/vt/ - Virtual Youtubers

>>16623645
It's not as good

More like Thousand Year cock stare

>>16623645
I haven't even listened to it. Don't really care to.

It's a heartful and happy idol song, but it doesn't have the repeatability of Myth of Treat.

Will the poor turnout of views finally stop anymore music being made by Calli? She has to stop. She can't keep getting away with this.

>>16623645
Not as raw and from the heart, to generic.
While myth or treat is a banger regardless and made after an alcoholic binge and still has more heart

>>16623645
It's good but not very memeable, and the latter is all Reddit cares about.

>>16623645
generic EDM beat blown out like shit with generic sappy lyrics and you can barely hear the girls sing
the instrumental for that halloween song is x1000000 better and the vocals are mixed x10000 better

Myth or treat is on Amelia's million sub channel, this song is on a dead channel.

>>16624084
Songs are memes bruh

>>16624224
Good point too

Tune not as catchy, MV not remotely as interesting to rewatch for details

>>16623645
Myth or Treat at least had the benefit of being Halloween-themed and released around the season plus getting Kanaru to do the MV was as a smart move.

>>16623645
Because Ina is singing

>>16623645
Why is the beat so loud? Fans want to hear their oshi sing.

They gotta stop Calli from doing anything that isn’t rap

>>16632780
You misspelled Ame.

>>16623645
I just don't care anymore, and apparently I'm not the only one. The bad seeds really ruined the brand.

It's because it's shit, like half the orisongs holoen makes

>>16633991
Ame = Sovl
Ina = no sovl

>>16623645
its missing a sick beat

It’s not as good. Not everything can be bangers.

>>16634478
Sovl doesn't mean shit when she needs to be autotuned to hell so she doesn't completely ruin the song.

>>16623645
It's too bland. Music producers always talk about how hit songs need hooks and I find it appropriate here.

>>16636129
All of them were autotuned. There's no saving Ina.

>>16623645
It was incredibly forgettable. Generic instrumental, generic lyrics, generic MV. Myth or Treat at least sounded different to 1000 other vtuber songs, and had an entertaining music video to rewatch.

>>16623645
Because you are a faggot.

>>16636265
Ina doesn't need saving only ame does. That's why she has to be autotuned the most out of all of myth.

aggressively mediocre

Cause its not as good or creative?

Halloween is more widely celebrated in Western countries as opposed to Eastern and not to mention they had specific riggers and artists to Myth or Treat

can't think of any EN content being good in a serious way. most 'good' content here is usually in humorous fashion.

>>16623645
Gura looks like she's on the spectrum here.

Myth or Treat was on Ame's channel and premiered on the day of Halloween itself. Journey like a Thousand years is on a channel I'd be willing to wager most of the EN audience is even aware of while for a costume reveal that's after the holidays (in the western world that is). I believe 90 percent of the reason of the differing levels of success due to these points.

>>16636997
>looks

>>16623645
>Why's that?
Because it's very poorly mixed and smothered in autotune.

>>16636997
You're on 4chan right now dude. Chances are pretty high you're on the spectrum.

Myth or Treat is catchier, has a full actual 3d animated MV with over 50 different little easter eggs to go rewatch to try and find, and was premiered at a much higher hyped time right on Halloween.
Journey was over a week after the holidays, was more generic, and was basically just still slides with some lyrics superimposed.

>>16623645
it is meh

Myth or Treat slaps and I can hear it in my head. I can't even remember what this song sounds like

>>16623645
Because everyone knows they won't last a thousand years

Myth or Treat was fucking godly. Kino MV, earworm music, no autotune garbage, perfect mixing, SOUL.

This one has ear worm music and SOUL, but it's ruined by Mori's shitty power point presentation MV and the autotune cancer on their voices, also bad mixing.

>>16636997
I think Ina is cute and a really good artist but she can only draw eyes in one style and she genuinely fucked Gura's eyes up lol

>>16623645
BECAUSE ITS ON THE HOLOLIVE ENGLISH CHANNEL YOU FUCKING RETARD

All these retards blaming the song instead of the dead channel its on. How fucking retarded are you guys? If it was on Mori or Gura's channel it would have 5 million views by now. Are there this many EN anti retards? Stop making yourself so easy to spot

>>16638416
>Are there this many EN anti retards?
King of rhetorical questions.

