/vr/ - Retro Games

[Anonymous No.5597865]

Havent played SMB3 in about 10 years, should I go for the NES or the nice All-Stars remake?

[Anonymous No.5597872]

>>5597865
Gba

[Anonymous No.5597876]

inb4 nitpick-kun.

[Anonymous No.5597884]

>>5597865
NES version is better in terms of aesthetic theming but All-Stars is fine and still looks good.

[Anonymous No.5597889]

>>5597865
Both are good.

[Anonymous No.5597890]

>>5597865
NES. It looks, sounds and plays the best. The remakes replaced the trippy snowy caves and their weird ass multidimensional walls in which you can see the stars in space... with boring ass generic brown caves. Just compare level 1-5 or the "inside the pyramid" levels from world 2 and tell me they didn't fuck up the extremely interestng art direction of the original. They also got rid of the "play" theme of the whole game.

I strongly recommend playing Super Mario Bros 3 Mix. It's a fantastic rom hack that may as well be an official sequel and is the second best Mario game of all time, right behind the original SMB3. Seriously, play that shit. You won't regret it. It's incredible how many mechanics were introduced to such an old game, including a save system, and every single world has levels based on a different game in the history of Mario (like Mario 1, 2, 3, 64, Sunshine, Galaxy, etc). The gravity levels in the Galaxy world are great.

[Anonymous No.5597891]

All Stars more like All Trash
Only lost levels is needed in the whole poackage.

[Anonymous No.5597892]

Play them all and decide for yourself which version sticks with you the most. Although there's no reason why you should have to commit yourself to one version or another. The game is fairly easy to clear.

I usually go to the GBA version with all the e-stages patched in and the palette reverted to the SNES brightness. The SNES version is great, but I do most of my gaming on my GBA.

[Anonymous No.5597895]

>>5597890
>>5597889
>>5597884
good answers thanks. i had played both versions back and forth as a kid, but i was drawn to the save feature of All Stars since I wasnt playing for long sessions at a time.
I'll take a look at that rom hack, it sounds pretty exciting

[Anonymous No.5597909]

>>5597890
I remember loving the grass in level 1-2 and the sand in the... second? level of World 2 when I was a kid. The whole aesthetic was just really pleasing to look at. Just a single uniform green/yellow color covered black dots. Really simple and charming. The remakes have some interesting parts art-wise, but they are generally a major artistic downgrade.

[Anonymous No.5597924]

>>5597865
Play Mario Adventure romhacks instead.

[Anonymous No.5597926]

NES version
>Star Wars original cut vs. Blu-Ray Special Edition

[Anonymous No.5597937]

>>5597865
All Stars is good but not nearly enough steel drum

[Anonymous No.5597940]

>>5597890
That one level from late in the game in which you fall down through an empty black pit full of floating platforms and eventually arrive at some cave, I always loved it. But the all stars version butchered the visuals HARD. I always let myself fall down instead of climbing up the platforms so I could see the alien-like red palette swap of the usual white space-cave at the bottom. I was disappointed to end up in some boring cave when I played the remake.

The bizarre space cave levels inside the pyramids also had some gameplay elements unexplicably removed. In the original, some stars in the background would look much brighter or even have a different color, hinting at an invisible block. The generic caves in the remake have the invisible blocks but nothing to hint at them.

[Anonymous No.5597958]

>>5597890
>the trippy snowy caves and their weird ass multidimensional walls in which you can see the stars in space
This so fucking hard. It's one of the reasons SMB3 is my favorite, it really captured my imagination as a kid. Especially when you entered a door on the side of a pyramid and the inside was... so fucking bizarre. It looked like you entered a pocket dimension inside the pyramid, an entire universe full of floating red space rocks, weird alien creatures (buzzy beetles look really weird in this game and tend to only show up in these strange levels) and the vast space full of stars in the background.

Hell, even the 5 seconds long pipe "levels" that transported you from one side of the map to another used that same weird snowy cave in the middle of space aesthetic. It was a pleasure to look at every time I used the pipes, making them much less tedious.

The NES version also lets you shoot green fireballs at the toad houses, which I always found funny.

[Anonymous No.5597970]

>>5597940
That level did lose something in the transition. I believe they even added some unnecessary background pipes to the free falling section, which was just a mysterious pitch black screen in the original with shit floating around, very reminiscent of when Alice fell through the rabbit hole.

Same with that one level where you can enter the right side of the screen to come out from the left and have to use the transparent arrow platforms to go up a maze of pipes. Adding detail to the pitch black background made the whole thing look incredibly boring. It took away the magic and WTF factor of the original visuals.

