/vr/ - Retro Games

I'm sick of my 360 controller's d-pad and I can't decide whether to get a DS3 or a DS4. The DS3 has analog face buttons, which would be great if I ever get into PS2 emulation, but if they're anything like the face buttons on the DS2, the analog-ness would make them feel a bit spongy and it would probably make them slightly worse for everything except the handful of games that actually require it. I'm also worried that they compromised the timeless design of the DS4 to add a relatively pointless touchpad.

On the other hand, I'd rather have micro-USB than mini-USB, the concave sticks of the DS4 look nice, and I'm fully prepared to believe that the changes in the DS4 are for the better and it's actually an improvement over the old standard. Even if it just feels like a larger DS3, I'm cool with that.

So, which is better? Does anyone own both?