[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature


View post   

File: 740 KB, 1203x1600, female_america_better.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7340269 No.7340269 [Reply] [Original]

Who is the greatest American writer of all time?

>> No.7340274 [DELETED] 

>>7340269
Aldous Huxley

>> No.7340275
File: 22 KB, 200x244, 432[1].jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7340275

desu

>> No.7340276

>>7340269
Gaddis by a wide margin.

>> No.7340282

>>7340269
John Green.

>> No.7340292
File: 844 KB, 200x150, 1405394492823.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7340292

>>7340276
>Gaddis by a wide margin.
Oh, man. ESLs crack me up.

>> No.7340299

Melville or Faulkner

>> No.7340300

Faulkner and Melville

>> No.7340308

Mark Twain.

>> No.7340311

>>7340299
>>7340300
/thread

>> No.7340312
File: 24 KB, 300x250, 1436614019195.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7340312

>>7340292
Interesting, people who haven't read Gaddis crack me up.

>> No.7340313

>>7340269
Tao Lin

>> No.7340315

>>7340300
>>7340308
>>7340299
>not James and Updike

>> No.7340318

>>7340269
Steinbeck

>> No.7340330

>>7340312
He's low tier desu
The whole mithra thing is such amateurish fucking trash lad
Where are you from btw?

>> No.7340336

>>7340269
mccarthy

>> No.7340339

>>7340330
Nigga, you trash. Amerilard btw.

>> No.7340343

>>7340339
foreigner confirmed

>> No.7340351

>>7340343
You can't confuse me, commie. The blood of white jesus runs through my veins.

>> No.7340357

>>7340351
haha nice one

Edit: How do I use the green font on this webforum?

>> No.7340388
File: 48 KB, 300x275, you don't even know who I am do you,.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7340388

>> No.7340389

>>7340388
That's not Gaddis

>> No.7340394 [DELETED] 

>>7340269
Ursala K. Le Guin

>> No.7340400

>>7340357
>2015
>not knowing how to implement meme arrows

>> No.7340402

>>7340269
TOP FIVE
1. Melville
2. James
3. Pinecone
4. Hawthtothehorne
5. The Twainster
NO POETS INCLUDED WHITMAN IS BEST AMERICUNT POET

>> No.7340406

>>7340402
>james
you're retarded bro

>> No.7340411

>>7340406
YOU'RE MOM'S RETARDED. SHE HAS A LARGE FOREHEAD AND SWEARS THAT IT ISN'T DOWNS, BUT YOU ALL KNOW IT'S DOWNS.

>> No.7340414

>>7340411
Youre a mean person

>> No.7340416

>>7340406
Haha did the man write something you didn't understand?

>> No.7340423

>>7340414
IF BY MEAN, YOU MEAN AVERAGE.

>> No.7340427

>>7340423
No, you use hurtwords

>> No.7340430

>>7340406
>>7340411
>>7340414
>>7340416
>>7340423
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hiRacdl02w4

>> No.7340431

>>7340430
That hurt my feelings. Please apologize.

>> No.7340434

>>7340427
HURTWORDS. ARE YOU POSITIVE THAT YOU HAVE ATTAINED THE CORRECT AMOUNT OF YEARS TO BE POSTING TO THIS KHALKHIN GOL CELEBRATION BOARD.

>> No.7340438

>>7340430
YES MY GOOD SIR. I CONCUR WITH THIS MEME. MY INTELLIGENCE IS LOW ENOUGH TO POST TO THIS PUSHKIN PUTSCH.

>> No.7340440

>>7340434
Please apologize. Pls.

>> No.7340444

>>7340269
Robert E Howard lel.

>> No.7340457

>>7340440
I HAVE MADE TERRIBLE MISTAKES THAT HAVE HURT THE PEOPLE THAT I CARED ABOUT THE MOST, AND I AM TERRIBLY SORRY. I AM DEEPLY ASHAMED OF MY TERRIBLE JUDGMENT AND MY ACTIONS.- ANTHONY WEINER

NOTE THAT i DID NOT MAKE THIS REMARK. I AM NOT SORRY. MY ANONYMOUS CUNTENANCE COURTS CONTENT BEYOND MY COUNT!

>> No.7340467

>>7340457
Pls

>> No.7340474

>>7340467
JUST AS ONE DOES NOT MOUNT MIDGET'S MIDDLING FUNDAMENTS AMONG MASSIVE MASKS OF AFRICAN CATS, SO TO DO I NOT APOLOGIZE TO ANONS.

>> No.7340487

>>7340474
Pls

>> No.7340496

Welp this is the most off-topic shit posting i've ever seen on /lit/

Congrats.

