/vt/ - Virtual Youtubers

>>47268627
Most JPs can't sing either and their concerts are very successful.

>>47268866
jps can sing on the level of "good for karaoke hangouts". All EN (except mori and gura) can't sign without even casual listeners cringing and bleeding ears

>EN seethe thread
>ESL
every time

>>>>>None of them can’t sing for shit

>>47268627
>Ame
Worst singer, absolute shit
>Mori
Wigger cadence
>Fauna
Second worse, can't keep a note or rhythm
>IRyS
good range but soulless robotic singing
>Bae
Sounds like she is wheezing while singing
>Gura
probably the best singer here, but relies too heavily on changing song keys to fit her voice (she sucks at singing with others)
>Kronii
dumb boring tone and doesn't use her diaphragm
>Mumei
too much falsetto to hide her real singing ability, only good for certain types of songs
>Kiara
chicken voice completely ruins her, sounds like an out of tune vocaloid
>Ina
Ugly nasally sing voice that cracks and can't keep a long note

sour grapes

>>47269146
Post it

Imagine paying money to watch fucking Fauna try to sing lmao

>>47268627
You know what will actually be cringe and will destroy your eardrums? NijiEN Concert(If it actually happens) lol

>>47268627
>None of them can't sing for shit
Does it mean that they all sing very well ?

>>47269700
lol Holofags may or may not know but Petra, Pomu, Millie, Enna, Reimu, Shu, and Uki all fucking wipe the floor with the combined Holotrash.

Here come the pedos who try to claim Gura can sing Lmao. Gura doesn't sing she just flatly reads the lyrics in her voice. 0 effort like everything else she does

>>47270461
Now that’s untrue in a completely different way than he intended.

rainbowcovid EN concert doko?

>>47268627
Mori, Gura, IRyS, Mumei, Bae are the good singers of EN. That's half to enjoy for the singing and the other half will be tolerable or carried by cuteness

>>47274067
>IRyS
>Mumei

>>47270887
Ok nijinigger, go back to your Enna cuck threads

>>47269129
Huh. This is actually pretty accurate. Nicely put.

>>47274231
Not the anon, but I will second that Irys is a indeed a good singer, her original songs don't do her voice justice.

>>47274067
>Bae
>Mori
If you enjoy their singing more power to you but good singers is factually wrong. On a personal note I actually want bae and gura to sing sweet appetite again it was so much better live

>>47268627
Mori can sing okay (too bad she'll do shitty rap instead).
Irys is good/decent.
Bae can do just a dance performance and it'll be great.
Overall I don't really care about the whole thing, might just Mumei because she cute.

>>47269700
i hate nijien but even i have to admit good portion of elira's clique sings much better than holoen
this one is watching restreams only for me

>>47269129
Fauna and ame will go for a cute song and it will be nice.
Kroni and mumei will go for a slow song and it will sound nice.
Bae kiara and gura will go for hype songs and will dance really cool.
Irys and mori will go for powerful songs and irys will do great while mori will be overrated
8/10 show it will be nice

>>47269016
>Mori

>>47268627
>None of them can't sing for shit
So they're all very good singers! Wow good job to them!

>>47275577
ESL schizos, please andastandt.

>>47269129
Everything you said is correct except gura has karaoke’s that are amazing that are the base key of the song some high and low. Ina can hold a long note but it’s like one single high C or D I believe. It’s limited but not impossible.

If you want decent combinations
Mori
>Irys, Gura (holds back too much but ok)
>Mumei, Bae but it would have to be a 3 man
Mori voice works by herself or when you can enjoy it complementary to someone with a much better sounding voice Suisei or Irys. Too much better sounding singers make her seem off putting like in sora’s moaning song

Kronii
>Ina, Kiara, Bae
>Mori but this is a maybe
Kronii only sounds good in one range and those 3 can capitalize on it. Mori could be hit or miss with her

Fauna/Ame
>Bae, Kiara, Mumei, Ina
>Gura, Irys are maybe
They can overwhelm them but still harmonize enough to let you hear them. Bae could fail depending on the song since she has near 0 fine control. Gura and Irys both best and worst case scenario they might hold back to much making it completely awful.

