, but she doesn't have the grinded-to-the-top inspirational backstory of Suisei or the gimmick of Mori and so on. IRyS is just another singer, and irregardless of her skill there are just far better singers outside of Holo so that's not the axis you should try to win your audience with.

>> No.51070494

>>51070060
You can take it further by saying Suisei got mogged by the pro band singer during her live

>> No.51072468

>>51062321
bet you also think gangnam style and baby had some god-tier singing

>> No.51073151

>>51040882
Her voice is also mid AF

>> No.51074385

>>51040354
I never buy her fucking songs and never will. also fuck her manager

>> No.51077483

>>51062321
She didn't put cover song in English in the title and used the actual animation from the anime in the video and uploaded it before there was ever even an official version on Youtube. How did the other cover songs on her channel do?

>> No.51077854
File: 552 KB, 1920x1080, baburys1.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
51077854

>>51073151
Nah I think her voice is more suitable for cute songs like Renai Circulation. It's just the management pushing her to sing these shitass songs.

>> No.51078158

>>51070060
That's the idol industry in a nutshell. Idols are sold on the basis of their personalities and presence, not their sheer talent in singing. That's why their image is so important, since that image is their entire brand.

>> No.51078232

>>51077854
Technically If you were to include "that" cover, she's most likely has the highest song-cover views in EN who was mistakenly thought it was an original song.

>> No.51078287

>>51078232
>>in EN
You mean in all hololive? lol

>> No.51078397

>>51040354
She was born to be a Disney Princess, but they don't have perms
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k1bRo5M7UDQ
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7GMHGFyf8Ws
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HC2BTjPN46c

>> No.51078436

>>51078232
>>51078287
holyshit these fkers knew the forbidden knowledge

>> No.51078483

>>51070060
Its weird you didn't mention Moona, Kanata, Risu, or Towa in your list. How interesting. You seem to be forgetting quite a few superstar talented singers in Hololive. Almost like you're just a bitter nijifag sad his talents get mogged by a retarded indonesia girl

>> No.51078701

>>51043009
Lol

>> No.51078740

>>51078483
Kanata is overrated as fuck. She has a really goofy sounding voices that completely carries over to her singing. Honestly the way she sings kind of reminds me of the way towa just normally talks. Sounds super fake. At least with towa it's just a voice that she can drop when she sings.

>> No.51078769

>>51078483
Anon they're just setting an example.... why are you mad that your oshis isn't included? grow up please.

>> No.51078801

>>51040354
>What went wrong?
Terminal shit taste, IRyS has one of the best voices in vtubing and I'll die on that hill

>> No.51078837

>>51078801
based

>> No.51078841

>>51044092
Why would she replace Sana?

>> No.51078858

>>51040595
I mean... I guess, yeah?

>> No.51078925

>>51078841
why not

>> No.51079110

>>51078397
holy shit they are so good

>> No.51079154

>>51078483
now say that again without crying, bitterfag

>> No.51079248

>>51061299
Among her family, isn't Irys like, really dumb? She's the one dumbass in a family of doctors and successful people. This is probably the best gig she has going for her.

>> No.51079548

>>51070060
>true pro opera singer
>vtuber
no such thing, you have very low standard of pro opera singer

>> No.51079579

>>51043194
Management clearly wanted her early music to cater towards a JP audience and didn't care about the EN audience at all. She released covers of Inochi, Palette, and SSS with only JP subs even though the originals all have EN subs. After her original MV Diorama was released with no EN subs someone in chat asked why the EN VSinger was ignoring her EN audience and she said that having English subtitles would somehow take away from a potential English version of the song that might get made in the future. It sounded like she was just trying to come up with some justification for a dumb management decision that she had no control over, but it remains one of the stupidest things she has ever said.

>> No.51080189
File: 139 KB, 849x219, mori idol.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
51080189

>>51040354
To put things into perspective, Mori's recent IDOL cover already has more views than some of Irys' covers.
Everyone seems to forget for some reason that she's still the number 2 EN vtuber in the world.

>> No.51080276 [DELETED] 

>>51040354
Imagine comparing hat man’s cow plow to IRyS.

>> No.51080424

>>51080189
People, be included that irys actually does songs and music. For example I know Mori has a new ep coming but idk wtf irys is doing next

>> No.51080508

>>51040354
Mori isn't a singer.

