[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/sci/ - Science & Math


View post   

File: 315 KB, 707x1000, a9a83e1625350cb77b3eeb1da3235bbb.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4602383 No.4602383 [Reply] [Original]

>>>/m/7684186
>Kidding aside, you can reenter atmosphere in a space suit and be fine (until the landing). You're not massive enough for gravity to speed you up to the point where your velocity would start fires and shit.

>> No.4602395
File: 25 KB, 492x400, 1313814771445.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4602395

>>4602383
>>Kidding aside, you can reenter atmosphere in a space suit and be fine (until the landing). You're not massive enough for gravity to speed you up to the point where your velocity would start fires and shit.

>> No.4602411
File: 23 KB, 599x486, 1332315100349.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4602411

>Kidding aside, you can reenter atmosphere in a space suit and be fine (until the landing). You're not massive enough for gravity to speed you up to the point where your velocity would start fires and shit.

>> No.4602419
File: 104 KB, 665x598, 1328523404683.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4602419

>Kidding aside, you can reenter atmosphere in a space suit and be fine (until the landing). You're not massive enough for gravity to speed you up to the point where your velocity would start fires and shit.

Until you realize the lack of friction in the upper atmosphere thus speeding you up to godly speeds. Then you hit a massive wall of air molecules turning you into a cinder.

>> No.4602577

How fast you're going by the time you hit the atmosphere and begin heating up from drag and the compression of molecules before you depends on how fast you were going beforehand or how far your fictional spaceman is from Earth when he begins accelerating towards it.

>> No.4602584

>>4602577
This. In principle, the statement holds for a low-velocity suborbital reentry.

Coming back from orbit? Not so much.

>> No.4602587

This is pretty much what MOOSE was designed for, right? Spacesuits with parachutes and some insulating foam.

>> No.4602592
File: 75 KB, 1071x772, Manned Orbital Operations Safety Equipment operation.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4602592

>>4602587
MOOSE is fucking awesome.

And yeah.

>> No.4602595

>>4602587
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MOOSE
So you need foam insulation, and ablative shield, and a parachute.

>> No.4602626

>>4602595
That's for orbit.

If you were to just drop from 100 km up, you could probably survive with nothing but a suit and a chute.

>> No.4602642

Unless I were coming in from orbital heights or orbital speeds, I'd be more worried about G forces. The highest straight-down dive is 32km. How are we defining "atmosphere"? The mesophere? Further than that and the distances involved are going to accelerate you to speeds you'd need active braking and a hell of a parachute.

>> No.4602652

Let's not forget your body turning into jelly after breaking the sound barrier.

>> No.4602663

>>4602652
The speed of sound is variable based on atmospheric density. If your parachute is good enough and you're not going absurdly fast by the time you get to a point where the parachute actually has enough air to brake on to mean something, it could slow you sufficiently. We would need to know the exact atmospheric density in bars or pascal at various heights.

>> No.4602670
File: 61 KB, 546x500, sts-41b.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4602670

Lsts just all agree yer fucked and stop pretending

>> No.4602672

>>4602670
That guy is hosed.

>> No.4603898

>>4602587
Yes but that's more than just a space suit. The guy in that thread implied that a normal space suit wont be a problem because falling speed depends on mass (it does not) and that objects in orbit start out stationary and gain velocity from gravity when the start to fall. (things in orbit are already in a state of constant falling)

>> No.4604009

In the interest of going somewhere in this thread, how feasible would it be to create a wearable suit that could withstand re-entry?

I ask because I just saw Lockout last weekend, and the finale consists of the protagonist + love interest jumping out of an exploding space station in these halo-looking heavy suits, that dis-engage after reentry so they can parachute down. So, what're the odds of actually developing such a technology?

>> No.4604017

>>4604009
For the record, I don't mean something like MOOSE, just a tough-as-nails suit by itself.

>> No.4604026

>>4604017
You could make a humanoid shaped heat shield, but that's not an optimal shape. And would probably be really bulky.

>> No.4604503

>>4604009
It's very NOT feasible if they happen to be jumping out of a ship already moving at orbital velocities. Their acceleration towards earth would be about 10m/s^2, so every 1m40s, they're traveling another km/s. Consider that low-earth orbit at 300km already has you traveling at 7-8km/s and geostationary has you at 35,786km going ~3km/s. That's a lot of speed by the time you get to a point where heat from compressing air is a problem, and a lot of braking to do. An object falling into atmosphere from an orbital velocity is almost assuredly screwed.

Aerobraking would begin somewhere around the 50km mark, albeit very slowly. 15-20km is the point where a parachuting human moving at orbital velocities would realize his mistake.

There are some more complications from radiative heat loss, oxygen supply, radiation shielding, etc. that are all very not good and get worse the further out you are.

Falling from LEO height if you are somehow not moving at orbital speeds with a parachute and a really good suit, you could probably pull that off. Falling from LEO already moving at orbital velocity, or falling from much higher whether or not you're moving fast to start with, and you're almost assuredly toast unless this is a really spectacular "future" suit.

>> No.4604848

> You're not massive enough for gravity to speed you up ...
Forgetting that gravity doesn't care how massive you are. The acceleration is the same regardless of mass.

>> No.4604891
File: 584 KB, 1417x1800, Kittinger-jump[1].jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4604891

Somewhat related, project excelsior was the world's highest skydive from 31.3km above the earth's surface.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Excelsior