[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/vr/ - Retro Games

View post   
File: 71 KB, 326x333, Super_Mario_Land.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3410396 No.3410396 [Reply] [Original]

This game was better than SMB3

>> No.3410407

The first? Nah.

The second? Maybe.

>> No.3410461 [DELETED] 

>>3410396
Fun game but it wasn't made by the normal Mario team and it shows. It doesn't even rank in the top 5 2D Marios. Music is catchy as fuck tho

>>3410407
Mario Land 2 was great... for a handheld game. It feels closer to a traditional Mario title than the first but it still controls semi-oddly. I loved that you could choose which worlds to beat first but that also meant that most worlds had roughly the same difficulty level (except for maybe the Space Zone.) Still is quite a ways away from SMB3-tier

I'd have a much harder time deciding if Wario Land 2/3 were better than SMB3

>> No.3410468

>>3410396
Fun game but it wasn't made by the normal Mario team and it shows. It doesn't even rank in the top 5 2D Marios. Music is catchy as fuck tho

>>3410407
Mario Land 2 was great... for a handheld game. It feels closer to a traditional Mario title than the first but it still controls semi-oddly. I loved that you could choose which worlds to beat first but that also meant that most worlds had roughly the same difficulty level (except for maybe the Space Zone.) Still is quite a ways away from SMB3-tier

I'd have a much harder time deciding if Wario Land 2/3 were better than SMB3

>> No.3410484

>>3410396
Super Mario Land is great, but dude, that's not a fair fight that you're trying to have there.

>> No.3410492 [DELETED] 

>>3410461
Wario Land 3 is one of the best platformers ever. I'd probably put it over SMB3 if I had to.

>> No.3410497

>>3410468
Wario Land 3 is one of the best platformers ever. I'd probably put it over SMB3 if I had to.

>> No.3410503

>>3410468

It's hard to rank Wario Land against SMB3 since they're such different games, despite being platformers. That said, I'd rank them:

SMB3 with a save system > WL2 > SMB3 > WL1 > WL3 >>>>> SML1

The physics in SML1 are pretty bad. They're not "fun" like the other mario's (change direction in midair easily), but at the same time they're not realistic either, so why bother? There's also some glitchy shit with conservation of horizontal momentum when jumping near pipes, which again feels bad and it's the only game in the series that does that. It's a top-tier soundtrack and a fun enough 50 minutes, but nowhere near SMB3.

>> No.3410514
File: 75 KB, 440x660, 1468841368183.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3410514

I love SML but that game is too simple to be compared with SMB3.

I wish Yokoi was still alive, though. His Mario and Wario games had a lot of personality and fun level design.

>> No.3410524

>>3410396
Nah.

The soundtrack is amazing though, one of the most memorable Marios in that regard by far. Neither super mario land is better than the nes games. The wario platformers might be though.

>> No.3410564

I saw Mario Land ported to TI calculator once and thought wow, this doesn't look anything like Mario. I didn't know Mario Land ACTUALLY looked that bad until I went to play it on 3DS VC.

>> No.3411460
File: 744 KB, 597x769, 1346418873687.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3411460

>>3410396
It is a good game and I respect your opinion.

I still like SMB3 more.

>> No.3411664
File: 23 KB, 654x368, 1405487599455.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3411664

Marioland was its own thing and there is no comparasion beatween the two series
I wish nintendo kept doing the marioland series, they were sifferent enough to be good but not too different to turn people off

>> No.3411850

>>3410396
100% wrong

>> No.3411867

>>3410396

This game is fun, but way too short to be compared to SMB3.

>> No.3412708
File: 337 KB, 1280x905, 9499373_p0.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3412708

>>3410514
And the Metroid games under him were actually some of the best games ever made. Metroid 4 was just sort of okay, and Other M...
Also maybe Kid Icarus would still be around. Kid Icarus Uprising is good, but it is just a one-off, and I don't like the "modern anime" aesthetic, characters, or writing style

>> No.3412924

>>3410396
No, but the second game is a good contender. I prefer the Wario Land series anyway; each of the games has its own unique style and they often deviate themselves from traditional platforming. Also, Wario is a more interesting character.

>> No.3413227

>>3410396
Mario Land deserves a certain amount of respect for being the first portable Mario game on the Game Boy.

The game itself isn't very good, but it remains nonetheless significant because of its status as the first Mario game on Game Boy. It's also attached to good ole Gunpei, which means that people have a soft spot for it (as well as the nostalgia).

To say that it's a "better" game than SMB3, however, is ridiculous. SMB3 is a better game in just about every respect.

>> No.3413889

>>3410503
>WL2 over WL3
From a purely platforming angle, MAYBE. WL3 decimates WL2 in ever other respect.

>> No.3413968
File: 45 KB, 560x582, 1470540509690.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3413968

>>3410497

indeed. The entire Wario Land series is phenomenal, but Wario Land 3 is god-tier among god-tier.