[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / g / ic / jp / lit / sci / tg / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports / report a bug ] [ 4plebs / archived.moe / rbt ]

/vt/ is now archived.Become a Patron!

/tg/ - Traditional Games

View post   

[ Toggle deleted replies ]
File: 41 KB, 355x500, haradls.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]
76943550 No.76943550 [Reply] [Original] [4plebs] [archived.moe]


Reclaim what was taken edition

>OFFICIAL Commander website, where you can learn the rules, see the current banlist, and read the OFFICIAL format philosophy, laid down by the rules committee:

>Statistically see what everyone else puts in their commander decks based on what is posted to the internet.

>Find out what lands you can add to your deck, sorted by category, based on a chosen color identity.

>Deck List Site: You can search for decks that other people have made. Authors often have comments that explain their deck strategy and card choices.


>Thread Question:
How do you make up for your deck's weakness?

>> No.76943585

First for mono green is cringe.

>> No.76943592
File: 167 KB, 1200x1200, KinnanTP_1200x.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

My deck has no weaknesses!

>> No.76943596

sorry bro but the consensus is mono green is based

>> No.76943615
File: 303 KB, 604x287, 1610088604492.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

>> No.76943625

>an actual retard depicted in the art
is this the representation that people finally wanted?

>> No.76943632
File: 39 KB, 429x600, 51WClX9hwwL._AC_UL600_SR429,600_.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

Okay fellow dragonbros

Post your favorite flappyboi(girl)

>> No.76943645

He looks how I picture most of you, except a different haircut and more beard.

>> No.76943646
File: 192 KB, 265x370, 1236125873.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

the ETB effect is just too good at deleting whoever I want

>> No.76943647
File: 88 KB, 878x332, Polish_20210113_192709958.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

Official /edhg/ color vote!

Currently on
>mono black
Currently 50/50 cringe vs based

>> No.76943648

>edhg is so cringe guys it's full of trannies
>meanwhile in mmg: getting cucked by a dog

>> No.76943653
File: 130 KB, 488x680, Spellbound Dragon_ARB.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

I still need a deck for him

>> No.76943657

Sorry, anything with green is inherently cringe now. They've done too much damage, it can't be saved.

>> No.76943665


>> No.76943666

la creatura mestipuerco amariconado de los triples tacos al pastor..

>> No.76943670

I like it.

>> No.76943682
File: 1.77 MB, 745x1040, frf-155-kolaghan-the-storm-s-fury.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

Here's my favorite flappygirl.

>> No.76943688


>> No.76943691
File: 710 KB, 526x949, 1589915430901.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

But it does contain the most heavyset badass

>> No.76943696

50/50 sounds right

>> No.76943706

Based, obviously.

>> No.76943710

50/50 sounds right because no color combo is inherently cringe or based.

>> No.76943712
File: 1.70 MB, 745x1040, tor-56-chainer-dementia-master.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]


>> No.76943716

Im trans btw forgot to mention in my post

>> No.76943725

It's okay I am too.

>> No.76943738

I knew those guys were not well in the head

>> No.76943742

mega cringe, how can people have fun playing the same 90 cards in every deck?

>> No.76943756

make a - symbol next to it when we get splits like this

>> No.76943762

post bulges

>> No.76943771

Based, fuck all you haters.

>> No.76943774
File: 278 KB, 672x936, frf-151-dromoka-the-eternal.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

Not my favorite but I have a question. Do the dragons get the bolster counters during their attack? Or do they get added after their attack?

>> No.76943784
File: 305 KB, 440x493, 1592552362493.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

/mmg/ gets more pathetic the more I hear about them

>> No.76943787

before they attack

>> No.76943793
File: 89 KB, 878x332, Polish_20210113_194627808.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

Shit might have to strawpoll some of these. We'll circle back to monoblack later.



>> No.76943797
File: 278 KB, 672x936, lrw-149-ashling-the-pilgrim.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

Dear exploding waifu simulator anon, I'm netdecking your list tonight

>> No.76943802

Depends a lot on the commander, more than any other mono color. I vote based because I still like this game.

>> No.76943811

cringe same issues as black where every deck is the same but with the added drawback of the player being a hipster

>> No.76943814

cringe, monobfags must have autism if they have fun playing the same deck over and over

>> No.76943821

Cringe. Mono White's unique strategies are limited and picking the weakest color doesn't make you special.

>> No.76943824

Based. Its an uphill battle but its doable. Ironically does have the tools to cuckmain threats if you're autistic enough to pursue it.

>> No.76943841

Cringe, unfortunately.

>> No.76943852

Would have been based if monoW players weren't such insufferable faggots who bitch about their color being bad and playing stax cards so they bring people down to their level of misery instead of having fun with what they have, so cringe

>> No.76943864

Oh man that sounds like it'd get confusing. How do you guys keep track of stuff like that without slowing down the table? Especially if you have a card like Immortal Sun, Kolaghan, etc. Where you're getting all these buffs from different places? Because I'm dumb

>> No.76943872

So, are we judging colors based on their playstyle or by the people who play them?

>> No.76943876


>> No.76943879

just remember how combat works and keep dice so you can visually show people what their stats are at all times

>> No.76943886

cringe because it's boring
ohh you made the 1/1 token
oh you gained the life
aha you blew up the lands 3 more hours of this game
while not shutting up about how hipster they are

>> No.76943901

Practice, honestly. It is confusing when you first start playing, but you get used to it. I did, at least.

