[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/sci/ - Science & Math

View post   
File: 33 KB, 778x440, 983478437897438974398743.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12541215 No.12541215 [Reply] [Original]

Which came first?

>> No.12541219

>>12541215
eggs because dinosaurs made eggs

>> No.12541289

The egg... I don't get this question.
before chickens were genetically similar animals that laid eggs too, so thus an egg was lain then a chicken came.

>> No.12541301

it's too easy with eggs, think of chicken eggs

>> No.12541309

chuck norris

>> No.12541589

both are yummy.

>> No.12541624

>>12541215
your mom

>> No.12541660

>>12541215
The chicken, of course, it has its full chick coat. The egg must have been laid after it, otherwise it would have gone bad or have hatched.

>> No.12541676

>>12541215
It all leads to ancestral worms. Worms lay eggs. I dont know what happened before

>> No.12541720

>>12541289
Only a chicken can lay a chicken egg you idiot.

>> No.12542085

>>12541215
The rooster

>> No.12542099

Define chicken
Define chicken egg

>> No.12542100

>>12541215
the father

>> No.12542118

me on the left

>> No.12542182

>>12542099
Chicken is a thing which hatches out of chicken egg.
Chicken egg is a thing chicken lays.

>> No.12542211

>>12541720
But that chicken had to have hatched from an egg you imbecile

>> No.12542280

The last chicken will travel to the past to lay the first egg.

>> No.12542294

>>12542182
Chicken is a thing which hatches out of a thing laid by a thing which hatches out of a thing laid by a thing which hatches out of a thing laid by a thing which hatches out of a thing laid by a thing which hatches out of a thing laid by a thing which hatches out of a thing laid by a thing which hatches out of a thing laid by a thing which hatches out of a thing laid by a thing which hatches out of a thing laid by a thing which hatches out of a thing laid by a thing which hatches out of a thing laid by a...

Simple as

>> No.12542485
File: 298 KB, 1200x1082, cozy tiktaalik.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12542485

>> No.12542502

>>12542100
and before that, hopefully dinner and a movie
let's have some standards, fellas, don't settle for hussies

>> No.12542758

>>12542211
Kek

>> No.12543175

>>12541219
Theres always a chicken inside the egg you fucking idiot the embryo comes first therefore the chicken

>> No.12543193

>>12541215
me :)

>> No.12543397

>>12541215
a more scientific question is: when did amphibians start to produce hard calcium carbonate shelled eggs?

>> No.12543473
File: 371 KB, 1600x1023, CE7F71E3-79FA-4816-B32F-AAE1D7DAD591.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12543473

>>12541720
behold, a chicken!

>> No.12543482

>>12543397
>when did amphibians start to produce hard calcium carbonate shelled eggs
When they migrated from semi-aquatic habitats to dry land. Their skin got scaley and eggs got stiff to protect them from evaporation. That's my guess at least

>> No.12543484
File: 8 KB, 228x221, 2cd.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12543484

>>12542280
Bravo Nolan...

>> No.12543491

>>12541215
It's simple.
Accept evolution as a valid theory.
Find common ancestor to all chickens.
The common ancestor would not, itself, be a chicken.
Assuming that it laid eggs, the first egg that it laid would be the origin of the first chicken.
Therefore, the egg came first.
Q.E.D.

>> No.12543499

>>12543397
Worms did it first. What preceded flatworms?

>> No.12543523

>>12543175
the embryo wasnt always a chicken though you dumb fuck, eggs came first.

>> No.12543529

>>12542118
based and terrible joke that doesn't make any sense given the context-pilled

>> No.12543663

>>12541720
Prove it retard.

>> No.12543690

>>12541215
None, first there was allah that created god.

>> No.12543693

>>12543690
*created both.

>> No.12543695

>>12541215
God -> chicken-> egg
Simple as.

>> No.12543769

>>12543695
Egg created god, then god created chicken.

>> No.12543872

>>12541215
depends if this is about chicken eggs, chickens, or the concept of chicken. We don't consider it a chicken unless we know the reproductive function of the chick(whether its chromosones determine its future reproductive function in the wild). Then again, some might argue that it's a female chick before it's a chicken, and completely dismiss the existence of hens.

>> No.12543886

Genetically?
The same time, the proto chicken laid a chicken egg. Inside the chicken egg is a chicken.

>> No.12543909

>>12543886
Pidgeon egg and gmo.

>> No.12544054

Egg, whatever it is you define as the first chicken came from an egg adapted to give life to said first chicken

>> No.12544119

>>12541215
Me

>>12541219
Chicken ARE dinosaurs.

>> No.12545154

>>12541215
the cock came on the chick which essenssially made the egg. i hope I've answered your question.

>> No.12545183
File: 126 KB, 960x694, 1600956599692.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12545183

>>12541215
if you are asking whether the chicken or chicken egg came first -
the egg that made first chicken cannot be laid by a chicken. it must be laid by whatever bird was before the chicken hence it is that birds egg. by this logic chicken came first.

now if you are asking just any form of egg or chicken cam first then its is egg without a doubt

>> No.12545224

>>12543491
first egg may make the chicken but it wasn't laid by a chicken hence it is technically not a chicken egg.

>> No.12545245

>>12542211
yes, but that egg was laid by the bird before chicken and that egg is technically not chickens.

