[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/sci/ - Science & Math


View post   

File: 17 KB, 288x285, AvocadoPhoto.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8182332 No.8182332 [Reply] [Original]

So how do avocados still exist? There haven't been any land animals alive for millions of years that would be able to eat the avocado whole and shit out the seed to plant more.

>> No.8182333

humans breed them you tard

>> No.8182337

>>8182333
But how long have we been planting them, like a few thousand years?

>> No.8182338

to compliment the avocado number.

>> No.8182351

>>8182332
there's an episode of scishow about this

>> No.8182358

>>8182332
The avocado falls to the ground and bounces/rolls a tiny distance. The "fruit" rots away. The seed is now in soil.

>> No.8182383

>>8182332
>There haven't been any land animals alive for millions of years that would be able to eat the avocado whole and shit out the seed to plant more

Implying this statement is correct
Implying our modern variety looks anything like the original wild variety (case point; the banana)
Implying all fruit need to be eaten by animals
Implying starting this shit-tier thread will give you more useful data than simply reading the wiki entry on avocado’s
Implying this isn’t a thinly veiled “what is the evolutionary purpose of…”-thread

Go away, OP. Go away and never come back.

>> No.8182399

>>8182383
avocados would have disappeared if not for aztecs. Animals that could eat them disappeared (giant ground sloths and glyptodons).
Avocados need to be eaten by those animals, and the seeds get out the other side with fertilizer (photosynthesis is not an option in the dense forest)

They disappeared a 10000 years ago, but humans hapened around that time and figured out how to cultivate avocado.

>> No.8183361

>>8182399
>Avocados need to be eaten by those animals
How can you be so sure?

When overripe you only need to step on one to expose the nut. And it is not obvious you need to expose it anyway to get it to germinate.

>> No.8183385

>>8183361
Can't you read? He literary said that the seed needed animal shit as fertilizer (energy source) because the other trees take most of the sunlight for themselves already. Without the shit avocado trees couldn't grow.

>> No.8183418

Mfw Avocados are literally a miracle of the universe

>> No.8183420

>>8183385
You do realize that decomposing fat of the avocado becomes a fertilizer, right? It doesn't have to pass through a digestive channel to gain energy.

>> No.8183423

>>8183385
You do know that soil is filled with animal shit right?

>> No.8183450

Same way we exist

for the lulz?

>> No.8183458

>>8183423
But the animal can't eat the avocado in the first place.

>> No.8183472

>>8183458
The animal can eat it in parts or eat around the seed.

Fucking hell.

>> No.8183488

What is the evolutionary purpose of the fat in an avocado?

>> No.8183495

>>8183458
Again, the avocado falls, the soft part rots away, and the seed is now in soil.

>> No.8183524

>>8182332
>How do coconuts still exist!?!? No animal can open them up!!?! Evolution is a lie!

>> No.8183570

>>8183524
Same as pineapples and chestnuts

>> No.8183574

Why cant it just fall on the ground and germinate, why does it need to be shitted out by a giant sloth.

>> No.8183575

>>8182332
gravity

>> No.8183592

>>8182332
Where are the seeds in the bananas ?

>> No.8183600

>>8182358
Why waste energy on fruit at all then?

>> No.8183615

>>8183592
Where are the seeds in seedless watermelons?

>> No.8184204

>>8183592
they are clones

>> No.8184260

>>8182337
Yes

>> No.8184269

>>8182383
show me the OG bananas

>> No.8184276

>>8183600
because the seed needs to be protected. fruit is made from the biology of the plant, all biology is energy and carbs. its a biological matrix that which other animals can consume to gain energy. fruit hits two birds with one stone. it attracts animals to eat it and to transport the seed and fruit protects the seed. its really ingenious actually.

>> No.8184304
File: 45 KB, 650x618, 00advocado.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8184304

an advocado wasn't meant to be eaten at all. we grew it into having more flesh. pic related: it's how wild avocado's look.
the shell is just there for protection, and method of spreading just rolling a few feet from the mother tree. it wasn't meant to be eaten by animals at all, so yeah, you are right on the "land animals havent been eating avocado's" part.

>> No.8184306

>>8183592
Inside the fruit. We've bred the bananas and got a generation that did not have seeds. Normally this would just die off without producing offspring, but in this case we just cloned the fruit because we like to manipulate nature like that.

