[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]

/lit/ - Literature

View post   
File: 61 KB, 900x900, 3FVKauhU.jpg medium.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17918264 No.17918264 [Reply] [Original]

Nobody has proven Marx wrong

>> No.17918274

>>17918264
I don't like these statements. Marx was right about a lot of stuff and had interesting insights but a lot of it is a crock of shit as well. There's no philosopher who was 100% wrong or right.

>> No.17918276

>>17918274
cope

>> No.17918277

>>17918264
Communism has never worked

>> No.17918292

>>17918264
The USSR happened before a communist state in Western Europe, so that's something he got wrong.

>> No.17918293

>>17918264
Reality did

>> No.17918296
File: 94 KB, 1280x720, maxresdefault (1).jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17918296

>>17918264
Broke niggas stay mad lmfaoooooooooo

>> No.17918312

You didn't understand Hegel.

>> No.17918376

>>17918264
Böhn-Bawerk did.

>> No.17918404

>>17918264
History did

>> No.17918418
File: 568 KB, 1262x1440, Franco Communism Meme.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17918418

>> No.17918432

>>17918264
I want to fuck Lio Fotia from Promare!

>> No.17918436

>>17918264
Marx proved himself wrong by positing materialism.

>> No.17918460

>>17918264
Your own twink ass refuted him

>> No.17918464

>>17918264
Good luck convincing me of that. Shouldn't you be off unclogging toilets?

>> No.17918469

You are right. Yet the amount of post Marxists should tell you that he is incomplete.

>> No.17918478

>>17918418
Get the red, Francisco !

>> No.17918480

Stirner BTFO early "humanist" Marx.

Depending whether you consider The Origins of Family reflects only Engels' or also Marx's views then Marx was completely wrong on most of the points in that work.

>> No.17918493

>>17918264
Go back to /pol/, you fucking racist.

>> No.17918571

>>17918418
Get the red, Francisco!

>> No.17918651
File: 269 KB, 1010x487, 1616513703040.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17918651

>> No.17918802
File: 219 KB, 1200x1200, bc3a72ed5c47e8c0dd5bc52028c5df5005-kanye-west.rsquare.w1200.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17918802

>>17918264
That's a man isn't it?
A communist man

Maaan commie democrats are such sissies

>> No.17918926
File: 1018 KB, 500x375, 1617174704419.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17918926

>>17918264
I want to fuck boys desu, but marx is a retard nigger like everyone of his followers sorry

>> No.17918958

>>17918926
Based and not Canadian pilled.

>> No.17918983

>>17918264
I wish I looked like that

>> No.17919011

>>17918983
I look –Exactly– like that.

>> No.17919012

>>17918264
>Nobody has proven Marx wrong
Raked

>> No.17919020

>>17919011
Want to trade bodies?

>> No.17919023

>>17918264
LTV is wrong no-one agrees with it

>> No.17919026

>>17919020
No.

>> No.17919048
File: 52 KB, 685x564, 1617080548785.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17919048

>>17919026

>> No.17919138

>>17918264
Tranny

>> No.17919174

>>17918264
Marx is far too simple. Most of his theories have simply faded into obscurity as they are no longer relevant. They were rather accurate at the time but not practical for the time.
Bourgeoise-worker relation, country-city relation; capital accumulation and circulation, work hours, capital generation; governments, politics--local, national, international--remember Marx was born 203 years ago and died almost 150 years ago. He didn't even see the industrialisation of Germany, the Soviet war industry, the Nazi concentration camps, the gulags and famines; he didn't see multinationals, consumer industry--everything that defines our modern industry.

If you're a socialist, marxist, communist in 2021 you're beyond wrong in all your beliefs, not just because you don't read theory, but because even that theory is no longer relevant--and the propaganda, the slogans, the socialist lables: they're even worse.
We need a new kind of collective ideology if we want to fight against the given structures. Nietzsche and Buddha completed individual dogma; Marx offered only one - incomplete - side of the collective coin.

>> No.17919193

>>17918264
Not even the state of reality?

>> No.17919197

>>17919011
may i demand a latest picture of your bussy thank you in advance

>> No.17919212

>>17918478
>>17918571
cringe

>> No.17919243

>>17919212
k, commie

>> No.17919540

>>17918418
Reminder Franco used Moors to rape Spanish women

>> No.17919611

>>17918418
GET THE REDS, FRANCISCO!

>> No.17919619
File: 85 KB, 305x374, Bohm.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17919619

>> No.17919665

>>17918264
Nobody has proven Marx right

>> No.17919671

>>17918276
No, he’s right. Sirner and Bakunin get him, others expand on his ideas. No one’s infallible, though he’s still very relevant.

>>17918277
It worked all the time. Global communism hasn’t been tried, and you’d unironically like it.
Read Kropotkin.

>> No.17919693

>>17919671
>Global communism hasn’t been tried
yikes

>> No.17919713

Marx’s metaphysics are are just plain wrong. He offers some great practical knowledge though

>> No.17919820

>>17919693
>imagines global Stalinism
Read Kropotkin or read Morris’ News from Nowhere

>> No.17920266

fucking Marxist prove Marx wrong when they can't explain value

>> No.17920318

>>17918264
did marx prove marx? or is it still a theory?

>> No.17920323

No need to. History proved him wrong.

>> No.17920799

>>17918651
This.