>> No.76943903


>> No.76943916

everything exists in context, vote however you feel like

>> No.76943927

Mega cringe

>> No.76943929
File: 132 KB, 828x816, Powerful.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

>Front side:
>Legendary Creature - God
>Flying, Vigilance
>Snow lands that opponent controls enter the battlefield tapped.
>Opponents have to pay 2 more to cast noncreature spell with 4 or more cmc.
>Back side:
>Legendary Artifact
>When source that opponent controls deals damage to you or a permanent you control, it deals minus 1 of the damage instead.
>Whenever you or a permanent you control is targeted by spell or ability that opponent controls, the opponent should pay {1}. Unless, it is countered.

>> No.76943940

Clothes make the man

>> No.76943948

Nice to see a hate card for snow.

>> No.76943960

>more white taxes
Damn, I might actually have to run her in my Avacyn deck.

>> No.76943963

i like playing white, and i will freely admit that most of the avenues towards winning with a mono white deck involve making the game worse
i only take my g/w deck out when i want to be petty

>> No.76943976

Mono white will always be the most based.

>> No.76943980

cant wait until we get to dual colors those will be fun

>> No.76943989

cringe, their most consistent win conditions are making the game take forever and not fun to play

>> No.76943992
File: 90 KB, 878x332, Polish_20210113_195908916.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

A sad day, cucked to death by wotc.

Ill be back in a bit, but im sure someone can cover while im gone.

Based. Not much variety but never degenerate, except for the sissies who play it

>> No.76944012

Based, everytime they play I go home that night feeling like a man.

>> No.76944018

Based obviously, is this even a question?

>> No.76944023

Its dogshit big surprise

>> No.76944027
File: 164 KB, 480x680, 81273651652871.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

selsesnya is based not only does it have my waifu but it also lets me run pic related and enchantments are fun

>> No.76944032

Selesnya is cringe, I don't see it.

>> No.76944047

big green monsters with all the buff enchantments from white

>> No.76944049

based I like the ecofash aesthetic

>> No.76944054

Based, WG makes white strategies actually playable and more consistent whether that be lifegain, tokens, etc. They're also pretty chill unlike whitefags

>> No.76944064

>bad Gaddock Teeg
Oh well

>> No.76944079

Someone post it, I know one of you faggots has it saved.

>> No.76944091

>mfw edhg is full of faggots
I'm sure selesnya will be called based too.

>> No.76944101

I always just see selesnya go tokens and all of the commanders just look eh to okay to me. Except Hamza that dude looks cool.

>> No.76944111

>edhg is full of faggots
You have finally ascended and learned the deepest truth anon

>> No.76944115
File: 69 KB, 480x680, 2781365987123817.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

if you are playing selesnya and not going big green nigger voltron your doing it wrong

>> No.76944119
File: 162 KB, 1360x1080, 1599409170844.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

Wow, pretty mediocre overall outside of standard probably. It'd actually be good if it taxed 4 CMC or less noncreature spells.

>> No.76944137


>> No.76944140
File: 36 KB, 600x625, u.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

you're here, so..

>> No.76944158

What if hes a faggot researcher

>> No.76944161
File: 933 KB, 1264x942, 1610162423578.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

Yes but I like booba so not a faget.

>> No.76944170

Based based based

>> No.76944184

What was it Nietzsche said, "the goatse gazes also into you"?

>> No.76944187

I'll need to look into that sometime then, I do appreciate dropping a fat fuck like that.

>> No.76944189

Being here automatically makes you a faggot anon, love of booba or no.

>> No.76944195

you jest but that's an actual job nowadays

>> No.76944201

there's no such thing
you already have fag tendencies if you're "researching"
it starts with "curiosity", and i ain't talking about the blue one

>> No.76944233
File: 248 KB, 300x418, Nyleas-Colossus.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

theres tons of big green niggers that are just meant to pop off with enchantments and its fun

>> No.76944243

the free market was a mistake

>> No.76944250

my g/w deck is D&T, tokens aren't even an ancillary strategy

>> No.76944261

trains man have booba too u must like poosa to be sure

>> No.76944263

so its confirmed that sissylesnya is based?

>> No.76944277
File: 230 KB, 1400x1399, 7196WdoZgiL.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

>trains man
Choo choo

>> No.76944280

If Phage is my commander, can I use Mastermind's Acquisition to get Phage out of the command zone and safely in to my hand?

>> No.76944282

>good bad, bad good

>> No.76944288


>> No.76944292

>Legendary Creature - God
>Flying, vigilance
>Nonbasic and snow lands your opponents control enter the battlefield tapped.
>Noncreature spells your opponents cast cost {1} more to cast
>If a source would deal damage to you or a permanent you control, prevent half that damage, rounded up.
>Whenever you or a permanent you control becomes the target of a spell or ability an opponent controls, counter it unless its controller pays {1}.
Now that might MAYBE be playable. As it is? Nope.

>> No.76944297


>> No.76944303
File: 48 KB, 265x370, narfibetrayerking.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

I really like this card

>> No.76944304
File: 107 KB, 672x936, 1610466574489.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

Did someone call for the biggest chad of a praetor?

