[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature

View post   
File: 185 KB, 299x475, 662.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7425682 No.7425682 [Reply] [Original]

Is this a good book?

>> No.7425685

Nah, might as well read a book on how to make model trains.

>> No.7425690

no

>> No.7425692
File: 561 KB, 705x785, 1443267659675-0.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7425692

>>7425682
Fountainhead gets the theory across and is way shorter.

>> No.7425694

I enjoyed it. Her philosophy isn't so bad, people just can't seem to handle individualism for whatever reason

>> No.7425697

>>7425692
Yeah, I enjoyed The Fountainhead much more.

>> No.7425701

>>7425694
strawman or someshit.

>> No.7426265

>>7425692
>way shorter
What the hell are you talking about?

I liked Anthem, Fountainhead, and Atlas Shrugged in that order, but don't bother with any of them. If you want to get an impression of her fiction, read the draft of her play/novel "Ideal", which was just published recently.
I think her philosophical prose, though, is excellent, and she's very good in interviews, even though her philosophy itself is bullshit.
She's an interesting character, and worth exploring for that reason, but there's not much reason or pleasure to reading her books.

>> No.7428015

>>7425682
Yes. It was instrumental in teaching me that plasmids are the future and lighthouses are the gateways to alternate worlds where waifus are locked up by giant birds in the sky by order of an old version of the guy who comes to rescue her. I don't know how, but it did.

>> No.7428023

It's not by any means a bad book

>> No.7428030

It's long and boring and very flat but I think that her aesthetic has something to it that's underrated and worth a closer look. I don't really care about morals and half baked philosophies in fiction so I'm apathetic to hers.

>> No.7428044

>>7425694
No, its not that people cant handle individualism, its that the way she writes is abhorrent and makes it exceedingly difficult to give any of her arguments credibility.

>> No.7428777

>>7425682
You should definitely read The Fountainhead FIRST.

And if you don't like that, skip Atlas Shrugged, but DO still read We The Living, which I think is her best novel and is very different from her other fiction.

And just keep in mind, the vast overwhelming majority of her detractors hate her because they disagree with her philosophy. Don't listen to any of it until you've read her stuff for yourself. Make up your own damned mind.

>> No.7428824
File: 604 KB, 1920x1080, image.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7428824

>>7428015

>> No.7430652

>>7425682
Officer Barbrady said it was the biggest piece of crap he's ever read.

>> No.7430656

>>7430652
>tfw Leslie is evil

>> No.7430664

>>7430656
I really liked when Kinny's dad is sick and he starts having diarrhea and does it in the trash, then nosebleeds, then vomits, then shits all over again.

>> No.7430676

>>7426265
>her philosophy itself is bullshit.
Explain. I don't see how you can call what is basically libertarianism bullshit unless you're some socialist fag. Giving people handouts doesn't make society better, it just reinforces destructive behaviours.

>> No.7431180

Chapter 2 is very beautiful. The rest is pretty awful. Just read his speech, and you'll get everything there is to know.

>> No.7431214
File: 14 KB, 292x323, 1449080649676.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7431214

>>7425682
No.

>> No.7431320

>>7425682
Even though this is likely b8, yes, it is a good book. Sure, the prose is dull and the characters siff, but the theme of individualism is one that cannot be missed. Unlike a lot of people, I actually enjoyed the story and plot. A lot of her largest critics have either never read her, or have and misunderstood/oversimplified/perverted her arguments beyond any reasonable justification. A lot of the people on this board who have read her and even claim to be Rand supporters often misunderstand her ideas.

Either way, I think Rand would want you to read it for yourself and decide on your own whether or not it is a "good" book. It was well worth the read.