[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports / report a bug ] [ 4plebs / archived.moe / rbt ]

2022-11: Warosu is now out of maintenance. Become a Patron!

/lit/ - Literature


View post   
View page     

[ Toggle deleted replies ]
File: 83 KB, 500x573, G.W.F._Hegel_(by_Sichling,_after_Sebbers).jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
21003967 No.21003967 [Reply] [Original]

Now that the dust has finally settled, why did he do it?

>> No.21003976
File: 76 KB, 602x612, schopenhauer 1842.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
21003976

no thaumazein, he had no takes. so he shuffled around hollow concepts in loose associative chains in the hope that something original would happen. some call it "daring to think radically".
>when strangers visited hegel they asked him when professor hegel would return home

>> No.21003981

>>21003967
Hegel was targeted by the mind parasites due to his massive brain power. They infected him with Boehmian and Plotinian dialectic and used his brain power to create a mental construction powerful enough to steer away people from the irrefutable Kantian philosophy.

>> No.21003993

>>21003967
to get pussy. everything a man does, he does for pussy

>> No.21004181

>>21003993
Did he succeed?

>> No.21004216

>>21004181
i'm pretty sure he had a bastard son with some maid

>> No.21004310

>>21003967
>why did he do it?
So what?

>> No.21004369
File: 66 KB, 540x564, 1539197781504.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
21004369

>>21003967
>majority of people who talk about Hegel have their concept of Hegel from hearing other people talk about Hegel
>majority of people who talk about Hegel don't read Hegel
>the conversation and its basis have mostly nothing to do with anything Hegel ever wrote
>>people think "spirit" is divine
>>"thesis antithesis synthesis"

>> No.21004823

>>21003967
Because he could.

>> No.21006313
File: 96 KB, 616x960, Hegel.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
21006313

>>21004310
remind me of the babe

>> No.21006419

>>21003967
By the end of the 18th century traditional Enlightenment rationalism had been discredited by a series of interlocking intellectual crises (scepticism, nihilism, Romanticism, the French Revolution and its disappointment), and the inadequacies of Kant's system were plain to everyone. Hegel was attempting to rescue the Enlightenment project with a system where Reason could justify philosophy, morality, religion and itself against radical criticism, without lapsing into the precritical dogma of a Leibniz, or the capitulation to irrationalism of a Schelling.

>> No.21006423

>>21006419
Did he succeed?

>> No.21006431

>>21006313
what babe?

>> No.21006432

>>21006431
You know. From the movie. The baby. Are you some kind of zoomy or sumtin?

>> No.21006435

>>21006419
>French Revolution and its disappointment

If the French Revolution was a disappointment then what were Hegels thoughts on the American Revolution?

>> No.21006439

>>21006432
Is the babe in someway powerful or something that you esteem it?

MARXGT

>> No.21006445

>>21006439
No it’s just a baby. The girl said she wished the goblin king would take him away so the goblin king did. Sad story.

>> No.21006450

>>21004369
>>>"thesis antithesis synthesis"
I hear far more often that this is wrong than i do that this is an accurate representation of Hegel. This seems to be the true midwit take.

>> No.21006451

>>21006445
Hegel is the goblin king

>> No.21006457

>>21006445
Did she have some kind of voodoo power to do that?

>> No.21006461

>>21006457
Nope just you know shit happens

>> No.21006464

>>21006423
He was very ingenious, but IMO no. Basically Hegel's move was to resurrect Aristotelian teleology in a new garb, which has a number of problems of its own.

>> No.21006467

>>21006435
second this question

>> No.21006468

>>21006461
Wow that truly does remind me of the babe.

>> No.21006479

>>21006464
Damn...back to the drawing board.

>> No.21006482

>>21006450
There's an element of truth to the formulation, in that Hegel's dialectic is about reconciling opposites (because he hated Kant's antimonies). But the thesis-antithesis-synthesis is just a schematic way to put it.

>> No.21006583
File: 140 KB, 222x394, 00A16476-0504-4C7E-B364-3ECB3EEFFE45.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
21006583

>>21003967
Because he was God

>> No.21006593
File: 12 KB, 186x271, 9291BA95-7885-44FC-A55A-2DE87E9C003E.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
21006593

>>21006583

>> No.21006907

>>21003967
Hegel was employed by the 19th century equivalent of a joint MKultra/manhattan project program.

>> No.21006925

>>21003967
>why did he do it?
Obviously because it got him a cushy career, a bit of fame, and women. His philosophy itself is garbage that attracts people who don't have any principles and think that endless lines of verbiage and "historical dialectic" can make up for that. He's probably laughing in his grave.