>> No.76944316

>snow lands
It's trash

>> No.76944317

No. The command zone is not outside the game.

>> No.76944320

That's a pretty cool card desu, I think they learned how to do better with legendary creatures now
Except white ones of course.

>> No.76944331

I miss when "Removed from the game" meant that you could use wishes to get stuff back.

>> No.76944339

>I think they learned how to do better with legendary creatures now

>> No.76944349

This is good, I've got a surplus of both, I just never pulled the trigger on going in on enchants or taxes, I think the closest I got was thinking about going abzan hatebears but I got lazy and didn't go for it.

>> No.76944352
File: 37 KB, 599x301, trainsman.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]


>> No.76944384

Based. They do compliment each other well without having to rely on blue or blacks bullshit and reds damage

>> No.76944389

That cards fun, but not overly powerful imo, same thing with commander legends, there was a lot of cool commanders that had interesting abilities but they didnt create overly powerful straightforward abilities like etb elemental and muldrotha. (With the exception of kodoma)
While they had this in the past, they strayed from it for a while, and now I believe while they're making made for commander cards, they understand the format a little better, even if their previous creations are wreaking havoc. That new serpent is a mistake tho

>> No.76944399

do it lad its fun

>> No.76944411
File: 4.01 MB, 5312x2988, 1591406659335.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]


>> No.76944416

The new serpent doesn't play havoc with anything, he just makes coils. Is he hard to remove? Yes, but he's also just a big fatty.

>> No.76944417

which commanerds for this¿

>> No.76944438
File: 193 KB, 622x896, u12y38716923871.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

mai waifu

>> No.76944443

Aha, I knew one of you had it.

>> No.76944445
File: 68 KB, 265x370, url.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

Christ I just realized that it didn't even need to be excess comcast damage from a source you control. Toralf is gonna be nuts.

>> No.76944459

It's the only thing keeping snowlands from being strictly better than their temperate counterparts. Be grateful you fagiolies

>> No.76944462

>comcast damage
They certainly do that.

>> No.76944463


>> No.76944464

Combat* FUCK

>> No.76944470


>> No.76944477

Expand on deserts the way they implement snow or I riot

>> No.76944492

i also have a mardu human tribal deck, so the black hatebears usually end up there
it's not my strongest deck, but it's actually pretty fun to play and i have some pretty retarded combos in it

>> No.76944496

NONcombat damage you tard

>> No.76944498
File: 226 KB, 672x936, inv-5-benalish-emissary.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

>> No.76944504

this is far more funny than it ought to be

>> No.76944506

I like how the dude who revealed the God card looks like weird al

>> No.76944518


>> No.76944519


>> No.76944522

>god is a narrow hate piece against a single archetype
>ability isn't at all applicable outside of the specific case, so will be wasted text in 90% of games
>Be grateful
I will not.

>> No.76944527
File: 78 KB, 878x332, 1610589564029.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

selesnya is confirmed for based
k lads since hes gone next up is orzhov

>> No.76944537

based if only for the aesthetic

>> No.76944541
File: 406 KB, 672x936, shalai altER.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

i use shalai for my D&T deck, but you can proxy it with this one

>> No.76944542

Hi Alex

>> No.76944550

Based but honestly this list is wrong.

>> No.76944556

>list is wrong

>> No.76944558

that's still easily done in red

>> No.76944559

>seething whitefag seethes

>> No.76944562

Big Based.

>> No.76944563

damn thanks, any other legendaries you have fixed?

>> No.76944566

Whys she fisting that mountain cat tho

>> No.76944570

No I play blue.

>> No.76944592


>> No.76944596

white wimmin amirite

>> No.76944604


>> No.76944606

Based for sure.

>> No.76944608
File: 198 KB, 375x523, Devout insight.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

>spare a crumb of card draw, maam'ro?

>> No.76944618
File: 7.86 MB, 4125x7845, card sheet 2.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]


>> No.76944629
File: 52 KB, 768x1024, 1607570573685.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]


>> No.76944638

Wow, I hate it.

>> No.76944646

if I go to sleep and miss the golgari vote, I vote cringe, they're literal dung cleaning jannies

>> No.76944661
File: 458 KB, 1280x935, d3kxkbo-a33ccbbb-181d-4b64-b758-f731f1689bd3.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

Angelic Destiny was the first MTG card to blow me away with its art. What the fuck happened with the art direction for nu magic?

>> No.76944703
File: 85 KB, 387x387, 1607360997541.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]



>> No.76944711

um that is definitely something. Could you make me one for Liesa? Something tasteful like the Shalai one pls

>> No.76944723

>countering spells and abilities

>> No.76944728

i didn't make it, so can't help you there

>> No.76944741

Pretty based. Cringe if Golos.

>> No.76944747

It's easily done, but does make it much less likely that opponents' sources will also be handing you triggers to work with.

>> No.76944761


>> No.76944769

I had never before noticed how much the actual buildings and architecture look like late 90s/early 2000s anime.

>> No.76944805
File: 80 KB, 878x332, 1610589564029.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

looks like orzhov is unanimously based next is boros

>> No.76944809

Its canon that the magic story is just happening in someone's back yard while 3 men play dress up for each character.