>> No.7340497

>>7340487
UNLIKE MOLLY AT THE END OF HER THOUGHT'S SALLY, THE FINAL WORD IS NO. G'NIGHT ANON AND ENJOY LIFE/

>> No.7340504
File: 33 KB, 1024x576, 4ccb243504fe3f3dd1a53a9205e41fa1b94af3a3a80b9bbb869a4c7a76db3c67_large.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7340504

>>7340402
>>7340315
>there are people unironically think that henry james was a good writer

>> No.7340507

>>7340496
Apologize

>> No.7340510

>>7340496
How's your first day so far?

>> No.7340516

>>7340504
>this person finds James boring because he doesn't understand James

>> No.7340519

Awful thread

Whitman, Crane, Gaddis, Melville

>> No.7340523

>>7340519
Good taste

>> No.7340527

>>7340519
Why Gaddis? What about him makes you think he deserves a spot over other American greats? I'm actually quite curious. I'm assuming you mentioning the best American poet of the 20th century means you're not actually shit posting.

>> No.7340535 [DELETED] 

>>7340527
>I'm assuming you mentioning the best American poet of the 20th century means you're not actually shit posting.
I like Melville too! *shakes hand firmly*

>> No.7340537

>>7340516
>he thinks James is difficult to understand because he's illiterate

>> No.7340539

>>7340527
So many things. Imagine a more lucid, verbose, less lewd Pynchon. It became evident to me in the first page of The Recognitions that he was phenomenal. I highly recommend him.

>> No.7340540

>>7340527
>I'm assuming you mentioning the best American poet of the 20th century means you're not actually shit posting.
That's strange, i don't see Ralph Waldo Emerson on that list desu

>> No.7340541

Gene Wolfe

>> No.7340543

>>7340535
>melville
>not dead in 1891
top kek.

>> No.7340546

>>7340537
Anyone who doesn't find at least one of James' novels difficult is either lying or a Milton-tier reader.
Somehow I doubt a 4channarian reads that much.

>> No.7340548

>>7340269
Tao Lin

>> No.7340550

>>7340543
DELET

>> No.7340551

>>7340546
>Anyone who doesn't find at least one of James' novels difficult is either lying or a Milton-tier reader.
Not really. /lit/ has lowered your standards

>>7340539
>It became evident to me in the first page of The Recognitions that he was phenomenal
But that page is already chock full of the juvenile ideas that ruin the book. His later work is much better imo

>> No.7340552

>>7340540
20th century senpai

>> No.7340553

>>7340539
I have a copy of JR I found for a couple dollars. Probably start it after I finish The Clown.

>> No.7340554

>>7340551
I'm not saying he is impenetrable, but he is difficult.

>> No.7340556

>>7340552
he's the greatest of every century desu

>> No.7340557

>>7340540
That's probably because Emerson isn't even a 20th century poet dumbass


The answer is Walt Whitman and anyone who doesn't think so either hasn't read him or isn't smart. Usually questions like "greatest blank of all time" are pointless and unanswerable but Whitman is simply the American writer, period.

>> No.7340568

>>7340557
Whitman is an overrated hack. Only people who write poetry understand this.

There is not a single good American poet though.

>> No.7340570

>>7340551
I felt that that was part of the point, though there is a very good chance I'm wrong.

>> No.7340572

>>7340568
What poets do you like?

>> No.7340575

>>7340568
>guaranteed replies

>> No.7340578
File: 981 KB, 720x1125, columbialily-tigerlily.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7340578

>>7340568
>Whitman is an overrated hack. Only people who write poetry understand this.
i've probably been writing reading and teaching poetry for longer than you've been alive
>There is not a single good American poet though
okay u got me i took ur bait congrats

>> No.7340580

>>7340269
hemmmingway

>> No.7340583

>>7340578
Reasons for living:
(You)

>> No.7340910

william faulkner

>> No.7340938 [DELETED] 

MOTHAFUCKIN HERMAN MELVILLE

Bastard didn't even go to college, he just sailed the world.

>Daily reminder to go reread Moby DIck you pleb

>> No.7340939

Either Fitzgerald or Hemingway

>> No.7340940

Huxley

>> No.7340945

>>7340938
The Confidence Man is also seriously underrated, and just as significant as an "American' text (i.e. it's about the nature of confidence and cons)

>> No.7341154

>>7340357
/spoiler use ">" /spoiler

>> No.7341173

>>7340269
Paine & Jefferson

>> No.7341175

>>7340557
>questions like this one are pointless and unanswerable
>but I'll still answer OK whitman > all and if you don't agree ur dumb

>> No.7341189

>>7340504
i was thinking he meant william james

>> No.7342119

>>7341175
>usually
did I stutter faggot?