[Anonymous No.5598073]

>>5597884
shit opinion desu. inb4 'muh blue caves'
>>5597865
play all-stars, it has the most aesthetic and the best physics in all of the 3 ports/versions. you can also save your game on real hardware. the ost is absolutely bangin and the visuals set the tone just right for a mario game. mario 3 on nes is quite ugly and lacks atmosphere.

[Anonymous No.5598148]

>>5597865
>All-Stars is better cuz “muh blue star caves”
Lmfao come on guys you need to use a better argument.

[Anonymous No.5598169]

>>5597865
Cringe

[Anonymous No.5598185]

Make up your own mind I hope you choose the right path

[Anonymous No.5598201]

>>5598073
>the ost is absolutely bangi
LMAO. Most SNES games, especially those whose music wasn't even originally composed for the system, which is the case of All-Stars, have that awful, uncomfortable tin sound that makes it seem like the sound is coming from somewhere far away. It's all muddled and has no energy.

[Anonymous No.5598208]

>>5598185
I just love the plain colors without clutter. A pure blue sky and a Mario made out of beautiful pixels of the same shade of color instead of having that ugly ass 16-bit shadowing that makes sprites look messy.

[Anonymous No.5598213]

>>5598185
>that warp world island map
Jesus. Why do they insist on replacing bizarre and interesting looking colors with boring ass realistic brown colors?

[Anonymous No.5598214]

>>5598201
True. The all stars music sounds like muffled bowser farts

[Anonymous No.5598216]

>>5598185
It's sucks how remakes are almost always made without understanding the intent and artistic vision of the original creators. They always get things wrong and miss the point entirely.

[Anonymous No.5598224]

>>5598208
This. Sprites with shading lack that beautiful retro simplicity and often look like someone pixelated a real drawing or photo and let the computer coldly do its thing. All those ugly shadows, ugh.

[Anonymous No.5598243]

>>5598185
I love the weird ass pocket dimension space "caves" and their floor tiles. It's especially bizarre because those same tiles are also used for the metal floors in the castles. So interesting.

[Anonymous No.5598246]

>>5598224
>>5598208
slightly off-topic, but thats how i feel when tv show cartoons get big screen films, the first thing they do is add "shading" to all the characters and it looks awful. hey arnold and rugrats come to mind.

[Anonymous No.5598249]

>>5598185
I can see the appeal of the SNES version. I'm quite fond of the golden bricks.

But holy mother of fuck how can ANYONE defend the caves?

[Anonymous No.5598254]

>>5598185
called it

[Anonymous No.5598256]

The one and only issue I have with the NES version is the lack of a save system, which isn't an issue if you're emulating.

[Anonymous No.5598260]

>>5598201
>>5598214
You're overreacting, the music sounds fine.
The thing is that the NES original has those famous drum samples and sadly they couldn't make it sound as good as on SNES.
I wouldn't discredit everything the SNES remake has going for it, but yes, if you want to nitpick, there's things to nitpick about. Still not real reasons to completely avoid the remake though, it's still good and I personally enjoy the more detailed graphics and more colors and shades.
I like playing both versions.

[Anonymous No.5598262]

>>5598256
You can get two flutes in like 5 minutes and go literally anywhere in the game if you use the second one on the warp world. Yeah, you lose the items you had in a previous playthrough, but you have a limited inventory anyway. It's not that big of a deal.

[Anonymous No.5598281]

all stars because nes only has composite out
it's a simple choice really

[Anonymous No.5598294]

Both versions are fantastic games, but the NES version looks drop dead gorgeous while the SNES version looks like your run of the mill homogenized Mario game.

[Anonymous No.5598348]

>>5598185
imagine liking the soulless garbage that is the nes version. what was nintendo thinking with that color palette and lack of depth per sprite and background? jesus

[Anonymous No.5598350]

>>5598201
>"LMAO!! DUDE!! GET TROLLED!!"
do burgers really post like this

[Anonymous No.5598572]

>>5598073
>inb4 'muh blue caves'
several posts too late for that

[Anonymous No.5598589]

All Stars looks like trash. Stay with the NES version.

[Anonymous No.5598595]

>>5597890
holy fuck this rom hack looks sick

[Anonymous No.5598638]

>>5597926
Not a bad comparison, actually. I would have gone for the good old soul vs. soulless myself (which also applies to the Star Wars trilogy, of course)

[Anonymous No.5598738]

>>5598595
Wait until you see the secret world unlocked by collecting all the star coins.

[Anonymous No.5598767]

>>5598256
The game already cost $70 new. Asking for a battery save was just too much.

