[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/vr/ - Retro Games


View post   

File: 2.22 MB, 4020x2300, Sega-Genesis-Mod1-Bare.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4918712 No.4918712 [Reply] [Original]

Why was the Sega Genesis so lacking in the JRPG department?

>> No.4918713

>>4918712
Quantity =/= Quality, my new friend. The titles it had were cool enough, especially their action RPGs.

>> No.4918896

>>4918713
No they weren't, I had to delete my Genesis emu because I couldn't find a great jrpg.
I blame the Snes literally taking all of them for itself. Then the same happened with Psx except that Nintendo at least did a first pary great rpg, Of course it pales in comparison to all jrpgs the Psx has.
We should be thankful that one sided shit didn't happen in future gens

>> No.4918904

>>4918896
>couldn't find a great JRPG
Phantasy Star IV
Shining in the Darkness
Shining Force II

>> No.4918991

>>4918712
Nintendo and PC-Engine snapped up market share and prominent developers before Sega had much of a chance. A lot of the time it's who gets there first

>> No.4919048

>>4918713
Sure, but JPRGs on Sega were basically shit so that statement doesn't actually matter because it had neither quantity nor quality. Also, ARPGs are not JRPGs.

That being said, Genesis did better on general action titles overall than the SNES did. Also sports but who the fuck cares.


>>4918904
Phantasy Star is trash - but at least you chose the best one. The early ones are extremely garbage.
Shining Force II isn't an RPG, it's a tactics game.
Shining in Darkness is a Dungeon Crawler not a JRPG.

>> No.4919104

>>4918712
The weirdos at Sega were obsessed with arcade games and assumed people wanted that kind of shallow rushed play on their comfy home console so they did nothing to get that genre on it.

It still had at least a dozen pretty good ones.

>> No.4919173

When it comes to story driven turn based JRPG's, well it's one of the weakest libraries in the the Genesis/ Mega Drive. Sure it's not totally barren of RPG's and there are a few good ones on the Sega CD as well.

But generally, the Genesis/ Mega Drive library is much more focused on action RPG's. The system has a pretty varied library of RPG sub genres, but there are still quite a large number of multi-platform ports. Not the biggest RPG library from the 16bit consoles.

Here's a list just coming off the top of my head:

> Turn based:
Phantasy Star II
Phantasy Star III
Phantasy Star IV
(Phantasy Star 1 was also released on the Mega Drive in Japan, but it is the Master System ROM in a MD cart)
Lunar Silver Star Story (Sega/ Mega CD)
Lunar Eternal Blue (Sega/ Mega CD)
Vay (Sega/ Mega CD)

> Action RPG :
Land Stalker
Story of Thor (Beyond Oasis)
Light Crusader
Crusader of Centy (Soleil)
Technoclash
Sword of Vermilion


> Action RPG sidescrollers:
Wonder Boy in Monster World
Monster World IV
Ys III: Wanderers from Ys
Exile
Cadash
Popful Mail (Sega/ Mega CD)

> Dungeon Crawlers
Shining in the Darkness
Might and Magic
Might and Magic III
The Immortal
Arcyss Odyssey

> Stratagy RPG's
Shining Force
Shining Force II
Shining Force CD (Sega/ Mega CD)
Warsong
Langrisser
Buck Rogers : Countdown to Doomsday

> CRPG's:
Shadowrun
Pirates Gold!
Dungeons and Dragons

> Rouge Like
Fatal Labyrinth
Starflight

Plus there are also after market RPG's like Pier Solar and Beggar Prince, as well as some of those unlicensed Taiwanese RPG's.

Plus the system has quite a few RPG's that were left behind in Japan. I have no idea what any of those ones are like, though.

>> No.4919180

>>4919104
>The weirdos at Sega were obsessed with arcade games and assumed people wanted that kind of shallow rushed play on their comfy home console so they did nothing to get that genre on it.

It wasn't that weird. Sega made the majority of their profits in the arcades back then. The arcade was always their central focus, so they aimed their home consoles in this direction too.

Back then, Nintendo had a legitimate monopoly on third party console developers. It made the home console market hard to get into back then. But Sega still had a lot of good teams dedicated to making console exclusives.

