[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/vr/ - Retro Games

View post   
File: 743 KB, 2896x2896, 20181127_051607.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5184167 No.5184167 [Reply] [Original]

Rank these classic games from best to worst

>> No.5184169

SMB3>SMW>S&K3>S2

>> No.5184170

>>5184167
SMW>Sonic<SMB3

>> No.5184171

>>5184167
smb3>s3&k>smw>s2

>> No.5184172

SMW > S2 > S3 > SMB3

>> No.5184181

>>5184167
Does the ability to be Knuckles in Sonic 2 apply? Or are we talking just regular non-docked Sonic 2?

>> No.5184184

>>5184167
SMW > Sonic 2 > SMB3 > Sonic 3&K

>> No.5184186

SMW > Sonic 2 > SMB3 > Sonic 3

>> No.5184192

>>5184167
S3&k> the others

>> No.5184230

>>5184167
S3& K > SMB3 > S2 > SMW

>> No.5184315

>>5184167
SMB3>Sonic 2>World>>>>>>>>S&K

>> No.5184329

Mario 3 > Mario World

>> No.5184340

>>5184167
SMW>S3&K>SMB3>Sonic2

>> No.5184353

Super Mario World

>> No.5184360

>>5184167
Sonic 3 is nowhere near 1 or 2.

>> No.5184394

>>5184167
s3 = smb3 > s2 > smw

>> No.5184397

>>5184171
/thread

>> No.5184407

>>5184167
S3&K > SMB3 > Sonic 2 > SMW

S3&K is the best 16 bit platformer for sure. I'd love to see Mania's dropdash implemented in in combined with the insta-shield move.

>> No.5184416

>>5184329
/thread

>> No.5184421

SMB3>S3&K>S2>SMW

>> No.5184452

Super mario advance 4 > super mario advance 2

>> No.5184458

For me its S3&K>Mario3>>SMW>S2
I love all these games, though

>> No.5184461

>>5184169
fpbp

>> No.5184468

>>5184169
This

>> No.5184470

SMW > S3&K > SMB3 > S2

>> No.5184481

>>5184167
S3&K>SMB3>SMW>S2

>> No.5184484

>>5184167
>>5184167

SMW = SMB3 > S3&K >>> S2

They're all good games, honestly, and I rank S3&K quite closely behind SMW and SMB3. S2 is the stinker of the lot. Not a bad game, it's just not as good as the rest.

>> No.5184528

In what twisted universe is SMW better than Sonic 2 let alone SMB3?

>> No.5184532

SMW>SMB3>S3&K>StH2
they're all good but the mario games and sonic games just don't compare

>> No.5184546
File: 1.01 MB, 800x900, sms_sonicthehedgehog_eu.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5184546

>>5184167
Pic related no.1
>Sonic 3
>Sonic 2
>SMW
>SMB3

>> No.5184587

SM3 > SMW >>>>>>>>> sonic3K/>sonic2

>> No.5184656

This thread just shows we will never agree on this subject.
I suspect OP just wants to watch the world burning.

>> No.5184663

>>5184167
Sonic 2 > S3&K > SMW > SMB3

>> No.5184669

>>5184167
World > 3 >>>>>>>>>>>>> Sonik

>> No.5184685

>>5184171
this

>> No.5184734

>>5184360
> sonic 1 better than any other classic sonic

i understand the "it was amazing when it came out" argument, but man that game is such a chore to play through compared to 2 or 3

>> No.5184746

I only like SMB1, SMB2J, S1 and SCD.

SMB3, SMW, S2, and S3&K all casualised the gameplay too much for my tastes.

>> No.5184752

>>5184167
SMW > SM3 > S3&K > Sonic 2

>> No.5184765

>>5184167
I never understood the fags who compared Italian Pedo Plumber to Furry The Yiffer

>> No.5184890

>>5184167
SMW > S2 > S3 > SMB3

>> No.5185012

>>5184167
SB3 = S2 > S&K3 > SMW

>> No.5185024

>>5184734
git gud spindash baby

>> No.5185047

>>5184167
Mario 3 > Mario World > I dunno about those other 2 to be honest.
Anyone not putting mario 3 at the top has shit for brains.

>> No.5185120

>>5184167
1. SMW
2. S3&K
3. SMB3
4. S2

>> No.5185307

SMB3 > S3&K > S2 > SMW

>> No.5185313

>>5185024
yeah but i always get bored by the time i get to marble zone act 3

>> No.5185315

3=world > Sanic 2 > 3 & K

>> No.5185316

>>5184734
Sounds like this faggot sucks at physics-based platforming.

