/lit/ - Literature

[Anonymous No.15306296]

What's with Jews and commentaries? Did they not realize how ridiculous it looks, or how much of an exegetic-bureaucratic nightmare it is to make commentaries on commentaries of commentaries ad nauseam?

[Anonymous No.15306314]

>>15306296
It's at least better than just having barely literate retards conclude whatever from passages they lack the history, philosophic and teologic understanding to analyze like o sadly happens with Protestants.

[Anonymous No.15306317]

>>15306296
Lol. Look at this goy trying to understand the Word of G-d with his animalistic nefesh....

[Anonymous No.15306324]

What's wrong with that?

[Anonymous No.15306366]

>>15306314
I'm not arguing that kikes are not the masters of hermeneutics (they are), but how is a jew who is not 100% immersed into this tradition like a rabbi supposed to make sense of this? How do laypeople keep track of all this? Do they just ask a rabbi to explain it all?

[Anonymous No.15306375]

Your g*ntile brain can't comprehend it. No surprises there

[Anonymous No.15306386]

>>15306375
kek

[Anonymous No.15306439]

>>15306366
They aren't there to be the end all truth of the matter, they're there to be a reference for truly considering the meaning of your faith. So if you had a religious quandary, you have a place to look for commentary and arguments by people who have already considered the same issues as you. Your rabbi would probably have some idea of what commentary and interpretations exist, though probably not 100% thorough.

You're also supposed to take it as a way to live life, not just accepting things at face value, but arguing them and passing on your accumulated wisdom to others.

[Anonymous No.15306451]

>>15306296
This honestly looks kinda based if not for the fact that all of the commentary is post-Christ and thus completely dubious.

Is there a similar thing for the Holy Bible?

[Anonymous No.15306465]

>>15306439
I guess the closest equivalent in Christianity is the Summa Theologica, then. More of a reference work for particular cases than a straightforward theological inquiry.

[Anonymous No.15306482]

>>15306296
My buddy is a Buddhist monk, you should see what the Pali Canon looks like!

[Anonymous No.15306493]

>>15306296
I didn't realize Shlomo was a real Jewish name

[Anonymous No.15306494]

>>15306482
I know that it's ridiculously huge, but does it have Inception-level commentary circlejerking, too?

[Anonymous No.15306513]

>>15306493
Someone please post the screencap of the /pol/tard who got amazed that the Israeli money is called Shekel.

[Anonymous No.15306517]

>>15306465
More like the entire Catholic canon. Orthodoxy works in a similar way. Reinventing the wheel and interpreting the Bible at will is a Protestant thing.

[Anonymous No.15306536]

>>15306451
>the commentary is post-Christ and thus completely dubious
How so?

[Anonymous No.15306601]

>>15306494
Yeah, though often you find that the commentarial cultures of all Buddhist texts are differentiated from one another, forming sectarian differences. It's often high circumference circle jerking

[Anonymous No.15306617]

They realised that judeisum gas falling apart afther Jesus so they put some garbage together to keep it on life support.

[Anonymous No.15306621]

Wait... you guys don't actually believe in a god, right?

[Anonymous No.15306639]

>Jesus existed and worked miracles
>the miracles in the Second Temple ceased at the end of Jesus' ministry

What did the Talmud mean by this?

[Anonymous No.15306647]

>>15306639
According to the rabbis he's busy trying not to drown in boiling hot excrement in the afterlife.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jesus_in_the_Talmud#Punishment_in_the_afterlife

[Anonymous No.15306654]

>>15306536
They lost the guidance of the Holy Spirit in interpreting scripture by commiting deicide and rejecting Christ.

[Anonymous No.15306660]

>15306647

>Coomers will be punished with boiling hot semen.

Lads im FUCKED

[Anonymous No.15306669]

>>15306647

>boiling excrement
>boiling semen

jesus christ why are the heebs like this

[Anonymous No.15306677]

>>15306669
Arabs, too. Semitics are subhuman.

[Anonymous No.15306699]

>>15306677
Hey goy, shut the fuck up.

[Anonymous No.15306702]

>>15306699
Gas thyself, kike.

[Anonymous No.15306742]

>>15306639
This page is unironically a good example of Pharisaic reasoning. You should read it but tl;dr
>It's just a coincidence

[Anonymous No.15306748]

>>15306742
Shit, here's the link: https://outreachjudaism.org/yomkippur/

[Anonymous No.15306754]

>>15306669
Genetic low empathy
Psychopaths just enjoy the thought of things like someone drowning and burning alive in shit

[Anonymous No.15307416]

How to stop being a gentile?

[Anonymous No.15307493]

>>15307416
Your perception of jewesses are distorted by the cute, modest clothing their parents force them to wear instead of the trashy, slutty stuff you're used to. Don't be fooled by the illusions of the kike.

