/vr/ - Retro Games

Comments on some of 400 min maps I've played so far:

>Moon Crater
The detailing is ok and the map is pretty fun, especially the last section with the Cyberdemon. The reward for getting the secret (nice The Chasm reference) is satisfying, even if it trivializes the last fight. The only nitpicks I have is that the lighting in the Pain Elemental tunnel feels much brighter than it should be, and I've found one small part where there's a missing texture. (pic rel)

>Caves of Koone
Feels 90's as fuck, I actually enjoyed it, but it does look like myfirstmap.wad. I'd keep it as a secret map or an extra because the ending is cute and the actual gameplay isn't that bad.

>Dash Tower
I didn't enjoy the map because of how cramped it is and because it's mostly crushers, it looks good though. As one other anon mentioned it sucks not being able to backtrack, I'd add some health for the final fight with the 2 Revenants and Archviles, and maybe make them spawn after you enter the room because I ended up having to shoot at them from the small corridor you warp to since there was no way to go inside.

>Magog a Go-Go
Looks really good and it's fun, I've found nothing wrong with the map. I love the moving floor usage here.

>Tuck Me Into Ramza's Foreskin
Strange but cool, also very short. The combination of the midi and the elevator fight was quite funny. I've also got nothing to really say about this one.