>> No.5185328

Sonic 2 > Mario 3 > Sonic 3 & Knuckles > Mario World

>> No.5185372

SMW > SMB3 > S2 > S3

>> No.5185401

I'd rather play Sonic games.

So, Sonic 3&K > Sonic 2 > SMW > SMB3.

>> No.5185412
File: 216 KB, 1280x720, super-mario-world-1280jpg-eedf17_1280w.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5185412

Super Mario World
>Huge overworld
>Creative powerups and level concepts
>Solid difficulty curve with a few hiccups
>Coherent, pleasing aesthetic
>Catchy tunes
>Tons of secrets + replay value

Then Sonic 3 & Knuckles
>Bitchin' OST
>Huge levels, fun to explore
>Blast processing
>Nice replay value (Tails + Knux)
>Blue sphere sucks my blue balls
>THE FUCKING BARREL

Then Sonic 2
>Tight experience
>Fair challenge
>Blast processing
>Marginally superior minigame to blue sphere
>Rockin' OST
>Tails is lame
>No replay value

Then Super Mario Bros 3
>Cool powerups, not implemented well
>Some fun levels
>Exploration is only on the overworld, levels don't have many secrets
>Even then, you only find more powerups instead of more levels
>No replay value

>> No.5185432
File: 184 KB, 1228x1228, 1541452481380.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5185432

>mfw the "Sonic was never good" meme is finally dying

>> No.5185436

>>5185432
It'll come back around again in your lifetime

>> No.5185441

SMW > S3&K > SMB3 > S2

>> No.5185868

S3&K > SMW > S2 >>>>>>>>>> SMB3

>> No.5186039

>>5184167
SMW>SMB3>Sonic 2>Large gap>S&K

>> No.5186040

>>5184167

Sonic 2, worst
Mario 3, havent played, it looks like shit
Super Marioworld probably as shit as sonic 2
Sonic & Knuckles goes ok

>> No.5186151

>>5185432
It's not exactly a meme per se, just some die hard anti-Sonicfags.

>> No.5186157

Sonic 2 is very nostalgic shit and the early levels, visuals and the music are all extremely memorable, but all Sonic games are a mess in terms of game design. In terms of game design, there can be no comparison to major Nintendo platformers like SMB3 and SMW.

>> No.5186252

>>5186157
S&K blows mario world out of the water.

>> No.5186271

>>5186040
>Mario 3, havent played, it looks like shit
get the fuck off my board normie REEEEEEEEEEE

>> No.5186273

KID CHAMELOEN >Sonic 2 > Mario 3 > S3&K > SMW, and this is simply because i never really liked SMW, it never struck a chord with me

>> No.5186278

>>5186271

no. no. no... let me correct that please, Mario 3 did look .... like utter HORSE SHIT even back then. Thanks, go on mate.

>> No.5186304

>>5186278
/v/ is that way >>>>>>>

>> No.5186895

>>5184167
SMW > SMB3 > S3&K > S2

>> No.5186925

SMB3 > S2 > SMW > S3&K

SMW and S3&K are flawed as deeply as the village whore.

>> No.5187443

>>5185316
I've beaten all of the genesis sonic games numerous times, and I do really like sonic 1, I just haven't had the patience to beat the whole game in one sitting in a long time

>> No.5187482

>>5184167
how about
SMB3: really good
Sonic 2: really good
Sonic 3 and Knuckles: really good
Super Mario World: really good

>> No.5187572

>>5184167

SMB3 > SANIC2 > SMW > SANIC3&KEKLES

>> No.5187606

Douby doondo dooby doo dilydislyhole. Is that the sms version of sonic 2?

>> No.5187610

>>5185412

Mein negger

>> No.5187623

S3 > SMB3 > S&K = SMW > S2

>> No.5187645

>>5184167
SM3>>S3K>S2>SMW

>> No.5187646

>>5185412
> sonic 2 minigame superior to blue sphere

really

the sonic 2 minigame is so god damn boring

>> No.5188158

>>5184181
>HURRRRR DURRR DOES ROMHACK COUNT GUISEEEEE PLSSSSS TELL ME THIS AFFECTS MY RANKING

>> No.5188159

>>5184230
The only correct response

>> No.5188287
File: 15 KB, 323x323, solo.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5188287

>>5185412
>No replay value
All of these games have good replay value.