Song popularity aside, I can't wait for them to sing it when they do their 3D live in Japan

>>16638548
>4 out of 5 can't dance
>3 out of 5 can't sing
it's gonna be a disaster

>>16623645
Because myth or treat is great and has a fun video, very rewatchable

>>16643086
It'll be a disaster no doubt, but entertaining all the same.

>>16623645
It feels very corporate.

>>16643086
>>16645828
This just makes me more excited if anything. Kiara center-stage doing all the choreography perfectly, four other girls doing various levels of SOUL behind her, learning why it is that all the other girls in the company do so much choreography practice

>>16623645
Japanese is a debuff.

>>16623645
Mori took herself seriously when writing the lyrics
turns out funny Halloween jokes>>sappy motivational chuunishit

I think Myth Or Treat captures their personalities very well. Ame is cutely mischievous, Mori is ineffectually edgy, Ina is subdued but still witty, Gura teases in that bratty way, Kiara is domineering, but feminine.
But Journey just isn't as good at that. It relies more on lore and maybe an allusion or two to something they've been through. It doesn't quite capture their actual personalities. Journey seems to be somewhat rushed, trying to force Myth into a sort of sappy narrative that doesn't quite line up with the reality of the situation.

>>16643086
theyre not really singing in myth or treat just saying lines

>>16624224
This is honestly the biggest factor. Not just the fact, that Ame has more subs, but also youtube pushes channels with frequent uploads in the algorithm. A big reason why serious youtubers try to upload a video almost every day.

>>16647171
>>16624224
>dead channel
Then explain how EN's Ochame Kinou is already in 3 mil views? And if you wanna bring up how its got all ENs, the christmas song is not doing as well in comparison.

>>16623645
>Ame is better manager than EN management
>Ame knows better her coworkers than EN management
I wonder why they perform better under Ame's leadership

>>16648854
>Ochame Kinou
The algorithm loves the name. I've seen that one pushed over and over again.

>>16623645
>Why's that?
not made by amelia watson

>>16623645
it's bad

>>16623645
>crappy wordy lyrics
>Mori's MV is fucking PowerPoint level
>Ina had an especially severe case of sameface and seemingly gave Gura some genetic disease
>Ame still deaf and had to be given lots of autotune even with next to no solo lines
>Kiara still using chicken voice

>>16623645
remove chicken then i will listen

>>16623645
Because myth or treat is a fucking banger. Mori fucking killed it writing it.

>>16646670
Myth or treat was done by Amelia's team.
It explains the success of the video. At this point, Amelia's team should be in charge of every managament idea behind Holo EN. Can you imagine how good the council shit lore would have been if they were on charge of it?

>>16645975
>Kiara dances perfectly
>Mori throws out her back
>Ina collapses from exhaustion
>Ame's tummy hort
>Gura got hogtied by her own clothing

>>16623645
Myth or Treat was not a Cover produced song that’s why.

>>16649092
Myth or treat was Gura and Mori’s child. Ame just commissioned the music video

>>16645975
>Kiara dances perfectly
>Mori grinds her hips against an invisible pole
>Ame dances like a drunk girl at a nightclub
>Ina awkwardly shuffles her feet
>Gura fortnite dances

>>16656191
Keep believing that

>>16623645
myth or treat was a fucking banger, that’s why

>>16623645
>Meme song lots of views
>"serious" song not as many views
I'll give you a hint, memes are very popular

Myth Or Treat is obviously better, but how does this fan song compare to Journey like a Thousand Years?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tazwGCPea9c

>>16623645
Probably because only one of them can actually sing?

>>16655639
>>16656422
Kiara dances perfectly until her body pain and asthma hits

NO SOVL

>>16623645
The chuuni lore weighs down what would otherwise be an emotional and genuine song. Whether this song is better than M&T or not, makes me wish for these girls to meet and ditch Hololive

>>16655579
they should just ditch Hololive and Cover as a whole and do their own thing as an indie group, removes shitty lore from the equation

>>16624224
Why does it matters which channel is on?

>>16656422
I feel like Ame would be the awkward type to be dancing

>>16656717
>a

Fuck this shit

>>16657168
Only 2 or 3 of them can manage to stay relevant outside of Hololive.

>>16623645
Myth or Treat was basically "hey let's make a song outselves" and doing everything at the last moment, just very barely making it on time.

The new song seems to be more along the lines of "corporate has decided you girls need a new song"