[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/sci/ - Science & Math


View post   

File: 32 KB, 425x500, bane of my existence.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
1958370 No.1958370 [Reply] [Original]

Have a homework question I can't figure, and it's making me angry.

y² = sin xy

I'm supposed to find y' by implicit differentiation, and here's where I'm at. (excuse the formatting)

dy/dx = sinx * dy/dx + y * cosx

This is as far as I could get before my brain shut off.

I haven't done much with it, just applied (misapplied?) the product rule, and did implicit stuff to the left side.

There aren't any parenthesis involved with the sin xy so I'm thinking that's what's messing me up.

Any thoughts?

Maybe I should use the chain rule. I ended up with

(cos (xy)) * ( sinx * dy/dx + y * cosx )

Pic related, it's the horrible book I'm using to learn this horseshit.

>> No.1958406

i'm gonna bump this. Thinking of leaving my answer as it is, and just taking a points hit.

>> No.1958414

<span class="math">\frac{d}{dx} y^2 = \frac{d}{dx} xy[/spoiler]
<span class="math">2yy' = (cos xy)(xy' + y)[/spoiler]

And then a miracle occurs? I... don't know where you can go from there.

>> No.1958416

sin(xy) or sin(x)*y ?

>> No.1958424

>>1958414
Oh, well I guess you could always just leave it in terms of x and y.

<span class="math">2yy' = (cos xy)(xy' + y)[/spoiler]
<span class="math">2yy' - xy'(cos xy) = y(cos xy)[/spoiler]
<span class="math">y' = \displaystyle\frac{y(cos xy)}{2y - x(cos xy)}[/spoiler]

>> No.1958425

>>1958406
But you only have so many hit points, and the nearest Pokémon center is miles away.

>> No.1958451 [DELETED] 

ah, yeah, I totally missed the y². Not thinking clearly. The left side should be 2y(dy/dx) (I fucking hate that Leibniz notation, I much prefer prime notation, but what does the instructor use?)


y' = ((cos xy) * (xy' + y))/2y

I dunno how to get rid of the y' in the answer, that can't be right..

Also, how do you make your equations all fancy like that?

>> No.1958458 [DELETED] 

>>1958424
On the left you missed y'-y' didn't you? that's what I kept running into, they cancel out, unless I'm doing it way wrong.

>> No.1958464 [DELETED] 

>>1958416
Bro there's no parenthesis, it's just "sin xy" written exactly like that.

>> No.1958500

>>1958451
I "made it all fancy" with LaTeX.

Here's how you get the answer:

<span class="math">\displaystyle\frac{d}{dx} y^2 = 2y \displaystyle\frac{dy}{dx}[/spoiler]
<span class="math">\displaystyle\frac{d}{dx} \sin (xy) = (\cos (xy))(x\displaystyle\frac{dy}{dx} + y)[/spoiler]

Group the dy/dx's on the left side

<span class="math">2y \displaystyle\frac{dy}{dx} = (\cos (xy))(x\displaystyle\frac{dy}{dx} + y)[/spoiler]
<span class="math">2y \displaystyle\frac{dy}{dx} - x(\cos (xy))\displaystyle\frac{dy}{dx} = y(\cos (xy))[/spoiler]
<span class="math">(2y - x(\cos (xy))) \displaystyle\frac{dy}{dx} = y(\cos (xy))[/spoiler]
<span class="math">\displaystyle\frac{dy}{dx} = \displaystyle\frac{y(\cos (xy))}{2y - x(\cox (xy))}[/spoiler]

Hope I didn't make a LaTeX mistake there.

>> No.1958506

And of course, I did. Here you go.

<span class="math">\displaystyle\frac{dy}{dx} = \displaystyle\frac{y(\cos (xy))}{2y - x(\cos (xy))}[/spoiler]

>> No.1958514 [DELETED] 

(consolidating and testing math tags)
ah, yeah, I totally missed the <span class="math">y^2[/spoiler]. Not thinking clearly.

The left side should be <span class="math">2y\frac{dy}{dx}[/spoiler] (I fucking hate that Leibniz notation, I much prefer prime notation, but what does the instructor use?)

<span class="math">y'=\frac{(cosxy)*(xy' + y)}{2y}[/spoiler]

I dunno how to get rid of the y' in the answer, that can't be right..


>>1958424
On the left you missed <span class="math">y'-y'[/spoiler] didn't you? that's what I kept running into, they cancel out, unless I'm doing it way wrong.

>>1958416
Bro there's no parenthesis, it's just "sin xy" written exactly like that.

>> No.1958521

(consolidating and testing math tags)
ah, yeah, I totally missed the <span class="math">y^2[/spoiler]. Not thinking clearly.

The left side should be <span class="math">2y\displaystyle\frac{dy}{dx}[/spoiler] (I fucking hate that Leibniz notation, I much prefer prime notation, but what does the instructor use?)

<span class="math">y'=\displaystyle\frac{(cosxy)*(xy' + y)}{2y}[/spoiler]

I dunno how to get rid of the y' in the answer, that can't be right..


>>1958424
On the left you missed <span class="math">y'-y'[/spoiler] didn't you? that's what I kept running into, they cancel out, unless I'm doing it way wrong.

>>1958416
Bro there's no parenthesis, it's just "sin xy" written exactly like that.

>> No.1958535
File: 12 KB, 193x216, GunshowRageKid.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
1958535

>>1958521
"Bro", you SHOULD have used parentheses. As it's written, it's completely unclear whether you mean "the product of y and the sin of x", or "the sin of the product of x and y".

>> No.1958541

OP you in math 150?

>> No.1958546

ohhh shit, you factor out the <span class="math">\displaystyle\frac{dy}{dx}[/spoiler]

I got it now.

But, this all presumes that the equation is meant to be sin (xy)

Still no fucking idea if that's right, but hopefully this effort will count.

Thanks a ton bro/broette, you've saved my ass.

>> No.1958548

>>1958521
I missed y' - y'? What the heck are you talking about? I grouped all y' terms on the left side and factored.

If I had:

2bx - 3ax = c

You would factor out x to get:

(2b - 3a)x = c

Then divide by (2b-3a) to get

x = c/(2b-3a)

This is stuff you should know FAR before calculus...

>> No.1958553

>>1958541
no I think it's 165, Calc 1

>>1958535
I didn't write the problem. I agree that the instructor should have specified, but I'm writing what I see. The fact that this isn't clear to you is shameful, Bro.

>> No.1958556
File: 62 KB, 375x500, pd1767181.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
1958556

>>1958535
the sin of the product of x and y, eh?

>> No.1958563

>>1958548
Yeah I know, it's basic algebra, hence the realization once I noticed the stupid mistake. I tend to overlook things like that when I'm worn out. Sorry!

>> No.1958569
File: 56 KB, 351x336, 1287923226034.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
1958569

>>1958556
Yep, when that dastardly i tempted X into giving Y the apple pi of the knowledge of true and false.