[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature


View post   

File: 46 KB, 328x500, fuckgoths.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18953497 No.18953497 [Reply] [Original]

Is there even such a thing as good gothic lit? I feel like i've read almost everything, and I still havent found anything I like, which seems improbable.

Or is all gothic literature just shitty? Am I missing out on some good obscure stuff?

>> No.18953568
File: 46 KB, 304x450, 9781681374666.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18953568

This one was very good.

>> No.18953601

>>18953497
Poe. Not sure who else.

>> No.18953623

>>18953568
Haven't heard of it. Thank you.

>>18953601
Poe was okay I guess.

>> No.18953668
File: 35 KB, 327x499, let the right one in2.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18953668

>>18953497
This Swedish novel is good, I read the english translation and its good

>> No.18953681

>>18953623
What did you read by him?
He's kinda cheesy, but that's the fun of gothic fiction.
The Black Cat and The Fall of the House of Usher are two of my favourites.

>> No.18953690

>>18953497
Have you read Brontë, Radcliffe, Shelley, Beckford, and Sade yet?

>> No.18953712

>>18953690
Yes, and don't get me wrong they were enjoyable. I just think The Monk was my favourite/the peak and was hoping you guys would disagree and rec me something even better.

>> No.18953722

>>18953681
Black Cat and The Cask of Amontillado. Hes good. I will read more. I guess i'm just hoping there were some hidden gems you would know about.

>> No.18953740

>>18953568
Why does the title not fit the cover? What were they thinking?

>> No.18953997

>>18953740
They were thinking the dumbasses on /lit/ were still going to buy it so they saved money on a halfassed cover. This is the only place I ever see Gaddis discussed. Try bringing up that book on r/books and watch 500 posts of how pretentious you are for trying to talk about something more difficult than young adult drivel

>> No.18954595

William Harrison Ainsworth, I got into him after reading one of his poems (The Mandrake) in a collection of Manchester Poetry

>> No.18954626

>>18954595
Thanks anon, I'll look into them.

>> No.18954724

>>18953497
French decadent lit is Gothic but advanced a hundred years and actually good.

>> No.18954804

>>18953690
How is Sade gothic?

>> No.18954862

>>18954724
Got any recs?

>> No.18954915

>>18954862
La Bas by Huysmans
Les Diaboliques by Barbey d'Aurevilly

There's also Disagreeable Tales by Leon Bloy but I haven't read it yet. I didn't enjoy Mirbeau's Torture Garden but you might.

>> No.18954924
File: 2.53 MB, 750x1177, Tales_of_Wonder2_96.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18954924

I like a lot of the stuff in Matthew Lewis's Tales of Wonder anthology, if you're into narrative poetry it's worth a look

https://archive.org/details/talesofwonder02lewi/
https://archive.org/details/talesofwonder01lewi/

>> No.18954929

>>18954915
I love La Bas! I also enjoyed the torture garden. Ive added the rest to my next purchases list. Do you have any more recs? All g if not.

>> No.18954956
File: 342 KB, 410x624, The Decadent Reader.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18954956

>>18954929
There is a giant reader of French Decadant lit that was put out by Zone Books/Princeton University Press, from memory it included d'Aurevilly Les Diaboliques.
https://press.princeton.edu/books/paperback/9781890951078/the-decadent-reader

Oxford, and I think Penguin too, have also published compliations of different short stories in Decadent readers.

>> No.18954963
File: 45 KB, 329x500, French Decadent Tales.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18954963

>>18954929
>>18954956
This one
>French Decadent Tales

>> No.18954973
File: 102 KB, 470x750, Dedalus.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18954973

>>18954963
And Dedalus have a whole published range of decadent lit they specialise in, not only translations from French but republishing less well known English works from the movement
http://www.dedalusbooks.com/our-books/index.php?cat=12&pg=1

>> No.18955361

>>18954924
This looks amazing thank you

>> No.18955366

>>18954973
>>18954963
>>18954956
Holy shit thank you so much. You and the other anons itt have made my day

>> No.18955589

>>18954915
>>18954924
>>18954956
>>18954963
>>18954973
Great recs indeed.

>> No.18955591

>>18954804
Sade was influenced by the gothic novel (or roman noir) such as Radcliffe. The main difference is a lack of supernatural elements, focusing on the horrors of Nature instead.