>> No.76944826


>> No.76944832
File: 204 KB, 1000x543, ONE DAY MORE.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]


>> No.76944833

Obviously based.

>> No.76944834
File: 4 KB, 691x597, hfdjhgs.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]


Looks neat. Wish I could have both sides on the field.

>> No.76944862

cringe because it has feather

>> No.76944872

Are there even any meta snow decks currently in any format outside of snowko in legacy? Snowko plays like 6-7 snow lands tops, and a 3 mana hatebear isn't gonna stop Oko from elking her on turn 3.

>> No.76944876

Cringe. Playing bad decks doesn't make you based.

>> No.76944896
File: 92 KB, 344x315, You have no idea how not mad i am.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

>mfw I play this and cuck all the people playing snow lands just because they think they're pretty

>> No.76944897

There are probably about to be, given that modern snowpiles are about to be F.I.R.E.d up.

>> No.76944914

>Inalla + Wanderwine Prophets
Absolutely cringe

>> No.76944921

I had to think about this one but I'm going with based just barely.

>> No.76944936

Back! And bummed i missed the orzhov vote, but i wouldve said based anyway.

Just like orzhov, boros is based for having all dem big tiddy angels. Also extra combat and shit is fun and fair too

>> No.76944937

Ngl, everytime I have to take a card out of a sleeve and flip it, I cringe a little bit.
I really wish I didnt have to do that because of my NM autism

>> No.76944963
File: 257 KB, 672x936, ogw-13-eldrazi-displacer.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]


>> No.76944991

Well Johannes Voss is a huge weeb so it makes sense

>> No.76945015

>anything but based
not only based, it's also whiteredpilled

>> No.76945030

Just get a second copy and sleeve it backwards in a different sleeve. No more flipping, and you can easily show people the other side if they want to know what it transforms into.

>> No.76945049


>> No.76945053

You're a special kind of stupid. If you flicker an MDFC, it always comes back front face up, so flickering Reidane will always get you Reidane back. And you can't go the other way either, since Displacer can only target creatures.

>> No.76945063

mono b is ultra cringe. It's just value grinding and your commander doesn't matter because your real commander is always cabal coffers anyway.
t. ex-mono b player

>> No.76945086

>ETB tapped snowlands
Decent depending on the Meta.

>taxing 4cmc non creature spells
Worthless since the majority of spells are less than 3cmc. If someone plays a 4cmc spell they usually have more than enough mana to cast it and it is usually a board wipe. Would rather Teeg.


Hot fucking garbage.

>> No.76945092

Play with transparent sleeves and just turn it around

>> No.76945141
File: 81 KB, 878x332, 1610589564029.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

5 based to 2 cringe looks like boros is based
next is Azorius

>> No.76945143

Quitter. I'm glad your stupid ass is out of our based ranks. If you think coffers was always the commander, you never knew how to play Mono B in the the first place.

>> No.76945172

I vote cringe

>> No.76945189

Cringe. Aesthetic is good but there's not interesting ways to close out the game.

>> No.76945194

Two cringe colors does not make a based combo.
Azorius for cringe 2021.

>> No.76945215

Based, both colors are based as fuck and the aesthetic is great too.

>> No.76945216

this. aesthetics and theme is cool, but its just kingmaker with extra steps

>> No.76945237

i need early game, noncreature color fixing that doesn’t involve fetches. chromatic lantern is perfect, but a short burst of mana like channel the suns works too.

>> No.76945239

Imma go sleep. If esper comes up I wanna vote cringe because someone said in one post months ago it is the tranny shard

>> No.76945246

>he doesn't want to play classic serra stasis but in edh
but why?

>> No.76945248
File: 811 KB, 1202x1849, 20210103_190320.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

Based. No other color combo makes faggots seethe as much.

>> No.76945256

Open the Omenpaths
I dunno

>> No.76945260

That new tibalt ritual

>> No.76945276

Cringe. No one likes seeing an Azorius deck.

>> No.76945288

You think it would be cringe but it ends up being greater than its individual components.

>> No.76945307

I really want that thing to be worth running in Jeskai enchantments, but I'm all but certain that just getting +1 mana off a 3cmc spell isn't worth the slot.

>> No.76945323

>missed Orzhov and Boros
Fug, well they're both based not that it matters.
Also based.

>> No.76945371

5 cringe to 4 based its close but Ill call it in 10 minutes

>> No.76945381
File: 32 KB, 223x310, Image (20).jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

I'm gonna say based

>> No.76945409

Dude just make a poll with all of them. https://fastpoller.com/

>> No.76945412
File: 57 KB, 600x839, phage_the_untouchable_by_eternal10k_d2wpoax-fullview.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

Rate my Phage deck. is there any phage tech I am missing?
>the restriction is the only creature allowed in the deck is commander phage

>> No.76945419
File: 251 KB, 976x680, Life is a bitch.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

No context, which would you choose?

>> No.76945425

Cringe. Aesthetics and lore are fun but the every azorious deck is tryhard af and the pilot is usually insufferable

>> No.76945429

the next deck i want to build is azorious bird swarm tribal with Vega is the commander

>> No.76945432

It's based, azorius niggas exist to make the other 3 players suffer.
>"there's a finite amount of fun to be had in a single game of magic, and I'm going to have all of it" -Justin Parnell piloting dragonlord ojutai

>> No.76945441

Thats how u get mono blue reddit trannies shitting up our democracy.