>> No.12545275
File: 28 KB, 250x256, unnamed (2).jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12545275

Who do you think?

>> No.12545279

>>12545275
You just KNOW.

>> No.12545671
File: 48 KB, 780x305, iStock-117543888_780.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12545671

>>12541215
>Which came first?
Trick question: NEITHER

>> No.12545760
File: 99 KB, 1920x972, ribonucleic_acid_and_deoxyribonucleic_acid.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12545760

>>12541215
Simple->complex

The egg is more complicated than the bird so it had to come first.

>> No.12546885

>>12545760
The egg contains a complex chicken.

>> No.12547059

>>12544119
Eggs becuse fish made eggs

>> No.12547323

>>12541215
This question is very misleading, whenever it comes up some idiot talks about ancestral crap and claim egg came first before "chicken". The proper way to phrase this is whether egg form or non-egg form came first, and it's obviously non-egg form, therefore "chicken" in this case (we aren't talking about the actual chicken dumbfucks)

>> No.12547367

>>12541215
A mutated prehistoric bird laid an egg that hatched the first chicken

>> No.12547402

>>12541215
a retarded fishfrog

>> No.12547683

>>12543473
Lol

>> No.12548091
File: 45 KB, 720x480, 1589990187841.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12548091

>>12541215
Which came first, the 13 or the 50?

>> No.12549469

>>12548091
>fbi crime stats
>science or math
pick one

>> No.12549581

>>12543175
punnet square
2 not_chickens made the current_chicken
cause both not_chickens had chicken genes.

>> No.12549638

>>12543473
that thing lays chicken eggs? crazy

>> No.12550652

>>12541215
The egg preceded the chicken which preceded the chicken egg.

>> No.12550691

>>12545760
>The egg is more complicated than the bird

>> No.12550869

>>12549469
>fbi crime stats
>stats
>science or math
>math
get off this board nigger

>> No.12550898
File: 47 KB, 720x710, 9xw3kyr5fej51.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12550898

>>12545760
>The egg is more complicated than the bird

>> No.12550949
File: 138 KB, 700x1042, Schleiden-meduse-2.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12550949

Chickens evolved from reptiles that evolved from fish that evolved from worms. Worns lay eggs. Worms evolved from sponges. Sponges reproduce by breaking off bits of itself that regrow as a new sponge, this is a sort of primordial egg. A sponge is a very simple animal, its just a porous mass of cells that filter sea water for nutrients. Imagine a 3D bacteria colony that breaks off a chunk to make new colonies.

>> No.12551071

>>12541215
I tried to simulate this on computer it throwed following error:

Maximum call stack exceeded.

>> No.12551090

>>12550949
Egg is a resource for omelette and similar foods.

I don't want to eat out of your kitchen.

>> No.12551093

>>12541215
Look into taxation documentation of farmer which he bought first.

>> No.12551096

>>12541215
The father, obviously.

>> No.12551107

>>12550949
Ha, this guy thinks jellyfish came from plants! If that's true then why are there still plants, checkmate.

>> No.12551285

>>12541215
Quantum theory tells us that we cannot know if an egg contains a chicken, as the contents are unobservable. It simultaneously does and does not contain a chicken until the shell cracks, causing the internal fields to collapse. This is why you sometimes get a yolk when you crack an egg. Thankfully, our technology is advanced enough that we can accurately predict which way the fields will collapse for a particular egg, so the ones you buy at the store are guaranteed to always produce yolks.

>> No.12551311
File: 205 KB, 1200x630, CAN_Sponges_1258.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12551311

>>12551090
YOU WILL EAT THE SPONGE. YOU WILL LIKE IT. YOU WILL BE HAPPY

>> No.12551517

>chicken ancestor
>chicken egg ancestor egg
---insert w/e metric you're using to define a new species---
>chicken
>chicken egg
>chicken
>chicken egg

>> No.12551522

>>12551517
oops should read
>chicken ancestor egg

>> No.12551529

>>12541215
your mom

>> No.12551534

>>12551522
>>12551517
there was an ancestor before egg laying species thus life came before eggs, but yes "eggs" came before chickens

>> No.12551552

There's 2 kinds of people in this thread:

Those for whom the answer is obvious, and don't get why this is even a question; and

Those who believe that "egg" *must* mean "a chicken's egg" in this context and are therefore stumped by the riddle.

>> No.12551568

>>12551552
which came first
chicken or chicken egg
if the ancestor of a chicken lays an egg is it a chicken egg because there is a chicken inside or is it still the egg of the chicken ancestor which laid it?

>> No.12552082

>>12541215
Egg is a more ancient technology.

>> No.12552124

>>12545224
It doesn't say chicken egg. It says egg, which can be interpreted as the egg containing the first chicken.

>> No.12552131

>>12551552
There's the guy who's talking about that specific chic and that specific egg.

>> No.12552133

>>12545275
Built for RSC, regular sized cock

>> No.12552151

>>12541215
The chicken because eggs are not sexually mature.

>> No.12552157

>>12551534
Sponges. Sponges break of bits of itself that grow into a new Sponge.

>> No.12553073

>>12541589
Well, since God made all living things from clay and it's much easier to make an egg out of clay than it is to make a chicken out of clay so the egg came first.