[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature

View post   
File: 586 KB, 951x852, Screenshot_2019-11-23 Heretic of the week René Guénon Catholic Herald.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14219183 No.14219183 [Reply] [Original]

Oh no no no no!!

https://catholicherald.co.uk/magazine/heretic-of-the-week-rene-guenon/

>> No.14219187

>>14219183
Seething Catholicucks fear the horse-man

>> No.14219189

BASED

>> No.14219191 [DELETED] 
File: 50 KB, 968x681, 2341.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14219191

>>14219183
>cathlocuck seething this hard

>> No.14219190

>>14219183
'heretic' should be worn as a badge of honor.

>> No.14219202

The Catholic herald is not only under the influence of Jesuits, but Anglo Jesuits to make it even worse. Guenon is an important figure in all modern theology and Catholicism is no exception. Wolfgang Smith, Rama Coomaraswamy, Jean Borella, and Jean Hani are all Catholic theologians heavily influenced by Guenon, with books that received the imprimatur no less. Guenon was even taught in SSPX seminaries at one point. Make no mistake, there are many things that Catholics must disagree with Guenon about, but this sort of Jesuit hit piece is a classic of the order and is extremely embarrassing to read as a Catholic. The article has no understanding of what Guenon means by tradition and religion.

>> No.14219212
File: 10 KB, 878x152, best argument for catholicism.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14219212

>>14219190

>> No.14219213

>>14219202
It's not even a hitpiece. The article is actually rather neutral. That his beliefs are heretical by Catholic standards is simply an objective fact.

>> No.14219215
File: 101 KB, 608x712, 0941981441.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14219215

>This is more authentically reflected in some religions than in others – and for Guénon, at best in Islam.
Wrong, he refers to Hinduism/Vedanta in his works as being the closest to the truth if not equal with Islam/Sufism.
>The whole idea of being “spiritual, but not religious” might be seen as a result of his work, though he probably would have disapproved.
Guenon had little influence upon the hippies movement of the 60's from whence that became increasingly popular, I think that's a really tenuous connection

my first impression is some boomer who has never actually read him and who felt compelled to write an article denouncing him after seeing Tradcaths on twitter debating for/against Guenon

>> No.14219219

>>14219212
>taking anything that moth fag says seriously

>> No.14219220

wasn't evola a "fallen-away catholic" also?

>> No.14219225

>>14219220

Your point?

>> No.14219227
File: 97 KB, 1072x736, 1521961028626.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14219227

>>14219219
>s-she was just joking!!

>> No.14219229

>>14219225
intelligent people eventually realize that catholicism is bullshit

>> No.14219232

>>14219225
that catholics are inherently based, even when they apostasize

>> No.14219244

>>14219229

That's because Catholicism is the ape of Orthodoxy, it's no wonder that all these branches and ideologies all stem from the western Latin Catholic tree

>> No.14219250

>>14219244
WE GET IT YOU WATCH JAY DYER

>> No.14219333

>>14219202
>Wolfgang Smith, Rama Coomaraswamy, Jean Borella, and Jean Hani
A cabal of whos

>> No.14219336

>>14219202
>coomasawary is a catholic theologian
stop

>> No.14219343

>>14219336
Rama coomaraswamy literally taught in a seminary and had regular correspondence with mother Teresa. Are you mixing up Rama with his father?

>> No.14219345
File: 69 KB, 670x573, 1568244009013.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14219345

>>14219333
>Coomaraswamy

>> No.14219347

>>14219333
All important catholic theologians. If you aren’t catholic you obviously wouldn’t know them since they go against the grain of academia

>> No.14219355

>>14219183
I like Guenon's traditional approach to religion, but I don't see how Islam fits the bill best when it's so orderly and spiritually oppressive. All these rules, so little natural experience.

>> No.14219364

>>14219355
> spiritually oppressive
whats your idea of spiritual freedom?

>> No.14219370

>>14219364
Cooming

>> No.14219372

>>14219244
the patriarch of moscow is about to go reformation mode on that sjw greek guy so be careful...

>> No.14219397

>>14219343
Oh yeah sorry

>> No.14219517
File: 220 KB, 925x910, Screenshot_2019-11-23 Heretic of the week Julius Evola Catholic Herald.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14219517

>>14219220
oh no no no no
https://catholicherald.co.uk/magazine/heretic-of-the-week-julius-evola/

>> No.14219551

>>14219183

I literally cannot understand how someone would consider Islam to be the most untainted religion of them all.