>> No.7342368

Melville. Wrote the GOAT novel, did kafka 50 years before kafka, pomo 100 years before pomo.

>> No.7342374

>>7342368
i don't think you know what "pomo" means

>> No.7342386

>>7342374
in the context of literature Confidence-Man is considered the first example of POMO, homo.

>> No.7342389

No female authors mentioned?

>> No.7342395

Boring answer, but Melville Hawthorne Whitman Crane

>>7340276

Fucking god no

The dude couldn't sustain the quality of his 950 page book past page 100, and the book turns to garbage after 450

JR and later are fucking awful

Freshman detected !!!

>> No.7342398

>>7342386
>postmodernism
>post
>modernism
modernism was an era in the early 20th century
post is a prefix meaning after

after modernism
after the early 20th century
Melville was before the early 20th century
not after it

get it?

>> No.7342411

>>7340539
embarrassing.

>> No.7342414

>all these gaddisfags out in full force trying to defend their favorite mediocre author

>> No.7342761
File: 901 KB, 1292x774, dream-movie.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7342761

John Kennedy Toole

>> No.7342766

james baldwin

>> No.7342880

>>7340510
edgy fuck

>> No.7344146

clearly Thomas Wolfe

>> No.7344168

Gaddis

>> No.7344171

Robert Ludlum

>> No.7344226

Vladimir Nabokov
disprove it

>> No.7344263

>>7340336
I second this

>> No.7344267

>>7344263
Cormac's great but I don't think he's greater than Melville.

>> No.7344403

>>7342389
None measure up.

>> No.7344622

>>7342411
I mean, it's not the best comparison. But there is a clear reason why everyone thought Pynchon was a pen name for Gaddis when he first started publishing.

>> No.7345050
File: 97 KB, 744x748, 1444622172983.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7345050

>>7340315
What's Updike?

>> No.7345070

who's the guy who wrote the biblle? hat guy is good thank

>> No.7346431

>>7340430
I'm actually really glad I watched that.

>> No.7346451
File: 49 KB, 600x427, bukowski093.11.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7346451

>>7340269
Charles Fucking Bukowski and Ernest Fucking Hemingway. Smd

>> No.7346454

>>7346451
Your opinion differs from mine; therefore, it is wrong.

>> No.7346455

>>7346431
It's a really good video and an old one.

>> No.7346471

>>7346451
theres a bluebird in my pants.

>> No.7346475

>>7346471
I've got a bigger cock than you

>> No.7347221

I'd say Gaddis because he's the new meme

>> No.7347228

>>7347221
Why some people insist on lowering the quality of this board I cannot understand.

>> No.7347478

>>7347228
Nice bait

>> No.7347677

Borges.

>> No.7347767

Me tbqhwya

>> No.7347787
File: 2.94 MB, 2485x3229, Hemingway_portrait_everwise.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7347787

>> No.7347820

>>7347787

>If the word has more than 7 letters in it, he won't use it

Naw

>> No.7347824

>>7347478
Stay pleb

>> No.7347825

I never understood why /it/ thinks Pynchon is the greatest living American writer. Roth is a way better desu

Also, OP, Hemingway and Fitz.

>> No.7347826
File: 106 KB, 570x913, il_570xN.654771908_lu9u.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7347826

DFW

>> No.7347977

>>7347826
>>>/tv/

>> No.7348122

Whitman you fucking retards

>> No.7348359

>>7342389
Harper Lee.

>> No.7348368

>>7348359
sup reddit

>> No.7348369

>>7347826
this desu

>> No.7348372

>>7340269
John Green :^)

>> No.7348381

>>7348372
>>7340282
/thread

>> No.7348538

The little slut who sits across from me on the train.

>> No.7348544

>>7347826
yeah, if we're being honest, but this is /lit/

>> No.7348734

>all these people in /lit/
>none of them read

Nice try faggots but the answer is unequivocally a fucking tossup between Emerson and Updike. Poetry goes to Eliot, fuck you Whitmanfags.

>> No.7348738

>>7348734
>Emerson and Updike
>better than Hawthorne, James, or Cabell
>Eliot
>better than Melville or Ransom
topuck

>> No.7348742

emily dickinson

>> No.7348745

>>7348734
>Eliot
>American
that pansy ass belongs to the british whose dicks he spent his whole life trying to fit into his tiny anus

>> No.7348754

>>7348738
>Citing the bastard children of an ideology as better than the source.
>Melville's poetry
>Melville's poetr
>Melville's poet
>Melville's poe
>Melville's po
>Melville's p
>Melville's
>Melville

>> No.7348757

>>7348745
Fuck you he does.