[Anonymous No.5598857]

>>5598767
Yeah, I know. I've just always wished it had one when I was a kid. Especially since 6 year old me had trouble with a lot of the later levels, The accomplishment of finally destroying a fortress and having a checkpoint was lost when my parents would eventually make me turn the game off before inching to the end of the world. There were a LOT of worlds I didn't see the second half of until the SNES port.

[Anonymous No.5598873]

Who gives a shit which version. All stars is just as much a relic of its time as Mario 3

Play all stars. Save. Enjoy it. Take your time

[Anonymous No.5598876]

>>5598738
this is rather impressive for a nes hack using the OG mario bros as a mini game needed to unlock items is pretty creative

[Anonymous No.5598982]

>>5597865
GBA version with all the e-reader levels in it

[Anonymous No.5599032]

>>5598572
its the only arguement they usually have.

[Anonymous No.5599336]

>>5598185
Damn

[Anonymous No.5599350]

Taking away the graphics/style/soul thing, mechanically speaking, is the NES version really the best?

[Anonymous No.5599357]

>>5599350
>no saving
Nah.

The best version mechanically is the GBA version because of those cool e-Reader levels.

[Anonymous No.5599367]

>>5598185
the autism in the picture, god damn.
NES version looks like it uses placeholder tiles for half the levels, and the background pieces are of a specific shade or use only 2 colours because that's all the hardware can push.

The only legit argument I've seen so far against All-Stars is that the art change made some clever hidden parts too obvious or too hidden (like the block of bricks in 8-1 or 8-2? or SMB, that is made to look like a background brick tile).
And that the physics of hitting a block is wrong, but even that part is nitpicking by speedrunner faggots.

>>5598201
The music is fine and goes especially well with the shroom theme of Mario. The underground theme is specifically fitting, since you are in a goddamn cave, it's supposed to have a tinny, echoing sound.

[Anonymous No.5599378]

>>5599357
Now I'm curious, are the GBA versions of other ports worth checking out over the originals?

[Anonymous No.5599509]

>>5597940
>That one level from late in the game in which you fall down through an empty black pit full of floating platforms and eventually arrive at some cave

Excuse me, which level is this?

[Anonymous No.5599592]

>>5598185
>/vr/ will defend this

[Anonymous No.5599652]

>>5597958
Speaking of fireballs, I have always hated the way fireballs from SMW and All Stars sound. The fireball sound effect from the NES game sounds more powerful and is superior.

[Anonymous No.5599679]

>>5599509

[Anonymous No.5599680]

>>5599652
It’s little comments like this that make me certain most of /vr/ is autistic.

[Anonymous No.5599882]

>>5597890
I just downloaded this

https://www.romhacking.net/hacks/2068/

this is it right, it gives two ips files to patch. Which one should it be? And it's pretty hard.

Do you recommend and other hacks. I prefer nes or snes. I enjoy a good rpg, zelda, mario

[Anonymous No.5599886]

>>5599882
one is for Rev 0 and one is for Rev 1. if you have properly named SMb3 rom it will tell you which rev it is.

[Anonymous No.5599938]

>>5599679
Thank you anon! For some reason, I thought you were referring to some level in World 8. This level is from World 7.

Where can I se all levels as per your image?

[Anonymous No.5599947]

>>5599938
You're both wrong. This is from World 5.

[Anonymous No.5599950]

I personally prefer the original SMB2 to the GBA remake which still has some charm (yes, the voices that some people hate are cute in their own way). The remake however is stupidly easier than the original.

[Anonymous No.5599954]

>>5597865
the nes version
memes aside, i definitely feel that it looks better. and even though it may be some kind of psychological thing instead of actually being true, i think the physics are different in all-stars.

[Anonymous No.5599972]

>Should I play something with SOUL or something that's SOULLESS?
Gee I don't know.

[Anonymous No.5599982]

>>5599367
in other words you have no real taste in art and probably shouldn't be calling anyone autistic

[Anonymous No.5599985]

>>5597872
Wahoo! This low resolution butchering of a classic is JUST WHAT I NEEDED!

[Anonymous No.5600002]

The NES shrill sounds gets to me after a while

[Anonymous No.5600074]

>>5600002
Yes. I much prefer things to sound like they're coming out of a tin can with a pillow over it.

[Anonymous No.5600090]

>>5600002
>>5600074
Maybe don't use cheap TV speakers with out an EQ. You could always trim down the high freq.

[Anonymous No.5600094]

>>5598185
> SNES BAD BECAUSE IT DOESNT HAVE THE SILVER PIPES AND ICONIC SKY HOLOGRAMS
Stop posting this garbage, You arent an art critic, you literally cannot do pros and cons or compare and contrast, this is just cherrypicked nostalgiafagging. Unlike you, I can actually come up with solutions, watch. If you people hate All Stars so much, why not just make a rom hack to have all the wonky nes graphics? People were able to 'fix' the SMB1 physics in a rom hack, You guys are running out of excuses

[Anonymous No.5600105]

is this the same poster who makes the smb3 vs smw threads?

