/vr/ - Retro Games

>>2900297
>upgrades for player stats
I'm cool with that.

>cutscene kills remain
I'm fine with that if it's optional.

>no real melee
I would prefer if you could just mow with the saw like in Doom 3, but be honest now, wasn't original Doom melee quite barebones?
It's punch, or punch harder with a powerup, and then a chainsaw that's just a really fast punch.

Not saying there's anything wrong with that, but it's undeniably plain.

>monsters drop health and ammo
Now, I would prefer finding health and ammo, and then maybe enemies with guns dropping related ammo, but I'm willing to give this sort of gameplay a try to see how it feels.

>>2900307
>It doesn't work in that form now
>It's questionable it worked then, too, in some respects
That's patently false, hundreds of fantastic shooters have done it that way and it works great, original Doom, Duke, Half-Life, Quake, Wolfenstein, Blood, I could keep going.