>> No.7348759

>>7348754
>Melville's poetry
is great desu

>> No.7348766

>>7348759
>Melville's poetry is great
>Melville's poetry is grea
>Melville's poetry is gre
>Melville's poetry is gr
>Melville's poetry is g
>Melville's poetry is
>Melville's poetry i
>Melville's poetry
>Melville's poetr
>Melville's poet
>Melville's poe
>Melville's po
>Melville's p
>Melville's
>Melville

>> No.7348769

>>7348754
>bastard children of an ideology
who's this lad

>> No.7348773

>>7340299
>>7340300
double dubs confirm

>> No.7348777
File: 1.94 MB, 230x175, 1405398792274.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7348777

>>7348734
>Poetry goes to Eliot

>> No.7348781

Pynchon, Gaddis, Morrison, Faulkner, Melville

>> No.7348783
File: 23 KB, 300x400, 30.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7348783

>>7348781
>Morrison,
whoa there! almost got me lad

>> No.7348787

>>7347825

Philip Roth is remarkably mediocre when considered on his own, Next to Pynchon he reads like a college student

>> No.7348791

>>7348781
>Pynchon
top kek >>7347825

>> No.7348792
File: 399 KB, 1920x1200, Jim-Morrison-the-doors-29018208-1920-1200.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7348792

>>7348783
you got a problem with the lizard king bro?

>> No.7348793

>>7340269
Steinbeck
Faulkner
Melville
Whitman

>> No.7348794

>>7342389

Toni Morrison is god-tier

>>7342386

That would be Don Quixote

>> No.7348796
File: 431 KB, 576x432, 1409843951485.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7348796

>>7348793
>Steinbeck

>> No.7348801

>>7348791

Top kek

>>7348787


>>7348783

Nice Penn Jillette pic, tell me more about the beauty of science and the outrage of social justice

>> No.7348807

>>7347825
Roth is better than Pynchon, but Gene Wolfe is better than both desu

>> No.7348810

>>7348801
>if u dont like my shit tier author ur le neckbeard
topkek
I'm a turkish woman

>> No.7348811
File: 219 KB, 1035x719, 1035x719-george1800-1404938050.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7348811

Are you talking about me?

>> No.7348814

>>7348796
Honey...

>> No.7348818
File: 1.73 MB, 209x213, 1417677423784.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7348818

>>7348781
>Morrison
>>7348794
>Toni Morrison is god-tier

>> No.7348819
File: 118 KB, 579x527, plebeian.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7348819

>>7348787
>Philip Roth is remarkably mediocre when considered on his own,
Have you ever read anything by him?

>> No.7348862

>>7348810

I don't care what you are, you're a moron

>>7348807

I puked
You doing read

>> No.7348865

>>7348819

American Pastoral, Portnoy's Complaint, Goodbye Columbus, Sabbath's Theater

>> No.7348883

>>7348865
If you did, you would know that American Pastoral alone is better than every Pynchon together but Gravity's Rainbow. Stop namedroping stuff and lying on the Internet, you pleb faggot.

>> No.7348888

>>7348883

Every Pynchon book apart from Slow Learner is better than any Roth I've read

Nice job to you and your buddies calling me a pleb faggot though, it demonstrates my point effectively

>> No.7348901

>>7348819
>>7348883
American Pastoral is mediocre beyond belief.

>> No.7348903
File: 97 KB, 300x389, Hedonism Melville.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7348903

I love Roth and Pynchon. You're both fucking retards.
Melville wins anyway.

>> No.7348938

Faulkner by a large Margin.

>> No.7348966

William Faulkner or Cormac McCarthy.

>> No.7348969

>>7344226

He wasn't American.

>> No.7348993

Melville, Dickinson, DeLillo.

>> No.7348996

Gotta go with my personal favorite author, Vonnegut. Faulkner is a close second.

>> No.7349053

Orwell.

>> No.7349085

Dracula.

>> No.7349565

>>7347820
Faulkner pls go

>> No.7349608

>>7340388
>>7340389

I've literally never seen his picture before now. That's a rad beard Melville has going.

>> No.7349677

>>7349608
I always pictured Melville as scraggly old man. Turns out he was handsome as fuck.

>> No.7349767

>>7349565
Kek
>2015
>not sending your readers to the dictionary

>> No.7349778

>>7348862
>assert something that no one with an ounce of brain can take seriously
>get assblasted when people call you out
They should add arithmetic to the captcha to keep mongs like you out desu

>> No.7349781

>>7347824
You know what? Meet after school under the flagpole. IM GOING TO KICK YOUR BUTT.