[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/vr/ - Retro Games

View post   
File: 699 KB, 903x665, sf2.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2385639 No.2385639 [Reply] [Original]

Let's take this thread to decide the best fighting game of all time. We will pick two, one 2d(or 2.5d) and one 3d. We will first decide on which company makes the best fighters. We have Capcom, Arc System Works, Namco, Baindai (I know the two are fused), SNK.. and I think that's it. Good luck.

>> No.2385646

ASW for 2d with Xrd being the best game
Namco for 3d with Soul Calibur 2 being the best game.

>> No.2385653
File: 240 KB, 850x1224, vampire1428623651073.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2385653

2D: Vampire Savior
3D: Virtua Fighter 2

>> No.2385657
File: 90 KB, 617x570, fbafac9d5e73831366070e57368dd41c.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2385657

>>2385653
>my nigga
agree with this 100%

>> No.2385658
File: 18 KB, 248x270, air-zonk-2.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2385658

>>2385653
My black brother

>> No.2385662

>>2385639
>decide the best fighting game of all time

If anything other than Super Turbo wins then this list is a joke.

>which company makes the best fighters

Capcom was most consistently great, but SNK probably had the largest quantity of quality games.

>> No.2385665
File: 36 KB, 250x250, 250px-PROJECT_DC.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2385665

Vampire Savior 2d
Project Justice 3d

>> No.2385669

>>2385653
>>2385657
>>2385658
>>2385665
>weeaboos
SSF2 2d
SC2 3d

>> No.2385679

>>2385669

Vampire Savior is westaboo as fuck.

>> No.2385683

>>2385662
vampire savior is more balanced/fun/interesting than turbo will ever be

>> No.2385687

>>2385646
>xrd being the best game
>not xxac

>> No.2385694

>>2385683
>vampire savior
>fun/interesting

>> No.2385695

I always wondered why Virtua Fighter 2 gets so much love over 3tb I thought 3tb was the better game

>> No.2385703

>>2385683
Well, I'm convinced.

>> No.2385705
File: 157 KB, 700x1000, wendy_ryan_from_psychic_force_by_ryugassj3-d8dh2x6.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2385705

2D: Guilty Gear XX #Reload
3D: Psychic Force 2012

>> No.2385720

>>2385653
i bet you dont even play either

>> No.2385728

>>2385720
I bet you're bad at guessing.

>> No.2385738

No Ultimate Ninja 3?
I know this is a retro board but
Ultimate Ninja 3 for 3d
Blazblue CP for 2d
Fighting games are just getting better guys. More balanced and everything. Time to take off the nostalgia glasses for a bit.

>> No.2385760

2D - Either Kof 98 or Garou
3D - I'm not educated enough, so I'd rather not say anything than parrot popular opinions and pretend I know what I'm talking about.

>> No.2385767

2D Street Fighter 3rd Strike
3D Soul Calibur II

>> No.2385994

reopening for discussion

>> No.2386020

2d = KOF '98
3d = Street Fighter EX

>> No.2386048

>>2385639
Personal:
2d marvel vs Capcom 2
3d Soul Calibur
Other Smash Melee

More "objective"
Street Fighter 2 Turbo
Virtua Fighter 4
Smash melee

I think Capcom wins because they have a selection of top tier 2d fighters, high quality 3d fighters, and some other cool stuff like Powerstone Muscle bomber.

>> No.2386102
File: 137 KB, 548x820, 1370824704057.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2386102

2D: Super Turbo
3D: Tekken 5 DR

Capcom has the best set of critically-acclaimed 2D games (HF, ST, A2, MvC2, CvS2, 3S, Vsav) so I'd give the crown to them. Although I haven't really liked a Capcom fighter since MvC2, but that's just my opinion. Arcsys is a good company too but a lot of their games are overrated, although GG is general is pretty good.

>> No.2386243

>>2385679
He's probably never actually played the series to see that it's based on Hollywood movie monsters, that everything squashes and stretches like Looney Tunes, that most of the characters look like something out of a cape comic, etc. He probably just saw some shitty Morrigan and Felicia fanart and maybe a couple awful crossover appearances, like most people who run their mouths about Darkstalkers.

>> No.2386252

>>2386243

Also the Vampire series producer is a big Marvel nerd, which eventually led to the X-men vs SF and Marvel vs Capcom games.

>> No.2386273

>>2385639
2D: Last Blade 2
3D: Bushido Blade 2

>> No.2386298

Bloody Roar

>> No.2386305

2d: Super Turbo
3d: Street fighter Ex2 Plus

>> No.2386310

>>2385639
2D: Vampire Savior
3D: Bloody Roar 3

>> No.2386321

>>2386102
2nding Tekken 5 DR I can't believe that wasn't listed yet. That is objetively the best 3d fighter to date until 7 releases

>> No.2386324

>>2386102
>games are overrated
>GG is pretty good
why do nerds keep saying this? Blazblue is the better game. It's a great game

>> No.2386335
File: 2.10 MB, 1680x1050, Dying of Laughter.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2386335

>>2386324
>Blazblue is the better game.

>> No.2386364
File: 186 KB, 1024x768, Bloody_Roar_3_Wallpaper_01.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2386364

>>2386321
Sorry but Bloody Roar is objectively better than Tekken, even Tekken devs know it since they copied Bloody Roars mechanics and even got the Bloody Roar development team to make DR

>> No.2386451

>>2386324
I don't want my kids to live in a world where you exist.

>> No.2386459
File: 223 KB, 1000x1000, Dohma bros.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2386459

2D:a tie between Vampire Saviour and GGAC+, honorable mention goes to 3S.
3D:Soul Calibur 4 without Mister Roogieor Bloody Roar 3.

>> No.2386562

>>2386364

Exactly how is Tekken a copy of Bloody Roar when it came out three years before? Also every Tekken game was developed in-house by Namco, mostly under the direction of Katsuhiro Harada, who hasn't outsourced any Tekken Project outside of Tekken Hybrid's CG movie.

>> No.2386593

>>2386324
I'm more of a fan of Blazblue than GG, but even I'll admit that GG is overall the better game. I do have more fun with Blazblue though.

>> No.2386596

2D: A really hard tie between VSav and Garou.

3D: I really love Virtua Fighter, but it's probably Soul Calibur 2 or Bloody Roar.

>> No.2386620

>>2385760
Garou is decent, but I don't know how you could even put it in the same ballpark as '98.

'98 for best 2D, hands down.

3D I will leave to the others, I don't care about those.

>> No.2386648

2D is 98's turf, I'll accept Super Turbo as a runner-up

3D I don't know as well but I'm leaning toward VF for nostalgia factor

>> No.2386798

>>2385705
Psychic Force 2012 master race

>> No.2387163

>>2386562
Bloody Roar had backdash canceling, bound, wall splat, crushing and guard attack long before Tekken did.

>Also every Tekken game was developed in-house by Namco
Flase, Eighting has worked with Namco on development more than once.

>> No.2387176

2d- SSF2
3d- VF2 although DOA2 with buds is beast

>> No.2387860

>>2386620
Garou was more of a runner up, I do prefer 98 as well.
But Garou is so damn fucking charming, and it's a fantastical game on it's own right, it's only drawbacks are the small cast and how simplified most supers are, I really hate the Power Geyser command in that game, just doesn't feel right.

But even then, I still prefer Garou over any Capcom fighter, so I gave it an honorable mention.