[Anonymous No.5600110]

>>5600105
Yeah, nitpick-kun.

[Anonymous No.5600119]

>>5599680
You are a brainlet and you don't appreciate video games. Why are you even here?
>HAHA WOW IMAGINE PAYING ATTEBTION TO SOUND EFFECTS BRO XDD TRU AUTISM MAN

[Anonymous No.5600129]

>>5600110
You’re that weirdo who called anyone who criticized Super Castlevania Bros “Australia-kun”.
You really should be put on medication. This level of paranoia is not normal.

[Anonymous No.5600151]

>>5600119
>Literally frothing at the mouth
Normal people don’t notice minute shit like that. The tune that plays when you beat a level? Sure. But not the fucking fireball sfx. You’d definitely have to be on the spectrum to some degree to complain about that.

[Anonymous No.5600161]

>>5600129
>he thinks australia-kun was the first -kun
How new are you to 4chan?

[Anonymous No.5600163]

>>5600119
>ur dumb n don’t like vidya gaems if you don’t obsess over every detail like a sperg
uh huh sure bud

[Anonymous No.5600165]

>>5600129
It was very obvious when it was you, australia.

[Anonymous No.5600175]

>>5600161
Nowhere was that implied, sodomite.

>>5600165
Yeah, I know. Was it obvious when I delivered your mail the other day? How about when I checked out those groceries for you?
I’m everywhere maaaaaaan.

[Anonymous No.5600185]

I love the original NES game too, but I'll just play the All-Stars remake (which has its own pros, like more colors, more background graphics) to spite on the autist that makes comparison collages.

[Anonymous No.5600192]

>>5600175
>Nowhere was that implied, sodomite.
Then accept it, if you're shitposting the same shit every single day, people are going to start recognizing you and calling you shitpost-kun.
Talk about paranoia if you think there's only 1 guy recognizing your shitposts.

[Anonymous No.5600220]

>>5600192
>If you’re shitposting the same shit everyday
That image has been around since before this board’s inception, newlad. SMB3 is just that latest game targeted by the whole soul vs soulless nonsense. You’re mad if you really think it’s one person.

[Anonymous No.5600225]

>>5600220
>soul vs soulless nonsense
It makes sense most of the time, but mostly when comparing newer remakes from non-retro era. All Stars has souls (even if some of the nitpicks are true).
Anyway, you're not better than him if you think there's only 1 person calling out the SMB3 autist and his meme pics.

[Anonymous No.5600231]

>>5600225
Your split personalities don’t count as different people.

[Anonymous No.5600237]

>>5600231
k.
If people recognizing you bothers you so much, change your bait a bit instead of repeating the same ones day after day.

[Anonymous No.5600242]

>>5600237
>people
Take your meds, la’.

[Anonymous No.5600248]

>>5600242
Yeah man, it's only me. I deliver your mail, I pick your groceries, etc.
Stop projecting, stop shitposting (or at least, mix up the shitposts a bit so that it isn't so monotonous)

[Anonymous No.5600263]

>>5600105
No, unlike that guy I acutally enjoy both SMW and SMB3

[Anonymous No.5600271]

>>5600185
based.
the remake looks pretty damn moody, it has a good atmosphere despite being different from the original.
Patricians enjoy both for their own unique traits. Plebs will argue about which one is "betttur"

[Anonymous No.5600443]

>>5598260
but there are no real reasons to play the remake either

[Anonymous No.5600451]

>>5600443
see:
>>5600185
>>5600271

[Anonymous No.5600453]

>>5598857
fuck youre young

[Anonymous No.5600593]

They soiled it

[Anonymous No.5601057]

>>5600593
The more you post these, the more I appreciate the All Stars remake. I used to think it wasn't that good because of the cave space backgrounds and sky powerup icons, but now I keep looking and I find more stuff I like about All Stars
>dat transparent water on the hammer bros screen
>that background in the pipe screen with the leak detail and all
>comfy background underwater and detailed stone wall
Not to mention the sprites themselves for enemies are more detailed with more colors.
Not trashing the original, it definitely has its charm, but the remake is pretty good and pleasant to the eye. I think I'm gonna slam my All-Stars + World cart on my SNES tonight and play a bit, I wonder what powerups I left there from my last playthrough.

[Anonymous No.5601105]

>>5600593
all stars so fucking good holy fuck. streaming this tonight /vr/, you'll know who I am. enjoy.