Best Performance Irys/Gura duet
>Bae, Mori, Kiara, Ina
If they don’t hold back like they do with others best performance easily. But Gura tries not to upstage her partners and Irys tries not to be a diva so anyone of those 4 could be a nice bridge if they aren’t doing their best. If it’s 4 then baemori, kiarabae, or inakiara won’t have to lower their level too much.

Any other mix and match will at worse be fine

>>47269016
>Mori

Her voice can sing properly but she insists on using her voice in the most inadequate way possible with her VERY raspy voice, while being either off key or using the world's worse falsettos.

She is the Ronnie Radke of Hololive.

>>47268627
>idols
>half of them can't sing or dance for shit
What a joke

>>47274887
You know it’s all of nijien correct? 80% of the guys are awful. Half the girls are fine at best.
>Elira, Pomu, Finana, Petra, Enna, are the only good ones
*I don’t remember Rosemi, and Meloco level

Still they have more numbers overall so they have more worst and good singers. But direct comparisons are
>Nina/Selen to Fauna/Ame (worst)
>Elira/Enna to Gura/Irys (best)
>Pomu/Finana/Petra to Kiara/Bae/Ina

I say holo takes it 4 to 3

>>47268627
The main problem is that they don't really have any good songs. No one is going to be excited to listen to "Rise" or "Daydream" performed live

>>47268627
>Ame
https://youtu.be/b0JeNRSJa8k
>Mori
https://youtu.be/XmoOgPsSPTI
https://youtu.be/8bc1GW-zsPY
https://youtu.be/-RiC4cqDkb8
>Fauna
https://youtu.be/0RMVJTLZOzQ
>Irys
https://youtu.be/A-n6_diZHTk
https://youtu.be/-t8Za0T1T8M
https://youtu.be/uzEEffCJOjs
>Bae
https://youtu.be/mt2gm30ZKtk
https://youtu.be/na6bysYNuS0
https://youtu.be/Jh2E_bVSDEE
>Gura
https://youtu.be/4jOmvTsWqGs
>Kronii
https://youtu.be/cR-FSQVfv7I
https://youtu.be/7HiAIzjTnxE
https://youtu.be/iEr1aBephZ8
>Mumei
https://youtu.be/RRq4-uktHiI
>Kiara
https://youtu.be/Lq9eqHDKJPE
https://youtu.be/Fwc-LH8IGj8
https://youtu.be/QI96hnhcr2E
>Ina
https://youtu.be/8ZdLXELdF9Q
https://youtu.be/injd7gHrIGU

>>47276352
True, Mori, Kiara, and Irys are the only ones with good original songs... I guess Gura does if you count her and Mori's cover of King which un-ESL'd the lyrics.

>>47269129
Wrong

>music project, but no ENsharts ruining it like they did Holo*27
>which also means they won't be invited to the inevitable concert they will do for the album
HYPE!

>>47268627
????? It'll be kino tough

>>47276730
Reflect, Play Dice, Astro girl are little better than most of their songs. Sweet appetite, and Q seem really good with a live band based on the performances.

Regardless, if it’s like any other cover live and they want to use other songs they get a budget to pay for said song

>>47277394
Oh, I wasn't counting Astro Girl because Sana won't be at the concert.

Ah shit why the seethe? Did the Niji concert got cancelled again?

>>47268627
The only one that cant sing is Fauna
Learn english

>>47268627
I'm expecting an incredibly embarrassing technical issue that could've been easily avoided but somehow it will ruin the mood of the entire show.
Like they'll play pre-recorded audio over a live segment by accident or something

>>47269016
>mori
Deadcuck detected, deploying counter measures

>>47268627
ESL-chama.....

>>47269016
>mori
>gura
both are karaoke levels. mori can actually rap though

>>47274475
Because she only has "one voice". It's the cutesy idol voice. Her songs doesn't fit her because she can't sing outside of her cutesy singing voice.

>>47268627
How many eops do you think will an hero once it becomes blindingly clear that EN3 will not be announced at this event?

>>47268627
Is this a nijifag knowing nothing about HoloEN?

>>47285342
funny you mention, reimu alone shits on all of them. doesn't even have to bring enna in.

>>47268627
Is English really this fucking hard? Literally one of the easiest languages to learn in the world, grammatically speaking, and you people still can't write one sentence right.

