[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]

2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/sci/ - Science & Math

File: 568 KB, 792x535, wLlsf4T.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]

Anonymous Thu Apr 12 06:39:21 2018 No.9666666 [Reply] [Original]

what would win 1000C lava sun or -1000C ice sun?

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 06:40:47 2018 No.9666675 shit get, kys. no bump.

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 06:41:29 2018 No.9666678 >>9666666 YOU DUN GOOFED

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 06:41:40 2018 No.9666679 >>9666666 Wow

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 06:42:45 2018 No.9666682 >>9666666

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 06:43:26 2018 No.9666683 >>9666666 Now you HAVE to answer this. Nice epic get my brosky.

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 06:43:44 2018 No.9666684 quality GET

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 06:46:25 2018 No.9666687 File: 66 KB, 500x446, 1502755844720.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] >>9666666

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 06:47:04 2018 No.9666689 >>9666666 Kill yourself.

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 06:49:31 2018 No.9666693 File: 69 KB, 960x666, 1461807727076.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 06:52:55 2018 No.9666699 File: 60 KB, 872x225, Trolling _sci_.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] >>9666666

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 06:56:54 2018 No.9666705 >>9666666 -1000C is impossible since the minimum temperature possible is -273,15C = 0 K

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 06:58:15 2018 No.9666706 File: 57 KB, 528x581, images(79).jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] >>9666666 The Song of Ice and Fire

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 06:58:28 2018 No.9666707 >>9666705 no fucking shit newfag

Anonymous Thu Apr 12 07:08:27 2018 No.9666716

>>9666666
Good thread.
IMO the Lava Sun would win at first because it melts the ice. But then the ice would become water and put out the lava, so they would cancel each other out and you'd be left with nothing. I certainly hope an ice sun never hits our own!

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 07:11:49 2018 No.9666720 >>9666716 A true /sci/entist and intellectual, unlike all those trolls here, thanks for the answer i needed t. OP

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 07:27:21 2018 No.9666730 >>9666707 >calls someone a newfag He was answering OP’s scientific question on the fucking science board, cut him some slack

Anonymous Thu Apr 12 07:34:40 2018 No.9666735

>>9666730
>"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""science board"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 07:40:51 2018 No.9666741 >>9666716 This is wrong, there is no air in space so heat can't propagate and the ice sun would remain frozen until contact, they would cancel each other out and create a sun made of rock

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 07:42:36 2018 No.9666746 >>9666706 >Reading meme books written by a retard.

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 07:45:29 2018 No.9666752 >>9666741 >implying a sun made of lava wouldn't cool of immediately >implying you can't transfer energy as thermal radiation through empty space >implying a sun made of ice would collapse and become a normal sun made of hydrogen and helium

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 07:52:08 2018 No.9666763 >>9666666 back to facebook, granpa

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 07:55:46 2018 No.9666767 >>9666741 but doesnt our sun melt mini ice suns all the time? thats why comets have tails

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 08:01:58 2018 No.9666773 >>9666666 >What would actually happen Both suns would instantly undergo nuclear fusion and become normal main sequence stars. Then they would collided causing a supernova. ...

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 08:02:03 2018 No.9666774 >>9666752 >wouldn't collapse Fixed

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 08:04:37 2018 No.9666777 >>9666666 >what would win ...would win what, fgt pls also detect, inspect, checked

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 08:12:30 2018 No.9666784 >>9666666 The result would be twice bigger 0C sun... but since space is cold it would soon start freezing again

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 08:12:53 2018 No.9666786 File: 109 KB, 568x552, 1522740465236.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] >>9666666

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 08:55:18 2018 No.9666848 >>9666666 Imagine you have 5 ice cubes and 5 fires, according to the equation of Fermat, 3 ice cubes will vaporise and 5 fires will liquidise. So ice sun

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 09:02:11 2018 No.9666860 >>9666730 No, he was answering the voluntary newfag survey. Anon calling him a newfag was simply informing him of such, since he was obviously unaware, being a newfag and all.

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 09:03:36 2018 No.9666862 >>9666705 This just demonstrates the power of the -1000C ice sun.

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 09:10:10 2018 No.9666877 If you had an ice-ball the size of our sun. It would collapse and ignite knto a star.

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 09:11:38 2018 No.9666882 >>9666773 Nope as a super-nova needs the shell to ignite which needs it to stabilize and become homogenous throughout its layers. And then, probably a supernovae?

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 09:14:33 2018 No.9666883 >>9666777 your trips are cool and all, but, HEXA 6

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 09:18:54 2018 No.9666891 File: 3 KB, 141x129, 1272482816215.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] >>9666666

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 10:10:54 2018 No.9666967 >>9666675 >>9666689 >2018 >kys/kill yourself actually neck lol

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 10:14:50 2018 No.9666975 >>9666784 kek

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 10:16:00 2018 No.9666977 >>9666666 Check em! Also lava melts ice

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 11:14:23 2018 No.9667053 File: 14 KB, 151x276, IMG_20180412_002528.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] don't they just combine and make a bigger sun? that's how it works on the space sandbox i watch on YouTube

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 11:20:43 2018 No.9667066 >>9666666 But is diamond the hardest metal?

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 11:37:23 2018 No.9667088 File: 74 KB, 500x451, MemeTastic_2018-04-12T12-34.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] >>9666666

Anonymous Thu Apr 12 11:37:52 2018 No.9667090

>>9666860
>>9666735
How is this thread unscientific? You may see a lot of butthurt morons saying it doesn’t make sense, but then you have people actually discussing the ‘sun of ice’ dilemma. Those are the smart ones.