[Anonymous No.5601116]

I'll play SMB3 SNES as my first SMB3 to spite the local /vr/ autist

It looks really good, too

[Anonymous No.5601137]

The best thing about All-Stars SMB 3 is some copies trigger the debug, letting you pick the power ups while you play the level with select.

https://tcrf.net/Super_Mario_All-Stars#Old_Debug_Mode

[Anonymous No.5601385]

>>5597865
Only play All-Stars if you want the save feature. It was a graphic upgrade, and an artistic downgrade. Gameplay was the same.

[Anonymous No.5601390]

>>5597890
While I prefer the SNES version of Mario 3 I'm still gonna vouch for this guy and say 3Mix is some good shit. No matter what version you play, check that out when you're done.

[Anonymous No.5601402]

>>5598249
I don't even mind the rock textures, but why the fuck is coloring removed? Is it really that hard to just have the rocks change color?

[Anonymous No.5601409]

>>5599378
I can't really say it's better than the SNES version, but World GBA has some neat things in it. Find the colored Yoshis will make them spawn in the main levels, and a few mechanics are changed around if you use Luigi - and I don't just mean how he moves.

Give it a try, but maybe just use Luigi. If you want to be Mario I recommend sticking to the SNES version.

[Anonymous No.5601410]

>>5598216
What are you talking about? You do realize that Miyamoto headed up the project and the original development teams provided input throughout right?

http://iwataasks.nintendo.com/interviews/#/wii/super-mario-all-stars/1/0

[Anonymous No.5601471]

>>5601410
If they were aiming to preserve the feel of the original gameplay, then how come they didn't catch that bug in SMB1 where Mario doesn't properly rebound from bumping blocks?

[Anonymous No.5601564]

>>5598185
I think the green fireballs were some kind of bug.

[Anonymous No.5601582]

>>5598185
it'd be really nice if someone made a chart like this without all the biased buzzword shit. Just show some comparisons and let the viewer decide what they think looks better

[Anonymous No.5601640]

>>5601564
Of course they were, nobody is saying otherwise. But why would you get rid of a fun bug?

[Anonymous No.5601647]

>>5600593
SNES is good for the novelty, but the NES version will always be the definitive.

[Anonymous No.5601903]

>>5601640
Some overworked jap probably changed it not realizing a handful of autists would consider it a grave error.

[Anonymous No.5601917]

Played some All-Star 3 just now.
It looks great. The backgrounds (like the caves) look MUCH better in movement than in still screenshots since they have different layers with parallax.
I'm really appreciating this remake more now.
Just got done the first world, tomorrow I'll resume on world 2.

[Anonymous No.5601929]

>>5598185
I can never see this image without wondering what kind of person actually had the impetus to make it.

[Anonymous No.5601942]

>>5601917
Mate it takes 10 minutes to beat world 1. The hell you stopping for?

[Anonymous No.5601952]

>>5601942
>Just got done the first world

[Anonymous No.5601953]

>>5601952
Yes?

[Anonymous No.5602894]

>>5601953
Your sentence has broken English, ESL-kun.

[Anonymous No.5602901]

>>5602894
You seem to have replied to the wrong guy.

[Anonymous No.5602906]

>>5602894
Why am I seeing "ESL" everywhere all of the sudden?
A sort of revenge by EOPs?

[Anonymous No.5602913]

>>5598073
If I wanted to play a graphical remake, I'd go with SMA4
SMAS is shit and has all the drawbacks of both the original and the GBA version with none of the advantages.

[Anonymous No.5602929]

I haven't played SMB3 in quite a while either and I noticed something as of late. I don't know if I'm sucking more at videogames now or what, but I often miss my jumps. Like I can't jump right after I touch the floor. I have to wait a tiny bit, and I found out it wasn't my controller or anything like that because in other games I don't have this issue. It's weird as all fuck, like I'm trying here to jump before I'm able to do so.

[Anonymous No.5602934]

>>5602913
>all the drawbacks
>GBA version
Nah, All-Stars has full screen ratio, better audio and no voice samples. SMA4 is fine if you can get the e-card levels though.

[Anonymous No.5602937]

>>5602929
Are you playing on an LCD screen/emulator or both?
Input lag is real.

[Anonymous No.5602941]

>>5602937
I'm playing on a Wii over a CRT. Not through virtual console, but RetroArch. I understand input lag is real, but with other platformers it feels like I can jump off the ground right after I land without issues. With SMB3 it's kinda different, almost as if I have to wait a few frames for it to allow me to jump.

[Anonymous No.5602957]

>>5602937
>Input lag is real.

[Anonymous No.5602971]

>>5602957
What's funny about that statement? If you have to plan your shit more often, your character feels heavier and such, it's not that enjoyable.