>> No.4919181

>>4919048
>Shining in Darkness is a Dungeon Crawler not a JRPG.
How retarded can you be? Many JRPGs had 1st person dungeon exploration, especially computer ones. Do you consider Shin Megami Tensei not to be a JRPG either?

>> No.4919186

>>4919104
>an arcade game developer wanted to bring arcade style games to the home console market
How is that weird? Arcade games were actually still popular back then and it was a good decision at the time.

>> No.4919190

>>4918712
reminder that the genesis was the poor kids console

>> No.4919213

>>4919181
>How retarded can you be? Many JRPGs had 1st person dungeon exploration, especially computer ones. Do you consider Shin Megami Tensei not to be a JRPG either?

90% of Shining in the Darkness takes place in dungeons. Dungeon crawlers were pretty big in Japan back then, and I'm pretty sure that was the goal of Shining in the Darkness. Even the title of the game implies that it's a dungeon crawler.

I agree that a lot of JRPG's have first person moments in them. The original Phantasy Star on the Sega Master System has first person dungeons, but it is not a dungeon crawler.

>> No.4919215

>>4919190
reminder you were a poorcuck with a shitty childhood if you didn't own a snes, genesis, turbografx, neogeo, 3do, jaguar and at least 50 games for each system

>> No.4919251

>>4918712
Coz it had really solid action rpgs instead, which are more fun to play in 2018 because they don't have dated grinding and aren't overloaded with terrible sub shounen anime tier writing.

>> No.4919342

>>4918896
>I had to delete my Genesis emu
Why would you do this? A single photo on my phone takes up more disk space than a Genesis emulator.

>> No.4919605

>>4919173
>and there are a few good ones on the Sega CD as well.

Here is a pretty complete list of SEga CD RPG's:

http://www.racketboy.com/retro/the-sega-cd-mega-cd-rpg-library

Most of the Sega/ Mega CD RPG's were left behind in Japan. If it wasn't for groups like Working Designs, The Sega CD would have been almost barren of RPG's in the west. Working Designs were going to localize more Sega CD games for the west, but the system just wan;t popular enough and was quickly overshadowed by the 32bit machines, which WD switched focus to.

There were also quite a large number of Dungeon Crawler-like RPG's for the add-on left behind in Japan.

>> No.4919612

>>4919181
Actually Dragon Quest is the only JRPG ever made.
SMT? It's a turn based first person magic monster shooter.

>> No.4919618 [DELETED] 

>>4918712
Only blacks and white trash had the Genesis, these people don't have the patience and intellect required for jrpgs

>> No.4919623

>>4918712
Because it was made to be a video GAME console.

>> No.4919635

>>4919048
Phantasy Star IV is just as good as FFIV, FFV, Lufia and Breath of Fire.

Dungeon Crawlers are RPGs.

>> No.4919638

>>4919635
ROFL look at this dude

>> No.4919642

>>4919635
I hope it isn't as good as Breath of Fire II because that was pretty mediocre.

>> No.4919646

>>4919638
Not him but Phantasy Star IV is a better JRPG than every single one on SNES with the possible exception of Chrono Trigger and Final Fantasy VI. It's a top-3-for-the-generation game.

>> No.4919648
File: 152 KB, 800x401, 839e8cb0248245e6fa94905f1c7aeb59.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4919648

>> No.4919652

>>4919638
The only RPGs on SNES that match or beat PSIV are FFVI, CT and MAYBE Lufia 2

If you're into Earthbound I guess that qualifies also, not my type of game tho

>> No.4919658

>>4919646
ff6 is overrated trash. It's not better than FF5, dq5 it's own rom hack (RS3), Lufia 2 and even Earthbound. And this ignoring action rpgs and western ones.

>> No.4919660

>>4919646
Chrono Trigger and Final Fantasy VI aren't even as good as Romancing SaGa 2.

>> No.4919661

>>4919658
>>4919660
Romancing SaGa doesn't count as it was never released in the US

>> No.4919785

Out of the JRPGs released in english at that time, Phantasy Star IV and Lunar II are both top 5 material.

