[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature

View post   
File: 259 KB, 940x705, sam the man.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12026156 No.12026156[DELETED]  [Reply] [Original]

>Lying is unethical. You should never lie, even with Nazis at the door and Anne Frank in the attic.

Huh.

>> No.12026163

>Lying is unethical. You should never lie, especially with Nazis at the door and Anne Frank in the attic.

fixed

>> No.12026188
File: 496 KB, 840x768, lying.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12026188

>even considering lying to nazis

>> No.12026192

>>12026156
>You just need non-spiritual spirituality just meditate and do MDMA like I did.
>god bad mooslim more bad
Goes on for 200 more pages. what a retard.

>> No.12026201

>>12026156
MAD DOG

>> No.12026221

Ah yes, a New Age meditation guru here to warn us against the abuses and evil of religion.

>> No.12026222

>>12026156
>ying is unethical. You should never lie, even with Jews sending you to prison if you deny the biggest lie of history, namely the "holocaust".

Huh.

>> No.12026234

Morality is a spoop

>> No.12026292
File: 218 KB, 1280x720, spoopy.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12026292

>>12026234
forget the pic that is related

>> No.12026495
File: 39 KB, 400x327, induction-stove.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12026495

>blocks your path

>> No.12026510

I hate this guy because he's a jew and i hate J. Peterson because he defends jews. Life is so much simpler when you are anti-jewish. Not anti-semitic, just pure anti-jewishness. It makes everything so easy and seems to make sense, it's always the jews who are to blame in the long term, hasn't failed me so far.

>> No.12026528
File: 152 KB, 579x1358, 1535839793254.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12026528

reminder

>> No.12026532

>>12026510
Jews are so bad their lies and behavior is so obvious and banal that the moral character and subsequent flaw only exists in those foolish enough to believe them.

>> No.12026537

>>12026156
Categorical imperative doesn't preclude you from refusing to answer, retards.

>> No.12026614

>>12026510
It's very crude and anti-intellectual on the surface but you'll be right a good 90% of the time, which is better than most "reasoned" approaches.

>> No.12026647

>>12026528
I hate this so much

>> No.12026652
File: 429 KB, 548x412, heh.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12026652

>>12026528
>let's assume

>> No.12026676

>>12026163
>>12026188

Now I'm confused. I also doubt OP has this comprehended properly.

How do you justify being honest to a storm trooper within an ethical framework? Seems like storm troopers are anti-ethical and anti-moral in their constitution (i.e. their Aristotelian incontinence is such that they are horrible citizens as they are corrupted and possessed by a malignant social growth)

>> No.12026678

>>12026222
Are you writing a science fiction novel or do you actually believe our authoritative historical sources are false?

>> No.12026907

>>12026156
who came up with this stupid nazi example anyway? it's been plaguing ethics 101 classes for far too long

>> No.12026923

>>12026907
It's just the modern version of that classic greek thing where your friend comes to your house in a red-hot rage and a sword in his hand asking to see his wife or some shit.

>> No.12026960

>>12026678
I would like to see exactly 1 (one) primary source demonstrating Hitler knew about the holocaust, let alone personally ordering the genocide of Jews. History hints at the opposite in fact: https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/haavara
Why would Hitler have done this if he wanted to kill all Jews?

>> No.12027004

>>12026960
Goebbels' diary entry about the 12/12/41 Reich chancellory meeting, which was also confirmed by Hans Frank. So we have a direct written eye witness account
Now go back to /pol/

>> No.12027008

>>12027004
>if u haf rong opinion haf to leav bord
so this is the power of lit intellectuals

>> No.12027012

>>12026156
>Lying is unethical
How exactly does one come to this conclusion, as a blanket statement?

>> No.12027020

>>12026156
Yes, especially in that case. Why would she have to starve herself and degenerate if she can get proper goverment treatment and registration that her neglecting family dose not want to give her?

>> No.12027027

>>12027012
You are giving factually incorrect information. Something that is not based in reality. How is giving wrong information a good thing ever?

>> No.12027037

>>12027027
I'm not saying it's good. I'm asking how you come to the conclusion that it's necessarily bad.

>> No.12027061

>>12027027
What of withholding information? If I choose not to answer a question rather than answer it truthfully. Or mental reservation, in which I answer the question but mentally qualify my answer so that is true "in a sense."

>> No.12027099

>>12027008
>facts are opinions
so this is the power of idiots

>> No.12027124

>>12026676
https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/kant-moral/#TelDeo

>> No.12027367

>>12026156
Wasn't that Petersons argument?

>> No.12027376

>>12026192
sounds based desu

>> No.12027400

>>12027367
No he advocates speaking the truth and trying to avoid lying but doesn't constrain you into a rigid system whose dogmatic adherence would cause you to dox Anne Frank. He's a pragmatist. That's not very pragmatic. I think Sam also values truth but I haven't read his book so I'm not sure.

>> No.12027431
File: 171 KB, 326x281, 1541261131819.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12027431

Zoomers make guys like Sam Harris famous because they're too low-attention-span to read books. As such, they get all of their information from YouTube videos and podcasts.

>> No.12027439

>>12026676
>Seems like storm troopers are anti-ethical and anti-moral in their constitution
It's the complete opposite. Ethics and beauty lost in WW2 from the capitalist American and communist Russian scum. Europe died in 1945.