[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature

View post   
File: 37 KB, 1114x946, IMG_2764.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9758556 No.9758556 [Reply] [Original]

Is Don Quixote still worth the read after all these years? It actually sounds very intriguing but I just want to hear from someone who has read it.

>> No.9758560

no

>> No.9758568

It's still funny if you like violent humor. Also, a lot of it is still relevant, like how at one point the idea that the media that one enjoys effects their ideology. Also about making your dreams into reality. And much more. It's very complex. Just read it.

>> No.9758575

>>9758560
This guy is a return. Grossman translation is the best text other than the original.

>> No.9758577

>>9758575
*Retard

>> No.9758675

>>9758556
I was going to read it whether it was relevant or not. I have never read a book or consumed a piece of classic media and got nothing out of it

>> No.9758679

I hear there is a lot of satire about the time period. Anyone know a good history book that can help me understand the basics?

>> No.9758695

>>9758679
i'd say it's more cultural critique than historically specific critique, so everyone can get it if you understand out of touch elites, gross peasants and stuff like that. it's not very historically specific stuff.

i'd say it's also nice because even if it makes fun of everybody most of the characters have some kind of moment of kindness of heart, even if limited. sort of a catholic message permeating all the book, which is almost always present in any old spanish literature.

>> No.9758707

>>9758556
>is the greatest novel ever written worth a read

>> No.9758715

>>9758707
yeah, think he's asking along the lines of what makes it the greatest novel ever written

>> No.9758717

>>9758679
>>9758695
also as commented there Don Quixote is a high-minded, kind and idealistic book, even if ultimately pessimistic

if you want nastier humoristic social critique you can try some picaresque novel like quevedo's El Buscón or anonymous' the life of lazarillo de tormes and of his fortunes and adversities. lots of brutish unfiltered poverty and all kinds of nastiness in there.

>> No.9758726

The whole thing is basically DQ doing somerthing autistic, calling someones mother a whore, getting beat up, repeat. Very worth it.

>> No.9758858

>>9758717
>the life of lazarillo de tormes and of his fortunes and adversities
i don't remember writing this

neat

>> No.9758860

>>9758726
>I only read the first half of the first half: the post.

>> No.9759378

best spain book?

>> No.9759431

>>9758556

This is an amazing book. I read a translation, I don't know which, but I actually quite enjoyed it. Without realizing it, this was my first great piece of literature I read. I didn't even know what the Canon was back then. I wrote a pretty good essay on it too.

>> No.9760697

>>9758556
as a time capsule, yeah, as a form of entertainment.. so-so? it was extremely inventive for its time period and broke a lot of walls, but a good deal of the satire and by extension its humor is lost in translation. cut a lot of the bloat and just get the abridged version. otherwise you're staring down a lot of needless repetition.