does this also apply to manga vs literature?

[Anonymous No.19512517]

found it on /tv/

[Anonymous No.19512528]

>>19512517
Explain to me what the movie on the left is and why it's all over lit right now I'll think about an answer.

[Anonymous No.19512538]

>>19512528
Bottom left is 2001
Top left looks like a Ingmar Bergman piece

[Anonymous No.19512551]

>>19512528
Top left is "Light in Winter" by Ingmar Bergman
Second from top looks like one of these arty 60s Italian movies, maybe Fellini.

[Anonymous No.19512563]

>>19512551
Last Year at Marienbad

[Anonymous No.19512583]

>>19512517

Your meme is nonsense.
1. Cherry picked examples. Like the dude who made the meme never watched a Marvel film or 70s blacksploitation.
2. Ethnocentric. European views are not Asian views. The bias of the meme author stinks.
3. Comparing apples to oranges. IN a movie you get what you shoot, and it is always less than what is seeable and includes what the director didn't want as well.
In an anime everything is drawn, so everything there has a reason.

4. Film, anime, literature, anime: the one thing they all have in common is that their purpose for the consumer is entertainment. Regardless of how it changes you or not, it is approached by the consumer as a distraction and an diversion, NEVER as anything else. The author may have artistic or monetary goals, but the consumer is always just looking for entertainment.


Knowing that, how can there possible be one narrative position that says one is better than another?

[Anonymous No.19512594]

>>19512583
>European views are not Asian views
two of the films on the left are Japanese and one is American I'm pretty sure. Just two are Euro

[Anonymous No.19512654]

>>19512517
Not really, it’s more like literature and manga are the (superior) counterparts to film and anime.
It’s obvious why literature is the more intellectual older brother of film so I won’t elaborate but in the case of manga it’s definitely more mature and respectable to read them than to reveal you watch anime.
Better art, no censorship (more scenes of gore and nudity), no annoying voice actors screaming at the top of their lungs and calling out attacks like chunnibyo, no annoying J-pop openings, no original endings that completely butcher the storyline, manga is simply the superior medium.
Many anime are literally just made as extended advertisements for the manga.

[Anonymous No.19512673]

>>19512517
Middle left image? Which film?

[Anonymous No.19512698]

>>19512673
the face of another by teshigahara

[Anonymous No.19512708]

>>19512583

japanese arthouse is culturally european

[Anonymous No.19512759]

>>19512517
anime will never be art. no anime has ever been produced without profit in mind, it is a media without nobility.

[Anonymous No.19512779]

>>19512528
>the movie on the left
There's a whole bunch of movies in the left. Look like winter lights, last year at marienbad, the face of another, no clue, and 2001

[« Ƹ̵̡Ӝ̵̨̄Ʒ » !!bGBGaUpA8kS No.19512919]

>>19512517
Whoever made that is a piece of shit.
Takahata was one of the best

[Anonymous No.19513172]

>>19512919
Takahata sure was, but grave of the fireflies sucks dick
Also you're a tranny so your support to the media of anime is more damming than anything

[Anonymous No.19513187]

>>19512517
i wish filmfags would stop appropriating the word 'art'

[Anonymous No.19513191]

>>19513172
How do you not have that tripcode hidden by now

[Anonymous No.19513207]

>>19512517
They are both amusement. Yes, including your Tarkowsky or any of the greatest of the greats you can think of. This is not to elevate your shitty seasonal anime. It's just a different flavor of the same thing. Art is just amusement. It can be amusement for 16 year old jerkoffs, it can be amusement for intellectuals, it's all amusement nonetheless. It's something for people who need to be amused to live. In its purpose all art is the same.

[Anonymous No.19513232]

>>19513191
how do you hide them?

[Anonymous No.19513247]

>>19512517
Filmcels be like “this dude staring at a wall for 60 minutes is a deep artistic expression because blah blah” I respect capeshit viewers more since they know cinema can never be art.

[« Ƹ̵̡Ӝ̵̨̄Ʒ » !!bGBGaUpA8kS No.19513255]

>>19513172
I’m not heavily into it, moid bitch. And GotF is just a hard pill to swallow. You can be filtered by it, kid.

>>19513191
Maybe he’s not autistic.
(Someone quote that for him).

[Anonymous No.19513381]

>>19512528
Bottom third in the left is The face of another

[Anonymous No.19513840]

There's nothing wrong with childish amusement. Even as an adult.

[Anonymous No.19515181]

If anime is so bad then why are animeposters the highest quality posters on the board?

[Anonymous No.19515196]

>>19515181
They aren’t.

[Anonymous No.19515300]

>>19512517
>VGH MY DEEP MOVIES

[Anonymous No.19516423]

>>19515196
They are, actually