>> No.76945445

Greven. Licia is cooler but she doesnt work and never will.

>> No.76945449

Left, Licia is gimmicky and overall bad. She's also black

>> No.76945457

lifegain is gay, and when you're in black you're playing the same exact infinte combo

>> No.76945458

No it's how you actually get in all the damn votes and people don't miss things. Leave the poll in the op for a bit so we can actually get proper votes.

>> No.76945460

Even though I like to play it, I have to admit it's kinda cringe

>> No.76945473

>>"there's a finite amount of fun to be had in a single game of magic, and I'm going to have all of it" -Justin Parnell piloting dragonlord ojutai
Based, while I diasgree with the playstyle I respect Azorious players for being upfront and honest with what they're doing. All of the other tryhard color combinations will make endless excuses as to why their deck is unique and fun. Azorious players will never apologize for trying to grind out a long game where the win con is the other 3 conceding.

>> No.76945500
File: 21 KB, 587x257, jutin parnell.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

allow me to present a retort

>> No.76945501

No fun is BASED! Crawbabbies need not apply.

>> No.76945509

Too much truth in this post

>> No.76945514

>so we can actually get proper votes
Do you actually think this is supposed to prove or establish anything? We're just fucking around, man.

>> No.76945527

Yes! Everything must be serious! Don't you know where we are? There is no time for funny jokes or pranks on 4chan.

>> No.76945533

Wow. Did not expect that from him tbch famalam.
They NEVER and I mean NEVER even mention anything like that on the show.

>> No.76945546
File: 82 KB, 878x332, 1610589564029.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

6 cringe to 6 based its an even split
next is dimir

>> No.76945554

Cringe unless it's zombies.

>> No.76945569

Honestly, I'm thinking of making an Abzan enchantment/bogles deck, it seems like my kind of jam, just need to figure on the commander. Maybe just Anafenza because she's cheap and easy.

>> No.76945573

Im gonna say based. Zombie tribal is fun and desu mill isnt that bad, so long as its not infinite combo library exile oona or something. Plus the actual dimir guild is one of the best lorewise

>> No.76945589
File: 73 KB, 469x640, s-l640.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

I like dimir mill when it plays off of what it mills from the enemy pic related and graveyard steal is neet

>> No.76945602


>> No.76945603

Based. Love Dimir.

>> No.76945612
File: 11 KB, 366x343, 1607283757217.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

Stealing is a crime, shaquan, and crime is bad.

>> No.76945623

Mild based but zombies are carrying it, constant rogue shit keeps dipping its toe into cringe

>> No.76945633


Its not as bad as Simic or Golgari but I can't in good faith give a based rating to a component of Sultai.

>> No.76945661

I think its restriction on interactions with artifacts and enchantments keeps it fair imo. Simic and sultai have no restrictions and thats why theyre degenerate

>> No.76945672

highly based because it's the best identity for mill

>> No.76945685

Blue just received artifact exile and black is now allowed to cause forced sacrifice of enchantments.

>> No.76945714

mill is 200% cringe and the only reason its fine is because EDH is 99

>> No.76945748
File: 127 KB, 488x680, drk-18-tivadar-s-crusade (1).jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

Bros... I just want to genocide goblins...

>> No.76945749

Welp. I know that's going in the Torbran deck.

>> No.76945796


>> No.76945827

It's complicated. I love all of the multicolor Dimir cards but none of the Commanders really excite me barring Wrexial, Taigam, and Nebuchadnezzar. I will say based though, it's getting more of an identity than just "mill stuff".

>> No.76945833
File: 16 KB, 215x300, th.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

Seraph Sanctuary: actually useful for an angel deck or only really there for flavor?

>> No.76945843
File: 990 KB, 1610x1755, 1fbb577eac9b3a7cd1a34ac18b11f8dc.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

Get Tivadar of Thorn, or for maximum memes, get the Chinaman to print you one with Goblin Slayer art.

>> No.76945864

I use it for flavor. Occasionally the tiny ticks of life gain have helped me, but it's not reliable enough to make a huge difference in the vast majority of games.

>> No.76945897

its a why not card
your running mono white if its angels so why not run it when you will be getting around 10 life over a game for free with zero downside

>> No.76945907
File: 222 KB, 672x936, DE178DEE-CFBD-4A97-8F91-A1C8CFA8432F.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

Based as fuck.

>> No.76945922

>your running mono white if its angels
You’re running WB if you want to take advantage of actual angel tribal payoffs.

>> No.76945925
File: 83 KB, 878x332, 1610589564029.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

5 based to 3 cringe
next is Rakdos

>> No.76945930

who is this fat bug looking idiot?

>> No.76945945

No. I'm not. Angels are for monowhite.

>> No.76945946


>> No.76945951


>> No.76945955

Cringe. Bunch of ICP faggots and homosexuals.

>> No.76945972

Absolutely based

>> No.76945977


>> No.76945999

Also, how did Mono-White end up as cringe? And mono Green is based? List is fucked up senpai. Also Mono-Black is based.

>> No.76946013

Probably some fag samefagging or something. For some reason there's some guy determined to shit on white in the magic threads.

