/vr/ - Retro Games

quick question, souls anon here

so I'm at a crossroads here. I have two potential control plans but I can't decide which one.

One control layout has:
>primary fire
main attack
>secondary fire
parry/shield - tap to parry, hold to shield

the other has:
>primary fire
light attack
>secondary fire
heavy attack
>zoom
shield
>reload
parry

While I like both systems I can see that #2 is a bit more clunky, but also I'd like to have light/heavy attacks. My other idea is having light attacks executed with a tap of the primary fire key, or heavy attacks on a key hold.