[Anonymous No.15307499]

>>15307493
They simply have class. No one is forcing shit.

[Anonymous No.15307665]

>>15307416
begome orthodox.
jews are the new gentiles.

[Anonymous No.15307712]

>>15306754
Circumcision, specifically on the eighth day, the start of the first puberty. Naturally, their hormones are affected, and they grow twisted even in looks.

[Anonymous No.15308352]

>>15306296
Makes it harder for the goyim to look into and see what is being said about them.

[Anonymous No.15308394]

>>15306296
>Scattered to the four winds
>Assimilation everywhere all the time
>800 AD
Judah and Levi 12 tribes do not make, and if they want their highly in-group selected far right Judean theocracy, let them (in their own land and in their own land only).

>>15306314
>sadly happens with Protestants
Entirely your Scofield Bible commentary's Golem.

[Anonymous No.15308408]

>>15306296
Well, this seems to be an effective and lasting method of teaching and keeping the knowledge. Probably a bit better then letting students to study Avengers movies.

>>15307665
> falling for the looks on a special occasion costume play

[Anonymous No.15308431]

>>15308408
>letting students to study Avengers movies
Why yes, I am a rabbi in Marvel studies, how could you tell?

[Anonymous No.15308434]

>>15307665
>become orthodox

[Anonymous No.15308435]

>>15306296
Agreed, commentaries are autistic. I'm glad Aristotelianism was nothing like this Jewish crap!

[Anonymous No.15308598]

>>15307665
Based

[Anonymous No.15308726]

>>15306296
How can the goyim know the full extent of what's in the Talmud? Only Orthodox Jews can say with any authority what's in it. If they wanted to edit or omit something, it would be impossible to prove.

[Anonymous No.15308773]

>>15306754
>>15306647
Why do goys love to talk about things they don't understand? Is it from trinitarian doctrine that their brains all fried from the coping? Or is it athiest blood thirst from lack of morals?

[Anonymous No.15309189]

>>15306296
That’s the point. Debating is a religious/cultural practice for Jews, and in most “sects” you’re allowed to disagree and interpret in different ways. Stop thinking about Judaism as Christianity without christ and pork.
Jews, even the religious ones, have an entirely different understanding divinity, G-d and religion, and of worship, than Christians. You retards are just too self obsessed to see it.

[Anonymous No.15309508]

>>15306296
They seem to work on the principle of "We're the supreme beings. Everything we do is Godlike and we must ruthlessly crush everyone else in every way".

They then have the difficult task of taking texts they stole from more creative peoples and slowly making them fit this world view.

In short it is psychopathic.

[Anonymous No.15309515]

>>15308773
Nice projection. When do we get to discuss Toaff's book on Ashkenazi blood rituals?

[Anonymous No.15309537]

>>15308726
This is true. In the 1500s the Catholic church finally found out what was in the Talmud. They were horrified. Since then the worst teachings have been made oral and no Talmud compiled after 1520 has been complete.

[Anonymous No.15309558]

>>15309189
They have no morality. Orthodoxy in Judaism is a misnomer. They practise Orthopraxy. "Follow the guidelines but think whatever you like." No group morality can stem from this. It's merely a strategy for winning.

[Anonymous No.15309602]

>>15306296
If they grow up in this environment it's no wonder they become lawyers. It takes a special kind of soulless to argue about semantics

[Anonymous No.15309637]

>>15309558
>>15309508
>christians projecting

[Anonymous No.15310303]

Judaism as a whole is cringe.

[Anonymous No.15310338]

>>15306366
They aren't. That's the point of Rabbis. That's the entire point of Jewish society: learned judges telling the rabble how to act. That's the entirety of Semitic society and religion: Do what the nerds tell you, or you die. That's it.

[Anonymous No.15310371]

>>15310338
But why?

[Anonymous No.15310409]

>>15306482
I mean even Homer had this, to the degree it may have become an issue to transcribe it.

[Anonymous No.15310420]

>>15306375
Jews are the masterrace desu. Unfortunately for them i'm jealous so I will destroy them.

[Anonymous No.15310434]

>>15310371
There is no why. Do what you're told, ignorance is no excuse. This isn't specific to Judaism, it's a Pan-Semitic thing. The Gods (which Judaism just singles down to one) are above you, hierarchy is a chain of who gets to torture whom, and if you don't do what your superiors tell you then the Gods will torture everyone and destroy everything.

[Anonymous No.15310501]

>>15309637
Christianity is a religion of self sacrifice. Islam is a religion of conquest. Judaism is a religion of mastery over other races.

And only one group projects all the evil it has done whilst simultaneously playing the eternal victim...

[Anonymous No.15311368]

>>15309189
>G-d
Cringe.
They disrespect God's name in order...not to disrespect it.

[Anonymous No.15311377]

>>15311368
...