>> No.76946033

Im just using the majority of what anons voted for mono white got cringe by like 3 votes and green overwhelmingly got based with black being 50/50 everytime I checked back

>> No.76946035

Based as long as its not le random chaos deck

>> No.76946058

Sane people are

>> No.76946066
File: 213 KB, 672x936, 4C216EED-44AE-43DE-8BCF-6946FEA0400F.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

forgot treasure tokens were a thing. this seems pretty based ngl

>> No.76946074

Based, though there are some stinkers like Anje and Blim for their respective reasons.

>> No.76946085

Im guessing golgari will be split but izzet and simic will be overwhelmingly voted cringe

>> No.76946103

Yeah well for this silly joke list, people simply aren't taking it seriously enough!

>> No.76946120
File: 84 KB, 878x332, 1610589564029.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

1 cringe to 7 based
now Golgari

>> No.76946127


>> No.76946141

I love monowhite but most people seem to think its just as linear as mono black. Yet, somehow monoblack has had the biggest split and the most vocal reaponses

>> No.76946154

Golgari is value cancer but I still love it because it was the original value cancer before S*mic started to be pushed.

>> No.76946163

Aesthetically based but mechanically cringe due to wizards always pushing it for whatever reason. I cannot abide by the cringe it has wrought, so that is my vote.

>> No.76946179

Based, but it was close. Value chasing tryhards and shit like meren and gitrog make people hate golgari

>> No.76946182

It was the one retard samefagging for the lulz. Dont think any of these responses are legitimate

>> No.76946188

Well, you see, blackfags don't shit up the threads with whining, so the color isn't as cringe.

>> No.76946190

Mono-W is only linear because there's some card you need to run to even compete, Mono-B is only linear because people are unoriginal in a color that can do anything reasonably well and has tons of based commander options

>> No.76946210


>> No.76946238

What card do you need to run to compete in white? I'm pretty sure your statement about black applies to white too.
Wotc doesn't fuck over black with shit cards every set. In fact black just got one of white's mechanics, so I'm not even sure why you would complain.
I don't think it was but it doesn't really matter, it's just a fun list and it's not gonna change what I play.

>> No.76946241

Cringe in EDH, where it's heavily shoehorned into "muh graveyard" shit.

>> No.76946261


>> No.76946264

>whiny white player doesnt get why anons voted white cringe

>> No.76946269

They will when they get officially declared cringe

>> No.76946289

>responding to a comment about how much you whine with more whining
You really don't get it, huh?

>> No.76946292

>stating facts about the unreasonably weak cards white gets in sets advertised to have powerful white cards is whiny
It seems pretty reasonable to me, especially seeing some of the shit from this set.

>> No.76946298

Cringe because there's no commander variety to make Golgari interesting in EDH.

>> No.76946307

>responding to the samefagging retard trying to push the whining meme

>> No.76946310

Now, now, it's also allowed to be elf tribal.

>> No.76946319

Ah shit I did fall for it, thanks.

>> No.76946327

>opinion I dont like, on my /edh/??? must be a samefag
niggy plz I dont need to samefag and general concensus

>> No.76946341

Based. It has Phairka and Mazirek, not everything needs to be graveyard value bullshit.

>> No.76946357

White doesn't have anywhere near the freedom Black does, Black has an abundance of draw options and amazing ramp, White decks do all they can for the two aforementioned effects with things like land tax and still come up short.
Fuck you I deserve to complain after playing the underdog deck every game instead of just playing UGx like a faggot

>> No.76946366

A year ago, people would have almost unanimously voted white to be based. Your incessant bitching and moaning is why everyone hates it now.
Normal people can recognize problems and voice their concerns without throwing a tantrum. But when every white spoiler card is met with
>oh gee thanks Wizards it sucks
and every nonwhite spoiler card is met with
>what the fuck why is this color allowed to get good cards?
then you're not exactly contributing meaningfully to the conversation.

>> No.76946367

Maybe unrelated but curious about dis.. can creatures that have summon sickness be used to block? Ive read that untapped creatures can block, and creatures with summon sickness arent technically tapped? What do?

>> No.76946372

It's very obviously some sort of samefagging or general trolling, even a retard could see that the current cards white seems to be getting are terrible, especially compared to what other colors are getting. That and the blatant hypocrisy from wotc regarding white and pie breaks/reasons for it not getting certain mechanics.

>> No.76946379

>responding to cuckold poster

>> No.76946388

God Anon it's like you're reading my mind
I too love huge black dick inside of mine and my wife's pussies.

>> No.76946390
File: 134 KB, 223x311, Image.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

Also snake babe

>> No.76946409
File: 85 KB, 878x332, 1610589564029.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

4 cringe to 5 based a near even split
next is izzet

>> No.76946414
File: 163 KB, 672x936, niambi cage.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

>> No.76946427

Yes they can block so long as they are untapped

>> No.76946429
File: 29 KB, 572x121, This shit is just obnoxious.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

Nobody disputes that white is in a bad place right now. That is accepted as a fact.
And, because we have accepted it as a fact, we don't need you constantly yelling it in our ears whenever a new card is shown. That's what people are sick of, and that's why people associate monowhite with cringe.

>> No.76946432

Cringe. Very cringe. Unbelievably cringe. Extremely cringe.

>> No.76946434

Sorry Niv, but your guild is cringe

>> No.76946444


>> No.76946446


cringe af

>> No.76946448

Cringe. I love Arjun, I love Okaun and Zndrsplt, but the buck stops there.