>> No.17920956

>>17918264
Communism will never work because it relies on people not being people and people caring about a state that doesn't let them personally rise. Why would anyone waste their life for nothing in return? You can't make me give a shit therefore it's just bunk from a rich boy who didn't understand how the world works. Capitalism is evil but it's pragmatic. Communism is hopelessly idealistic and that in my opinion makes it more evil because it's never going to work. It helps that pure capitalism has never been tried either. Mixed methods is the best option by combining socialist ideas like free healthcare, public schools, etc with a free market and the ability to acquire wealth so long as it's by a majority agreed upon set of rules and guidelines and everyone pays the same percentage in taxes.

>> No.17920975

>>17920266
based. many so-called "marxists" do the biggest disservice to marxism by being illiterate.

>> No.17921019

>>17919011
What's the going rate for your hand in marriage?

>> No.17921032

>>17918276
cope

>> No.17921100

Promare was absolute trash and fuck you for liking it

>> No.17921282
File: 667 KB, 543x664, 1616857476757.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17921282

>>17918264
marx btfo by cartoon

>> No.17921305

History has, but only the solution to the problem of capitalism he analyzed. This analysis of the problem of capitalism still stands up as one of the monuments of economics, of wealth accumulation that drives wealth into fewer and fewer hands, causing the system to eventually collapse. This analysis still holds true to this day, and even a conservative like John Gray has admitted to the brilliance of this analysis

>> No.17921332

Completely and utterly BTFO by Hayek, Mises, Sowell et al.

>> No.17921478
File: 643 KB, 1022x731, 1599549764592.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17921478

>>17918264
Marx's life proved marx wrong

>> No.17921523

>>17919671
>It worked all the time. Global communism hasn’t been tried, and you’d unironically like it.
no i won't, fuck off.

>> No.17921592
File: 32 KB, 866x1200, blacksun2.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17921592

>>17918418
Get the reds, Francisco!
HEIL

>> No.17921598

>>17921100
I just assumed Promare existed to pander to fujo whores and nothing else. And of course, I was completely right about my suspicions.

>> No.17921606

>>17919619
>>17921282
Marx was a critic of economics, not an economist himself

>> No.17921639

>>17921606
Yes he was. He offered no alternative to economics, he simply subverted it.

>> No.17921755
File: 46 KB, 708x523, 4E125219-BA90-4F08-98CF-D75F0233D608.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17921755

marx in tha whip

>> No.17921834

>>17919671
You fell for bait. Both the post and international communism. And dying alone with pets who will eat your corpse.

>> No.17921848

>>17918418
GET THE REDS, FRANCISCO!

>> No.17921854

>>17918296
This is how Satan mocks God.

>> No.17921861

>>17921282
demand is a prerequisite for something to have any value at all, but labor determines how much value it has
it really isn't that hard to understand anon

>> No.17922097

>>17921755
...the 20 year old male caked in make-up who think he looks girly but he takes only camera shots that hides his hideous chin or jaw

>> No.17922108

>>17921834
I'm okay with being eaten if mr meowmeow is hungry.

>> No.17922119

>>17922108
Lawl you got raked. Go back to your containment board, cunt.

>> No.17922129

>>17922097
Femboys arent women. They are feminine men. the goal is not to look “girly” but to be a hyper-twink for the porn-addled homosexual. God I love it

>> No.17922176

>>17922129
>the goal is not to look “girly”
wtf who cares then

>> No.17922181

>>17922119
Rude.

>> No.17922190

>>17922129
t. faggot unable to cope with accepting his attraction to women

>> No.17922230

>>17918296
YOOOO SPOTEMGOTTEM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=anwChPGJBSs

>> No.17922291

>>17918264
Marx’s economics sometimes verged into schizo-tier but he was right about some things in terms of interaction with who holds power. He seethed pretty hard at Darwin after Darwin explained how natural selection worked though, claimed it was too “Victorian” because Marx couldn’t cope with how central intraspecific competition was to life on earth.
>>17919540
>Reminder Franco used [post-medieval Spaniards] to rape Spanish women
>>17918296
Yo I heard he linked up with shiesty, cap or no cap?
>>17921606
So he fundamentally failed to give any solid explanation?
>>17922129
That image is true but perception of it is not helped by gender dysphorics co-opting twink terminology and culture to relate themselves to something less disturbing.

>> No.17922478

Yes communism worked so well didn’t it oh. Wait

>> No.17922611

>>17918418
GET THE REDS, FRANCISCO!

>> No.17922707

>>17921282
Are you fucking retarded? Or at least the image is cuckoldry of the biggest imaginable proportion, I'm no fucking Jew to support Marx on most levels but that picture really IS a missunderstanding of his theory. Society changed you fucking nigger, that's why it became socially necessary labour.

>> No.17922896

>>17918418
GET THE REDS, FRANCISCO!

>> No.17922950

>>17918264
Elon Musk's existence does

>> No.17922961

>>17918264
Based.Right-wingers deserve the rope and they’ll eventually get it

>> No.17923018

Cum negante principia nequit disputari.

>> No.17923024

>>17922961
>Cringe, Left-wingers deserve the rope and they’ll eventually get it
sorry for the typo

>> No.17923030

>>17922961
Yikes.

>>17923024
Based.

>> No.17923195

>>17918418
GET THE REDS, FRANCISCO!

>> No.17923198

>>17918264
Hayek did

>> No.17923207

>>17918264
leo promare is so hot