/sci/ - Science & Math

>>8205590

I can post examples of false syllogisms all day too. (pic related). I know what it is, and i can recognize it. Debase my arguments if you're so clever, don't invent new examples that aren't even compatible with the situation.

>>8205602
>The possibility of tall non-doctors and male tall non-doctors are both given by the statement "some" which allows for the construction of those sets (which could be empty or non-intersecting) with any combinations of the elements of "men" "tall" and "doctors".

While "male tall doctors" are implied by the statement, "male tall non-doctors" aren't. They're only a possibility, not a fact, like "male tall doctors".