>> No.76946450


>> No.76946457

Based. Decent selection of options in terms of what you want to play, and a nice halfway point between the consistency of blue and the fun, but inconsistent, style of red.
Admittedly, there are a decent number of annoying players that idolize the color pair.

>> No.76946470

What so people aren't allowed to say that a card is bad? I'm sorry for criticizing wotc's designs but they're shit and it's annoying seeing them continue to be shit every time.

>> No.76946475

Cringe. Not the worst it gets, but still cringe.

>> No.76946480

CRINGE, but somehow becomes based if you just add black.

>> No.76946481

Do not respond to cuckold poster

>> No.76946490
File: 14 KB, 516x480, 1609361566780.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

>mfw watching assblasted wiggers invent their own boogieman to explain why no one likes them

>> No.76946496

ultra cringe, literally the reddit tribe

>> No.76946507

Atleast they aren't black

>> No.76946515

Why is izzet reddit?

>> No.76946526
File: 86 KB, 878x332, 1610589564029.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

8 cringe to 1 based I think the results are obvious
now simic

>> No.76946540

Why are we wasting time with voting for Simic we bitch about that tribe every day

>> No.76946551


>> No.76946552


>> No.76946553


>> No.76946554

Literally the most cringe color combination, literally nothing is worse (although 3+ colors with these two are tainted)

>> No.76946556

Ultra Cringe except for big dick sea monsters. I was on the fence til that fat tranny from ikoria settled it

>> No.76946560

Are you actually autistic? I'm serious, you seem to be struggling to pick up on the point being made.
It's not that you point out the flaws with white. They're real, and they're present, and they need to be addressed. It's that you do so CONSTANTLY, taking any possible excuse. Red gets a new Chaos Warp effect for spells? That's a reason to complain about white cards! Blue gets limited land animation? That's a reason to complain about white cards! You're a broken fucking record, and normal people don't find that level of repetition to be comforting or whatever it is you Aspergers fucks get out of it. We find it obnoxious and grating, and it makes us dislike you.
So, sure, when WotC spoils a shitty 2/3 hatebear god, complain about that. Point out its flaws. Express your frustration. But when they show off a red god that interacts with direct damage, that is not the time or place to whine about how the Jewzards of the Dilate are undermining the pillars of white's strengths and trying to erase it from the game.

>> No.76946572


>> No.76946576

Although an obvious answer I'll vote anyway. Cringe, always has been cringe, but somehow gets more and more cringe every set. No one who plays simic does so thinking they're anything but cringe. Fuck Simic and fuck Wotc for making it.

>> No.76946581

Its so cringe that 3 color tribes with UG in it make it cringe by association

>> No.76946584
File: 256 KB, 759x1197, Get out the vote.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

>actually asking for votes on Simic
c r i n g e

>> No.76946588

I appreciate the call to vote despite already knowing the answer.

Is legit the most cringe color we've voted on so far, most cringe of all the 2 colors by far and maybe even the entire list.

>> No.76946600

why does this general hate simic so much :(

>> No.76946601
File: 549 KB, 238x240, 1599440076577.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

Just kidding its fucking cringe, mate.

>> No.76946609

Im with you, but to be fair they spoiled the white and blue uncommon removal around the same time. With such a blantant comparision/color pie break, that was a reasonable time to bitch

>> No.76946613

There are a select few fun commanders for it, but still cringe. It's only outmatched in cringe by some of the UGx 3 and 4 color pairs.

>> No.76946623
File: 86 KB, 878x332, 1610589564029.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

unanimous cringe it is wont even bother counting
now its gruul time

>> No.76946624

God please shut the fuck up. White players are complaining because WotC revealed a U spell that exiles creatures and artifacts, a red counter spell, and white got one of the worst card the game has ever seen.

>> No.76946625

Because God hates mutants.

>> No.76946638

unga based bunga

>> No.76946646

Xenagos is cringe, though

>> No.76946651

eh, kinda boring color combo

>> No.76946654

>Xenagos is cringe, though

>> No.76946658

Grug say Based

>> No.76946659

>revealed a U spell that exiles creatures and artifacts
Name of card?

>> No.76946661

Based. I know people meme that Gruul is the Xenagos colors but between Klothys, Rosheen, Wort, Borborygmos and Ruric Thar, Gruul is surprisingly diverse with its options while still being that "fuck you, you're dead" color combo.

>> No.76946667

Giga based

>> No.76946669

The color of the simple joy of smashing AND saying fuck you blue? Based.

>> No.76946675

we were getting slow and I needed to wake everyone back up

>> No.76946678
File: 167 KB, 265x370, qwrmdcGHcVjmAgxXFqZHnHQLTk-YabjUeB73tzw7d3M.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]


>> No.76946679

You never shut the fuck up, so why should I? White players were also bitching about Toralf and Dual Strike, effects well-attested within red's pie. And Tergrid. And everything under the fucking sun.
You can act like a child and throw tantrums. Nobody can stop you, and it's entirely within your rights to do so. But then you don't get to be surprised when everyone treats you like a crybaby.

>> No.76946680

Overall pretty based

>> No.76946681

How is Xenagod cringe? His gameplan is super telegraphed and has a hundred opportunities to counterplay it.