>> No.14219649

>>14219227
>she

>> No.14219674

>>14219551
Because you're an American who's never studied Islam in depth.

>> No.14219679

>>14219674
Please enlighten us, sure there's a lot of truth and beauty in *some* parts of Islam but as the greatest, definitely not. As this anon>>14219551 said.

>> No.14219696

>>14219212
I swear butterfaggot was shitting on Gnosticism in other threads?

>> No.14219724

>>14219183
Oh shit I love Guenon even more now

>>14219190
based

>>14219212
based

>>14219517
BASED

>>14219551
Because it is the most untainted religion, its also the fastest growing religion and spreading all throughout the west.

God is on the side of the Muslims. Cope harder.

Christian Larpers are barely even human

>> No.14219735 [DELETED] 

>>14219679
http://93.174.95.29/main/404000/81930ace0609f1dad97b70d2482e0d08/Charles Le Gai Eaton - Islam and the Destiny of Man (1985).pdf

>> No.14219826
File: 689 KB, 1225x1230, guenon-rene0.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14219826

Traditionalist Publishers:

Sophia Perennis
World Wisdom
Matheson Trust
Angelico Press
Inner Traditions (for Evola)

>> No.14219846

>>14219826
Based Son of Light

>> No.14219885

>>14219674
>American

Nope.

>never studied Islam in depth

Definitely not as much as I could have but enough to know that the Islamic tradition is as much tainted and meddled with as the christian one. Most of the written works are written decades or centuries after the events took place by second or third hand witnesses and nowdays the authenticity of most hadiths is doubted by most secular scholars.

>> No.14219894

>>14219885
Islam was corrupted when Kafirs usurped Muhammads chosen successor Ali

>> No.14220103

>>14219183
hahahaha, cathocucks are the world's biggest source of cringe

>> No.14220137

>>14219183
Cathoboomers get the rope first.

>> No.14220173

>>14219183
>Catholic heretic of the week
well he must be doing something right then

>> No.14220175

>>14220173
unfortunately he isn't, otherwise heretics are pretty based

>> No.14220216

>>14220173
He definitely is.

Ignore the buttblasted >>14220175 who is seething that Islam is the fastest growing religion

>> No.14220230

>>14220216
I enjoy Guenon's ideas but his writing is too boring for me. same goes for evola

>> No.14220306
File: 59 KB, 390x338, 1566472628710.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14220306

>>14220216
COPE

>> No.14220363

>>14219183
Catholics still doing the 'heretic' shit in 2019.

>> No.14220392

The single biggest problem with Catholicism, and really Christianity in general, is and has always been Christian dogma. These articles just expose that. Whether you like Guenon or not, they’re opinionated hit pieces formed from a wiki page and no more. Anyone who’s familiar with Guenon would not be shocked at all that a “Catholic” corporation is not a fan of his. Move along.

>> No.14220406

>>14220363
They coom doing it. Every catholic i know just loves to point fingers at people calling them heretics and threatening them with eternal punishment in hell, it's amazing.

>> No.14220432

>>14219183
>>14219517
Wtf I hate Evola and Guenon now. They must not like the environment and socialism like Pope Francis does.

>> No.14220825
File: 221 KB, 820x1024, this is what catholics actually believe.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14220825

>>14219183

Should have practiced ritual cannibalism and drooled at Pagan idols, like real Christians. I bet he would've disapproved massacring the Cathars too. In fact, I could find no evidence that he has diddled ONE kid!

>> No.14221023

>>14220406
coom destroys religion

>> No.14221200

>>14220406

You shouldn't take it personally, if they're warning you about hell it's because they know it's probably true and are scared for your soul and theirs

>> No.14221249

>>14221200
>t. neckbeard that recognized himself in the quoted post

>> No.14221264

>>14220406
t. SEETHING heretic

>> No.14221275
File: 39 KB, 708x800, 1574017212050.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14221275

>>14220406

>> No.14221667

>>14220392
>having solid truths is bad
lol

>> No.14221764

>>14221667
>solid, truth
>orientalism
lololol

>> No.14221855

Lmao Guénon sucks.
Debunked by French catholics : Jacques Maritain/Emile Peillaube/Etienne Gilson.

>> No.14221954

>>14221855
>French catholics
Who cares dude. Go worship pachamama