Now here’s the real answer: a sun of ice would cancel some of the lava from the sun of heat, but not all, for ice is simply frozen water which can fuel fires sometimes, so it won’t completely put out the fire.

There may be a lot of steam though, which might be why people are so nervous about the question: they don’t know how the steam will be displaced

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 11:39:07 2018 No.9667092 You get an obsidian sun

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 11:41:03 2018 No.9667094 >ctrl+f >No mention of water splitting Brainlets.

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 12:11:54 2018 No.9667135 >>9667092 i get that reference

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 12:56:59 2018 No.9667214 >>9666666 lole nice

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 13:00:04 2018 No.9667221 >>9666730 >OP’s scientific question L0Lno fgt pls

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 13:03:48 2018 No.9667228 >>9666666 https://www.strawpoll.me/15488698

Anonymous Thu Apr 12 13:08:27 2018 No.9667235

>>9666666
-1000 C eh

Did America make up their 'imperial' version of centigrade?

Assuming it was around absolute zero, the lava ball will always win because the gravity of the ice-ball will cause it to rapidly heat up and start fusion reactions further melting the ice-ball until it is a mostly hydrogen star.

Prof Sai Thu Apr 12 13:14:06 2018 No.9667246

>>9666705
>>9666666

Wrong wrong. A "Sun of ice" (H2O) can't exist:

No matter what the temperature of the ice is, the weight of it all would cause fusion reactions at its core. This would vaporize anything, and soon you'd have an ordinary star. (Except for having lots of oxygen, which wouldn't be a big deal.)

https://what-if.xkcd.com/14/

>>	Prof Sai Thu Apr 12 13:20:08 2018 No.9667255 >>9667246 Meanwhile the lava sun, being made of mostly carbon, silicon, and iron, but little hydrogen, would become a red giant star. It would be hotter and larger than the formerly ice star, but wouldn't last long.

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 13:31:31 2018 No.9667283 >>9667090 It is a common meme posted periodically for years. It OP was serious and not word for word reposting then it might qualify.

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 13:33:31 2018 No.9667285 >>9667283 >he thinks it might qualify That is a troll post you’re responding to and I am the poster. You’ve outed yourself as a pseud

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 13:37:49 2018 No.9667294 Only that there isn't a -1000 degrees Celsius, tard.

Anonymous Thu Apr 12 13:39:34 2018 No.9667298

>>9666773
>Both suns would instantly undergo nuclear fusion and become normal main sequence stars.
This.

But the "lava sun" would have a lot of rocky planets orbiting since it has a high amount of Si (Silicon)

And the "ice sun" would have only gas giants orbiting around.

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 13:40:39 2018 No.9667301 >>9666666 >six sixes were wasted on this post. >an hero.jpeg

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 13:42:28 2018 No.9667303 >>9666666 get out evil econ-anon

Anonymous Thu Apr 12 13:46:22 2018 No.9667310 [DELETED]

>>9667255

Ironically the Ice planet will end up hotter than the Lava planet.

The Lava "sun" would cool down very fast, becoming a Brown dwarf.
>https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brown_dwarf
Since it's mostly silicates, without enough hydrogen for fusion.

The Ice "sun" by other hand will heat up, becoming hotter than the Lava "sun. because the gravity will ignite the hydrogen starting the nuclear fusion.

Anonymous Thu Apr 12 13:47:38 2018 No.9667311

>>9667255

Ironically the Ice "sun" will end up hotter than the Lava "sun".

The Lava "sun" would cool down very fast, becoming a Brown dwarf.
>https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brown_dwarf
Since it's mostly silicates, without enough hydrogen for fusion.

While the Ice "sun" will heat up, becoming hotter than the Lava "sun.
Because the gravity will ignite the hydrogen starting nuclear fusion.

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 13:49:48 2018 No.9667318 >>9666666 they would cancel out and create a 0°C singularity that transforms into an antimatter portal to one of infinite dimensions, most likely leading to World War III. t. science PhD n shit

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 13:52:19 2018 No.9667326 >>9666752 >>implying a sun made of ice would collapse and become a normal sun made of hydrogen and helium you mean a sun made of water?

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 13:57:05 2018 No.9667336 >>9666741 But there is an air and space museum

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 13:57:34 2018 No.9667340 >>9666741 bad physics troll dude

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 14:51:54 2018 No.9667452 >>9667298 Idk. Why would we get an accretion disk?

>>	Anonymous Thu Apr 12 14:56:12 2018 No.9667464 File: 50 KB, 900x600, FB_IMG_1497143812045.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] >>9666706 these shit books need to die already

Advanced search
Text to find
Subject [?]Search by post subject. Leave empty for any.
Username [?]Search for user name. Leave empty for any user name.
Tripcode [?]Search for tripcode. Leave empty for any.
Email [?]Search by email. Leave empty for any.
Filename [?]Search by image filename. Leave empty for any.
From Date [?]Enter what date to start searching from. Format is YYYY-MM-DD
To Date [?]Enter what date to start searching until. Format is YYYY-MM-DD
Image hash
Search in	All Posts OPs Only
Deleted posts	Show all posts Show only deleted posts Only show non-deleted posts
Internal posts	Show all posts Show only internal posts Show only archived posts
Order	New posts first Old posts first
Capcode	All Posts Only by Users Only by Mods Only by Admins Only by Developers
Results	Posts Threads
Action	[ Simple ]