>> No.76946690

Cringe timmy shit. Made worse by gruul players being literal brainlets
>"dont attack me. im no threat, i only have 23 lands and 50 4/4 tokens! Attack the azorious player with 3 lands and a grand abolisher!"

>> No.76946694

Watching Maro get salty over this card making it into the final set, but being unable to actually criticize it as much as he wanted to because UPCOMING PRODUCT, was deeply entertaining.

>> No.76946695

You just answered your own question.

>> No.76946699

He's probably from the "popular = cringe" club.

>> No.76946700

The reason it's brought up when other colors get spoiled is because wotc continues to print white cards as just generally worse than other colors, while often using fairly white seeming mechanics in other colors. They do this all while lying to everyone that they're trying to make white better. I know the opposition agent and hullbreacher thing is tired as fuck but seriously, seeing white get Jack shit in a set that was advertised for having strong white cards while other colors get powerful hate (stuff people tend to ask for in white) in the colors that most commonly do the things the cards hate on, is really damn annoying.
Ravenform my guy.
I'm pretty sure I saw literally everyone complaining about tegrid because she's literally a better it that betrays.

>> No.76946716

Cringe as fuck.

>> No.76946726

t. simic player

>> No.76946738

>poster boy for pubstompers

>> No.76946748
File: 87 KB, 878x332, 1610589564029.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

7 based to 2 cringe
now onto the 3C combos with Naya

>> No.76946751

Vega, the Watcher-what do you think of this commander? What based tech have you thought of for it?

>> No.76946757
File: 190 KB, 265x370, en_lxFuROLjuQ.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

How the fuck is this a white seeming mechanic?

>> No.76946765

>poster boy for pubstompers
What fucking year do you live in

>> No.76946773

>a pubstomp deck
Are you playing pubs with literal retards?

>> No.76946774

Moderately based. Certainly not offensive enough to be cringe.

>> No.76946775


>> No.76946779

Based, adding white fixes the cringe that is gruul. Plus i get to slap my boy sun titan into pretty much every naya deck that exists

>> No.76946786

It's not. I was referring mainly to the cards I mentioned in my post. I'm honestly not sure why people were mad about that card, it seems fun as fuck to me, I love forks.

>> No.76946790

Based. Favorite color combo in the game.
>t. Ghired, Rienne, Hazezon, Jared, and Marisi player

>> No.76946791

Hmm, I don't have too much exposure to Naya but what I have seen is Jared, Rith, and Obuun and they're based, Obuun is land faggotry but is the least offensive land faggotry out there

>> No.76946794

Loses some points for being 3 color but ultimately being RG+ saves it. Based.

>> No.76946798


>> No.76946801


>> No.76946821

Hullbreacher and Opposition Agent were legitimate complaints. That's two cases, compared to all the posts along the lines of
>Oh, sure [color] gets this card that's good at what that color normally does...but white keeps getting fucked!
That's the shit that people are sick of. The cancerous need to turn every conversation, every commentary on any aspect of the game, into a discussion of how white is getting fucked. Yes, it's getting fucked, but there are other things to talk about as well.

>> No.76946846
File: 88 KB, 878x332, 1610589564029.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

8 based unanimous
now Esper

>> No.76946847

Why shouldn't people talk about the most pressing and obvious balance issue that hasnt been addressed for years?

>> No.76946855

Eh I think it's kinda just jealousy, which is kind of understandable? It's frustrating seeing other colors actually get good and fun cards that are in their color identity while white gets... Situational tribal anthems at mythic, or removal with an incredible downside. Both things in whites color identity, but for some reason wotc never pushes them to real playability like the other colors. You know what I'm saying?

>> No.76946859


>> No.76946862

Overwhelmingly cringe, only Varina and a few other, non degenerate legends are based.

>> No.76946867


>> No.76946873

Based, that fat fuck on the chair sucks but I like that color trio.

>> No.76946874
File: 2.58 MB, 2560x2000, iKOlSR2E5Erss9mMsUhpUBXGtudckCk8PYQG8SYteAY.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

Based. Powerful yet fair. People are justified in complaining about oloro though.
Also its got top tier waifus

>> No.76946877

Cringe on a level that is only outdone by UGx degeneracy.

>> No.76946905

Based, one of the coolest shards in terms of aesthetics.

>> No.76946914

Based, but only slightly. Fun stuff like Yennett and Ertai; used to have a polarizing monopoly on artifacts but it got better.

>> No.76946921
File: 159 KB, 672x936, c19-46-marisi-breaker-of-the-coil.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

Absolutely Based

>> No.76946940

Cringe. Incredibly so.

>> No.76946950

>but there are other things to talk about as well
The point was not "stop talking about white being shafted," it was "stop trying to ONLY talk about white being shafted." Your inability to grasp this simple concept really does come across as incredibly autistic.

>> No.76946955

I wanna say cringe but it's also the color of Dakkon Blackblade so I'm gonna say BASED

>> No.76946962


New, move whenever

>> No.76946967

It's not the responsibility of other people to bring up subjects you want to talk about. If there's something you want to discuss then being it up retard.

>> No.76947087

Oloro and Sharuum by themselves make the entire color cringe

Name (leave empty)
Comment (leave empty)
Password [?]Password used for file deletion.