[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature

View post   
File: 544 KB, 1855x2560, J.K.-Rowling-2021-Photography-Debra-Hurford-Brown-scaled.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
21648841 No.21648841 [Reply] [Original]

How successful would HP be if he were a girl? Also who is this generations JK?

>> No.21648850

>>21648841
>How successful would HP be if he were a girl
No clue. I think females find it easier to read from a male perspective than vice versa.

>who is this generations JK
I don't think there has been one yet.

>> No.21648852

read another book series

>> No.21648857

>>21648852
Why?

>> No.21648939

Game of Thrones man is the new Rowling.

>> No.21648968

>>21648939
For children?

>> No.21649073

>>21648841
it wouldn't have been succesful, that's also why her pen name is JK and not Joanne Kathleen, as per her editor's initial advice.

>> No.21649080

>>21649073
Why is this? Is it because boys don't like reading stories with a female lead? Alice in wonderland is popular with both genders all over the world.

>> No.21649087

>>21649080
>girls want to be alice
>boys want to bang alice
also written while trippin on lsd

>> No.21649092

>>21649087
What if HP and Alice were a female anthro character? Kids love animals.

>> No.21649170

>>21648841
Are there any hints of Rowling's ideology in HP books? I mean, we all thought it was the liberal series par excellence but it came out her author was a "radical".

>> No.21649180

>>21649170
Something about goblins being Jews... I forgor

>> No.21649190

I wish I could clap her cheeks

>> No.21649195

>>21648841
OH GOD, WHY IS SHE SO CUTE!?

>> No.21649216

>>21648841
Her works have genuinely a really good flow, she's a great writer. But she fails with the coherence of the story, many plot holes or nonsense explanations

>> No.21649219

>>21648841
Not nearly as successful. Don't have one and I don't think we ever will.

>> No.21649238

>>21649080
They'll get made fun of and their friends will call them gay. Early on little boys learn to never show even a hint of interest in things with girls in them.

>> No.21649262

>>21649170
More than half the people defending trannies nowadays didn't give a single fuck about them 20+ years ago

>> No.21649286

>>21649262
More like 10 and even less.
Jon Stewart was making fun of them in 2005 and now he dedicated a whole episode to the importance of puberty blockers.

>> No.21649296

>>21649286
ok but we're talking about author ideology in Harry Potter

>> No.21649375

>>21648852

>> No.21649572

>>21649170
>fleurs feminity is portrayed as dangerous and bewitching
>character openly shit on that trait
>nymbhadoras feminity is also trait she is born with. Like it was disease.
>books hate her and treat her like shit
>lavender is girly and femine.
>is made agonist for JK own self insert
>lavender is treated badly just becouse she was in love.
It's clear she hates feminity in woman. She thinks proper woman is more dominant and cool. Mother is ultimate form of woman. No idea how deep she is in trad mentality. But I wouldn't be suprised if she comes out and says womans place is in kitchen rising her children.

>> No.21649579

>>21649216
That's true for first 3 books. 4 is slow and convoluted. 5 could cut 200 pages. 6 is just usless book.
If she had just writen book about Harry's school life without much bigger plot. It would have been better then 4,5 and 6

>> No.21649597

>>21649170
She literally said if you were a Christian you’d be able to guess the ending of the series. Harry dies and experiences a heavenly vision (you might say) in the chapter titled ‘Kings Cross’. Is it a train station? Yes. Does it allude to Jesus? Yes.

>> No.21649618

>>21648841
I love Harriet Potter

>> No.21649650

>>21649572
As a tomboy and femdom enjoyer I can only say BASED

>> No.21649680

>>21648841
>Also who is this generations JK?
It'll never happen again. There's too much competition for consumers' time across way too many forms of media, and most of it is also algorithmically served up to people to engage them specifically.

>> No.21649691

>>21649170
Yes, plenty. Even though there's loads of systemic issues, the narrative and the characters all attribute many of the faults of society (wizard or otherwise) to a few bad apples. Typical status quo fellating neoliberal nonsense (and I mean actual neoliberalism, not whatever dumbfuckery idiotic burgers think liberlism means).

>> No.21649882

>>21649286
>importance of puberty blockers
Are they that important?

>> No.21649900

>>21649170
She's an early 2000s centrist liberal and just hasn't changed her views. Transexualism was seen as a rare mental condition back then, not a society-defining social issue.tx4wvy

>> No.21650579

>>21649170
there was a troll attacking the female lead in the girls' room...

>> No.21650679

>>21648968
Precisely

>> No.21650704

>>21648841
I don’t see why not.

>> No.21650845

>>21648939
But JK finished Harry Potter, GRRM still has two more thousand page scat fetish stories to write.

>> No.21651719

>>21648841
The development of woke Ideology can be mapped purely through harry potter. Harry potter used to be a right wing meme attacking the left "read another book" but now it has switched sides so much so that it is now right wing whereas leftist trannies seethe over it. Curious.

>> No.21651754

>>21651719
No. It was an extremist meme from all sides to make fun of "liberals".