Super Mario Tier

[Anonymous No.8117062]

Create a list of retro games in the Super Mario series ranked from best to worst. (the original FDS Super Mario Bros. 2 was added by me.)

https://tiermaker.com/create/super-mario-games-48662

[Anonymous No.8117067]

[Anonymous No.8117095]

>>8117067
OK, Dunkey.

[Anonymous No.8117287]

didnt think this through too much

[Anonymous No.8117939]

>highest tier is red
>lowest tier is green
what color-symbology-ignorant autist made this chart?

>>8117067
>>8117287
kek & cringe, respectively

[Anonymous No.8117963]

>>8117939
Red for Mario. Green for Luigi.

[Anonymous No.8117974]

>>8117287
>Superstar Saga above Super Mario 64 and...everything
>Luigi's Mansion above World
>Super Mario Galaxy at B. Super Mario Galaxy 2 at E.
Must be trolling.

[Anonymous No.8117992]

>>8117067
Time to kys

[Anonymous No.8118005]

[Anonymous No.8118019]

>>8117287
Gross, kys zoomie

[Anonymous No.8118038]

[Anonymous No.8118071]

>>8117062
Everything at S

[Anonymous No.8118078]

>>8118071
turbo plumber engaged

[Anonymous No.8118227]

>>8117939
>what color-symbology-ignorant autist made this chart?
a pomologist

[Anonymous No.8118240]

>>8117062
Gotta disagree on world, albiet it was early SNES,it just didn't hold the charm of the other mario games.


>>8117067
you seem like a white girl in a diaper


>>8117287
I agree with some of this, but yeah I heard colorsplash and paper jam were souless.


>>8118005
shit tastes,


>>8118038
why does everyone like world so much. I played it back then, but it was kinda sucky in comparsion to yoshi's islandand Mario rpg

[Anonymous No.8118274]

>>8118038
I honestly don't get why people rate world so high? Sure it was the firest 16 bit title, but yoshi's island was leagues better in retrospect from a gameplay and artistic standpoint.
>>8118005
>>8117067
shit tastes white girl in diaper

>>8117287
paper mario was pretty great


My rating is based upon this
>artistic direction
>gameplay
>music

The early rpgs had the most interesting character designs, and setting, galaxy was a close second, the setting and gameplay were out of this world, there was nothing like it before.

[Anonymous No.8118303]

>>8117939
yep not gonna use it because of this retarded bullshit
FUCK YOU OP

[Anonymous No.8118725]

>>8118005
I'm following you with Super Mario Bros. at the top, then Super Mario Galaxy, then Super Mario 64 and Super Mario World.

Then you go and put New Super Mario Bros. (DS) above Super Mario Bros. 3, Yoshi's Island, Super Mario Sunshine and even Super Mario All-Stars. You may dislike the aesthetic changes in Super Mario All-Stars, but how is it worse than New Super Mario Bros. to be at the lowest tier?

Also, I'll never understand the bone people have to pick with Super Mario Sunshine. If you love Super Mario Galaxy and Super Mario 64, how is Super Mario Sunshine D? I understand not preferring it, but what makes it so irritating? People only come up with the most deflective criticisms. ("I don't like the FLUDD. I don't like the camera.") I have yet to read a constructive critiicsm from anyone who finds Super Mario Sunshine to be vastly inferior to Super Mario 64 and Super Mario Galaxy. I can get behind people who dislike it as much as Super Mario Galaxy since at least they just think it was all downhill after Super Mario 64 which I think is more consistent and also an opinion I can sympathize with. I think Super Mario Sunshine is much better than Super Mario Galaxy and if I was including non-retro games in my tier I'd have put it at B, a full tier below.

If Super Mario RPG is below Paper Mario which is only at C, I'll assume RPGs aren't your thing.

[Anonymous No.8118746]

>>8118274
You're a stereotypical Paper Mario fan that was bitter about the direction the series took after Paper Mario: the Thousand Year Door, though understandably so. I call you a Paper Mario fanboy because you also clearly vastly prefer it and Super Mario RPG to the mainline series. Super Mario RPG and the first two Paper Mario games are at S, Super Mario Bros. 3 and Super Mario 64 are merely at B, Super Mario World is as low as C, and Super Mario Bros. 2 is even D. (on this note it's funny that you hate the two most recent Paper Marios so much they're below even that. And you clearly think Mario & Luigi took a turn for the worse also.)

Why is Mario & Luigi Dream Team Bros so much worse than Mario & Luigi: Partners in Time? lol

[Anonymous No.8118750]

Let the hate flow through you

[Anonymous No.8118779]

>>8117062
Your list is totally fucked. Mario 3 is the only game in the right order.