>> No.4919857

The console that wins Japan wins JRPGS. Sega was dead last, since the NES came out before it and scooped up plenty of developers, the PC Engine enticed developers by being somewhat similar architecturally to the NES, and the SNES continued in the legacy of the NES.

>> No.4919873 [DELETED] 

>>4918712
It was the least popular console (compared to SFC and PCE) in Japan. In the days pre-Final Faggotry VII, JRPGs were a niche genre in the west (almost nonexistant in Europe and a growing niche in the US at best).
So it's understandable that devs tried to appeal to the international market in a console that was more popular outside of Japan.

>> No.4919880 [DELETED] 

>>4919104
Classy /vr/ anti-arcade rethoric

>> No.4919893 [DELETED] 

>>4919880
If you're really an arcade hardcore gam3r, you wouldn't waste time with Sega's home system ports though, only the real thing at the real arcade centers, competing against the real dudes in Japan. Accept no fakes, /vg/-kun.

>> No.4919895 [DELETED] 

>>4919893
Why are you still this assblasted? Let it go

>> No.4919896 [DELETED] 

>>4919895
Assblasted about what? Just telling it how it is

>> No.4919909 [DELETED] 

>>4919896
Arcade posters have pretty much left the board and you're still angry at them

>> No.4919924 [DELETED] 

>>4919909
>Arcade posters
No such thing. /vg/-kuns are just kids roleplaying as "hardcore arcade players", but they just spend their days watching superplays of japanese guys and getting angry at "dads" buying expensive PCBs.
The real "arcade posters" are here on /vr/, since they actually did play arcades back in the day, but they don't care enough to engage in useless shitposting wars.
Cheers.

>> No.4919929 [DELETED] 

>>4919909
They're still here, they just don't have much to post because arcade games are necessarily shallow, not that it's a bad thing.

>> No.4919943 [DELETED] 

>>4919924
>No such thing. /vg/-kuns are just kids roleplaying as "hardcore arcade players"
Want me to post some twitch accounts from regulars there?

>> No.4919947 [DELETED] 

>>4919943
>twitch
Nah, got some tapes of them playing at real arcades back in the 80s/90s, though?

>> No.4919958

>>4919880
>>4919893
>>4919895
>>4919896
>>4919909
>>4919924
>>4919929
>>4919943
>>4919947
Why did you delete?

>> No.4919963

>>4919958
Because /vg/ needs to stop being tsundere for their big brother.

>> No.4920013 [DELETED] 

>>4919958
Because you know who loves you know what and hates the other thing. Same stalker on the vg thread
>>4919963
More like you need to stop sucking off Big Brother mentality

>> No.4920043

Why would anybody want to waste the infinite processing power of the Motorola 68000 on slow moving text box games?

>> No.4920214

i'm not sure if it's complete, but here a list with JRPGs released for the Genesis / MD (either cart or CD formats):

>jrpg / dungeon crawler
Phantasy Star
Phantasy Star II
Phantasy Star III
Phantasy Star IV
Lunar: Silver Star
Lunar: Eternal Blue
Blue Almanac
Vay
Surging Aura
Cosmic Fantasy Stories
After Armageddon Gaiden
Daihoushinden
Seima Densetsu 3X3 Eyes
Shining in the Darkness
Death Bringer
Fhey Area
Illusion City
Shin Megami Tensei
Aisle Lord
Alshark
Dragon Slayer
Dragon Slayer II
Burai
Traysia
Arcus I-II-III
Maten no Soumetsu
Fatal Labyrinth
Funky Horror Band
*Beggar Prince
*Brave Battle Saga
*Legend of Wukong
*Pier Solar
*Ya-Se Chuan Shuo
*Tunshi Tiandi III

>s-rpg

Shining Force
Shining Force II
Shining Force CD
Langrisser
Langrisser II
Dark Wizard
Vixen 357
Sorcerer's Kingdom
Record of Lodoss War
Shadowrun CD
*Tiger Hunter Hero Novel
*Fengshen Jiengchuan

*unoficial releases

>> No.4920285

>>4919648
I don't get it. Did the PA guys actually ignore the 16-bit consoles? Back then everyone knew Streets of Rage, Phantasy Star, Shinobi, etc. The only difference is Nintendo continues their old franchises while Sega doesn't. So I can get why babies assume the Genesis only had Sonic and spots, but these boomers?

