only patrician opinions itt

[Anonymous No.9228117]

>best
Ithaca
>runner up
oxen of the sun
>worst
Penelope
>overrated
Circe
>underrated
Cyclops

[Anonymous No.9228726]

>>9228117
Why do you consider Ithaca the best? I know what it has going for it, but is it really the best chapter in the whole book?
I agree that Penelope is the worst though, although it's hard to call any chapter in the book "worst".
Here's my list
>best
Hades
>runner up
Wanding Rocks
>worst
Penelope
>overrated
Circe
>underrated
Nausicaa

I know "Hades" and "Wanding Rocks" aren't that good when it comes to the prose and structure if you compare it to some other chapters in the book, but I really loved how comfy they both feel.

[Anonymous No.9228936]

>>9228117
>best
Ithaca
>runner up
oxen of the sun

Nothing to change here.

Wouldn't consider Cyclops underrated though. I'd rather leave that category to Sirens.
And worst is actually Aeolus.

[Anonymous No.9228973]

>best
Oxen of the Sun
>runner up
Nausicaa
>worst
Eumaeus
>overrated
Not sure
>underrated
Anything from the Telemachiad

[Anonymous No.9228978]

>>9228117
Y u fgtz k33p talkin bout dat shit here pleb boi????

[Anonymous No.9229109]

>>9228973
>>>/pleb/

[Anonymous No.9229127]

I don't want to be a faggot and rate "Penelope" as worst simply because it was the one that was most annoying to read. It's awfully tempting, though.

In reality, "Aeolus" is probably the worst chapter. It's super trite.

[Anonymous No.9229142]

This thread is fraught with insecurity.

[Anonymous No.9229156]

ranked

Proteus
Ithaca
Circe
Penelope
Sirens
Cyclops
Hades
Oxen of the Sun
Aeolus
Scylla and Charybdis
Telemachus
Nausicaa
Eumaeus
Calypso
Lestrygonians
Nestor
Lotus Eaters

[Anonymous No.9229170]

>best
Proteus
>runner up
Ithaca
>overrated
Sirens
>underrated
Wandering Rocks

[Anonymous No.9229203]

>>9229142
I think you mean board

[Anonymous No.9230265]

>>9228117
I'd list Oxen and Wandering Rocks as best and list Telemachus as underrated too, otherwise agree.