>>47285693
>Reimu
Roru

>>47285693
Proof?
I like Reimu, I want to hear a Reimu song
there's still like 3-4 HoloENs that sing about as well as her though.

Daily reminder it doesn’t matter how hard Enna mogs anybody at singing when I can’t stand the sight of her

>>47285886
double negation actually differs between different dialects, sometimes it's just used for emphasis.

>>47289025
Facts don't care about your feelings

>>47276352
The SPWN chat from Day 2 disagrees with you on Daydream; the JP Bros ate that one up surprisingly even if one of the most common comments was "very plays during the end credits of an RPG" -esque.

I didn't read any of this thread, I love my wife and her singing, you should jump off a cliff.

>>47285693
Petra, Millie, Pomu, Uki, and Shu mog the fuck out of HoloEN too. It's not just Reimu and Enna.

someone make a /vt/ sings so you fags can embarass yourselves vis-a-vis the comments ITT kek

https://youtu.be/92q7ufO5l_0

>>47276707
>that mori part of your world
The fuck? Why doesn't she sing like that all the time?

>>47270887
>Who?
I’ve never watched them nor do I intend to.
Because you know what? I don’t watch trash.
The place for trash is in the gutter, not my mind.
You know what else I’d like to complain about, the city I live in.
They’re suing me for putting my trash in the gutter.
They say I should put it in the trash can, but you know what belongs in a trash can, Nijiniggers. Because you know what, it stinks.
And you know what else? Get out of my house!
Get out!

https://streamable.com/wx6tqo

>>47285693
Enna kneeled before, and respected both Mori and IRyS, sis

>>47270887
Maybe they should wipe the floor more instead being a bitch, those virtual covid not gonna get rid of itself you know.

>>47270939
>t. Seething Nijicuck

>>47297172
OH NO NO NO nijisis, you should kneel and lick your oshi oshi feet.

>>47268627
Of course Gura is in the middle, of course the rest are only relegated to NPCs. As it should.

>>47285693
>Reimu
Thanks for proving the point I guess

>>47285693
>barely any karaoke streams, no concert and no original songs
How do you know? Even if our singers are worse, at least we get to actually hear them more than once or twice a year kek

>>47269129
>Wigger cadence
if she ever has her own record label, it'll be called this
or is she redebuts as a chuuba somewhere else

>>47268627
Would be fine.

>>47277052
>>music project, but no ENsharts ruining it like they did Holo*27
>pic rel
>Sweet apetitie mogging the Pekomiko song
Anon...

>>47304755
Neither sweet appetite or the pekomiko song are in the image anon.

>>47268627
ESL thread.

>>47306158
Those are two separate statement, anon. EN is mogging JP on the original album AND on the cover album.

>>47268627
It's less that they can sing for shit and more that EN lacks stage presence. While this is an issue for some JP, ID and quite a few JP have it in spades and is why people tend to have a higher opinion of ID and JP's performances in FES than EN's.

>>47307285
Yeah, Mori is literally the only EN that knows how to work a crowd.

>>47307327

>>47269129
Ina voice cracks? Wdym?

>>47278857
>>>/#/
Go back sister

>>47278857
Hee-ho

>>47307327
Crowd seemed pretty excited during Bae and after that, IRyS's segment in Holofes, too, anon

>>47312567
I was thinking more about how she was the only musical guest at the Apex Dream Match concert to get cheers from the crowd during her performance when I was making that comment.

Mumei will carry the entire thing

>>47296431
She sings like that more these days than she used to, but she's still pretty autistic about only going all-out on songs she's practiced a lot.

>>47268627
Bae will save the concert

>>47268627
if it's prerecorded it'll be fine

>>47296431
This song from the same karaoke was also pretty good. https://youtu.be/XhRytAaZUnc
I think she gets a buff if it's a song she liked singing along to ten years ago kek.

>>47268627
yes

The amount cuckbeat cope in this thread is embarrassing. Just accept that no one likes your pig. You can’t force them to agree with your shitty taste either.

My ranking of TOP EN Singers:

Irys=Bae=Mori=Kiara=Mumei=Gura>
Kronii=Ina>
Fauna=Ame

Each has their own scuffed issues that it comes down to subjective voice quality.
Irys is technically the most skilled but has an arguably generic sound while the others colour/personality make up for it to equal her.

JP and ID top dogs mogs them though.

