[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/vr/ - Retro Games

View post   
File: 16 KB, 284x177, download (17).jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4172497 No.4172497 [Reply] [Original]

best rpg on snes is dragon quest right

>> No.4172502

>>4172497
I love the franchise but my vote goes for Final Fantasy V.

>> No.4172516

no

>> No.4172517

>>4172502
but dragon quest have kinda better gameplay mechanics

>> No.4172521

>>4172516
then what is

>> No.4172524

>>4172521
you're least favourite gaem

>> No.4172541

This a bait thread?

Chrono Trigger by miles

>> No.4172647

dems fighin words

besides DQIII is nes

>> No.4172656

>>4172647
Has an sfc remake


Best sfc rpg is smt2 followed by dqv

>> No.4172672
File: 14 KB, 326x233, kekels.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4172672

>>4172656
>Best sfc rpg is smt2
yes
>followed by dqv

>> No.4172679

>>4172541
Short, linear, easy.
FF6 is better in every way.

CT is not in the top ten games of all time.
CT is not even in the top ten SNES games.
CT is not even in the top ten SNES RPGs.
CT is maybe able to reach #10 rank in SNES regular RPGs (not action, tactics, or dungeon crawler RPG).

>> No.4172693

>Not smrpg

pleb

>> No.4172743

>>4172497
I think it's a bit unfair to say a remake of a game is the rpg on the system. Still, the DQIII remake is a phenomenal game. Personally I have to say either Dragon Quest V or Earthbound, but that's just me. Metal Max Returns is also great but also a remake.

>> No.4172801

>>4172517

>but dragon quest have kinda better gameplay mechanics
What?

>> No.4172867

No, Lufia 2 is

>> No.4173158

>>4172867
Ma Dekar

>> No.4173183

>>4172502
Fpbp

>> No.4173246

>>4172541
>Chrono Trigger
Normie's choice.

>> No.4173271

>>4172679
>Short
If you get more than 20 hours out of a game it's worth it. 15 hours is even fair.

Getting ending 1 or 2 on a blind run takes longer than that and getting all the endings gives you plenty of replay value

>>4172679
>linear
Open world is a meme. Plus you can jump to different eras at the end of time anyway

>>4172679
>easy
All RPGs are easy when you level up high enough. Grinded a bit in early bloodborne and tore through the rest of the game

>> No.4173371

FFVI and Chrono Trigger are mainstream and overrated as fuck but they're both very good when you look past that. People love to shit all over Chrono to look cool and smart not realizing it makes them seem like obnoxious pedants.

That said I think DQV is probably the best one. Like FFVI it's a good balance between gameplay and story, but DQV's combat is better balanced than FF's. Chrono's battle system was ambitious but didn't have the refinement that DQ and FF had over so many games by that point.

If there are people who have arguments for other beloved ones like Secret of Mana, Star Ocean, Romancing Saga, etc. I'd like to hear them.

>> No.4173761

>>4173371
I played Secret of Mana before any of the turn based games. When i finally did play games like FFVI, i found the battle systems odd an detached in a way, like I was no longer controlling my character

>> No.4173789
File: 117 KB, 1625x876, rpglogo.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4173789

>>4172497
No, Shin Megami Tensei is.

>> No.4173806

>>4172679
What are some good SNES dungeon crawlers?

>> No.4173817

>>4173806
Here you go

>> No.4173837
File: 387 KB, 1600x1200, Brandish.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4173837

>>4173806
The Brandish series

>> No.4174493
File: 103 KB, 600x413, terranigma.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4174493

How many of you remember this game?

>> No.4174564

earthbound

>> No.4175870

Sorry, it was Final Fantasy IV.

>> No.4176050

>>4172497
pretty sure it's earthbound

only rpg with half-decent writing and original concepts

everything else is bog-standard fantasy with about as much thought put into it as a ham sandwich

earthbound was written by an actual essayist

>> No.4176057

>>4172867
Took long enough for the right answer to be posted.

>> No.4176152

>>4176050
this

>> No.4177090

>>4176050
>everything else is bog-standard fantasy with about as much thought put into it as a ham sandwich
Live-A-Live, Secret of Evermore, Metal Max Returns, etc., etc.

>> No.4177106

>>4176050
here come the delusional motherfags with their overrated dragon warrior clone

>> No.4177149

1. Final Fantasy V
2. Super Mario RPG
3. Chrono Trigger
4. Final Fantasy VI
5. Secret of Mana
9001. Earthbound

>> No.4179587

>>4174493
I do
It's just decent

>> No.4179620

>>4174493
It's an action RPG, they tend to not be included in "pure" RPG lists.

>>4172867
It would be, it's just that the story is so fucking stupid it brings down the game. But the post game content (ie Ancient Cave gift mode) is awesome and it is probably one of the best RPGs from a pure gameplay perspective... but what makes it awesome is its rogue-like mode, not the RPG gameplay itself.

>> No.4179672

>>4172497
Dragon Quest V, yes.

>> No.4179754

Have snes emu on phone to play jrpg's in bed. Which SFC Dragon Quest would u recommend?

>> No.4180381

RSaGa 2 and FFV are the ultimate rpgs for the SNES if only because I'm a sucker for job systems. Obviously DQ3 is the third best

>> No.4180385

>>4172497

I'm not a fucking pencil-necked nerd so my vote goes to Super Mario RPG.

>> No.4180465

No, SMRPG is.

>> No.4182572

>>4177149
Switch out smrpg with >>4172497 and it's accurate

>> No.4182703

>>4177149

>normie