>> No.4920291

>>4920285
They only had what their parents gave them.

>> No.4920312

>>4920285
Guess PA guys were nintendards

>> No.4920314

>>4920312
nintendorks is what we called them. We weren't clever enough to think of NoFriendo.

>> No.4920424

>>4920285
that was the "joke"

>> No.4921060

>>4920312
>>4920314
>PA didn't bike to their friends' houses to play uncensored MK and practice Ghouls N Ghosts for when they went to the arcade
Explains a lot actually.

>> No.4921078

>>4920013
>More like you need to stop sucking off Big Brother mentality
It's true though, although it's not all of /vg/, just the shmup general. If you don't believe me, check it out right now, it's mostly about they being mad at /vr/. Even some of them acknolwedge that there's some shitposters there that come here and then also shit up their general.
Weird people.

>> No.4921287

>>4920214
>*unoficial releases

Has anyone here ever played any of unlicensed Taiwanese RPG's? They have always looked interesting to me.

>> No.4921563

>>4918712
Because you can't read japanese I guess

>> No.4921571

>>4921060
>Had a Genesis
>Friend has a SNES
>Go over to each other's houses and play the good shit for each system.
That was true friendship, it crossed consoles.

>> No.4921598

>>4919213
>90% of Shining in the Darkness takes place in dungeons.
Dungeon crawlers ARE RPGs you dense retard.

>> No.4921610

>>4921598
>Dungeon crawlers ARE RPGs you dense retard.

Sure. But they are still a distinctive sub genre of RPG. I don't really count them as JRPG's.

>> No.4921636

>>4921610
>I don't really count them as JRPG's.
The japanese ones fully qualify as JRPGs, therefore they're JRPGs.

>> No.4923978

Jarpigs are for fags.

>> No.4924113
File: 260 KB, 1542x1080, sorcerer's kingdom.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4924113

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pZEZc6uHVtc

Sorcerer's Kingdom is one of the overlooked Genesis RPGs and one of my favorites on the system. It's a turn-based strategy RPG where you control a group of adventurers and go on little quests to increase your rank within the kingdom. A story develops over time, but for most of the game, the quests are discrete adventures that don't have much to do with each other; you're just ridding the land of evil and exploring.

It's a lot of fun, there's a real sense of adventure to it and more people need to check it out.

>> No.4924127

>>4923978
That's why I like them. They're much more enjoyable now that they include content specifically for fujoshi :-)

>> No.4924136

>>4924127
>A Fujoshit outs himself
Time for the rope, my friend.

>> No.4924912

>>4924136
>fujo
>him
That isn't how it works, sweaty.

>> No.4924917

>>4924912
Traps aren't women.

>> No.4924945

>>4918712
Cartridge limitation. NES and SNES games optimized their carts better when it came to saving and mechanics for RPGs. NES/SNES had a LOT of RPGs because it has been done far longer. Genesis had few because SEGA focused more on arcade/action/platformer games.

>> No.4924946

>>4924136
What's wrong with RPGs with same-sex options, honey? Too scared to deviate from your cuckold fetish porn?
I enjoy the tears every time a dev includes LGBT characters in their game. The thought of cuckservatives getting rustled all over the world makes my dick hard.

>> No.4924952
File: 402 KB, 730x780, 1458057968290.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4924952

>>4921610
>this Japanese Role Playing Game is not a Japanese Role Playing Game

>> No.4924956

>>4924946
>Says the fatass mouth breathing activist for the 17th time today as xe plays the latest hit from a AAA studio that panders to xer fetishes. "Those Misogynistic shitlords wouldn't know a good game if it bit their faces off"
>Xe then sees the sales for the game being poor within a month of that statement and cries that xer favorite game isn't liked and blames Misogynist dudebros and goobergaters for not liking it.
>Xe then demands more representation despite not learning that Social Justice does not sell and winds up having a heart attack from being so angry all the time

>> No.4924974

>>4918712

Because NO ONE cared for RPG's until Final Fantasy 6 came along. Especially in the west.

