[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/sci/ - Science & Math


View post   

File: 17 KB, 340x270, il_340x270.1119147369_6va3.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9422749 No.9422749 [Reply] [Original]

Time to Dispute this. Theres an Engineer, Mathematician and a Physicist. They all are given a problem that's decently moderate in difficulty. Whos gonna be faster at mentally solving it? Which one has the better computational adroitness?

>> No.9422762

>>9422749
The engineer would lose because they are the epitome of plug and chug, and would be useless with mental arithmetic
The physicist would beat the mathematician, because only somebody who made the poor life decision of becoming a physicist would both to memorise mathematics, whereas a mathematician would preserve their brainpower for more important tasks.

>> No.9422766

What kind of problem? Does it have a formula? If so would it have been formula the enginer would have learned as opposed the physicist? Is the formula given or must it be remembered/ figured out through logic? Is it a simole question of math, or a question of theory? There are a lot of variables that go into this, none of which you considered.

>> No.9422780

>>9422766
Its Computational Thinking, you're given an expression or equation that have numbers and operations to them, the objective is to look at it and solve it mentally. e.g. Think of MIT integration bee, kids compete with one another trying to solve integrals.

>> No.9422788

>>9422780
All things being equal, the one who writes the fastest will win. But if I had to give a real answer I would think the mathematician. Simply because they have the highest rate for getting into law school and that's my only argument.

>> No.9422791

>>9422788
But its Mental not written, I guess they could prop there finger I'm air and wave it around imitating them actually writing it

>> No.9422792

>>9422791
Ok, then refer to the second part of my post. That's why I put "if I had to give a real answer." and then gave a real answer backed by opinionated logic.

>> No.9422800

>>9422792
Why law school? what's your reasoning behind that?

>> No.9422813

>>9422800
It's logic based. That's pretty much it.

>> No.9422815

>>9422749
It probably depends more on the specific individuals or type of engineer/mathematician/physicist, than on the trichotomy given.

>> No.9422818
File: 112 KB, 1191x670, 01b.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9422818

>>9422749
An engineer, a physicist and a mathematician are in a room with a psychologist and a blond woman.

A blond babe sits on a chair and says she will let any man take her but they must approach in half measures only every time she says "Green light".

The physicist, realizing that half measures would mean never reaching the intended target because closing in on zero is impossible to arrive at through fractions.


The mathematician instantly realizes that approaching one in half measures will never truly result in one and thus ignores the challenge completely.

The engineer on the other hand begins approaching the woman every time she says the word "Green light"

When asked by the psychologist why he was approaching anyway the engineer replies;

"Well for all practical purposes, I will be close enough for all my needs."

>> No.9422836
File: 433 KB, 560x960, 12e.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9422836

>>9422818

>When the physicist realizes that in theory atoms actually never touch each other so using smallest measurement units he could in theory get to touching point without breaking any rules.
>Tfw.
>Mfw.

>> No.9422844

>>9422818

Mathematician:

I DECLARE THE SPACE BETWEEN WOMAN AND ME "x" TO BE EXACTLY 2.

Check mate.
Both of you BTFO

>> No.9422845

>>9422762
The engineer would solve it the fastest.

>> No.9422846
File: 8 KB, 247x204, Woah.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9422846

>>9422844
Did you just imply a mathematician could ever find a girl?

>> No.9422857

>>9422846
*tried to imply*

>> No.9422870

The physicist, these niggas can solve ODE's by head, they struggle for 4 years doing stupid calculations.

Mathematicians waste 4 years developing another way of thinking, proving shit and so.