[Anonymous No.8118785]

>>8117062
Terrible opinion
>>8117067
Faggot
>>8117287
Kill yourself
>>8118005
Somewhat based
>>8118038
Reasonably based
>>8118274
Based
>>8118750
Nostalgiafaggotry like many others

[Anonymous No.8118804]

>>8118750
LMAO

[Anonymous No.8118819]

>>8118274
>shit tastes white girl in diaper
?

[Anonymous No.8118824]

>>8118750
This is almost a reasonable list, but then...

I couldn't fathom putting the first Super Mario Bros. at D and Super Mario Land at B. What do you have against Super Mario Bros, the original that started it all. (It also really makes me wish the tier included Super Mario Bros. 2 FDS/Lost Levels to see you put that at a wildly different tier from the original.)

[Anonymous No.8118832]

>>8118746
>Super Mario RPG to the mainline series.
I enjoyed the story and world, also the art direction was far superior it gave me somewhat of a challenge when I was younger because at that point platformers had become much too easy for me.

>Galaxy
Something like this wasn't even fathomable before it was released.
>Super Mario Bros. 3
It was great for what it was and had intersting power-ups and levels, but it didn't stand the test of time.

>Super Mario 64
Innovative, but it was really just a tech-demo for what was to come. It aged poorly compared to the top row.

>, Super Mario World
again art direction and music. Those sprites aged like shit. Also it was piss easy even when I was younger, cleared the mondo levels with ease.

> Super Mario Bros. 2 is even D
piss easy, could clear it when I was 9, alot of repedative shit in gameplay, it's not even a mario game, it's doki-doki panic. Also many of the enemies like fry-guy and mouser are shit tier designs

>Why is Mario & Luigi Dream Team Bros so much worse than Mario & Luigi: Partners in Time? lol

Art direction went down the fucking toliet, Massanori Sato was ejected from art direction from the project and started making characters that looked like fucking reject muppets, and it was in a really dull setting.

[Anonymous No.8118838]

>>8118785
>"Nostalgiafaggotry like many others"
>Mario & Luigi Superstar Saga at A, Super Mario World at C, Super Mario Bros. at D.
There's almost no doubt you're not being serious here but otherwise, look in a mirror.

[Anonymous No.8118846]

Playing Paper 64 and Odyssey right now. Haven't played the others.

[Anonymous No.8118858]

>>8118838
Superstar Saga is a 10/10 RPG with very kino graphics. Super Mario World is a good game, but doesn't really do anything unique. It was actually possibly the first video game I ever played. Super Mario Bros isn't very fun to play. I am serious.
>look in a mirror.
What is this, an elementary school playground?

[Anonymous No.8118859]

>>8118779
>List for subjective preference in games
>Your list is fucked. The games aren't in the order I'd have put them in, therefore it's objectively wrong

[Anonymous No.8118861]

>>8118838
Nah that ranking is 100% nostalgia dude. You're assuming he meant nostalgia for 80s

[Anonymous No.8118867]

>>8118859
cuck mentality

[Anonymous No.8118919]

Replace 64 with RPG and that list would be correct.

[Anonymous No.8118942]

>>8117062
SMB2(J) FDS would go into S tier if it were an option. If I were to judge Mario Maker as a Mario game then it would go into E tier

[Anonymous No.8118984]

>>8118942
Here's mine

[Anonymous No.8119298]

>>8117062
Drop Yoshi's Island to A tier, drop Sunshine to C Tier, and bump OG Mario and Six Golden Coins up by one tier, and it's perfect.

[Anonymous No.8119306]

I am gay I like to stick my dick in men's assholes

[Anonymous No.8119325]

>>8117062

[Anonymous No.8120551]

>>8118861
No, the point is nostalgia can be for any generation to the exception of another one.

Above everything else, just look and see that their lists aren't even that different. One has Superstar Saga at A, the other at S with Super Mario 64 at the top for each.

He yelled at >>8118750 for "nostalgiafaggotry" i.e. bias influencing which games were ranked where, but he >>8118785 clearly has nostalgia for the early 2000's to the exception of everything else, as evidenced by Superstar Saga being at A and most of the best mainline games being well below.

[Anonymous No.8120554]

>>8118919
>>8118859

[Anonymous No.8120652]

>noone ranked mario paint
ngmi

[Anonymous No.8120878]

Not pictured: The Lost Levels is somewhere in A tier (yes, above OG SMB, fight me), Yoshi's Island DS is D, The Origami King is a high E, and All-Stars is ignored since it's a compilation. I'm too lazy to add them so just pretend they're there, okay?

[Anonymous No.8120903]

[Anonymous No.8120929]

>>8120652
Lots of games are missing. Wrecking Crew, Super Mario Bros. Special, Super Mario Land 3 (Wario Land), Super Princess Peach, Super Mario Run, Super Mario Maker 2, Luigi's Mansion 3, etc. I'd throw in the pre-SMB arcade games and Donkey Kong '94, too.