>> No.4924976

>>4924917

Women are fat.

>> No.4924992

>>4924952
It's worse when it goes like;

>All JRPG's are the same!
>Someone shows some JRPG that it's not the same.
>That's not a true JRPG!

>> No.4924994

>>4924974
>Especially in the west.

Only in the west.

>> No.4925024

>>4924956
Who are you attempting to quote? Nobody requested the use of meme pronouns or tumblr social justice, I think your brain has been fried by /pol/ propaganda. Does it upset youso much that people want more options for gay relationships in their roleplaying videgames which already feature straight relationships? Did a gay individual cause you emotional trauma at some point in your life?

>> No.4925048

>>4925024
Careful, you'll make the janitor uncomfortable.

>> No.4925052

>>4925048
He's too busy fucking with random anons on /vg/'s shumps and 2hu threads to bother checking up on /vr/ right now.

>> No.4925069
File: 108 KB, 1080x1440, 196569700.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4925069

>>4924917
if they pass, they are

only a faggot wouldn't fuck Poison

>> No.4925110

>>4918712
bcause only black people owned a genesis, fact.

>> No.4925168

>>4918712
you weren't look hard enough

>> No.4925171

>>4925069
Poison is actually a real woman, not a trans. They just called her trans so that parents or SJW's wouldn't get upset over men beating up a woman in a video game. However this doesn't seem to be the issue with Streets Of Rage, since Sega catered to a different audience.

>> No.4925223

>>4924917
>Fujoshi specifically refers to women who like gay porn/BL you nunce.

>> No.4925269

>>4924946
We just don't want our favorite video game characters to get AIDS, that's all.

>> No.4925274

>>4924952

I just call them JRPGDC's for ultimate accuracy.

>> No.4925325

>>4925171
>inb4 newhalf concept artwork
I really don't think she's anything other than a woman in either version since she was outright replaced in North America with those punk rock thugs. I know they were thinking about making them trans to get them under the radar in North America but since they were replaced, I've never seen anything outside of concept art that definitively states that she wasn't born a woman.

>> No.4925380

>>4919173
>starflight a roguelike

Wait, what.... is this true?

>> No.4925427

>>4925223
You misread. He's saying I'm trans and he wants everyone to know he's transphobic. I'm actually a cis dude but I often like what fujoshi like

>> No.4925472
File: 164 KB, 1240x786, 5ae.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4925472

>>4925269
>Gay=AIDS
Nice logic shithead
>inb4 AIDS/HIV infection rates pics
NIce try. Even though its true that on average gay males have a higher rate of HIV/AIDS in many countries than do heterosexual men and women, that is no valic justification to see them as less than human nor view their lives as having less inherent value.

>> No.4925531
File: 14 KB, 244x285, 1310649205254.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4925531

>>4925427
>>4925472
pls stop

STOP

>> No.4925551

>>4925531
You voluntarily clicked on a JRPG thread.

>> No.4925554

>>4924912
>Attempts being condescending
>Misspelled a simple word
Time for the ol' rope-n-dangle dance for you too.
Until there is concrete proof of actual women here on /vr/, it's nothing but dudes. And no, traps aren't women. You're just a guy that likes to play dress up and take dicks in the ass, nothing more.

>> No.4925560

>>4925554
Can't I say I enjoy stuff made with the fujoshi demographic in mind and not be called a woman?

>> No.4925584

>>4925560
Yes, however you would be called a massive faggot

>> No.4925589

>>4925472
>NIce try. Even though its true that on average gay males have a higher rate of HIV/AIDS in many countries than do heterosexual men and women, that is no valic justification to see them as less than human nor view their lives as having less inherent value.

Please go back to /lgblt/ with your hateful bait. It's not funny to make other's struggles into a joke.

>> No.4925646

>>4925589
>lgblt
Great, now I'm hungry for a sandwich that keeps claiming it's a sub despite it lacking the proper ingredients.

>> No.4925657

>>4925554
women don't come to this site at all