>> No.21006948

>>21004181
he did have affairs and was overall very popular among his peers

>> No.21007075

>>21006450
Don't bother with him, both Hegel fans and haters rely on the work of others to understand what is going on.

>> No.21007624
File: 643 KB, 1105x647, Kant and Schopenhauer.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
21007624

>>21003967
Who?

>> No.21007635

>>21007624
What is it with schopenhauerfags and their seething?

>> No.21007647

>>21007624
Schopenhauer bastardized Kant, he just did it in a more subtle and therefore more subversive way than Hegel.

>> No.21007671

>>21004369
Ok, what is this "dpirit" which supposedly is coming to understand itself through history and how is it not divine?

>> No.21007672

>>21007635
>>21007647
>muh belief in Hegel

Hegel is dead.

>> No.21007675

>>21007672
I didn't say I believed anything hegel wrote

>> No.21008251

>>21003981
Sounds interesting, but i have no idea if you are right or not.

>> No.21008363

>>21007672
Prove it

>> No.21008956

>>21003976
Its incredible Schoppenhauer seethed so hard he even got weird nerds on a taiwanese tapestry forum 2 centuries later to seethe in the exact same pathetic manner.

>> No.21009010

>>21007671
Mr. Brainlet, that anon is just pointing out that Hegel did not mean "spirit" in any divine sense and people who say this haven't read him. You don't need to have a knee jerk reaction everytime your fantasy universe is a wee bit challenged. This is the 21st century. Build some tolerance.

>> No.21009438

>>21008956
It’s a school of thought, you need a brain to get it.

>> No.21010561

>>21006450
Don't be silly. It has been and continues to be an extremely common way of representing Hegel. It's nice to hear you're beginning to see it be cleared up

>>21007075
???
There's nothing wrong with reading secondary literature. If you need to have your fuckin hand held I'll clarify to you that I am referring to people who make no effort to engage Hegel at all, and only repeat what they've heard in passing.

>>21006482
It is highly misleading. It paints an alternative picture and fails to shed any light on what Hegel is saying. The "dialectics" are varied, complex, and subtle, and where opposition plays a role, it's generally not a decisive role. Hegel's own use of the word "antithesis" - which is rare - never refers to anything resembling the so called "hegelian dialectic". Consider his definition of pure change - "antithesis within antithesis itself, or contradiction". Also, his definition of opposites proper, which is something that contains within itself a trace of its own opposite - it is opposite "of" something.

There's a limited set of things to which the terms may apply, arguably, and it's mainly just that there's a triadic pattern in his explanations. Not a claim about some special way that antitheses interact with their theses. The "thesis antithesis synthesis" mantra makes people think that there's some given metaphysical result from knocking contrary things together but it ain't really like that.

>> No.21010643
File: 340 KB, 1341x1744, 1649647200523.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
21010643

Is anyone else upset that Phenomenology of Spirit was just hastily thrown together during the Napoleonic wars? Perhaps part of the reason why the work seems indecipherable to many is simply because Hegel never had the time to properly revise it.

>> No.21010647
File: 125 KB, 634x659, 1638940426952.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
21010647

>>21007672
>Hegel is dead, and we killed him.

>> No.21010964
File: 26 KB, 480x480, 2786554767891.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
21010964

>>21003976
Staring contest.

>> No.21010971
File: 33 KB, 790x396, 278654678991.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
21010971

>>21010647
>Hegel

>> No.21011047
File: 86 KB, 227x278, 1663569279466.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
21011047

Hegel is a sophist.

>> No.21011136

>>21003967
>Now that the dust has finally settled, why did he do it?
GIRLS, BEER, FAME.

>> No.21011177

>>21003967

Why did he use such obscurantist language to describe relatively simple concepts? So much misunderstanding could have been avoided if he'd chosen a more accurate term than "geist" for the peculiar kind of self-awareness that he was trying to describe.

>> No.21011192
File: 426 KB, 892x723, Shit cunts gonna shit in your…cunt.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
21011192

>>21011177
Same reason as Heidegger.
Same point of failure.

Any attempt to freshly describe ontological terrain will result in the same feeble re-reading of the text as Platonic or Aristotelian by pathetic pseudo-Christians.

For a systematic attempt to destroy the possibility of a language to express the ontological without a realisation of the ontological examine your choice of ontological Daoism or Cha'an buddhism.

>> No.21011427

>>21006948
He didn't cheat on his wife when he married her. What are you talking about?

>> No.21011433

>>21006435
In Philosophy of History he says that Russia and America will be next candidates of the Weltgeist.

>>
Delete posts
Password [?]Password used for file deletion.
Captcha
Action