[Anonymous No.8122235]

>>8118984
>>8119325
Interesting to see people prefer the first Super Mario Land so much to Super Mario Land 2, and Super Mario Galaxy so much to Super Mario Galaxy 2. I'm curious for the reasonings. I think both Super Mario Lands are about on par but do prefer the first for being more original.

But how is Super Mario Galaxy 2 worse than the first one, besides being more derivative?

[Anonymous No.8122242]

>>8122235
>I think both Super Mario Lands are about on par but do prefer the first for being more original.
>But how is Super Mario Galaxy 2 worse than the first one, besides being more derivative?
I think you answered your own question.

[Anonymous No.8122246]

>>8120929
Besides Super Mario Bros. Special, which I don't think warrants a place on the list, none of these count. (they're not Super Mario games.) I think it's inconsistent the tier includes Luigi's mansion and Yoshi's New Island at all. (because then where's Yoshi's Island DS?) It should be limited to Super Mario games and RPGs, but if it were to include Super Mario Run, it might as well include the entire Mario Kart series.

You could argue Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island shouldn't count if we really want to be "consistent" here, but the first Wario Land absolutely doesn't count as part of the Super Mario series. If there were no other Wario Land games then you'd have a point on your hands, but that spawned a whole series and four direct sequels if you include the Virtual Boy one, (seven if you include Wario World, Master of Disguise and Shake It) there's enough Wario games to warrant its own tier list.

[Anonymous No.8122310]

>>8122235
I like how Land 1 looks and plays more than 2. Weightier physics, more compact, slightly more challenging, and I love the tiny sprites with no outlines. I wish more Game Boy games used a similar style

[Anonymous No.8122329]

Galaxy is the worst out of all of them followed by Odyssey.

[Anonymous No.8122358]

>>8122329
>SMB1 in the trash tier
You're likely retarded

[Anonymous No.8122383]

anyone who thinks mario sunshine is an acceptable game deserves the rope

[Anonymous No.8122432]

>>8117062

[Anonymous No.8122442]

>>8122246
>You could argue Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island shouldn't count if we really want to be "consistent" here, but the first Wario Land absolutely doesn't count as part of the Super Mario series.
I'd argue that, if "Super Mario Bros. 5" counts, then Super Mario Land 3 deserves a spot at the very least.

[Anonymous No.8122585]

>>8122358
Just ‘cause it was the first one doesn’t make it a good game.

[Anonymous No.8122621]

All the Mario games I've played, based on the prospect of playing them today. No points for historical significance. Might be biased by how recently I have or haven't played them.

[Anonymous No.8122674]

I didn't include games I haven't finished and most of these I've played a while ago so it might not be 100% accurate.

[Anonymous No.8123074]

R8 & H8

[Anonymous No.8123081]

[Anonymous No.8123083]

>>8122235
The Galaxy games only really have atmosphere going for them and 1 beats 2 at atmosphere.

[Anonymous No.8123087]

God: SMB3
Awesome: SMW, SMB1
Good: Yoshis Island, SMB2USA
Decent: SML, SML2
Meh: Everything not mentioned here
Shit: all 3d Mario games

[Anonymous No.8123094]

>>8123087
Also, pathetic how basically every fucking one of you kids think Mario 64 is at least good. Holy fuck, your entire generation was fucking brainwashed, wasn't it? Thank fuck I was an adult when that pile of trash came along so I could see it for the garbage it is.

[Anonymous No.8123101]

S and A tiers are absolute must plays. Everything else I could take or leave.

[Anonymous No.8123109]

>>8123101
On second thought I'd put Galaxy 2 in C tier

[Anonymous No.8123110]

>>8123094
Hello, >>8123096
Any other threads you want to paste that drivel into?

[Anonymous No.8123497]

>>8122442
>Super Mario Bros. 5
What are you talking about? The Japanese title is "Super Mario: Yoshi Island" and the American title is "Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island."

(The title for the first Wario Land is the same for Japan and the U.S. but you're engaging in pointless pedanticism at this point. The purpose of my comment is that if anything neither Yoshi's Island or Wario Land should be present since they belong to their respective series.)

[Anonymous No.8123502]

>>8123087
Was this written by George Wood? (of "Gaming in the Clinton Years"/NaVIGaTR notoriety.)