However current methods of emulation coupled with decent displays make it to where the difference between it and real hardware + crt is so minimal that it's not worth using the second option.

[Anonymous No.5602984]

>>5602957
Imagine saving pictures of random dudes

[Anonymous No.5603032]

>>5602941
Why not play on a proper emulator instead of a fucking Wii?

Also, who the hell plays old platformers with a controller? That shit does have input lag and is also uncomfortable as fuck. Arrow keys or bust.

[Anonymous No.5603223]

>>5598185
>"cool green fireball" was ~censored~ and not just a fixed palette bug
this has to be trolling at this point

[Anonymous No.5603257]

>>5603223
Woosh. Are you autistic?

[Anonymous No.5603280]

>>5598073
>you can also save your game on real hardware
If he's got an Everdrive, there's a hack for the Famicom version that adds a save feature.

[Anonymous No.5603285]

>>5597890
>I strongly recommend playing Super Mario Bros 3 Mix
Make sure to get the latest version directly from the developer's website. The version on Romhacking.net is older and is far buggier from what I remember.
http://www.sonicepoch.com/sm3mix/

[Anonymous No.5603480]

>>5597865
>nice All-Stars remake
>nice

Way to load your own question, bud.

[Anonymous No.5603510]

>>5603285
Isn't the version on RHDN up to date? The version number is apparently the same as the one in the website.

[Anonymous No.5603526]

>>5603032
Not him but probably because of the 240p output without building a dedicated PC compatible with CRT EmuDriver

[Anonymous No.5603551]

>>5603510
Oh, seems like they've changed it. The latest version was released in 2015, and I last checked RHDN in 2018. Good thing it has been finally fixed.

[Anonymous No.5603562]

THEY FORGOT THE SKY HOLOGRAMS

[Anonymous No.5604568]

>>5603562
kek

[Anonymous No.5605889]

>>5602941
>"I understand input lag is real"
Wow tell us more genius

[Anonymous No.5605891]

>>5605889
hahah I agree anon, input lag isn't real! I'm streaming my video games from mednafen on a ps3 emulator to the Vita and running my vita on a 4K monitor. I have to wait a bit until the characters on the screen move, but input lag isn't real

[Anonymous No.5605916]

The caves are the only reason I hold this game in such high regard. Shit is trippy.

Playing a version of SMB3 with the pocket dimensions full of multicolored rocks floating in space replaced by boring ass real life caves is just pointless.

[Anonymous No.5605927]

>>5597865
OP this isnt meant for you in particular, but why dont you faggot just play both instead of always discussing this trivial background and aestethics bullshit. I would be glad to sit down an half an hour and play either of them through, hell you could play them back by back and you would still have the whole day

[Anonymous No.5605969]

>>5605927
Where do people find the original ProGeria dick pics? I want to laugh at him.

[Anonymous No.5605986]

>>5605969
Honestly, if you Google Jared penis it should Show up when you click on picture Tab, I got it on my phone, if this weren't a blue Board I'd Show you that prodick :^)
Läßt week you could have just gone on Twitter, his dick was there for days kek, Twitter didn't care.

[Anonymous No.5606000]

>>5605927
Why is everyone shitting on this dude? He cheated on his wife? Who the fuck cares? He solicited nudes from fans? Again, who gives a shit? They were underage? Oh, here comes the SJW patrol.

I don't even care for this asshat, but anyone who shits on him for those reasons is a moralcuck.

[Anonymous No.5606043]

>>5606000
because people need something to hate today so they can feel like their in on something.

[Anonymous No.5606046]

>>5605986
>tfw you realize the colors of the koopalings in SMW is because they match the Super Famicom clover colors, like the palace switches and the yoshies

[Anonymous No.5606063]

>>5597865
NES looks better but All-Stars has saving
If emulator, NES, if not, All-Stars

[Anonymous No.5606076]

>>5606000
Did I shit on him? Nope, actually I still like the Lil fucker, really dont care what he does in his free time, I want him to do his job again and upload, he was playing a zelda alttp metroid combo randomizer hack, was really fun. Honestly, even if he did that shit I dont care, I still watch naked gun with oj simpson, Listen to Michael Jackson music, watch hangover... People just like to judge to make their own miserable lifes look better

[Anonymous No.5607426]

Speaking of remakes, do any maps of the GBA remake of Super Mario World exist for all of the dragon coins?

[Anonymous No.5607430]

>>5597890
rom hacks
Nah I don't like playing unofficial stuff. It just feels fake.

[Anonymous No.5607447]

>>5602894
At least I speak more than one language, retard.

[Anonymous No.5607503]

>>5597865
NES. Though the differences are minor.

