[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature


View post   

File: 106 KB, 612x491, retard.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16450199 No.16450199 [Reply] [Original]

Why do people hate semi-colons? Are they just brainlets who can't figure out how to use it properly?

>> No.16450205

>>16450199
>use semicolon
>not mozartesque
>F

>> No.16450213

>>16450199
I use semicolons all the time; it's never bothered anyone.

>> No.16450234

>>16450199
Semicolons--usually used by pseuds--are like--to use a similie--salt--to use a metaphor--that are overused--like your nan--by pseuds

>> No.16450239

>>16450199
normies can hardly use commas properly, they probably won't be able to use any other symbol that has a more complicated use than "at end of sentence" or "before and after text".

Also, aren't commas used for the same purpose or does the semi-colonhave a specific use in English? Afaik we were never thought to use the semi-colon here.

>> No.16450254

Semicolons are for homos- I’m a dashCHAD

>> No.16450258

>>16450239
>Afaik we were never thought to use the semi-colon here.
Africans can barely read, mate. No wonder you weren't taught how to use punctuation marks.

>> No.16450260

>>16450199
Semicolons are a pretty ugly and disruptive mark. I recently read The Ox-Bow Incident (1940) which used one in the middle of dialogue, of all places. Imagine speaking in a semicolon? It makes no sense. Kill this mark.

>> No.16450318

>>16450260
>Imagine speaking in a period.
Retard

>> No.16450325

>>16450318
You do speak in periods. The very word comes from the period of uninterrupted speech, mongoloid.

>> No.16450330

>>16450258
What makes you think he is African, anon? Did you somehow misread “Afaik” as “Africa”? Or perhaps you thought it was a typo? Afaik is just an initilism for “As far as I know”.

>> No.16450393

>>16450239

They have a similar role, the semicolon is essentially a more pronounced comma. There are no formalized rules, which is why some people use them and others avoid them.

>> No.16450448

>>16450325
But the function of a semicolon can't appear in speech?

>> No.16450454

A semicolon is used for joining two otherwise complete thoughts that the author finds tightly coupled for whatever reason in their headcanon. It is always better replaced with a full stop.

>> No.16450467

>>16450448
Correct, it would be indistinguishable from a full stop. It's a purely literary device, and, as such, takes too many liberties. You could replace either of the full stops in this post with a semicolon and remain valid, which is just goofy.

>> No.16450477
File: 105 KB, 840x472, F33033BB-5031-4382-8951-140F9289C694.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16450477

>semicolons

>> No.16450490

>>16450477
This man's approach to punctuation is beautiful and heroic, and the only bad thing I can say is that he's so popular that removing quotation marks is now seen as imitating his style, when it's rightly seen as evolving the written language to a higher plateau.

>> No.16450564

>>16450260
Retard. Speech is probably the most appropriate place to use semicolons, as people will regularly say sentences with a short pause between clauses rather than a conjuction:

"We dated for a while; didn't work out".

>> No.16450570

>>16450564
>We dated for a while. Didn’t work out
There. Fuck you

>> No.16450578

>>16450570
I want to connect those clauses. Fuck YOU.

>> No.16450605

>>16450578
They're still connected. By common sense.

>> No.16450608

>>16450578
hehehhehehe

>> No.16450632

>>16450570
yeah i guess that works for dialogue when you're writing a grug tier nigger who talks in abrupt fragments but that's stylistically grotesque

>> No.16450646

>>16450254
That's a hyphen babey

>> No.16450652

>>16450564
Why not: "We dated for a while. Didn't work out."?

>> No.16450976

>>16450652
Depends on how connected you want the two statements to be. When spoken, it would rely a lot on the emphasis and tone given to each clause.