>> No.8184318
File: 27 KB, 256x228, wild_banana[1].jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8184318

>>8184269

>> No.8184324

>>8182332
Jeb Bush magic

>> No.8184351

>>8184318
what the FUCK

PLEASE tell me there is a book on this subject and modified fruits in general, I am now interested

>> No.8184384

>>8184351

Jesus are you 14?

>Whoa bananas actually have seeds!?

>This is awesome man knowelllllgggee!

Fucking kill yourself you pleb.
You're ignorance is disgusting.

Sorry for being rude but you're clearly not old enough to be here.

>> No.8184396

>>8184318
Why don't they sell this kind of banana?

>> No.8184398
File: 67 KB, 600x600, 3b85a26275d1622ac9a3ddef8ea4f814.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8184398

>>8182332

How do coconuts still exist? They haven't any land animal alive for millions of years that would be able to eat the coconut whole and shit it out to plant more.

>> No.8184403

>>8184384
>I'm likely being told this by a 20 year old
Fruits and agricultural history are so far down my priority list, but they are interesting when it comes up, so yes, I am ignorant but that should have been obvious since if I wasn't, I wouldn't be asking for a book on the subject

>You're
>kys sorry but not sorry
You could've just said you just looked up on Wikipedia and don't know any book as opposed to showing everyone how miserable you are with your unstable inferiority complex

>> No.8184407

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coconut_crab

>> No.8184411

>>8184407
For >>8184398

>> No.8184417
File: 41 KB, 462x316, ten_thousand.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8184417

>>8184384

>> No.8184419

>>8184384
if you have nothing to contribute, please shut the fuck up.

>> No.8184429

>>8183458
The animals can step on the seeds and drive them into the ground, they can get especially deep if its muddy.

>> No.8184430

>>8184351
https://youtube.com/watch?v=2z-OLG0KyR4

Do not believe his lies

>> No.8184463

>>8184384
>being curious is a bad thing
kys

>> No.8184669

>>8182351
This

If I recall correctly, their extinction coincided with the time humans started practicing agriculture in central/south America

>> No.8184850

>>8182332
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resplendent_quetzal#Feeding
turns out a bird eats and distributes them

>> No.8184897

You numbskulls, the reason the avocados needed the animals to eat them was because the digestive juices strip away the outer coating of the seed itself and activate it. The animal shit is bonus fertilizer in a place where the ground is always covered with decaying leaves.

>> No.8184907
File: 117 KB, 372x351, 1455923043050.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8184907

>>8184419
>>8184463
>if you fucking have fucking nothing to fucking contribute then fucking shut the fuck up

>> No.8185339

>>8182332
how is the seed so shiny?

>> No.8185340

>>8182399
>cultivate
what did he mean by this?

>> No.8185342

>>8185339
That's actually a polished ceramic bowling ball in a giant plastic avacado.

>> No.8185405

>>8184396
>Why don't they sell this kind of banana?
Depends on where you are. Inside EU this is a hugely political thing where some countries pushed through that only bananas from their former colonies should be allowed into Europe. So Europe is a bit bland in this respect. Outside Europe you will find a huge variety of bananas, many of which are not for eating raw but usually fried.

>> No.8185415

>>8184897
Cite?

i put a few avocado seeds in a flower pot and now I have a few mini-trees. And I can assure you no digestive juices were involved.

They grow quickly at first, about 20 cm in a week or so. After that it grows slowly but can reach several meters in height with time also indoor in colder climates.

>> No.8185640

>>8185415
>In 1982, evolutionary biologist Daniel H. Janzen concluded that the avocado is an example of an 'evolutionary anachronism', a fruit adapted for ecological relationship with now-extinct large mammals (such as giant ground sloths or gomphotheres). Most large fleshy fruits serve the function of seed dispersal, accomplished by their consumption by large animals. There are some reasons to think that the fruit, with its mildly toxic pit, may have coevolved with Pleistocene megafauna to be swallowed whole and excreted in their dung, ready to sprout. No extant native animal is large enough to effectively disperse avocado seeds in this fashion.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avocado

Under Coevolution. The fact that modern growers still need to pierce the pit to get it to grow also speaks to this.

>> No.8185678

>>8182338
underrated post

>> No.8185843

>>8182337
In the wild wouldn't am avocado fall from the tree and plant itself

>> No.8186054

>>8185678
I don't get the reference

>> No.8186061
File: 78 KB, 1920x1080, maxresdefault.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8186061

>>8183418
>mfw avocado can be an ayy lmao

>> No.8186103
File: 7 KB, 217x232, avacado man.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8186103

>>8186054

>> No.8186148

>>8186061
Ayyvocado?