[Anonymous No.5608036]

>>5597865

Play GBA for the extra e-reader levels and nice graphical upgrade to Mario Bros.

All-Stars is a solid remake.

Some of the backgrounds are weird compared to the original but honestly the save feature makes it overall much better and for the most part the graphics and sound are great.

I can see people like the aesthetic of the original more but they both do different things great. Saying either looks like shit is an exaggeration which is typical for this board filled with faggots.

Honestly I'd recommend playing each version of the first four Super Mario Bros. games.

[Anonymous No.5608038]

>>5608036
>GBA sounds like shit but has extra levels and powerups!
>SNES looks like shit but you can save!
Physicalfags everyone. Pretending NES romhacks don't exist.

[Anonymous No.5608050]

>>5608038

>Physical fags

I have all three versions digitally on my Wii U/vWii so I could save state if I really wanted to. That was my suggestion if OP wasn't into them.

I just really like Super Mario Bros. 3. Probably beats out World for my favorite 2D Mario game. No version of it sounds or looks bad. I don't know what the fuck you neckbeards have to argue about

[Anonymous No.5608079]

>>5608038
Snes looks way better

[Anonymous No.5608230]

>>5607447
Spanish?

[Anonymous No.5608376]

>just
>what
>I
>needed

[Anonymous No.5608448]

>>5608376

The voices add a lot of soul to the game.

[Anonymous No.5608458]

>>5608230
No, goblino de las americas.

[Anonymous No.5609054]

Soul Overload.

[Anonymous No.5609057]

>>5609054
Soul Overload.

[Anonymous No.5609060]

>>5609057
That starry night sky is peak soul imo.

[Anonymous No.5609152]

>>5609057
All Stars SMB1 is super underrated. It’s my favorite version (once you patch the block physics).

[Anonymous No.5609285]

>>5609054
I prefer how the original looks (and no, I barely have any nostalgia for it). But this does look amazing and much better than Mario World.

At least it's a proper reimagining of SMB1, unlike SMB3 which is just the same game with all the unintentionally trippy stuff replaced by boring shit.

I can't believe they went through the trouble of making SMB1 look this pretty and didn't bother recreating the physics properly or even playtesting it. Anyone would notice that the unpatched block physics ruin your momentum and feel like shit.

[Anonymous No.5609307]

Does the brick issue exist in the all star + world version?

[Anonymous No.5609312]

>>5605927
God I wish that hand were me

[Anonymous No.5609316]

>>5609307
Yeah sadly.

[Anonymous No.5609453]

>>5608458
Mexico?

[Anonymous No.5609476]

>>5605891
No one plays like that. Stop being autistic.

[Anonymous No.5609510]

>>5603257
explain yourself.

[Anonymous No.5609931]

>>5599938
Seriously? The url to the source's webpage is printed right on the image in the post you quoted.

[Anonymous No.5610810]

>>5609316
And the patch for the all star version works for this one? Maybe I should just get the rom without the world game.

[Anonymous No.5610990]

>>5610810
All of the patches works for the All-Stars+World version, too.

[Anonymous No.5610991]

>>5597865
NES and don't even consider the others

[Anonymous No.5611007]

>>5600094
>you can't criticize game, because you are able to use chunks of your time to learn rom hacking, and then mod the illegal rom just to make it almost like the nes version
or then we can just play nes version instead? logic.

[Anonymous No.5611009]

>>5611007
It takes less time to hack the rom than playing and beating the game.

[Anonymous No.5611016]

>>5611009
But why? What's the point really? Why would there be need to hack to snes version to be almost like the nes version, when we already have a working nes version? I don't understand your logic at all.

[Anonymous No.5611036]

>>5598185
The "over the clouds" background is tremendous, it really feels like you are way up in the sky.
Yeah, the caves are a bit boring with that background but the SNES version is nicer to look at. BTW, i don't know why is there such a problem with full colored decorations in the final bit of the levels, i mean, you can't have props backstage?

We need an unbiased comparison

[Anonymous No.5611049]

>>5600593
man, look at the SNES background on the first comparison, it's so beautiful

[Anonymous No.5611057]

tfw no graphics mod that creates the best of both worlds, using the SMB3 or All Stars art depending on what looks better

[Anonymous No.5611060]

Tfw you just wanted to play Mario 3 with Luigi physics but they never released that card in English.

[Anonymous No.5611197]

>>5597872
This is my go-to version, simply because I can't ignore those e-Reader levels.
Although it'd probably be best to play either the NES or SNES version and have the GBA version on hand exclusively for the e-Reader content.

[Anonymous No.5611296]

>>5611016
The point is that it looks better and plays the same.

[Anonymous No.5611348]

>>5611197
It's only a matter of time until they hack the e-reader levels into the original SMB3.