>> No.18955634

>>18953497
Then you don't like gothic, if you think that The Monk, Frankenstein, The Phantom of the Opera, The Witch of Ravensworth, Dracula, etc, are bad books I can only tell you to stop because you obviously don't like gothic.

>> No.18955829

>>18953497
Faulkner lol

>> No.18956045

>>18955634
It was reverse psychology.

>> No.18956223
File: 32 KB, 333x500, 41Ta9NSbrlL.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18956223

>>18953497

>> No.18956864

>>18956223
Great post

>> No.18957059

>>18953497
Poe and Shelley

>> No.18957069
File: 263 KB, 1280x720, ns8fgh9sd.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18957069

>>18953497
it was a good story

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Sandman_(short_story)

>> No.18957103

>>18953712
have you read Melmoth the Wanderer by Charles Maturin?

>> No.18957204

>>18957103
Si, estas ma booka favorita
>t. Borbes
:DDDDDDDDDDDDD

>> No.18957269

>>18953497
The Devil's Elixirs by Hoffmann. It's kind of a meta-retelling of The Monk. The book is being overtly referred to and is read by one of the characters.

>> No.18957628
File: 155 KB, 600x902, 21212864718.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18957628

>> No.18957634

>>18957204
?

>> No.18957654

>>18953668
no

>> No.18957694

Check this, one of the best spanish publishers: valdemar

Has a gothic line of publishing:
http://www.valdemar.com/default.php?cPath=4&osCsid=5a190c823c913b134eaf15e2042bf0f1

If you don't read spanish, at least you can check the main authors.

Learn spanish, just for reading this high quality books its worth it.

>> No.18957863

>>18953568
How is this gothic lit? It's a dark comedy/ satire

>> No.18957876

Mariana Enríquez' last novel

>> No.18957926

Isnt there a chart?

>> No.18957935
File: 36 KB, 324x500, 5D26DADF-F3B6-4BF1-804B-1E573E5BD84D.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18957935

>> No.18958246

>>18953497
Yes most of the well known gothic is boring, the best stuff is almost all unknown. Look into publishers like Wakefield Press and Snuggly Press along with the Dedalus Decadent collections.
The book Samalio Paradulus is a quite solid Belgian gothic novel that was completely unknown until it was translated into English for the first time by Wakefield Press a bit ago. Now its slightly known.

>> No.18958898

>>18953497

Try 'Melmoth the Wanderer'

>> No.18959225
File: 26 KB, 255x400, the-manuscript-found-in-saragossa-book_5007.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18959225

I thought this one was pretty good.

>> No.18959329

>>18957103
No, I haven't I'll check it out.

>> No.18959337

Melmoth the Wanderer fucking sucks except for the section on the island.

>> No.18959341

>>18959225
Can you expand? I’ve heard some good things about this book but it always remains buried in my TBR list

>> No.18959578

>>18959337
Thats the whole book.

>> No.18959594
File: 517 KB, 720x1280, nml9yi3yyro51.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18959594

>>18954915
>Read La Bas
>Comfy setting and strong, sentimental friendships
>Wish I could have lived in that time period
>Narrator finds his own time period decadent and shitty
>Realize I would be disappointed regardless whether I lived then or now

What's the best time period to have lived in, /lit/?
Also does decadent literature lament or revel in decadence?

>> No.18959730

>>18959594
>What's the best time period to have lived in, /lit/?
None
>Also does decadent literature lament or revel in decadence?
I'd say both, but moreso the latter

>> No.18959791

>>18959594
2150

>> No.18960309

>>18959578
The section with Immalee on the island in the Indian Ocean ya goober. The rest of the book sucks, especially the Spaniard's tale.

>> No.18960542

>>18959594
Hey at least you or friends don't have tuberculosis consuming you from the inside. Pinker is right in some ways, certain things are better now.

>> No.18960632
File: 43 KB, 494x621, Outerdark.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18960632

>>18953497

>> No.18960769

>>18960542
Very true. I think it's a grass is always greener mentality. Having read La Bas, Frankenstein, Dracula, I love how characters talk to and about each other with such warmth and grace. It's not a virtue but I do daydream sometimes of having such beautiful friendships.

>> No.18960786

>>18959225
Should be talked about more often

>> No.18960862

>>18953497
The Monk is amazing and such an evil book. I would kill for an Eggers film adaptation of the material.