[Anonymous No.8123643]

>>8117062
You have a very cozy bed, and strong opinions on Super Smash Bros. You see yourself as both a defender and a peacemaker. Usually play Yoshi in the spinoffs.
>>8117067
You are convinced you exist on a level beyond human comprehension. The messages in your dreams are telling the truth. Either Birdo or Boo is your character of choice.
>>8117287
Big lore dude. If someone asked you why the borders of the Mushroom Kingdom and shape of Mushroom Castle consistently change, you'd have an answer. You would play as Luigi if you played any spinoffs, but you usually don't.
>>8118005
The lone wolf. You seek to improve your skills even if you find yourself pushing others away. You don't lack creativity, but you have a plan in mind. One of the few people who actually plays as Mario in the spinoffs.
>>8118038
May be defined as a "zoomer" in some threads, but you've done your research. You laugh at people who try too hard to be subversive and contrarian, and seek to learn the rules before you break them. You can win a lot of the time as Toad, even if you don't like the character personally.
>>8118274
You can name the influences on Mario's artstyle, and the unique traits each team member brings to the direction of the world and emotions. Though very strong-willed, you never make an opinion on something without at least trying it. You play as Rosalina whenever possible, and occasionally masturbate to her.
>>8118750
You appreciate Mario, but deep down you're really more of a Sonic fan. You get paranoid about "mandates". In spinoffs you either choose crossover characters or Miis.
>>8118785
Intelligent, Nihilistic and with a Wicked Sense of Humor. You've replayed your favorite games many times and like seeing new mechanical discoveries. Funky Kong player.
>>8118846
The gnawing emptiness of the void consistently follows you. Every day seems a little less magical, like you're losing your ability to enjoy old things. There's no hatred, you just want change. Koopa Troopa player.

[Anonymous No.8123714]

>>8118984
You laugh uproariously at YouTube Poops, and seek the first editions of comics. Slight phobia of water. Miyamoto's views on level design and storytelling really resonate with you. Wario player, you never interact with Waluigi players.
>>8119325
Your Japanese skills are constantly improving. Fan of highly-saturated colors and fold-out manuals. Your day is very strictly regimented and focused on specific tasks. Donkey Kong player.
>>8120878
You oftentimes have trouble empathizing with others' problems, but you have a hard time getting worked up over trivial things. Love/hate relationship with portable systems. Likely a close relationship with a sibling. Daisy player.
>>8120903
Having a trouble getting a read on you, and I think a lot of people do, too. Big fan of experiments and new directions. You've only played a couple of spinoffs, but you like using the Koopalings or Bowser Jr. if they're there.
>>8122329
You're getting up there, but still have some spit and vinegar going around you. Mostly settled and content with the way things are going for you, and quick to both share your knowledge of things you like and go on rants. You play as Bowser, especially in Smash.
>>8122432
"Meh." You don't always have time to dedicate to games, but you do make sure to look out for things that interest you. Pretty good reader. You're one of those guys who selects "random" for both character and stage selection.
>>8122621
Adventurous, unbiased, you have fun watching people discover new things. You're part of vtuber culture or something similar. Maybe a gardener. You play as Peach, but feel strongly about her characterization in spinoffs.
>>8122674
You used to post cringey memes and feel bad about it today. Good taste in movies and you organize watch parties often. Waluigi player.
>>8123081
The most important thing to you is getting away from it all and losing yourself entirely in something. A decent amount of friends, but you still deeply value alone time. Yoshi player.

[Anonymous No.8123739]

>>8123087
You wish the industry would go back to the time where everyone was doing retro revivals with pixel stuff. Either really love or really hate boomer shooters. Zero interest in spinoffs.
>>8123101
Great talent with a musical instrument. You like to listen to game soundtracks and lo-fi while you study. Sometimes second-guess yourself. Dry Bones kinda dude.

[Anonymous No.8123780]

I'm late millenilol so the N64 ones are my regular replays. Everything else I either haven't played or suck too hard at to rate fairly (SMB)

[Anonymous No.8124180]

>>8123497
>What are you talking about? The Japanese title is "Super Mario: Yoshi Island" and the American title is "Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island."
It was actually changed at the last minute, which is why one or two magazine previews still call it Super Mario Bros. 5, so "Super Mario World 2" is actually not a total invention of localization. The devs keep flip-flopping on whether it's considered part of the core platformers or not.
>The purpose of my comment is that if anything neither Yoshi's Island or Wario Land should be present since they belong to their respective series.
They can exist in both series at once. Sekien Densetsu: Final Fantasy Gaiden (Final Fantasy Adventure / Adventures of Mana) is considered both a Final Fantasy spinoff and the first game in the Mana series as the full title does not preclude the other.

[Anonymous No.8124225]

>>8123643
>>8123714
thank you

[Anonymous No.8124230]

tiers not ordered within

[Anonymous No.8124291]

Sure, I'll bite. Galaxy and World have always been some of my favorite games ever, and other games like SM64 and Sunshine never struck any chords with me. I have tons of fun with most of the RPGs that everyone else hates though.

[Anonymous No.8124356]

>>8117062