[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/sci/ - Science & Math

View post   
File: 62 KB, 960x540, dog-licks-lips-960x540.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11665911 No.11665911 [Reply] [Original]

To what extent do animals have "mind" as we conceive of it? To what extent are they just responding to stimuli?

>> No.11665913

To what extent are we just responding to stimuli?

>> No.11665931

>>11665913
I dont respond to stimuli

>> No.11665933

>>11665931
>I dont respond to stimuli
stop responding to anon's posts then

>> No.11665934
File: 4 KB, 208x243, 3jn4kl2j3kl;jfsdkl;.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11665934

>>11665931
>I dont respond to stimuli

>> No.11665941

>>11665933
I dont respond to anon's posts

>> No.11665958

>>11665913
I think our actions aren't as motivated by what happens in our minds as we would like to think, but we still do have mind. or at least I do

>> No.11665965

>>11665911
Well I can tell you that dogs are very sensitive to human emotion and display similar emotional characteristics to us. They also dream. My dog dreams just about every single night.

>> No.11665972

>>11665931
>I dont respond to stimuli

>> No.11665978
File: 331 KB, 960x960, 6FA3F86B-199F-408A-BB43-618B2B8BD171.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11665978

>>11665931
>>11665972
Fuck forgot photo. You’re a brainlet

>> No.11666206

>>11665911
To the same extent as humans. If by "animals" you include Jews and Native Africans then of course the answer is those are exceptions; they don't have minds.

>> No.11666357

>>11666206
Hello? Yes this is based department

>> No.11666378

>>11665911
Woof woof bark bark woof woof
>Woof woof woof woof
Woof bark woof

Bark

>> No.11666381

>>11666206
grrrrr BARK BARK BARK!

>> No.11666420

>>11666378
Dogs are good

>>11666381
If you are doing the racist dog thing it’s not working.

>> No.11666776

>>11665911
>To what extent do animals have "mind"...
are you including "humans" in what you call animals?
if not, then to what extent are humans NOT considered animals?

I'm not trying to be coy or cute here. If you answer 1 question you answer both of them. They're kinda the same question in a weird way.

>> No.11666841

>>11665933
He's a monad, baka

>> No.11666867

>>11666776
I think in this case the difference is that we know humans have a mind because we're experiencing it when we think about this. And we can use language to communicate about it and based on the responses of others we can see that they've used abstract reasoning to think about it and therefore probably have a mind

>> No.11666879

>>11665911
Huh, We could ask the same about ourselves.

>> No.11668345

Bump because animals.