[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/sci/ - Science & Math

View post   
File: 52 KB, 836x622, Trolled logic OC.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
1833299 No.1833299 [Reply] [Original]

Serious question guys. Not troll logic. Does this picture unexplain light is the fastest theory?

A fan center turns at the same speed no matter how long the blades right? Look at the picture. Mind blown. Reward please.

>> No.1833313

inb4 time dilation

>> No.1833321

>>1833299
>Does this picture unexplain light is the fastest theory?
No. Why bother considering possible refutations if you don't even grasp the bare essentials of special relativity?

>> No.1833324

>>1833321

How old are you?

>> No.1833331

This is like this retarded idea about the stick thats one lightyear long... and if you push one end the other end imediately moves (right? RIGHT?)...
Sorry OP you did not disprove relativity.

>> No.1833337

At those lengths, the metal will break from the force of being moved, rather than moving. The inertia will be incredible.

>> No.1833340

>>1833337

Let alone the amount of energy JUST to get it spinning would be ridiculous.

>> No.1833341

Why not just use the example everyone already knows and tries, that of walking forward on a train traveling the speed of light? Why come up with a NEW way of being wrong?

>> No.1833347

Force can not travel faster than light, molecules are held together whit electromagnetic force and electromagnetic wave can travel "only" at speed of light.

>> No.1833353

>>1833299

DUUUUUDE. WHY WOULD YOU WANT TO CUT THE UNIVERSE IN HALF!? :[

>> No.1833357

>>1833353
Because I don't want you to touch the stuff in MY Half, duh!

>> No.1833358

>>1833340
Not if you use magnets attached to the ends of the blade that pull the ends of the blade.

>> No.1833364

Learn to special relativity. Seriously.

>> No.1833366

>>1833299
win

>> No.1833367

>>1833358
Magnets don't work that way.

Hell, nobody really knows HOW the fuck magnets work.

>> No.1833368
File: 7 KB, 274x302, charizard pipe.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
1833368

Does no one realize the pokeball in the middle of the picture? This is obviously the work of /vp/.

>> No.1833378

Plot twist: this fan is made of a massless metal. It is 100% rigid.

Why don't you guys just accept questions like these as thought experiments? There are better explanations than "there's no way you could make that in real life".

>> No.1833390

>>1833378

Because its retarded.

Go to /lit/ and discuss the inscription on the back of your commemorative nascar plates.

>> No.1833391

ANTI MATTER

>> No.1833393

>>1833378
1) Any conclusions drawn are completely irrelevant because we already threw reality out the window
2) It is goddamn ridiculous

If we're talking about a magical land completely different than ours, then I suppose OP has broken relativity. By envisioning a place were it doesn't exist. That's about all that can be said. Gee, you're right, that sure was fun.

>> No.1833400

>>1833378
Plot Twist: Suppose stuff moves faster than light.

OMG I REFUTED RELATIVITY

>> No.1833408

The forces between the different atoms that compose the fan can only travel at the speed of light. Satisfied?

>> No.1833523
File: 51 KB, 1024x768, 1111.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
1833523

Let's say that the fan is massless and all that crap since it's a thought experiment.
The center rotates at lightspeed, let's say.
(nevermind that this doesn't make sense because "lightspeed" is speed, not angular momentum, but let's say that it rotates at lightspeed a few centimeters away from the center.)

The tip of the fan, located a gazillion light years away, still only moves at lightspeed.

the speed of light in a vacuum is the absolutely maximum speed of everything. If something should go faster, it doesn't. If it means stuff will break, then stuff will break. If it means things will stop making sense from a newtonian perspective, then things will stop making sense from a newtonian perspective.