After all, SMB3 Mix added a bunch of crazy powerups and even fucking Yoshi.

[Anonymous No.5611490]

>>5611296
It doesn't look better dumvass. And it plays worse due to more input lag

[Anonymous No.5611538]

NES version is just an ugly shit compared to the SNES version. Sorry retro faggots, your magenta tinted glasses hide the absolute reality from you.

And I didn't even talk about how awful the music was in the NES, not to mention the lack of saving.

[Anonymous No.5611759]

>Beat SMB1 on NES
>Beat SMB1 on GBC with Deluxe
>Recently played All-Stars
>Feels pretty much the same

Maybe you guys just need to get good

[Anonymous No.5613382]

>>5600185
More colors and background spirits is a dumb pro, especially when it makes everything uglier. but playing it to spite somebody is a good enough reason

[Anonymous No.5613496]

>>5597865

[Anonymous No.5613842]

>>5598185
Wtf I hate snes now

[Anonymous No.5613845]

>>5613382
>More colors and background spirits is a dumb pro
How so? If anything, thinking more colors and backgrounds is a con is very, very dumb.
>especially when it makes everything uglier.
Everything? a little hyperbolic, don't you think? The screenshot in the post you're citing looks amazing.

[Anonymous No.5613883]

>>5597865
GBA version

[Anonymous No.5614492]

>>5597865
both at the same time

[Anonymous No.5614497]

>>5614492
Get outta here Goro

[Anonymous No.5614524]

https://www.neogaf.com/threads/super-mario-all-stars-is-a-truly-horrible-remake.1036207/

[Anonymous No.5614553]

>>5614524
>all that text to pint out the brick issue
Which there is already a fix hack.

[Anonymous No.5616897]

>>5598185
>green fireball "censored"

[Anonymous No.5616954]

>>5614553
That would mean encouraging emulation, which Neogaf obviously is not going to do.

[Anonymous No.5617069]

>>5598767
Cost and price are not the same thing.

[Anonymous No.5617453]

>>5597865
All stars has fucked physics, so nes

[Anonymous No.5618682]

>>5617453
patch it out if it bothers you so much
otherwise the physics are exactly the same

[Anonymous No.5618829]

>>5614524
I knew that kind of guy would go to neogaf

[Anonymous No.5618983]

>>5603223
not shit sherlock
it was trolling from the start ffs

[Anonymous No.5619665]

>>5614524
>neogaf

[Anonymous No.5619669]

>>5618682
Or just play the original?

[Anonymous No.5620342]

>>5597865
All-Stars isn't a remake, it's an enhanced port.
In today's world it would be called a remaster.
Same goes for the GBA games. They're ports of the All-Stars versions, making them ports of ports.

[Anonymous No.5620740]

>>5619669
If the fix is available why not play the better looking and sounding version?

[Anonymous No.5620850]

I found this random glitch. The block is unusable and I can't even touch it. Wonder if it's fixed in the SNES remake.

[Anonymous No.5620863]

>>5619665
I dont like neofag either, but come on theyre right on thus one.

[Anonymous No.5620929]

>>5598185
I grew up with the All Stars version instead of original, but I agree with every comment in the image.

[Anonymous No.5621031]

>>5597865
Pick the one you have the most nostalgia for.

[Anonymous No.5621038]

>>5620740
>why not play the better looking and sounding version?
Yes, I agree there's no reason not to play the NES version.

[Anonymous No.5622878]

wish the level overworld music was longer than an 8 second loop

[Anonymous No.5622979]

>>5598185
I agree w everything.

[Anonymous No.5623021]

>>5597865
I've always strongly preferred the NES version. It's got a way more unique aesthetic, both among Mario games and among platformers in general. I'm not really an art guy, but it's got this pop art sort of look that I really like. The SNES version still looks pretty good, but everything is pretty generic all things considered. You know, regular old caves and sky backgrounds that you can see in so many other games.

The other thing I don't really like so much in All Stars is the sound design, particularly the sound of stomping on enemies. To me, it comes across as the sound that you'd get when your attack was ineffective. And in-general, while I typically am a fan of the SNES sound chip, it just doesn't seem to quite work for Mario games. Aside from a few bopping tracks, I feel the same about SMW.

>>5609054
>>5609057
Visually speaking, I definitely prefer All Stars SMB1 to the NES version. They really knocked it out of the park with that one, although I also think there was more room for improvement relative to NES SMB3.

[Anonymous No.5623098]

>>5597865
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7E-xBVSbYnM

[Anonymous No.5623102]

>>5597865
They're both fine. Play whatever is more accessible to you to.

[Anonymous No.5623104]

NES is the only version worth playing.