/vr/ - Retro Games

S&K > S2 > S3 > S1

>>7731087
>S1 last
Filtered zoomer detected.

>>7731102
i like the game but its just weird. no spin dash, a few levels that are clearly designed for slow pace as if they were made for mario and not sonic. it's a very comfy game but not a very good one

>>7731080
correct.

1 is the best

>>7731080
S3k > Kin2 > 2 > Spinball > 1 > 3D Blast >>>>>>>> CD

S3&K > S2 > S1 > S3

i like them all about the same honestly

>>7732408
Same. They're all pretty enjoyable, and pairing S&K with 3 or 2 is a lot of fun.

>>7731080
Yes.

Also SOR2 > SOR3

Shadowthedge.png>sonic

>>7731201
Didn’t ask, shit taste

It's widely accepted that 2 is the best in the series.

Sonic 3 and Knuckles are 2 separate games that join for a single narrative and can't be rated as a single entry. In fact only the autists on /vr/ refer to it thusly because "muh dev's intentions" while every normal same person view Sonic and Knuckles as the 4th title in the series that just happens to have a lock on feature with the previous 2 games.

S3K blows Sonic 2 out of the water at everything but music, which Sonic 2 is simply the best at. S3K's branching level design is unparalleled, diverse and highly replayable. Its 3 selectable (1 player) characters makes it an even more replayable game. It also does away with most forms of "go fast -> get punished" philosophy that still has a few relics in Sonic 2 - generally the failure state of the game is dropping to a different route of the stage, not death - and also doesn't have Sky Chase Zone, which no one wants to wait through.

Sonic 1 is better than Sonic CD. These are a separate style of games from Sonic 2 and 3. Sonic 1 isn't about speed so much as moment. Sonic CD just thinks it's a methodical slow platformer. They play like one style that only one successfully executed.

Sonic = Trash

I wish "ugly man picture, opinion with no other point" posting was ban worthy.

>>7733107
>S3K blows Sonic 2 out of the water at everything but music
No zone from S3K matches Chemical Plant.

>>7733158
Chemical Plant isn't even the best zone in Sonic 2. It's pretty mid aside from the music.

>>7733761
Good thing they were talking about the music.

>>7733158
Absolutely. I also prefer Emerald Hill to Angel Island. But that's a low proportion of the game.

>>7734117
Nooooo. You can't like Sonic 2. S3K is better in everyway!!!

>>7734818
Chemical Plant Zone is the best zone
S3K is the best game
These are both true and not conflicting statements.

>>7733779
>No zone from S3K matches Chemical Plant.
Reading comprehension isn't your strong suit, is it?

>>7731080
Being a contrarian doesn't make you more chad.

>>7735453
>>7735459
Multiple anons in this thread prefer sonic 2 over S3K. Face it 2's zones feel right and there's no stupid barrel haulting progress.

>>7735471
There's the SKY CHASE ZONE halting progress instead, for much longer than the 5 seconds to get by a single barrel. There's also godawful shit zones like Mystic Cave and Aquatic Ruin, and medium-shit zones Casino Night and Oil Ocean. Think about how much of the game is left if you "only consider the good zones".

>>7731080
Why are memes homo now

>>7731080

>>7735481
>Autoscroller = bad
Congratulations on being a drone who can't think for himself. SMW hacks show the power of autoscrollers really well.

https://youtu.be/fXqVmc2Awe0?t=117

And theres nothing wrong with Aquatic ruin. Just don't fall down to the bottom sections.

>>7735647
look at that chode lmao

>>7736745
Don't be mean, he has aids

>>7735913
That's an example of a poor autoscroller. Nothing fucking interesting going on for 12 minutes and if you snooze and get crushed it's all over again from the beginning.

>>7736851
Its a piss easy level. Don't spin dash and you should be right. I would play Sky chase over Marble Zone.

poor Sega want to bury Sonic so badly and forget about him but they can't