Wuthering Heights
House of Seven Gables
A Mirror for Witches

Reading Manuscript found in Saragossa now..a bit of a slog at times but solid so far.

>> No.18961584

Does the king in yellow count?

>> No.18962279

>>18953497
the adventures of ferdinand count fathom. i haven't it read it, just heard about it today. it's about this dastardly man roaming in jolly old England killing people left and right. some critics called it a proto gothic novel. too me, it sounds like a funnier blood meridian.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iWTOS2HLP7w

>> No.18963329

Arthur Machen ought to be mentioned. Specifically the White People. The Great God Pan is quite good too, but a little overhyped.

>> No.18963501
File: 36 KB, 295x475, 207313.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18963501

Melmoth the Wanderer

>> No.18963519

>>18957935
retarded

>> No.18963671

>>18953497
Gilles de Rais' biography.

>> No.18963743

>>18960769
>It's not a virtue but I do daydream sometimes of having such beautiful friendships.
I feel the same, anon. Why does it have to be so difficult? I realise that I too am to blame, but I must still ask the question.

>> No.18964734

Artaud's rewrite of The Monk

>> No.18964998

>>18964734
What the fuck are you talking about? Where do I get this?

>> No.18966334

>>18953497
Castle of Otranto is total shit.

>> No.18966443

>>18960309
I think that's the general consensus. The Spaniard's tale is a filter and Immalee's is the best one. It's not a bad book at all, I love it, but I don't have the willpower to go through the Spaniard's tale again, it was unnecessarily long.

>> No.18966449

>>18953668
How does it compare to the movie

>> No.18966475
File: 3.09 MB, 3865x3456, P_20210902_131518_1.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18966475

>>18963329
I highly recommend this edition of Machen's work.

>> No.18967367

Everything Brian Stableford translated for Snuggly Books.

Start with Jane de la Vauderes The Mysteries of Karma. One of the bets novels Iver ever read.

>> No.18967718
File: 66 KB, 1080x1080, 1629723319952.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18967718

>>18963743
I think part of it is a culture of letter writing. You legitimately share how you're doing and what you're feeling. Social development without electronic media and unnatural dopamine spikes.
On special occasions I have written heart-felt letters to friends, and while they've appreciated it, doing so in return seems as of it's foreign to them. Still, they are good friends in other ways.

>> No.18967874
File: 17 KB, 299x474, 4105H0DJFVL._SX297_BO1,204,203,200_.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18967874

>>18964998
(published by Creation Books)

>> No.18968471

>>18963501
what do people say to be disappointed after reading it?

>> No.18968556

>>18968471
what? is english your second language?

>> No.18968811

>>18966475
How's Varney the vampire?

>> No.18968954

>>18968811
It's an awesome mess. I don't know if the plethora of locations and Varney's constant change of heart were written intentionally, but I liked the inconsistency. Reading hundreds of short stories about the same character in the same location would be boring.
Warning: those two books are glorified photocopies. Instead of rewriting the stories whoever edited these books literally photocopied the originals.

>> No.18968965

>>18968471
Because it's disappointing. There is only one good section in the entire book and the Spaniards story is incredibly dull.

>> No.18969125

I still don't know what "gothic" means.

>> No.18969461

>>18967874
thanks, seems bretty cool

>> No.18970396

>>18969125
It got its name when the first “gothic sotry was mad in a goth castle

>> No.18970635

Bump

>> No.18970949

>>18968954

Planning on a read this year since the plot reminds me a lot of Jojo Phantom Blood and I want to see the influences for Dracula. I've got the massive Wordsworth edition where it is 1000 pages or so

>> No.18971407

I'm surprised no one's mentioned the The Castle of Otranto by Walpole yet. It's one of the earliest examples of gothic. It's decent, but not as good as The Monk.

>>18957103
I've never heard of that book before but it sounds amazing. Personally, I generally enjoy a month or so of gothic/horror reading in and around October, so I'm trying to put together a list for this year.

>>18957103

>> No.18971766

>>18953568
this is not remotely gothic, this is postmodern

>> No.18972110
File: 147 KB, 458x648, 9a973000-4b4c-41ab-89ec-75bfd4daa8c5_1.fe1e1837e1252b696c4014501e8f7425.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18972110

>>18953497
I don't see Hanns Heinz Ewers mentioned often in these threads so here you go.

>> No.18972507

>>18971407
That’s been on my to read list when i first heard that has some prince being crushed by a giant helmet.

