[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/sci/ - Science & Math

View post   
File: 28 KB, 915x609, diagram.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4067779 No.4067779 [Reply] [Original]

Okay, just follow me here /sci/

What I'm about to say is going to be pretty fucking pants on head retarded, but just bear with me. Let's get a hypothetical situation.

So we all know that Black Holes really aren't literal holes. They are just mass that is so dense, that its gravity doesn't even let Light escape. Furthermore, they don't necessarily have "infinite" mass. It's just their mass is so ridiculously large, it's impossible to quantify it -- let alone measure it.

So, theoretically, a Black Hole can be ripped apart.

What I'm about to say is going to get really banana's, and won't ever feasibly happen at any time. However, theoretically, is it true?

At this point, look at the Diagram.

The black hole in question is A. Black Holes B and C form on either side of it, or come into gravitational range. Now, both B and C are equal in strength, equidistant from A, and are pulling with the same force. They are also stationary, and are in a vacuum, and out of range of each other respectively.

A is suddenly ripped in half by the significantly stronger black holes and all its mass is flying towards either one. Now, Black Holes D, E, F, G all form the INSTANT "A" is broken up. These black holes are so strong, they rip apart B and C instantly. However, they are just marginally out of range of pulling on the remnants of A. So, therefore, the matter that was ripped apart with the Black Holes' destruction is now free floating in space between like 4 black holes.

Would this work?

>> No.4067799

Why make 4 blackholes, and not just two more on either side of B and C, i wonder...?

>> No.4067818

You are making the common mistake of thinking that the gravity from black holes is somehow more 'destructive' than other objects.

If the sun were replaced by an equally massive black hole guess what would happen to the Earth's motion...
absolutely nothing!

Now.. We like to say that the matter in a black hole is concentrated at its center, no telling if this is exactly true, but it will probably help in this discussion.
The gravity a particle feels from the blackhole it is in (if we can even talk about individual particles within a black hole) would be greater than any other black hole outside of its event horizon.
If it were within the event horizon then those two black holes will merge.


So in short... black holes can't be pulled apart into distinct pieces by gravity.

>> No.4067822

Fuck thats a shitty Feynman diagram, im not even going to read your post until you draw ir better.

>> No.4067823

>>4067818

>If the sun were replaced by an equally massive black hole nothing would happen

Now that's wrong. Black Holes are incredibly dense compared to the Sun. If you mean if a black hole replaced the sun that had the same DENSITY, then yeah. If you mean the same SIZE, then no.

>> No.4067829

>>4067823
>key word was massive
>density and size no longer any part of the equation

Konata, you just went full baka

>> No.4067835

>>4067822
>Thinks thats a Feynman diagram
>laughingwhores.jpg

>> No.4067836

>>4067823
>>4067818
>>4067818
>massive
>mass ive
>mass
>>4067823
>>4067818
>mass
>>4067823
>dense
>DENSITY
>incredibly dense
>SIZE
>>4067823
>>4067818
>massive
>sun

>> No.4067838

>>4067823
He means the same mass, you retard. Not density (which is infinite in a black hole) nor size (which would weigh way more than the sun).
Btw, OP, black holes don't have infinite mass, they have inifite density. Also, black holes can't be ripped apart, they can only merge. They can "evaporate" but thats different.

>> No.4067969

>their mass is so ridiculously large, it's impossible to quantify it
No, the mass is very finite and quantifiable, the density is theoretically infinite.

>So, theoretically, a Black Hole can be ripped apart.
Hmm, certain ways exist. Go on.

>A is suddenly ripped in half by the significantly stronger black holes
No.

>Would this work?
No.

There are two theoretical ways to dismantle a black hole:
1. Natural dissipation over extreme time scales.
2. Making the black hole spin fast enough so it first becomes a torus and then breaks down or becomes a cosmic string, though the latter case is extremely speculative.