>>47324947
Reasonable list desu

>>47324947
I generally agree with this list, but I'd put Mumei a tier lower.

>>47324947
Holy shit, someone on this board who actually understands they each have their strengths for the most part.

>>47268627
retard

>>47269700
rent free

>>47268627
Will EN3 debut early enough to do a watchalong?

>>47276039
I hate how my oshi tends to do this too :(
at least she's saving her sweet soft voice for our ears only

They should just sing covers and forget about their original songs. Especially the English ones. Just plain horrible.

>>47268627
I know right? How can they expect to compete with the likes of Noel?

>>47268627
oh my, look at that bae tummy

>>47269129
methinks you don't really have any shade to throw against Gura
or
you're confused so lemme help you. how does "unique voice but gives range debuff" sound?

>>47308901
not sure about her singing in practice, but that anon meant that she's too scared to sing, doesn't practice enough, and makes her voice thin and quiet to compensate, causing her vocal chords to crack easily

>In the perfect funnel world

Fauna->Gura->Moom->Irys

>>47284507
It's not a cutesy idol voice, it's a stacy kpop girlband voice. how the fuck is her voice cute compared to so many cutesy JPs and other ENs like Gura and Mumei?

>>47276039
Yeah, that's fair.

>>47278857
t. least terminally online anti

>>47307285
I don't know man, Bae had a pretty big stage presence to the point where Marine's performance afterwards seemed lackluster
The crowd wasn't super excited when Bae first appeared but they increasingly got more hyped throughout her performance and were roaring near the end

>>47269016
Gura and Mori are also only on the "Good for karaoke hangouts" level. I actually can't believe people STILL think that Gura is some god tier singer.

>>47345378
People unironically putting gura over irys or mumei

>>47324947
Kiara isn't as good as the holos who can actually sing

>>47268627
It's crazy how sex Bae, Moom, Fauna and IRyS are. EN3 had better have better designs if they want to beat those tits.

>>47268627
Just admit that you're angry you didn't get tickets.

>>47324947
Kiara below Ame
Fauna SLIGHTLY above Ame.
Then, I agree with this list desu

>>47268627
Why don't you have fun for fucking once?

>>47269129
>>Ina
>Ugly nasally sing voice that cracks and can't keep a long note
confirmed for never having watched a single karaoke or performance beyond debut. Ina has improved dramatically and can not only hit high notes, but sustain them well.

103 chad here
Enjoy your shit angles others sections

>>47269016
>He didn't watch 4th fes

>>47270887
Who?

>>47276277
>Neither can most of JP

>>47357949
coping takek

>>47324947
i think i give the nod to irys to slide higher, maybe gura too (on songs that suite her).

Kiara and Mumei on their own tier above kronii/ina.

i'd place irys/gura with Reine, Shion, Ayame and La+ (and some others, 2nd tier is quite crowded for Holo i think)

>>47269129
The 2 I could listen to ramble for hours happen to be the 2 worst singers. Funny how that works out. Then again I like listening to irys talk too so there's no real correlation.

>>47346788
>Mumei
i'd almost agree if she doesn't nerf herself all the time or go for songs outside her range.

I think Irys is the best in EN.

The fact this is still going on and people haven’t discovered it’s a disguised anti thread. Half these post can’t even describe the girls voices correctly and others are parroting out of context statements that only work for that particular karaoke

>>47373035
all catalog threads are anti threads

>>47269129
Based.

>>47268627
>how cringe would it be?
depends if they take it seriously

>>47269016
irys...

>>47269129
Swap Ame and Fauna and you're probably right. I think it's pretty obvious Fauna is the worst singer in the branch. In fact, Fauna was probably even worse than Sana when she was around.

>>47268627
Don't worry it's prerecorded and edited to sound better and have hired dancers behind the avatars.

>>47370257
Recommend me some Reine singing? Also don't sleep on Anya.

>>47269016
From what i have seen i would say in terms of staying in key and actually singing good in a live setting, i predict Gura and IRyS and maybe Bae will do the best out of everyone, Calli, Kiara and Ina will be okayish, Mumei and Kronii will be so-so in the middle and Ame and Fauna will not be that great.
Fauna is my oshii but lets be real, her singing is not very good

>>47268627
Normie detect
Cringe
Ching billing fungus concert 2024