>> No.18972979

>>18971766
Can't a postmodern novel be gothic?
>>18972110
I don't speak German.

>> No.18973561
File: 3.21 MB, 2708x4235, we-have-always-lived-in-the-castle.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18973561

>>18953497
The Monk is pretty funny you have to admit. Have you tried this?

>> No.18974859

boomp

>> No.18974933

>>18967874
Fuck creation for being criminals, now all their books are way too hard to get a hold of. So much I want to read

>> No.18974969

>>18960786
Isn't it one of the most well known works of the genre? It's often cited as one of the first english works to do the whole text-within-a-text thing

>> No.18975008

>>18974969
>english

>> No.18975147

>>18974969
It's in French and it was written by a Pole tho

>> No.18975540
File: 146 KB, 337x164, liamocuriv.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18975540

>>18953497
>>>
>Anonymous 09/02/21(Thu)17:14:21 No.18969125▶>>18970396

>> No.18975549
File: 99 KB, 1200x1600, adambeycee.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18975549

>>18953497
often people get offerances from the waist.
>ib4shy

>> No.18976619

>>18953497
bump

>> No.18976885

>>18966449
The book was really good. Better than the movies. The pedo was actually terrifying in the book after he gets his face melted off with acid and the vampire parasite basically reanimates him.

>> No.18977623

Any good emo /lit/?

>> No.18978275

>>18977623
Person
by Sam Pink

>> No.18978932

>>18978275
How is it?

>> No.18979489

Bumping in interest. I want to see any more suggestions but these are very nice so far.

>> No.18979705

>>18979489
If you are interested in obscure books:
https://www.valancourtbooks.com/gothic--romantic.html

>> No.18980254

>>18979705
Shit that's actually really cool. I love this sort of stuff where they allow readers to rediscover authors like this. Thanks, I'll definitely have to check this stuff out.

>> No.18980289

>>18953722
Poe actually wrote a lot of funny stuff too you should just read anything he wrote

>> No.18981697

One last bump

>> No.18982640

>>18980289
What are they?

>> No.18983952

>>18953497
What is considered gothic anyways?

>> No.18984003
File: 1.15 MB, 1836x2794, P_20210905_114207_1.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18984003

>>18959225
This thread convinced me, I just received it. I think it was cheap, ¥1.343.

>> No.18984048

Horror’s Call is pretty good for this desu. Lots of spooky gothic imagery.

>> No.18984198

>>18960862
>Eggers
Jesus, what has /lit/ become?

>> No.18984204

>>18972507
The story is basically about a giant mecha knight.

>> No.18985431
File: 59 KB, 500x795, forefathers-eve-b-iext46919305.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18985431

>>18953497

>> No.18987400

>>18953497
Bump

>> No.18987546

>>18972979
>I don't speak German.
It's been translated, I just grabbed the German cover off of Google. The Frank Braun trilogy has three of his books in English: The Sorcerer's Apprentice, Alraune, and Vampire.

>> No.18987618

Is "Gothic Violence" a Gothic book?

>> No.18987630

How the fuck is this thread still up after 6 days?

>> No.18987735

>>18987630
because we are booooomping at opportune moments, now shhhh.

>> No.18987767

>>18987630
/lit/ is a slow board

>> No.18988994

>>18953497
Bump

>> No.18989560

Is there any contemporary gothic novel worth the read?

>> No.18990159

>>18983952
It's hard to pin down exactly what a genre is, but in general terms Gothic Literature has to do with superstitions, mystery and suspense. Often it included a tragic romance but that was usually used to throw the dark world in contrast or show how said dark world can bring tragedy to something that should be happy.

>> No.18990217

>>18983952
https://youtu.be/gAQ-uBEy2iA
https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x3htt49

>> No.18990960

>>18953497
Has anyone read power of darkness? It was a Finnish translation of dracula that’s been recently translated back to English. I heard it’s quite different from the original English version. It’s alot more violent, sexy and less nuanced.

I also heard about a Turkish version of Dracula which the English translation of the Turkish translation of Dracula is titled Dracula in Istanbul. It’s a bootleg translation of Dracula mixed in with some Turkish nationalism.

I wanna know if you guys heard about them or even read them, and what’s your thoughts on the translations.

>> No.18991047

I cant believe this is still up. Anyone know where I can grab a copy of Artaud's The Monk?