>> No.51080520

Uhh why are deadbeats keep trying to compare IRyS to Mori? We already know IRyS is a complete and utter failure compared to Mori

>> No.51080567

>>51040354
If their debuts were switched, IRyS would have been bigger than Gura and Calli would have rage-graduated after two weeks of being told her model is ugly. Calli's success is 100% because of Covid and her model being hot. Everything that is "her" is just awful.

>> No.51080580

>>51080424
pretty sure she's been recording a lot lately as she mentioned it onsteam.

Might also be the reason why she got sick again.

>> No.51080593

>>51077483
Yep she got lucky because she did a snake move like that before dmca was thrown around like it is these days. She wouldn't be able to replicate that a again

>> No.51080663

>>51080567
IRyS wouldn't have recorded a whole album before debut because she's lazy and honestly not that talented. You can't even compare the two.

>> No.51080712

>>51080580
Yeah sure but where's the promo or hype? Knowing she's recording doesn't mean much.

>> No.51080769

>>51080663
Irys has a beautiful singing voice. Mori raps which takes zero talent.

>> No.51080820

>>51080769
Can IRyS' voice network with producers and decide a musical direction for an album? Apparently not.

>> No.51080846 [SPOILER] 

>>51078232
Yeah, I really thought that was original since it has a hundred mil views.

>> No.51080861

>>51080424
It doesn't help that management genuinely hates IRyS with every fiber of their being. They forced her into getting vocal nodules for goodness sake! To put that in perspective, imagine a track star tearing both of his ACLs because their coach forced them to run in 19 inch heels while carrying a school bus down a jagged mountain side. Then being surprised and angry that they got hurt. I will NEVER NOT BE MAD ABOUT THAT AHHHHH!!! IRyS is too sweet of a girl to have gotten literally fucked over for life [continues screaming]

>> No.51081048

>>51080769
Raw singing means nothing without style or soul. You just blend into the thousands of other singers that can sing. It's why establishing a style is important early on

>> No.51081147

>>51080712
She's most likely don't give that much information about those kind of stuffs these days until a week or two before it officially released. Just look at how early she hyped Akatsuki to Hana mv, until now there's no mv for it.

>> No.51081151

>>51080861
Maybe she should lay off those 8 hour superchat readings and streaming for long hours. No other EN has the same problem to the extent she does

>> No.51081183

Mori likes creating original music, Irys likes singing. nothing wrong with that, but it means shes beholden to whatever management puts in front of her and they're all bad at their jobs

>> No.51081563

>>51043597
Yes, they both went to Japan as grown women. They've experienced their formative years under American influence.

>> No.51082604

>>51078740
Nah if anything Kanata gets consistently underrated on this board. She’s a great singer, but people act like she’s deaf, regressed, and middle of the pack.

>> No.51082693

when is irys doing an internet yamero cover

>> No.51085152

>>51082693
Soon

>> No.51085394

>>51082604
and yet she has no solo concert or even an EP

>> No.51087597
File: 109 KB, 850x1374, __mori_calliope_and_mori_calliope_hololive_and_1_more_drawn_by_zeragoes__sample-47a27cd17d09fd0878f96160c3a93e14.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
51087597

>>51040354
Irys is the better singer {Kareoke), but Mori puts 10x the effort into her songs.

Also Mori is super sexy, and Irys is brown.

>> No.51088087

>>51044311
Are these discord leaks in the room with us now?

>> No.51090880

>>51040354
>What went wrong?
you

>> No.51094108

>>51040595
fpbp

>> No.51095401

>>51087597
Mori sex buff

>> No.51095577

>>51060526
Most of that song is:
"HEY, NIG, DEATH, IS, SO, KAWAII. I, AM, MORI, CALLI, OPEE, *insert generic beat*"x3
It's cringe as fuck

>> No.51096165

>>51095577
and yet she's had a solo concert and multiple EPs/albums. meanwhile the other one is "recording" with no upcoming songs in the horizon.
you hate it, i don't care about it but it definitely hit a niche.

>> No.51098204

>>51040595
kek

>> No.51101905

>>51041030
meh

>> No.51102496

>>51085394
and?

>>
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action